The US M1819 Hall Rifle was the wonder weapon of its day. Not only was it a breech loading flintlock (later converted to percussion) it had interchangeable parts. This is a true treat to get hands on with such a historical piece. The M1819 Hall rifle was the first breech-loading rifle adopted by the U.S. Army. John H. Hall patented the design in 1811. It’s a flintlock with a breech block that tilts up at the rear for loading, which made it much faster to reload than the muzzle-loading rifles of its time. Production at Harpers Ferry Armory is a landmark in the history of interchangeable parts and American manufacturing. In this video we look at how the Hall rifle works, its history in the U.S. military, and how it shoots today.
Oh.
Gentlemen, welcome back to Administrative Results.
Today, we're going over the 1819 Hall Rifle.
And I'm very excited.
To help me on this great expedition of Black Powder,
we have a guest to the channel, Revere0311.
All
right.
Hey, there.
Thanks for having me on.
And yeah, this is an original model of 1819 Hall Rifle.
It is a breech-loading military flintlock rifle.
This one was made in 1838.
We'll show you the loading process.
Come on in here, Colton.
So we have our top pan right here.
Do a little powder.
You can see the touch hole.
It's kind of fun.
Close her on up.
We're at half cock.
We hit this device, this lever, I guess, that goes backwards.
And then we can load up the rest of the powder.
We're doing a 75 grain charge for this, some 2F powder.
Load her all in.
And then Mr. Revere, the British are coming,
the British are coming.
Load that in.
See if we can't hit the target.
Ah you definitely feel some of that heat coming off.
Ah look at that. So that's one of the issues
that you run into with the hull rifle is that this is actually
not a complete gas seal. So when this
thing goes off it is sending powder out
and through the brakes of this wood everywhere.
It's also sending powder underneath
and inside of the mechanism into the breech. So that was one of
the problems they had with it.
So it's actually going to lose some energy because of that.
Hey, all right.
Nice.
We just had to move up.
So it feels interesting in the hands.
The balance point, just walking with it,
you know, it's kind of about right here.
Kind of bounces out the front of the barrel,
the breech mechanism.
Definitely a bit weird from my perspective.
If you came in here a little bit cold
when you look at the front sight post because it's off center
You're like is my barrel messed up?
But then when you go down to get a sight picture you're like, oh, okay
This makes more sense because you got a giant lock blocking your view.
Yeah, and that touch hole is not in line with the barrel either
So one of the things John Hancock Hall said
was a benefit was since you have that
ignition straight in front of your face,
he said it would reduce the soldier's flinching
because it's right there in front.
I don't know if that's completely true,
but I just, I'm pretty flinchy.
I'm a pretty flinchy shooter. Let me know if
You find, like, you flinch less.
That's one thing doing the flintlock stuff.
It made me even appreciate modern firearms more.
You sound like such a sissy when you say it because everyone's
like, oh, yeah, what are you, just power through?
It's like, dude, when there's a fireball going off
in front of your eyeball, the most human thing to do
is to be like, oh!
How's the recoil?
Not bad at all.
Yeah?
Not bad at all.
It's only, like, a seventy-some grain charge.
It's very manageable.
Yeah, so the patent was developed in 1811.
In 1816, the U.S. Army tests about 100 of them on Missouri.
In 1819, he gets his first contract to make 1,000
of these rifles out of Hall Rifle Works,
which would be at Harper's Ferry Armory.
1819 is the model.
The first gun doesn't come off the line until 1824.
Oh, wow.
I don't know.
I still feel like there's a bit of a flinch.
Yeah, I can't.
I'm done.
Let's try this.
I wanna see if we can't cook up
with a little bit more speed.
Do you wanna have a few balls ready?
See if we can't.
I'm rigged up for my Ferguson.
A surprise, a mouse tool to help us later.
I wanna see if we can't do a little bit
speed shooting off the rip.
We could be a crew served hall rifle.
That's honestly-
I'll be right behind you at the hall
and just drop it in, drop it in, drop it in.
Historically speaking,
it's like getting your powder monkey, you know?
Which was just small children on a ship
that's like, all right, go get me another keg of powder.
Yes, sir, right away.
The manual of arms during this time period
is you prime first and then you load.
That's obviously kind of counterintuitive
to modern black powder muzzleloaders.
Well, I think they do it a lot for safety nowadays.
For safety, yes, yeah.
