Burgundy vs the World: Time to Rethink Great Pinot Noir?

World of Fine Wines
5 followers
1 Video View·Nov 15, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi everybody, this is Agnes from No Sediment
and today I want to ask a question whether Pinot Noir
has a Burgundy problem,
meaning why every great Pinot Noir has
to be compared with Burgundy.
It seems to me that in the world of Pinot Noir we idolize Burgundy,
not only wine lovers but also hard-nosed professionals.
Red Burgundy has become the
benchmark of what Pinot Noir ought to look like,
smell like and taste like. Pinot Noirs are judged
by how closely they conform to our Burgundian idea of fragrance,
complexity and elegance.
I've seen it over and over again amongst my friends
and colleagues in the wine industry.
Encounter a not-so-great bottle of Burgundy,
and it is simply blamed on the bad bottle,
bad vintage, the wrong producer.
Encounter not-so-great bottle from Oregon,
and all of a sudden we question whether or
Whether or not this region has what it takes
to make truly amazing Pinot Noirs.
Another thing I have noticed over
and over again is that Pinot Noirs from outside Burgundy
are constantly being compared and contrasted with those of Burgundy.
That is even more common amongst wine professionals
and even I myself am sometimes to blame.
It is almost as if when it comes
to Pinot Noir we have forgotten the beauty of diversity
and simply judge wines by how Burgundian they are in the glass.
Very much like Burgundy. 10 points.
Not so much like Burgundy. Three points.
If my previously mentioned Oregon makes an outstanding Pinot Noir,
why should the highest compliment be that it tastes like Burgundy?
Why not celebrate it as an extraordinary expression of Oregon?
So instead of asking these wines to be something they
are not and judging them for it,
maybe we should stop expecting Pinot Noir
not from Burgundy to act like Burgundy.
And there's one more argument I want to make here,
something that we so often forget or choose to
ignore. Burgundy, even if we look only at its Pinot Noir expression,
is not one thing. There is an
incredible variety of styles.
Even within a single Grand Cru, even within the portfolio of a single
producer, there can be an enormous diversity.
We have different Léo D on the labels, in a way
By the way, already underlying diversity through terroir.
But we also have different winemaking practices,
picking dates, blending and
élevage choices, whole cluster, semi-carbonic,
fully destemmed, all of it affects the final wine.
There are powerful, rich and plump Pinot Noirs in Burgundy,
and there are ethereal, delicate, flowery Pinot Noirs.
How can we expect Pinot Noir from outside Burgundy
to adhere one single descriptor Burgundian
When Burgundian is not even Burgundian in Burgundy.
Many of my tastings have focused on price and value,
but today I wanted to take Burgundy
with its expression of Pinot Noir
and pit against other highly rated Pinot Noir wines
from across the world.
And maybe instead of discussing how Burgundian they are,
let's talk about their unique
style, their fruit quality,
and perhaps the unique expression of terroir.
Or maybe they really are trying to be Burgundian.
So we will start with the first wine
and it will be open label and it will be Burgundy.
It is meant to kind of calibrate our taste
so then we can move on with rest of the wines.
And next five wines are from top regions
that are associated with Pinot Noir and you would
expect high quality Pinot Noirs from these areas.
So let's start with wine number
I don't have a number here,
I have just B because it's Burgundy and it is an open label.
It is Domaine Henri Gueuge
and it is Nuits Saint-Georges Premier Cru Le Prouillet
from 2023 Vintage. Let's taste it.
The fruit is quite nice here and
In a way, you can feel that you are in Nuits Saint-Georges area
because just yesterday I tasted
this absolutely beautiful ethereal Pinot Noir from Volnay,
one of the top Premier Crus.
And that was so delicate and light
and it was almost difficult to, you know, catch.
And this one is a bit firmer, a bit fuller on the nose,
you know, darker, riper fruit profile.
This is exactly what I told you before.
Pinot Noir and Burgundy can be so diverse,
it is very difficult to define what really
Burgundian is, so how can we expect everything else
you know to be similar
to Burgundy?
But let's taste this wine.
Okay, so this is quite interesting
because we tend to associate burgundy with this really
light perfume, those light feet,
maybe just two centimeters above the ground, you know.
And this, I think, is quite a stable example,
you know, with both feet on the ground,
you know, with a bit of punch, with a bit of...
Structure as well. It has elevated beautiful acidity.
It is different style of what I tasted
yesterday and it definitely shows the more structured,
more fuller bodied examples of
Pinot Noir from Burgundy.
It has more weight on the palate and for those of you who will ask me
why I didn't choose, you know,
some ultra premium example from Grand Cru, which we would expect to
to be the benchmark of red burgundy.
