Today, I am going to list the 9 most disappointing cars I have ever reviewed. To be clear, these are not the 9 worst cars I have reviewed. This list is about cars that I was expecting to be good, but turned out to be disappointing.
Here's Why I'm Disappointed By the New Toyota Land Cruiser video: • Here's Why I'm Disappointed By the New Toy...
CHAPTERS: 00:00 THIS... 00:31 CARS & BIDS!!! 01:05 "Disappointing" is the Key Word 01:57 A Bad Tesla Competitor 04:00 The Best Sounding Worst Car 08:59 Who Needs a Windshield? 10:33 Should Have Had a V8 11:40 Disappointing, but not THAT Disappointing 13:56 An Unsuccessful Halo Car 15:43 A Far Too Expensive Porsche 17:33 High Hopes Not Met 18:51 The Worst EV 20:48 Final Thoughts
Doug DiMuro reviews vehicles that failed to meet high expectations, focusing on the gap between brand hype and actual performance. From overpriced luxury coupes to characterless powertrain shifts in performance cars, these vehicles are highlighted not necessarily as the \"worst\" ever made, but as the most disappointing relative to their potential.
This is Doug DiMuro,
and today I'm going to tell you the nine most disappointing cars
I've ever reviewed.
I get this question a lot.
Have you ever had a car where you showed up,
you were all excited to review it, then you
actually drove it, and it was really not, it didn't measure up?
And the answer is, not all that often, actually.
A lot more cars surprise me in the positive direction than
the negative, but it has happened,
and some cars have disappointed me
a lot more than I expected, and so today I'm going to
tell you what they are.
Today's video is sponsored by Cars and Bids,
which is my online car auction website for modern enthusiast cars.
Cars and Bids has around 600,000 registered users all participating
in our auctions of
cool, special, exciting cars like this,
and this, and this, and this.
If you're looking to buy or sell an enthusiast car from the modern era,
do it on carsandbids.com.
Okay, so the nine most disappointing cars I've reviewed.
And again, this is not the nine worst cars I've reviewed.
If you want to see those, you can go
on the DougScore spreadsheet and you can just go
to the bottom and those are the worst cars I've reviewed.
Some of them were so bad that they
were comical and it was fun and fine.
This is about cars that I was expecting to be good
and then were quite bad.
Disappointing. Cars that disappointed me.
And I think that's almost a worse position to be in.
I go drive a BMW Isetta or a Trabant or a Yugo
or a TukTuk and I know it's going to be terrible, right?
But you go drive a car that you think is gonna be good
and then it's really bad, that is actually kind of worse.
And so let's talk through
some of my biggest automotive disappointments.
Now, these are not ranked in order.
I do not wanna be responsible for naming a car
the number one disappointment.
These are alphabetical and you can decide
which one is the most disappointing
based on how I talk about it.
So starting from the start, the alphabetically
most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed,
the Jaguar I-Pace.
I remember when the I-PACE came out,
and it was like 2018 or 19, and basically at that
time, other automakers were trying hard
to get electric vehicles to market, and no one
was, and Tesla was just sitting there.
Grabbing market share from all these luxury car brands like they had
the X and the Model S and the three had just come out and
Everybody in Tesla was not only making the great electric
car, but they were way ahead
Frankly, they still are in a lot of ways
They were way ahead in the electric car that they had developed
and so the Jaguar I-Pace comes out and it gives some hope
It's like oh, here's, here's it. Here's a car.
This is happening. Here's a car
That's just come out, that's finally here to rival Tesla
And I remember driving the I-Pace and reviewing the I-Pace and thinking
Ah, like it just missed a lot of the what made the Teslas
so desirable over the air updates and
the supercharging and the range for dollar value
and the performance level. It just wasn't there.
It wasn't competitive. The I-Pace was a good car.
It was an excellent car for people who didn't want
a Tesla, but.
Especially at that time, before we knew Elon Musk was insane,
there weren't a lot of people who just didn't want a Tesla.
Most people did or were willing to.
And so the I-Pace was supposed to be this, okay,
here's legacy auto finally coming in to take on the big EV Tesla.
And it just was a non-competitive car.
And that became clear very quickly.
uh big deals and incentives on these cars to try to move them
and they never became popular
deservedly so and i don't know if it's still in production
but obviously Jaguar is like shutting
down everything to retool the whole brand
so that gives you an idea at least in their mind of you
know where that went and how successful
that was tesla ain't shutting down to retool the whole
The I-Pace was just a flop.
It just wasn't what it could have and should have been.
And by the way, that's especially true
considering how many years they had to watch
what made Tesla so appealing to consumers
and then try to replicate that.