And military-wise, back in the day, you primed the pan first,
and then, say, in a traditional musket, you would go down,
you would pour your contents, ram it all home,
and then come back up to an already primed pan.
I think what you'll find with a lot of ranges today,
they'll be like, no, don't do that.
Yeah, definitely, yeah.
So you'll prime your barrel first or load your barrel first,
and then you'll prime the pan to fire.
But in theory with
A lot of these flintlocks, there's
like a lock where if it's at half cock,
that thing's not going anywhere.
Let's see if we can get a little speed going.
I think I have an idea
for what I want to do.
Come on.
Ball me.
Okay. Well, we've got a little 1R1 in gun guy terms.
Shoot one, reload one.
How does it compare to your other breech loader?
And then how does it compare to what you thought
it would be? The Ferguson has its charms and its drawbacks.
For instance, on the Ferguson,
a big concern the shooter has is making sure
that that breech block doesn't fall out,
like unscrew out. So you really have
to be cognizant of keeping the gun level. With this
one, there's no concern about that whatsoever,
but it's counter to the Ferguson where when I
When I load it up, I typically,
Tilt it forward to get all the powder into the breech area.
On this one, you're doing the exact opposite
because you primed the pan, go back up,
load all your contents, push it all down,
and then you kind of like sweeping cock it all back to fire.
So it's pretty much just like reverse of the Ferguson so far.
Yeah, the infamous rifle trials,
you read about the able to shoot
seven to nine rounds a minute.
I think that's in the 1826 trials
that were done at Fort Monroe.
It absolutely blew the other competition out of the water.
I think a big thing slowing me down in this moment
will be my powder flask.
So having to shake the powder out, as opposed to with the Ferguson,
I have the horn, I can just dump it all in, so it's a bit quicker.
I died.
Gentlemen, this video is sponsored by Optics Planet,
though we don't have any optics on this Hall rifle, sadly.
There's still time.
I do want to give a big thank you for
being a big supporter of the channel.
I can't tell you a discount code, guys. I'm not allowed.
Take a wild guess.
And of course, if you want to get your start in gunsmithing
and technology such as, I'd encourage you to check out sdi.edu.
It's going to be linked in the description down below.
A DEAC Online Accredited College where you can get your start
in anything from 1911s, bolt-actions, and modern sporting rifles.
And as part of the coursework during your certain semester,
they'll send you a lathe out, which is pretty sick.
And you can get some hands-on with the components
from the comfort of your own home.
And while shooting these flintlocks,
I took a quick break to fire off some .300 Blackout
thanks to Badlands Munitions, the ammo sponsor of the channel.
Not only do they have .300 Blackout,
but they have 9mm 5.56 and 7.62x51 and a wide variety
of grainages.
And they're cooking up some sick Nos 3 cases,
which is pretty sick and I appreciate them
greatly.
And they've even sent off ammo
to the Marine Corps shooting team, which is pretty cool.
They're big ass because you stay up to date
with their email list so they can let you
know when stuff
is on the shelves.
Eventually she'll go.
It's my first time shooting.
I've never actually
been outside before.
Now with the Hall rifle, I think the breech loading flintlock
is just so much fun.
It's contemporary of the era.
Maybe its competitor from across the seas
would be that of the Ferguson rifle.
Now the Ferguson rifle, as cool as it is,
saw very limited numbers compared to the Hall rifle,
which was spun up to the tune of how much?
About 20,000 of the model of 1819 Hall rifles were made.
But more were made as carbines, the percussion variants.
Contractors made some as well.
So much more drastically successful.
Run of guns than the Ferguson.
Shooting this one, I'm a bit more biased
towards it in the manual of arms.
Maybe it's just me shooting it more.
Maybe it's my Anglophile showing through
with my big simping for the Sharp series.
I don't know what it is.
That being said, the Hall rifle is still very cool
and has a bunch of charm to it.
Now, one thing I'm curious about,
do you mind if I, can we try 3F powder in that?
See if it does anything different?
Of course.
Let's try it.
Let's give it a go.
Whoa.
Whoa.
I got a lot more juice back to the face on that one.
Let me tell you.
I think it definitely burned a bit better, but that was unpleasant.
Paul was saying that he uses 2F with this.
The 3F definitely gave me some good back blast.
This is about a what?
Rough, maybe rough hundred?
YouTubers never miss, right?
Just gets edited out.
Sir, I miss an abundance.
He who has never missed has never shot a gun, sir.