The answer is very easy. I buy all my wines myself
and I cannot afford high quality beautiful Grand
Cru's from Burgundy. Very rarely will I be able to afford them.
So I went for top quality producer
and maybe some good examples from Premier Cru vineyards.
So I will give this wine 92 points.
I think this is not as light and not as, you know,
ethereal or flowery Pinot Noir as we expect,
or maybe in my mind I have painted the picture,
but I think it proves my point even better.
So let's move to the first blind wine of today,
and wine number one. Oh my, wow!
It is completely different from the Burgundy, at least on the nose.
I haven't tasted it yet.
It is so intense, so rich,
it seems very powerful but it does not have the power of
Cabernet Sauvignon or power of Nebbiolo.
It has a power of something light but something very
also strong and resistant. I don't know, it's just so interesting.
So intense and it is ripe fruit profile.
It seems like this wine has seen a lot of sun.
It's not overripe or jammy in any way but there
is this quality of pure ripe darkish fruit style.
And it is so intense like the nose
is so so intense. Let's taste the wine. This is
Puzzling to me.
It is very difficult to place it in one specific area or region.
It shows a bit lower acidity level than the Burgundian example did
and there was some fruit
sweetness at the very beginning when I tasted the wine.
It was like the first sip it felt almost
sweet and really ripe but then it evaporated
and I got that slightly chalky maybe slightly greenish
grippy tannin texture
and it is one that still dominates on my palate, my aftertaste.
Like hint of Earl Grey tea.
Tea, maybe rose stems, some floral character, dried herbs as well.
I think this wine is, it is unique, definitely.
And what I like is that it is not particularly similar
to the Burgundian example,
despite the fact that Burgundian example was towards that richer,
riper style as well.
I will give this wine...
I will give this wine 91 points.
Let's move to wine number two.
Okay, so for wine number two,
on the nose, this wine is way shyer,
way more calm than wine number B,
the Burgundian example, and wine number one was.
Wine number two is something that you
have to sit down and spend some time
and wait for it to open up for you.
It is not an immediate click and here you are.
We do feel those fragile wild berries,
raspberries, wild strawberries here.
It is really delicate fruit driven.
Those soft fruit, you know,
they just so easily crash under their own weight.
There's element of pine needle here,
some lavender as well.
Ah, it's opening up like layer after layer.
I start to like it. I like it. I want to taste it.
Let's taste it. It's so perfumed. It is lovely wine.
So here, as we would expect from high quality Pinot Noir,
I will not say Burgundian Pinot Noir,
but high quality Pinot Noir,
we have this really high beautiful mouth-watering acidity.
It is one of the defining features of this wine.
It is very light on its feet,
just as you would expect from Pinot Noir to be.
But there is beautiful structure as well. There is this
This veil of tannins, they're soft in a way,
maybe slightly, you know, they remind you
and pick at you and, you know,
they are still adding a bit of structure to this wine, but
in no way they are overpowering the fruit
or overpowering the wine itself.
I like this wine a lot.
I felt that element of fresh, sour cherry.
All this time while I was speaking with you,
I also felt that element of floral character,
that element of pine needle on my palate as well.
It is not leaving me.
I will give this wine 96 points.
I really do enjoy it.
Let's move to wine number 3.
All right, so this wine.
Again, and this is beautiful thing.
Again, this wine is completely different than wine B,
wine one, wine two. So we have Pinot Noir expressing
these beautiful differences
of where it has been grown,
of what has been done to it in the winery, in the wine cellars.
Why do we want for Pinot Noir to resemble that of Burgundy?
In a way I understand because Burgundy is so expensive
and maybe you want to look for alternative,
value alternative for Burgundy.
All right, so this wine...
is unique because on the nose it is even shyer than
the wine number two was but if you remember
wine number two it started you know being this scared little wine
and it just opened up and
revealed itself and with this one i've
been swirling it in the glass for a while now and i
I feel.
Like, it is still someone I have to catch, you know?
Come on, come on, let's have a discussion,
let's have a conversation. And it is not giving in to me.
The intensity of the aroma is not as
expressive as I would expect for Pinot Noir to be. And yeah...
Sometimes you start to feel you know delicate elements of florals
and at some point you start
to pick up something like fresh strawberries
and raspberries maybe even maybe slightly riper
in style as well and then some vanilla element
or toastiness but then it just evaporates. It just
evaporates and it's like like was it
a dream? Let's taste it. Okay I think
this wine represents a unique
Speak style.
I think the style maybe in this specific case
is overpowering any expression of terroir perhaps
and maybe even any expression of the grape variety.
Now I will be honest with you, for me personally
it can be difficult to judge certain wines where there
is too much of a fingerprint of a winemaker
Maybe I'm actually lying to you, maybe it's not the case, maybe it is.
fault within me because when I like the style
and I recognize the winemaker's style I'm very happy.