And after all that time and all that ability to develop,
they just didn't do a great job developing.
Next up, most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed.
I'm not looking forward to the blowback on this one,
but it's my honest opinion, and I'm going to give it to you.
The Lexus LFA.
The Lexus LFA is...
Bar none, one of the greatest sounding cars of all time.
And I got to be honest, I have heard one recently.
It's always said that the LFA
and the Carrera GT are the two best sounding cars of all time.
And I got to be honest, you know, I'm a Carrera GT guy.
I've got one.
I don't particularly like the LFA.
I've got a Carrera GT.
You'd think I would be like, no, a Carrera GT is better.
But I heard an LFA driving the other day.
Okay.
Uh.
The LFA is better.
Oh, hi.
Thanks for having me.
The LFA simply sounds better.
I am really glad to be here.
It's my pleasure.
Have a great day.
Okay.
Thanks, man.
Thanks, man.
Have a great day, too.
Have a great day, too.
It's a better sounding car. They're both amazing.
Bye-bye.
Bye-bye.
Bye-bye.
And honestly, calling this the second best
Bye.
Bye.
sounding car of all time isn't exactly a criticism.
Bye.
Bye.
Bye.
The LFA sounds better. Unfortunately,
Bye.
Bye.
in every single other possible way, the LFA is not better.
Bye.
Bye.
Bye.
Bye.
And I remember going to drive that
Bye.
Bye.
Bye.
car and hoping for the best.
And there were some, there are some real drawbacks to the LFA.
When it first came out,
the LFA was an unsellable stone that sat on dealership
showrooms and nobody was interested in buying one.
And in fact, a huge portion of LFAs went
to Lexus dealership owners who bailed out Lexus
and just bought the damn car and said,
fine, I'll take it, whatever, because they
couldn't find anybody else to buy it.
And I remember when the LFA was going to first come out,
they had said there won't be any
selling of this car. It's going
to be leased only to curb speculation.
And then there was no speculation
because no one was actually interested in having an LFA.
And eventually they had to hire a full-time employee who took
the car around to various events trying to convince people to buy one.
It wasn't a good situation, and frankly,
I think that that's what the car deserved.
In the last few years, the LFA's reputation has grown.
Oh, the LFA, it's so cool.
And I see people now on Reddit and car forums say,
oh, I always loved the LFA.
It's like, no, you didn't.
I was there.
I was of age.
In 2012, I was like 25.
I was working for a car company.
I was paying attention to what was going on,
and everybody was criticizing the LFA.
And now, 10 years later, people are finally starting
to get into this, oh, I love the LFA.
It's so cool.
I don't think it's particularly cool.
I still think that the problems
that people criticized it for when it was a new car are
still valid today, which is it has a very clunky,
bad, poorly designed, not good transmission.
It's just not a good driving car when you're driving along.
And that's a pretty important part of what you want from a car.
You know, the Carrera GT had a manual transmission that is sublime.
One of the greatest manuals I've ever driven.
I drove this car to work today and I'm like...
Always astonished by how perfect that car is.
The LFA, by comparison, clunks around.
The transmission is just so bad.
It's so clunky and slow to change gears.
And it came at this horrible era where we
were just at the end of the single clutch,
which is what the LFA has, and about
to start with the dual clutch transmissions.
And the dual clutches are just so much better.
And the LFA would have been great with a manual transmission.
Toyota has a history of wonderful manual sports cars like
the Mk4 Supra, but they didn't.
It would have been great with a dual clutch automatic.
And then it would have been faster and exciting and all that,
but they didn't.
And so it has this clunky, bad transmission.
The other issue with the LFA is it simply
is not particularly attractive.
Lexus really wanted a halo car,
desperately wanted a halo car to try to bring people into
the showrooms after they watched the success that Audi had with the R8.
And what happened was they priced the LFA too high
and they didn't make it attractive
enough of a car.
And so nobody really knew that it was there.
It wasn't bringing people into showrooms
because it was too rare and too expensive.
And then when they came into showrooms, they were like, this?
It wasn't daring enough of a car.
The R8 was this mid-engine, cool-looking thing.
And it also just wasn't attractive enough as a car.
It was not a particularly well-styled car.
And Lexus still felt that the Halo car was worth it after the LFA
and did a great job of coming out with the LC,
which was both more attractive and less expensive.
And frankly, I think the LC is the more attractive
car compared to the LFA.
You put them next to each other,
and people would pick the LC nine times out of ten.
Now, car enthusiasts watching this are
going to say, no, I would never do that.
You know the LFA is a special one, but if you show it
to a random on the street, the two cars next to each other,
they're going to say the LC looks better. They just will.