Right in the chest.
There you go.
You broke his heart.
All right.
I want to see how I fare with the Fergie real quick.
There
we go.
One, two, three.
That was three shots out of three, right?
Yes, but like about 20 trigger pulls.
Oh, sorry.
Definitely noticing some weird little corks with it, I will say.
For instance, when you shoot at a bunch, you have a lot less wood
and a lot of metal you're touching that's heating up.
So, for instance, when I'm going to this position to load it up.
To balance the gun, it's kind of like,
all right, what am I going to do here?
Do I hold down here, which doesn't feel
as good as opposed to holding up higher?
And you're just kind of being mindful of keeping
your hand on the wood as opposed to the barrel,
which is heating up rather quickly given the rate of fire.
One of the little quirks about a gun,
you kind of learn from shooting it.
There's a congressional report where they're
talking about over the course of 20 years,
they're going to pump out about 800,000
of these is what they're looking at.
This could have been the arm that
was heading into the Civil War, but they weren't.
They went back to muzzle loading for the model of 1841.
What's commonly known as the Mississippi rifle.
Model 1842 is a smoothbore muzzle loading percussion
military arm.
But that is the first mass produced arm of completely
interchangeable parts.
This is completely interchangeable,
but the model of 1842 musket is the first one they made.
I don't know how many.
A lot.
Steady, boys.
Steady on the line.
Don't shoot until we can see the white of their eyes!
Aye, sir.
Oh, I can see the white of their eyes! Shoot now, damn you! Shoot now!
Bad time to have a flint malfunction, Mr. Revere!
Oh, you got him.
For a moment, I was worried we would have to go to bayonets.
Oh, we're going to bayonets!
It was never sold as a primary replacement for the musket at the time.
They'd call it the common musket.
We know it as the model of 1816.
They said it would be used for the light troops.
So you'd have flank companies, light companies,
and not even all of them would be armed with the hull.
Maybe half of them would be armed with the Hall.
The others would be armed with, they would call
the time the Harper's Ferry Rifle,
the model of 1803.
Its first real combat debut.
I was in the 1832 Black Hawk War.
The 6th US Infantry under Brigadier General Atkinson
actually had his entire regiment outfitted
with Hall rifles minus the light companies.
So we could assume that the light companies
were probably issued the Model 1803 Harper's Ferry Rifle.
They went down to fight in Florida during the Seminole Wars.
There's a primary account saying
they did not perform very well in Florida.
As you can imagine, we've only shot so many rounds
through it, but you can actually see, see that powder?
The inside of this is already caked.
What's going on is it's pushing that powder out the side
and it's also bouncing off the bottom in the wood
and it's going into all the internal mechanisms.
I was telling you I have another Hall rifle made in 1826.
It's in rough condition.
The insides all rusted out.
All the screws are in pretty bad shape
to the point where I couldn't take them out.
The maintenance on this thing,
You'll see more of it as we kind of play around with it.
But it's pretty maintenance intensive.
You have powder everywhere.
It's dirty.
And just having your regular infantryman
break apart the internal mechanisms,
that's kind of like an armor level.
You get the PowerPoint presentation on the Hall rifle.
You're like, oh, this thing's got to be awesome.
It's rifled.
It shoots faster.
It's got all those things.
And then you realize when you take it out to the field,
it's a little bit more maintenance intensive.
It's not quite, I think the word's ergonomic.
It's an interesting piece of history nonetheless.
It's like the Cyclops of death on that thing.
That breech just popped open.
Yeah, the Cyclops.
You can actually see how it's not actually completely lined up.
You see how it's a little to the top.
So when this is pushed down, it's not perfectly lined up.
So what's happening here is that there is no...
it'd be like a ladder on the 1826 there's a ladder
that would stop you from going too far down
what they found is after repeat use that was just smashing
and smashing and smashing so they
actually got rid of that little step
that's underneath the breech so now it's just it just
comes down which when i first got it was a little nerve-wracking right
because if this ball is going
into the receiver you know that's all she wrote
no it was just built in it was a way as they
As they, through the production cycle,
Improve it now is the breech right here.
Is that narrowed down more? So no, it's it's open. It's fluted
I think isn't it concave or convex? I don't know.
It's like this. So it goes it goes like that
It'll funnel the round into the breech and send it out.
So there's a little bit of room for error
There's a little bit of room for error
the first contract which is my first gun
It's an extension of the first contract.
