In The Courts: November 15, 2026

Fox - 5 DC
33 followers
Nov 16, 2026
Thanks for joining us for In the Courts this week.
I'm Katie Barlow. Off the top,
a lawsuit leads to violence.
On Thursday, Dr. Matt Lambert took things into his own hands,
killing a Logan Circle condo building manager inside
a gym after suing the building and its
management back in 2025.
Lambert killed 46-year-old James Stewart before escaping to his
His condo and shooting five others from his balcony, lighting his.
Apartment on fire and then killing himself.
There's also a Twitter handle called Of Mice and Mold that we believe
is connected to Lambert that tweeted at 8:06 on Thursday morning,
quote, My manifesto is an engineering report.
And that appears to be connected to a lawsuit that Lambert filed
against the condo building, the Metropole, back in March 2025, claiming
that they failed to address serious issues involving water intrusion
and mold in his unit and others throughout the building.
That lawsuit.
filed in D.C. Superior Court has been ongoing with plenty of back
and forth over the past 20
months. And Lambert claims that despite paying $15,000
in a special assessment meant to address
building concerns, that the building continued
to ignore these issues with the water and mold.
And the most recent filing on the docket appears
to be from just a couple of weeks ago on October
26th, where Lambert asked the court for extra time
because he claims that Metropole dropped
An additional 1,500 pages of discovery on him at the last
Last minute discovery involves documents relevant
to his ongoing legal claims.
But there was no recent decision on the docket
or something that may have led to sparking his actions.
But Lambert Sawyer spoke on Thursday night saying he
was surprised the man he knew could commit such violence.
Great spirits. He had just had some new beginnings on the horizon,
starting a new job on Monday.
Sunday.
So I'm at a loss for how things took any sort
of turn that would have us here today.
It is, uh...
At least as I understand what's being reported,
because I have no first-hand facts,
it appears that someone
who was also involved with the litigation may have also been affected
and may have been a victim of today's violence.
Again, there's nothing I can say
to justify any actions that took place.
Lambert's lawyer also alluded to next steps in the lawsuit,
although it's unclear
whether there will be an estate to take over
the fight against the condo building
or what exactly happens next.
Meantime, in Fairfax County, more than two dozen
plea agreements in criminal cases were rejected
by judges over the last year. Generally,
Judges don't often reject plea agreements when prosecutors
and defense attorneys are on the same page about the consequences
that someone should face for committing a crime.
But it appears multiple judges rejected more than two dozen plea
agreements in the last year in Fairfax County in a range of cases,
from child abuse to assault to animal cruelty.
A nine-year-old boy told police
that Shanoah Darlene Camp beat him with metal rods and cords,
forced him into a locked bedroom every day where he
was made to urinate in a bottle and sleep on
the floor between 2022 and 2024. Camp was indicted for child abuse.
Two different judges rejected two
different plea agreements because they were insufficient.
Judge Dipti Padikkati-Smith
ultimately accepted a deal giving Camp five months in jail.
DeShawn Kalique Williams was charged
with abducting his partner in January.
Williams also kept her from police trying to intervene,
who could see that she struggled
to open her left eye. The sentencing guidelines
recommended jail time between one year and 10
months, up to five years and three months.
The original plea deal proposed no active
incarceration. Judge David Obolon rejected the deal
while noting he was not criticizing
the attorneys in the negotiation,
but he said the deal was insufficient given the facts.
Brian Rojas barricaded himself
in a showdown with police in December 2023.
According to court records,
he swung a machete at an officer and was arrested for
attempted malicious wounding of a police officer.
Officers also found a kitten
in his apartment brutally beaten and stabbed.
The judge who rejected the plea deal accused
the Commonwealth's attorney's office of failing
to provide details about the cat's injuries and death after attempting
to drop the animal abuse charge from a felony to a misdemeanor.
Quote, the Commonwealth's repeated failure
to fully inform the court of the severity,
lethality and brutality of the injuries distorted these proceedings.
It also looks like the Commonwealth's attorney eventually dropped
the charges against Rojas and Williams as well.
We've reached out to their office for comment,
but have not yet heard back.
Meantime, the fight continues
in court over President Trump's triumphal arch.
This week, President John F. Kennedy's family filed a lawsuit separate
from those that have already been filed by veterans.
Virginia and the district claiming that the arch would cast a shadow
over the eternal flame and the Kennedy family memorial at Arlington.
The suit says the arch will obstruct the clear sight line
of the Kennedy grave sites and the JFK eternal flame
in Arlington National Cemetery from the Arlington Memorial Bridge,
destroying an essential element of the grave sites design.