But when I maybe I'm not as excited about specific style
then then I say oh no no this is not good.
So let's keep an open mind. Agnes keep an open mind.
I will describe to you the style that I
feel on the palate and you
also can decide maybe it is a style for you. So I think that here
There is a lot of tannin and the tannin is a bit greenish in a way
and it overpowers the delicacy,
the juiciness of the fruit.
And Pinot Noir is a great variety that has very delicate fruit. It is
so easily overpowered
and I feel that maybe in this specific wine the tannin management
has overpowered the
The lightness, the fragility of the wine's fruit specifically.
Because while I speak with you,
it is not the fruit that I feel on the palate, it is
the astringent aftertaste that I feel on the palate.
And I understand the nature of this wine,
it is just not my personal style.
It could be a dear style to other wine lovers.
And I completely imagine some of my friends tasting
and sipping this wine and enjoying
their style. That's completely normal.
As with books, as with art, as with movies and even
video games and music, you know, you understand the quality behind it.
It's just not your style.
And I think this is the case with wine number three.
I will give this wine 93... 92 points
Because of the...
Stylistic expression. And let's move to wine number four.
Okay, so we are moving back towards more intensity
on the nose, towards darker fruit
that we felt in wine B and wine number one.
Maybe riper fruit profile as well. It seems
discussing power and structure, that darker side of Pinot Noir.
Let's taste the wine.
This wine, wine number four, it is so interesting.
It reminds me with that
darker fruit profile, with that earthy,
like black earthy element on the palate,
it reminds me something that I associate with one country
when it comes to Pinot Noir.
Thank you so much, Mark.
And I would want to think of Germany somehow, I don't know.
There's a certain weight on it.
And what I find very interesting that stylistically
wine number three and wine number four are quite similar.
You know, lower intervention,
hands-off type of wine making, but while in wine
three it felt like it was written over the wine,
here it felt like it was part of the wine.
You know, the wine had not lost its
Character.
Even though the winemaker also added their expression
and their idea of how this wine
should look. It felt like this wine had greater depth on mid-palate,
it felt fuller in a way and
The fruit was still shining and while I speak with you,
yes it is sour type of fruit,
maybe slightly fermented type of crushed fruit on the palate.
There is certain earthiness,
that black earth, that element of autumn leaves definitely is present
in this wine. And I have a bit grippier tannin texture as well.
But the aftertaste is long,
it is fruit driven and the fruit is not overpowered by the acidity
or the tannin. And I feel that maybe
this wine expresses that lower intervention hands-off
winemaking in a slightly better way.
So I will give to wine number four 94 points. Wine number
four 94 points. Let's move to the number five
which is our last wine of today.
I guess I know what style I like in my Pinot Noirs.
It's that delicate, fragile,
red berry fruit, that soft berry element.
And when I feel it, I am just happy.
And this one shows exactly that nose.
You have those wild strawberries, raspberries, maybe
you know some sweeter cherries on the nose.
But there's also some delicate smokiness, toastiness,
but not smoky element you know from wood,
but smoky element that you feel in the fog,
in the early morning.
That kind of you know almost mystery element on your nose.
I am sucker for fruit I guess.
Let's taste this wine. It is it is nice way to end.
At least on the nose I like this wine.
Wow! What kind of acidity is this? Like it
really shows you that it is coming from a cool climate
or at least climate that
has significant cooling influences.
You know it's just so juicy, mouth-watering.
It does feel like, you know, biting with a bunch of sour cherries.
It's just your saliva is coming back and just wants to,
you know, clean that acidity from your palate.
There's also chalky tannin texture.
This one is really fine, really tightly,
tightly grained and really like powdery almost on the palate.
But with all of that everywhere,
in every spot left open from acidity and tannin,
you have that sour red berry element. It has a lot
of energy. It has a lot of crunch.
And while I speak with you, I feel like it has
filled myself me with energy like with wine number three
and four I was maybe you know
a bit philosophical in a way
and with wine number five there's a lot of you know that child
happiness in it you know that child energy in it
and this wine represents that. I will give this
wine 90 I will give this wine 94 points as well.
We should reveal the wines now.
We will start with the lowest scored blind wine
because we all know what number
B was. So it was wine number one
with 91 points. Tall Puddle Vineyard
2025 Vintage Pinot Noir from
Tasmania. Okay, I have to be completely honest with you,
I have not tasted a lot of Tasmanian
Pinot Noirs. Not a lot.
I probably, you know, can count on one or two fingers.
One, two, three, four.
I can probably count on one or two hands,
and so I don't have a lot of experience.
What I remember distinctly,
I was talking a lot of sunshine hours, and that could be
the case with Tasmania.