It is just it's just hole on hole. Really?
Yeah, but you have that step to stop it
So that's kind of one of the bigger changes
that happens mostly the same gun
Until it ends production in 1841,
I think they might have made some percussion variants
into the 1840s. I don't know.
I'm mostly focused on the 1819 breech loaders. Well tested. You'll
see a lot of these Hall rifles from the late 1830s
in pristine condition. Like I was telling you,
I don't think this had ever been shot.
It's got this brown lacquer finish, two-toned actually.
From what I've been reading, a lot of the ones from the 1830s,
late 1830s, were never issued.
And that checks out.
There were policies at the time that the
U.S. Ordnance Department, U.S. Army put out that they wanted
to burn through some of the older guns in stock first.
Their best
and their newest stuff they would actually keep in the arsenal,
and then they would get rid of their other stuff to field test it out
until, you know, break glass in case of war, then break these out.
I wonder what events so recent in their history
were concerned about a big war.
Yeah, exactly.
The Mexican-American War starts off in the late 1840s, right?
And they're taking smoothbore, flintlock, muzzleloaders down there.
I've read the Dragoons are taking their percussion variant.
Some of the Dragoons, when they would overcharge the carbine variant,
it would, like, shatter the stock.
It's a lot of work to get the Hall Rifle back down
to the Southwest once more.
Well, he's suppressed if he's not dead.
Damn fine shooting, son.
Damn fine.
All right, now, a big benefit of the breech-loading flintlock
is being able to shoot from different firing positions.
So Mr. Revere and I will demonstrate that for you
right now.
Make ready, fire.
Well, it works better when your gun shoots.
Kneel,
damn
you,
kneel!
Prone.
I will say, doing black powder from the prone
is perhaps one
of the most torturous of events.
Looking down the muzzle of a, oh, man.
Now this is a two-fold test because we can see
Where perhaps one mechanism shines and where the other struggles.
You know I like
the Ferguson
when it actually sparks.
Hearing the rounds go down range with they're just moving.
That's the best part about shooting in the woods.
Even if you miss something you just hear
that round just knocking off little tree limbs and stuff.
So a funny part about doing black powder stuff is managing your powder
when you do go to the prone.
For instance on a powder flask I've had
this problem before where my powder just falls out.
Let's get this out.
From the prone position, it becomes, I lost my powder.
So I had to make sure to be cognizant of re-spicketing the spout.
But you can see that there's a clear advantage.
I'm not.
Now, the Ferguson's nice in some ways.
I don't know how you fared going to the prone.
Kneeling with these is just like standing.
But the prone is probably the most dubious of positions,
especially with black powder guns.
Obviously, I had to go like 90-degree angle, pop it up, load.
So I'm not completely in the prone.
I'm guessing you're having to prop it up and then undo.
Well, so when I was on the prone,
I have to find a way to dip down as far as I can and shake it in.
And I'm dipping back up.
Yeah.
So there's two concerns.
Me dipping down into whatever I'm laying in, right?
Whether that's dirt, dust, mud, water, debris.
It'd be ingenious if they found a way
to load this from the back of the breech.
It would be phenomenal.
Maybe they should do something like that.
I really hope they develop that technology
for maybe a back of the breech loader.
That would make life a lot easier.
One could hope, right?
One could hope.
Nine in a minute.
That's your...
We have expectation.
Nine in a minute?
They said seven to nine in a minute.
When I did the math on a report, it was like 3.5 in a minute.
When I've done it, I've gotten about three
to four in a minute with paper cartridges.
It's
sticky.
Powder flask, I feel like, is the weak link here.
If you're
really...
Nah.
Four shots, 74-45.
Oh, there you go.
I can see the potential shortcomings now.
It is one of those things, when you hear about the Hall
rifle, I was like, because I was getting
a lot of requests on the black powder stuff,
like you should check out the Hall rifle.
And I check it out, and I'm like, oh, that sounds awesome.
But from what I've learned from the Fergie
and the other black powder guns, on paper,
this idea sounds rather romantic.
But when you meet them in real life,
and you actually get out there, you're like, OK,
this is where I am seeing the shortfalls.
Because this is going out to the frontier right? It's going out to your
your private infantryman on some fort
in Kansas and you're going to have to
expect him to maintain this which
is part of you know being a soldier but
This is just me contemplating.
If you're an officer, you're seeing the testing going,
you're going to know that you need to work
at the lowest common denominator, which is your
infantry private. It works, it excels in some aspects.