And according to a forensic study,
the arch will permanently cast a shadow over the Kennedy
grave sites and the graves of servicemen and women who.
Who made the ultimate sacrifice for this country.
Like the other suits filed over the arch, they too argue
that congressional approval is required before Trump can build.
Also this week, the Supreme Court cleared the way
for the Trump administration to continue building
a border wall in the Big Bend region of Texas.
A district court judge had temporarily blocked the construction
after challengers argued that DHS secretaries Kristi Noem
and Mark Wayne Mullen violated the law when they waived certain
environmental and conservation requirements to put up the wall.
The order was brief. It was also unsigned by way
of the shadow docket or emergency docket.
But Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said she disagreed
with the court's decision.
In Manassas this week,
Naresh Bhat was found guilty of murdering his wife, Mamta Khafli Bhat,
after he admitted to dismembering her body
on the witness stand in his defense.
After a trial that took weeks, jurors reached a verdict in just hours.
We're going to bring in trial attorney Mike Hollingsworth
to break down this heartbreaking case.
Mike, thanks for being with us tonight.
You know, there's a saying in the law,
if the law isn't on your side, pound the facts.
If the facts are not on your side, pound the law.
And if neither are on your side, pound the table.
And I just can't imagine that this is anything else other than
that with this decision at the end of the case to admit
to dismembering her body after what seemed like two years of lying,
although I know he refuted that on the witness stand.
Take us behind the scenes of a possible conversation
with defense counsel here.
I mean, what made this the best strategy?
I honestly do not know.
I've been racking my brain about this ambush of strategy by
the defense here. I don't really get it.
Now, I will say there was this attempt by the defense
to call this lawyer that represented Mr. Bhatt,
I guess, at the outset of this investigation in 2024.
They wanted to try to show that, hey, he said this back then too.
So you should believe him now.
And we're going to offer this lawyer's testimony to
corroborate what he's told you today on the stand
that he didn't just make it up a few days ago.
But at the end of the day, A, that's not admissible.
Plus, they forgot to put the guy
on the witness list, which is just unfathomable in a case like this.
But I don't know, to be
honest with you. I do not know other than they didn't have
a real strategy coming in.
Um, and they pivoted once they thought they had no other choice,
but in a case of this
magnitude that got the coverage it did, it's a bizarre decision.
You say it's unfathomable.
I understand that.
Um, but explain to audience members
who have not gone to law school or been through a trial,
why it is unfathomable to forget someone
or not put someone on a witness list and what
a witness list is.
Yeah, no question about it.
So in these trials, there's discovery involves basically a full
disclosure of not every tactical thing you're going to do in a case,
but who your witnesses
are going to be. And the Commonwealth has other things they have
to disclose. If you're going to
use forensic evidence, if you're going to use an expert,
so the other side can fairly prepare.
So it's not this ambush situation.
Now, take it all the way back to when
you first get a case like this.
You have to decide then, okay, what are the facts?
What is our story? What is the theme?
How do we frame the case? And especially in a case like
this, is the defendant going to testify? If he is,
Then preparation starts immediately.
It's meticulous. It's repetitive. It is rehearsed.
You select language. You go over emotions.
You anticipate cross-examination.
I don't know whether that was done here.
I'm not going to say because I wasn't there.
But that is how it goes. If he's not going to testify, then that is a
decision that needs to be made early as well because,
again, it frames the case.
So if your client's going to take the stand,
that is obviously very impactful, very important case
changing evidence. Also,
you want to tell the jury about it in your opening statement.
You want to give the jury your theory
so that they're thinking about it. And then you weave
in your theory in your cross-examination
of the Commonwealth witnesses. In this case,
the theory that was introduced to the jury
and framed in the beginning was completely different
From what wound up being the defense case toward
the end of the trial, which is law
school 101, you don't tell the jury one thing and then switch later.
Because if you listen to the jurors
who talked after the trial, they made their decisions
on these obvious credibility problems and the lies for Mr. Bott.
But really not just Mr. Bott,
but everybody on the Bott camp was not being totally truthful
from the get go.
We only have about a minute left, but I also want you to speak
to if I don't know if you've been in this kind of situation,
but the willingness of prosecutors to push this all the way,
knowing from day one that they just had circumstantial evidence.
They didn't have direct evidence and they were going to have
to convince a jury on a murder count beyond a reasonable doubt.
That's remarkable.
It is, but I'll push back on that a little bit
because I don't personally think where you have
this particular victim with these connections
and this background and this available information
to build that circumstantial case,
that it is all that intimidating from their perspective.