It is not the warmest region,
but it does have a lot of solar insolation, if you can
say so, yes, solar radiation, and we know what...
I will also be honest with you,
I somehow in my mind had
an idea that this would be
Highly rated wine from my side.
So let's move to wine number three, which I gave 92 points.
And maybe you remember I spoke about style,
maybe over the expression of the grape or the
expression of the terroir. Another screw cup.
And that's Jackson's block Terra Sancta,
Single Block Pinot Noir from Central Otago.
Now, yeah.
This one was...
Like highly rated wine. It I think has received 98 points
from James Suckling, if I'm not mistaken.
And it was one of the reasons why I chose it,
because I was not familiar with it.
But I do know that they bottle their wines un-fined, unfiltered.
I don't know about their SO2 regime
but what I really liked when I was studying and reading
on this producer is that they grow their vines with no tilling
and that's fabulous,
that's amazing. So in a way they represent that lower intervention
winemaking and viticulture and that's beautiful.
Anyway let's move to next
Two wines, wine number four and wine number five,
which I gave the same points, which is 94. So let's
start with the wine number four.
And this wine also seemed to me towards that lower intervention,
hands-off winemaking,
but I felt like the Pinot Noir still shone through,
like I could still feel the delicacy,
the elegance of Pinot Noir in this wine.
Okay, so this is Vazenhaus Hochland Landwein
Pinot Noir 2024 Vintage from Baden.
We are in Germany. You know what is interesting? It's 12% alcohol.
And when I tasted this wine it had quite a lot of weight,
it had quite a lot of structure,
it was not an empty wine. So it shows to you
that without high alcohol level you can still achieve
a lot of substance, a lot of mid-palate, a lot of weight on the palate.
So I think this was done
Quite nicely in this wine. Let's move to wine number five.
which seemed to me coming from cooler area.
Storm, storm or storm, storm. Pinot Noir 2023
from Hemel and Aarde valley in South Africa.
All right, so Hemel and Aarde is quite
cool area from South Africa. It is a coastal area, so we do have that
Benguela stream influence cooling the vineyards,
so that's nice to hear. And
It was so jolly and so inviting and so juicy.
I did like this wine. Yeah I think it was
it was really beautiful expression of what Pinot Noir can also be.
Maybe not as serious, maybe not
as you know intense and not necessarily requiring
a lot of attention from your side and still very
pleasant and quite delicate.
So let's move to the wine number two which I gave the highest score.
I already know what it is.
Do you think it's going to be Oregon since I mentioned Oregon in my
introduction? It's not. It's Racine's
La Reconquista vineyard from Santa Rita Hills
Anything else?
from California.
Those of you who know know that this could be almost cheating
because it is a joint venture project with
De Monti with Etienne De Monti from Burgundy
and I have been lucky to visit that estate.
So they have their know-how, they have taken their Burgundy know-how
to California to Santa Rita Hills and they make the wines there.
But honestly I thought that this was a beautiful bottle.
It was absolutely beautiful. I was so happy
for it to reveal, you know, different aromas after aromas.
Well, I haven't checked with other wine
critics to think about this wine, but for my taste,
for what I understand of as high quality, fine,
Beautiful.
Bloody delicious wine.
This was definitely within the category so I really enjoyed it.
And in the end I want to tell you one thing.
When I was preparing for this video and checking
you know the winemaking techniques of these wines,
their regimes, every single one of them,
every single one of them in their web page had some kind
of reference to Burgundy.
And it is astonishing.
This one, the winemakers
of this winery have worked in Burgundy previously.
I think one of them have worked with De Monti.
This, you know, they talk about making delicate,
more elegant style of Burgundy instead of central Otago style.
And every single one is trying to kind of pick
and be part of that Burgundy club.
But I think in a way, those that may be,
instead of trying to be like Burgundy,
but maybe, you know, taking the know-how from the Burgundy,
taking the know-how from the Burgundy.
did best. I think because you cannot replicate Burgundy.
I love Klimt so much. Klimt is one of my
favorite artists.
And you can get perfect reproduction of the kiss,
but there's only one kiss.
And you can create very similar wines to those of Burgundy.
But they will never be Burgundy,
so they should always reflect their own land, their own style,
and I think this is where the truth comes in.
This is something that I invite you
to think about and maybe comment.
What are your thoughts? I've always felt
bad for the regions and sometimes even bad for the winemakers
who want to resemble that.
Holy grail what is Burgundy or what is Mosel
when we talk about rieslings or you know what
is champagne when we talk about sparkling wines.
But sometimes I think that you should be your best
self and I think there is beauty in that.
So let me know in the comment section below.
Do you agree with me? Maybe you don't and that's fine as well.
I do love to have a good discussion
but meanwhile make sure to watch this video here.