During the Black Hawk War, they talked
about how good it was when firing
and maneuvering through the woodlands and stuff and firing from
the crouched and different shooting positions.
I could really see that being kind of the sweet
spot is in a less open environment
because the accuracy is another concern of this gun.
But when you condense the distances down, you up the fire rate,
that's where this thing is starting to be much more appealing.
If you're going against Indian troops that have bows and arrows,
that may be a concern of keeping the fire rate up
when they have such a quick follow-up arrow coming at you.
And as much as for like TTP's Indian fighting, I've read is you fire
from one tree, then you move to the next position, fire, reload,
move to the next, you're constantly moving, and that this...
would excel at that. Not having
to move through the woods and trying to ram
down with a ramrod, I would take this.
I imagine working with the dudes you've
been living with for years out in the frontier,
you get a pretty good rhythm going upon them.
Enemy contact, you know, you just start hearing the ka-ka-ka-ka,
ka-ka-ka-ka of the gunfire going
downrange. It probably feels a lot better despite
the drawbacks of once you start shooting this
thing and say it does work, the flint's sparking properly.
Probably starts to feel pretty good.
I have yet to find the smoking gun on why they didn't up production.
I have yet to find the
smoking gun of why it got replaced.
I read a lot of other people's opinions on it, but I've never
read like an official document saying like, hey,
like this is a great idea. Push comes to shove.
We're going back to the muzzleloader with the percussion.
I don't know why or if there was a single nail
that went into the coffin that ended this
from hitting full production
or maybe it's just a timing thing, right?
The percussion comes out, percussion's more reliable.
You could do it with the percussion.
We've seen the haul with the percussion,
but if anybody out there knows a primary source document
that talks about why they discontinued the haul,
I'd love to read it.
Yeah, any of you pencil pushers know the words on the paper.
You let us know, okay?
You better tell us.
Wanna shoot it as a pistol?
Hell yeah.
All right, let's pop it off.
You don't want to take the other screws out.
Those are to keep the receiver into the stock.
It's kind of like an M1 Grand, you know?
You have to, so this, yes.
Just that one screw.
Look at the inside, and you can see
the concave of the back of the breech where it cones in.
Cleaning the barrel is easy.
Yeah.
But another thing is, look at the inside of here.
There's powder underneath this screw head.
Remarkable for a screw made in 1838, by the way.
But all of this is caked. It's a lot more work
to clean this mechanism than a traditional flintlock.
As opposed to pissing down the barrel.
As opposed to pissing down the barrel.
You have now one of the smallest muzzle loaders.
I'm gonna let you shoot.
Okay, there is an account from Mexico City during
the Mexican-American War that a soldier took the
breech block out and used it as personal defense weapon.
I've tested this before. If you have a
You have a hole, you kind of have to shoot it
as a breech block, at least once.
powder. So I'm walking through Mexico City,
a ruffian comes around the corner
and he tries to take me for all I'm worth.
And I put a round into him. I look
around and I just decided I've committed murder
because I'm off-duty and I'm not
supposed to do that. So then I run down the street
and get out of town. Oh no! So
yes you can, you should do it.
I would love to, yeah,
we'll see that. Tally-ho!
I'm not going to lie, there was a point where I was like,
is this where I lose my fingers?
Yeah.
It was great being an admin with fingers.
All safety was observed, Seth.
All safety was observed.
Well, that's cool.
That seems like a very inconvenient way
to go around with a pistol.
It's one of those things.
Somebody wrote it.
They said they did it.
Sure, I guess.
I mean, pistols exist at the time.
So I guess if that's the last thing you have,
then you're also walking around because you would assume it,
Well, if it's a half cock.
Right.
The trigger could just catch on anything at any time.
Give me your money.
Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh.
I doubt it.
I have my doubts, dude.
Yeah, but it's part of the whole experience
is to shoot it as.
A breech block.
That is bananas.
He does.
Ha ha ha ha!
I was like, how much energy do I got to put on this?
Yeah, because there is quite a bit of spring tension, right?
I don't know if it's spring tension.
There's quite a bit of tension.
It's like, even getting an accurate shot.
I have questions about that story.
Yeah.
It can be done.
It can be done.
Should it be done?
I will say, getting a Hall rifle on the channel is a true treat.
And yet again, thank you to Mr. Revere for bringing it out here,
coming all the way to Arizona,
a place where perhaps it's all conflict.