Yes, they have the burden and all
of these things, but if you think about it,
They had all of the circumstantial proof of life
or lack of proof of life, right?
But then they also had these forensics
and the blood spatter and all that technology
and things like that at their disposal.
And in a way, they can't officially do it,
but in a subtle little way, it kind of shifts
the burden to the defense.
And I know they're not allowed to come out and say that,
but that's kind of what happened
here if you think about it.
Trial attorney Mike Hollingsworth, thank you so much for your insight,
both this week when the news came out and on the show tonight.
You have our audience learn more
and understand kind of what happens behind the scenes.
We really appreciate it.
Well, I'm happy to do it. I appreciate you. Take care.
Still ahead with the Democratic landslide in the midterms,
incoming leaders are promising to investigate the Trump administration.
We've got Maryland's Democratic Congressman
Glenn Ivey joining us to talk about that next.
Welcome back.
Democrats on the Hill have told
the Trump administration officials to lawyer up after
regaining control of Congress.
Their majorities paved the way
for countless congressional investigations of the administration's
wheeling and dealing.
But Dems are also in the market for a lawyer themselves.
They posted a job for House General Counsel,
basically probably going to be the most important lawyer
in the House in the next two years.
Joining us to talk about it, another important lawyer in the House,
Democratic Congressman Glenn Ivey joining us.
Thank you so much. Welcome back to the show.
Thanks for having me.
I want to get down to brass tacks with these investigations
because I can't imagine you're going
to be facing a willing administration
to hand over the documents or to provide testimony.
And not many people.
People know how contempt works.
Thanks
How are you going to enforce some of these subpoenas
that I know there are already letters
going out saying, you know, hold documents, get ready.
How is Congress going to make these investigations actually function
for
and enforce the requests
for information?
having
Well, usually you'd have contempt as an option,
criminal contempt would be something
you could move forward with.
The problem is just the Department of Justice
that would have to move forward with that.
And we all know Todd Blanche is not going
me.
to go against the Trump administration or anybody
So civil contempt would be an option.
Another would be, which I think is the most likely to be effective,
because the civil contempt can take years to work out in court.
I think you go after the private sector people
or whoever was on the other end of these conversations.
So you have an email from somebody in the White House
to an email at Fortune 500 company
that did something like building the ballroom
or something, why did we give you $20 million?
You get that from the companies.
I don't think they're going to be fighting Congress about
refusing to comply, you can still get a lot
of the same information you need. But I think we
still have to continue to litigate in court.
I think it's important historically, actually,
because I think we need to set a marker
for future presidencies that if you're committing
these kinds of acts, you're still subject
to congressional oversight, and we're going to
fight you tooth and nail until we get
all the information we should get.
One thing you didn't mention was that there
is an inherent contempt power that Congress has.
They haven't used it since the 1930s.
But you guys can arrest people and throw them in jail.
And there have been a lot of standards, let's say,
that have been broken in the last few years.
Do you think that's another one that might go,
or do you think Congress won't touch that?
Well, I think it's unlikely for a couple of reasons.
One is it's a big step.
You know, you get pushed back for impeachment.
Actually grabbing people and arresting them is another deal.
And I don't know how courts would react to that as well.
I'm sure there'd be a lot of litigation with that,
and you'd be raising the, because inherent
contempt isn't as well-grounded legally as civil contempt,
for example, and I'm sure
they'd be fighting that tooth and nail.
So the goal is to get the information,
because I think if we get the information, I believe
there's criminal conduct that's been committed
by people in the Trump administration.
This Department of Justice won't prosecute it, but the next one will.
And the statute of limitations runs beyond two years
for a lot of the things you're talking about.
Usually five to ten years, so we've got time to do it.
And Judgment Day is going to come.
So let's talk about,
I'm curious for how these priorities are going to work coming in,
because the American people obviously sent
a message about affordability and that being a
priority. But a lot of people are also saying,
you know, lawyer up, we're coming after you,
congressional investigations. You can only do so much.
I know you can walk and chew gum at the
same time, but you can only do so much.
And how are you going to balance going after what you
believe is criminal conduct with the affordability crisis
with Maryland in particular's priorities of
Both of those things. I mean,
what do you think Marylanders want to see?
In my district, they want both, and they want it in a big way,
especially the accountability piece.
We've got 30,000 people plus in the state of Maryland
who are forced out of their jobs,
federal government employees who are doing good work,
getting excellent reviews, serving the American people,
and the way they were treated was ridiculous, to say the least.