Do it.
Plausible.
Plausible.
Now, I will say that wonder weapons of their time,
after doing the firearms thing for a bit,
you kind of learn about the wonder weapons
and the conflicts they were involved with.
Think about even the STG-44 during World War II,
an assault rifle coming out of that conflict.
In reality,
They had a very high reject rate.
The one that I got my hands on,
I had to download the magazine to get it to work
and cycle properly.
Or if we look at other guns, say the Ferguson rifle,
a wonder weapon of the revolution,
but not fielded enough in numbers to really make a dent.
And today I will say shooting flintlocks
definitely makes me appreciate percussion caps.
Percussion caps make me really appreciate
the self-contained cartridge.
Between rain spurts, we were shooting the .300 Blackout,
and it was like, ah, wow, this feeds another round rather rapidly.
And it works when I pull the trigger.
Marvelous technology.
Now, getting the hull rifle on, it is a bit of a legend.
And so I was very excited to check this thing out.
The silhouette, man, when you look
at it from the side, it looks so crazy.
It's like one of those flintlock that Ian
McCollum would show off and be like,
this thing could fire 900 rounds a minute.
And it was a flintlock.
And it's like, wow, Ian, that's crazy.
But then you get out here and you shoot it, and you're like,
oh, okay, there's some of the short...
comings to it. Things that are weird about it
is that breech block just coming straight up and
having to really tilt the entire gun up as opposed
to what I was used to with the Ferguson of say
tilting down to keep all the contents in the chamber.
In a way it's kind of nice because
it's like all right you balance it up load
everything up and you're good to go. Now from
the accounts and talking to Mr. Revere
the gun struggled from some accuracy. Now historically
speaking was that a thing that they found
or is that maybe a modern issue?
Well, they found over time that the continuous firing would wear out
and increase that gap even more.
As that gap would increase, because obviously, like we said,
it's not completely flush, you're losing a lot of energy out the sides.
One report I read...
Pretty famous from 1837.
They were shooting aged white oak at 300 yards
and the round wouldn't even indent
compared to like a muzzle-loading
Harper's Ferry rifle, the 1803.
It just didn't have that punch power.
It's like I think of the Baker rifle
where you have a muzzle-loading rifle
and though they are slower to load,
at least when it is all loaded up proper,
in theory, you're going to have a more accurate flintlock
or a more accurate black powder.
This is trying to bridge the gap of,
say, the Ferguson and rifles of the time
and you're trying to just really hasten the fire
rate of the rifleman. Water is wet.
What an obvious statement. There are just things about
like the incremental improvement of small things
that I really do dig compared to say
the Ferguson rifle. Barrel bands I really dig.
I love the metal ramrod. I really do appreciate that
on the muzzle loaders when you see a metal ramrod
and that's not crazy technology because it's like
the Brown Bess had that and so I don't know why they didn't
do that with the say the Ferguson
rifle. Granted it's like an emergency thing you need
in case you got to pop stuff out or
Ram a ball down, but it's one of those quality of life.
Now, on the Ferguson rifle, and it's
going to keep coming up in the video, but on that gun,
I have to lube it up aggressively
to make sure it doesn't seize up with the threads.
Talking to you about this, this doesn't need
any sort of lube whatsoever.
And that's also really cool, in my mind, a bonus to this gun.
Before with, say, the Ferguson, you
have to have all this ecosystem of stuff
to make sure it works well.
You have to have grease for the mechanism.
You have to have finer powder.
That makes it shoot better.
You have to have a different ammunition
than, say, opposed to the Brown Bess.
With this, you guess you have different ammunition,
but everything else is, that's about it.
So that's a big bonus.
As technology develops, do you know of any sort
of Minié ball loadings that this could
have potentially had?
I've never read or seen or heard.
If you have, I'd love to hear about it.
I would assume maybe perhaps a twist rate concern is there.
I don't know enough about the Minié balls.
I just know that because the Harper's Ferry 1841
rifle, I don't think that fired a Minié ball either.
This rifle gets replaced by the model
of 1841 muzzle loading percussion rifle.
I ask about the Minié stuff because even
when I tell folks like, oh yeah, I have
an interest in this black powder muzzle loading
stuff. Yeah, they fire a spherical ball.
They're like, well, can you also load say like a Minié
ball in there? And I was like, well, talking
to all the people that know more than me, they're
like, no, the twist rates are concerned
because it's just not going to work well with that style
Because in theory, it's like, well, you got a rifle,
you know, it's a black powder, just
like a rifle Minié ball, black powder musket.
And so why can't you just...
Take that ammo for the right size and throw it in that.
And it's like, twist rates.
So that's something that I was curious about
if that played a part into this or not.
The breech block, you know, I really do like it
because the breech block is kind of sick.
And unlike the Fergie, you don't worry
about losing your breech whatsoever.
It's a massive fear because with that thing, I have to level it out.
I'm like, okay, kind of keep a hand on it, keep an eye on it.
And when it does get more fouled up after shooting,
it kind of sets in rather nicely.
But it's nice not having that be a concern
whatsoever on a gun like this.
We're really just hashing out things
that we like about a gun that's been
You know, antiquated for damn near two millennia, sir.
The iron sights, you know,
it's one of these guns with the irons,
trying to figure it out.
You're gonna live and die by these irons.
You know, you're going off to the frontier
and there's gonna be a bunch of angry Indians
trying to scalp you, but trying to figure it out.
I figure if you shot more,
you'd probably get a good dial of like,
okay, where we hit and where we're not.
Now, from my rough understanding, Mr. Revere,
this gun underwent a rather rigorous trial process.
Absolutely, so,
Basically, for 15 years,
this mechanism is tested extensively by the U.S. government.
From the patent rifles of 1816, 1824,
1825 is when the first thousand rifles get put out.
And then in 1826, you have these famous Fort Monroe trials.
And they're constantly testing this thing.
They're stress testing it.
They're putting...
8,000 rounds through one, which is the equivalent of 15 years.
They are trying to basically break it,
and that is one thing that has definitely, without question,
it's a sturdy mechanism. Can I interrupt you real quick?
Absolutely. The idea of firing 8,000 rounds
through a black powder gun sounds so tiresome.
Just having a crew of guys,
what did you do today, honey? I just loaded and shot a musket all day.
If I remember correctly, they're shooting
at one point 500 rounds a day through it.
They're just testing it and testing it and testing it.
So this without a doubt was tested to the fullest extent
because the army was always like,
what are we going to do with it?
Like, is this where we want to go?
They had that potential if they got tooled up, if they really invested,
they could have had 800,000 of these built by the middle of the 1850s.
That's just not where they went.
The cost at the beginning was a concern,
but by the end of production, it's costing about
$13 for a rifle.
For comparison, it costs about $9 to $11 at the time
to make a smoothbore musket out of one
of the national armories of Harpers Ferry or Springfield.
So this cost is coming down over time.
But the government just, they never completely buy in.
And even when they first accept them into service,
they only accept them, like we were saying,
for the light troops, for the flank companies.
And even then, it wasn't completely replacing the rifles
that they already had.
So it was like 50-50.
It's safer to go with what you know works
from my impression of reading.
I am obviously no expert in the Hall Rifle.
I just read the books by Peter A. Schmidt.
He's the guy, so.
Well, you know more than I do.
And he has a wonderful YouTube channel,
so just go check it out.
There's going to be a, it's going to pop up like
when I say this right now with the power of editing.
Impressive. Thank you.
Ferguson had a known issue of a weak point in the stock.
Was there any sort of concerns
or was that all hammered out during the trials?
I've never read about a weak point in the stock.
I have read if you over tighten some of these screws,
you can split the stock back here.
I've read more problems about
the percussion carbine variant that the Dragoons had.
The biggest Achilles heel about
this rifle to me was the loading itself.
It's really cool. It's really convenient. I'm sure if you used
cartridges, it could be, you know, it could be negated, I could say.
But to me, the biggest
drawback was filling it with powder and then loading it.
And the reason is you could overfill it
You're not going to be able to shoot is the issue,
but if you put your ball in and it doesn't close,
you now have to solve that problem on the fly.
What I really like about the Ferguson
is that you can't overload that or even worry about it.
You can put as much powder in there as you want.
Once you close the breech, all the excess
is going to come up and out.
And then you just scrape it away, no problem.
And so to me, the speed remains stronger
on that style of action with the Ferguson as opposed
to the Hall Rifle.
Because even with the spigot, or even trying
to eyeball it and go fast, because to me,
The fastest way to shoot with the Ferguson
is with like a powder horn. You just dump it in there.
You kind of figure out your count and then
you close on up and you proceed to fire.