So I think my district might be a little different than some others,
but I think to your larger point, the accountability track, I think,
Is going to be critical, and the polls we've seen,
people want to see that as well, just like the affordability piece.
And some of it will depend on, you know,
what your personal situation is.
People that are having trouble keeping a roof over their head
and getting food on the table, that might,
you know, the affordability might weigh higher.
But for the accountability piece, especially if we're able
to show how it's led to problems with affordability, like...
You know, the tech bros getting things
that they shouldn't be getting, and that's part
of why your prices are going up, or price gouging,
the trade issues with tariffs and
the like.
I think we can do both.
And remember, we have, like, dozens of committees in Congress,
in the House, in the Senate.
Different committees can follow different tracks,
and we can all get to the same place
that we need to get on each of these issues.
You mentioned tech bros,
and you also mentioned going after administration,
you know, individuals where you think there has been criminal conduct.
Which do you pick first?
Who's your priority?
I mean, crypto has been making headlines, AI, those tech bros.
We just saw what happened on Friday with the FAA.
I mean...
What's the number one priority on day one?
Well, I think different committees will have different priorities.
So for oversight, for example,
the Epstein files is still a big issue for them.
Also, in my view, the pardons for pay,
I think, is shocking and disgusting.
The Trump family gets $2 million or so,
the Binance situation, for crypto payments, and
then a few days later, there's a pardon for the CEO of the company.
That's outrageous, and there are dozens of versions of that.
Also, there's just waste, fraud, and abuse.
Thank
$15 million for the reflecting pool, $16 million for the cage fight.
I don't even know how much they're going to have to pay.
He said he would do the ballroom with private funding,
but it doesn't look like that's going to be the case.
And now we've got NVIDIA giving $25 million for the ballroom, but they
got special treatment on how they were going to handle the chips.
you.
There's a lot to investigate.
I'm going to burn time here, but I only
have 10 seconds, so I need a quick answer.
But on the ballroom case, the Supreme Court said there wasn't standing
for the people challenging it.
Congress now with a flip in power, and this is a constitutional
question, so you might not have the answer,
but do you think that Congress or the House
or even the Speaker might have standing now
to challenge some of that stuff in a way that other people haven't?
I think it'll be easier for us to bring the case
because usually the majority is able
to get standing in a way that the minority can't.
It will be tested.
It's going to go up to the court, no doubt.
All right, Congressman, thank you so much for joining us.
Thank you.
And we'll be right back after this.
The 32-year-old son of actress Virginia Madsen
and well-known soap opera actor Antonio Sabato Jr.
was arrested for a fatal hit-and-run in Alaska.
The couple wants privacy for their son Jack after he
was accused of killing a 42-year-old man
and then fleeing the scene.
NBC News reports Jack is being represented by a public defender,
according to the court document.
New Jersey's Office of Attorney Ethics
is going after former Trump appointee,
U.S. Attorney Alina Haba, for her deal.
For her role in a deal that covered up a sexual harassment claim made
by a former waitress at Trump's golf club in Bedminster,
the office recommended that she face discipline, so now the case
will proceed to determine exactly what penalties will look like.
Habba has also recently come under fire
by her former boss, President Trump,
for an alleged $50 million deal she made with a pardoned
Venezuelan billionaire trying to get an in with the White House.
And to sports in the courts, former New York Jets head coach Rex Ryan
is accused of injuring two people after running over their feet
with his pickup truck in Nashville and then fleeing the scene.
According to the New York Post, Ryan was arrested on Wednesday
for the incident that happened back on November 5th.
He was released on a $6,000 bond.
The Post reports he's now facing six misdemeanor charges.
Still ahead tonight in the courts, I'm back with some final thoughts.
Don't go away.
Thanks for joining us tonight in the courts.
If you ever want to chime in and tell us what you
want to hear about on the show,
or you have legal questions or ideas or even guests.
You can hashtag us on social media at hashtag in the courts,
or you can send me an email with
your ideas, katie.barlow at fox.com.
We always love to hear from our audience, especially those
nerdy legal questions where we can hopefully at least go research
and find an answer for you.
We'll be back the same time next week,
but until then, have a good night, everyone.
I may not write poems in these songs dedicated to you in.
The mood for empathy, it's blood in my pen.
Better yet with your friends in them.
I really want to know you all.
I really want to show you all.
Pour up plenty of champagne.
Cold nights when you curse this name.
You called up your girlfriends
and y'all curled in that little bitty range.
I heard that she want to go and party.
She want to go and party.
Don't approach her with that.