With this, I would assume it's kind of the same thing
where if you could eyeball it and then load it,
then yeah, you're going to be able to shoot very
fast. But the problem is eyeballing it,
if you do fill up that chamber too much, now you have to
get some of that excess powder out and it's rather inconvenient.
That to me seemed like the biggest
Achilles heel of this. Everything else about it,
I feel like you could work around it and it's just
no factor but that was like okay that's why i'm really
not enjoying this is in a haste trying to
work with it and granted i was using one
of the powder flasks that has a cut off but trying to
even shake that powder out really slows it down
so that's why i wanted to use say a powder horn
but then say a cartridge could negate
that but then you have to deal with the cartridge of say
priming the pan and then manhandling the cartridge
as opposed to having things freely attached to
your body which i enjoy a little bit more
as a preference for my style of shooting and it's
And it's also interesting
because Hall uses that as a selling point, it would
Reduce the amount in which a soldier would over powder his ball.
But if you over powder a ball in a musket, it doesn't matter.
The round's going down range.
And that's why they proof test these with two
to three times the amount of powder it's
supposed to take to try to make sure
that the barrel could handle that stress.
But like we ran into earlier,
we're trying to finger out the ball out of its little seat
there.
It almost makes me wish for like the falling block design.
You know, if they could have figured out that quicker.
A little quicker?
Yeah, because, I mean, it shows up.
But, yeah, that falling block, really,
with the black powder seems so ingenious.
Oh, yeah.
Because it's like you combine the speed
of the Ferguson without the user error of the Hall.
You just dump everything in, fill it with powder, lift up the block.
Everything excess is there.
You could just sweep it into the pan if you needed to.
Like, that's like, oh, you guys are so close.
Like, it feels so close to what it could be.
What if you take this thing coming up,
and what if we just go down with it, you know?
Yeah, and you make it a percussion, and then you have the Sharps.
It looks like you need to get a Sharps on here.
So I guess it's a spiritual predecessor to the Sharps in a way.
Sometimes when I look at this breech block,
I like to get the idea that maybe some Joe back in the day was like,
what if they made a breech block where you could have
a bunch of breech blocks and just quickly insert it?
And it's like the proto self-contained cartridge.
And they're like, what if? Dude, there's a lot of potential.
And that guy was like, you know what? I'm going to go invent one.
Then he gets killed by some, you know, disease.
Please.
Dysentery is much more likely to kill you than...
An Indian's bullet, so this is...
Yeah, no kidding.
It's crazy, man.
It's really just...
It's a very elegant, cool-looking rifle.
I was telling you about this.
When you first see it now, it bulges out.
You're just like, I don't know how I feel about that.
But it grows on you.
It's a little lumpy, you know?
But, uh...
It looks better from the side than it does from flipped upside down.
Why do I feel like this Marine is constantly trying
to innuendo me on my channel, dude?
You have a channel of innuendo's. I'm just trying to keep up.
Keep it going, sir. We'll play it soon.
Yeah, this is really slick, man. You hear all about it.
So if you're taking one rifle to combat,
you taking the Ferguson or you taking the Hull?
Like you said, I want to go with what I know.
Probably go with the Fergie.
Yeah.
I just like the Ferguson more.
I don't know if I'm a bit of an anglophile or not.
I think you might be a little bit of an anglophile.
I might be a little bit of an anglophile.
Perhaps I might just play it safe and go the Baker.
Nah, I'd go the Ferguson.
So help me God, as long as it strikes when I need it to.
Shooting flintlocks is an experience and not always a good experience.
That it is, good lord man, sometimes you're just pleased work.
Well this was a nice little video on the 1819 Hall Rifle
and I was very excited to get it on the channel and check it out.
It comes highly recommended
in the comments section whenever we go over black powder guns,
especially black powder wonder weapons if you will.
Thanks so much for inviting me out to come...
Burn some powder, especially when it's not even my own powder.
So I really appreciate that.
And yeah, thank you so much.
I had a great time.
It's probably not good to fly out
to Arizona with a pound of black powder.
I will say checking in a Hall rifle
at the airport is probably a top five experience
in my life because you're like, look, can you clear this out?
It's like, I would love to.
Let me pop this thing out.
You want to ask me about it?
Yeah, I would love that.
I will give you the whole history there.
I know a lot about the hull rifle.
You want to ask me about the hull rifle?
All right, I got nothing else.
Godspeed.
Walk off that way.