It was a better looking car. And so to me, the LFA was too expensive.
It was not attractive enough and it just doesn't drive all that great.
It sounds better than any other car, but it was a disappointment.
And the market, the cars have gone up in value to a level that I think
is ridiculous. The Nürburgring Edition LFAs are a million dollars.
I think that is insane for that car. It does not deserve it.
But I do take solace in the reminder that they only made 300 LFAs
and a regular one is still an 800 car,
whereas they made 1,270 Carrera GTs
and even the worst one is a million bucks.
And the market speaks loudly there.
The market prefers analog, attractive, good driving cars.
The LFA, I think, has become way more valued than it deserves to be,
but it's still not a market darling, although it has come up.
And frankly, I felt it was a disappointment.
Now, again, that one will be controversial.
Here's a supercar opinion that will be less controversial,
most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed,
the McLaren Elva.
The McLaren Elva is an absolutely ridiculous car.
I know a couple of really rich people
who are desperate for whatever reason
to get into McLaren's good graces,
and even they passed on the McLaren Elva.
For those who don't know,
The Elva is basically a 720s without a windshield or a roof,
and for some reason McLaren thought that
this was a cool idea. And not only that,
but they were going to sell it for two or three million
dollars. The market, interestingly,
a lot of roofless cars came out at this era. Aston Martin
had one, the Speedster, something or other.
Ferrari had the Monza SP1 and SP2. The market
The market didn't like any of those cars.
None of them have greatly appreciated in value.
Some have declined, including the Elva.
It was overproduced.
It was weird looking.
It is not a drivable car.
Who wants to drive a car without a roof?
It is just not a situation.
They eventually added a windshield as an option,
which went against the whole purpose of the car,
but they needed to sell it.
It was a great example of McLaren going too far
in the direction of making special cars
that simply weren't special.
Too many special editions,
too many special models,
just too far.
We'll
The Elva was probably the worst example of that.
Not only was it not special, it was just a 720S without a roof,
but they overproduced it, overpriced it, and no one wanted to drive it.
be
And I thought it was cool as hell,
right
it had some really amazing quirks and features,
but it just wasn't the type of car that I had any interest in using,
and I think that's true for most people who bought them, frankly.
back.
Okay, next car, nine most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed,
the new Mercedes-AMG C63.
Does not need to be a lot of conversation or dialogue here.
Everybody knows this car has been a disappointment,
including Mercedes-Benz,
who I notice has really held the release of the new E63.
And I assume that's because there was a scramble
to the drawing board to kind of retool
and not give that car a lesser engine like the C63 got.
The basic gist is the new C63 is a great car.
It's attractive.
It actually drives pretty well,
despite its massive weight.
But it is simply not a fun car to drive
because of its four-cylinder engine.
It feels like a Mercedes-Subaru STI.
And I like the Subaru STI,
but the Subaru STI is not a $100,000 car that previously had a V8.
Uh,
You just don't want to be driving around in a peaky turbo four-cylinder
when you should be driving around in at least a turbo V6,
but probably a turbo V8.
New C63, a disappointment.
I'm a Mercedes-Benz guy.
I own two right now.
I've owned...
12 probably in my life.
They're great cars.
I love a lot of things about them.
That car, I'm just going to tell the truth.
It is not, not a desirable car.
It was a big disappointment.
Next up, most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed.
This is also going to be a controversial one,
but it's, I don't, it's, I'm not that disappointed
in it.
It's the Pagani Huayra.
The Pagani Huayra is an interesting car.
Pagani made the Zonda and it was one of the greatest cars of all time.
I've been lucky enough to drive a Zonda not very far,
not very fast, but I drove one and it is an
unbelievable car. The dynamics are incredible,
the appearance is incredible,
the shift action, clutch,
it's all absolutely amazing.
The Huayra, by comparison,
was Pagani embracing their personalization and beautification
Really, really, really special.
era rather than the driving experience era.
And so the Huayra has an automatic transmission,
a sequential manual that doesn't feel that great.
Frankly, I find the V12 for some reason in that
car to just not really do it for me.
The Mercedes V12, it's a great engine, but it's an Autobahn
Fast engine, not a supercar performance car engine,
and I've had the same criticism with
the SL65 Black Series.
Taking that engine and making it into a sports car, that's not what
the engine was designed for. It was designed
for massive high-speed cruising. Remember,
the first car that engine went into was the S65 and the CL65.
Those were cars that were
intended to be cruising on the Autobahn
at 150 miles an hour for four hours on end.
Then some people repurposed that engine for supercars,
and it just never felt right.
And the Huayra had a lot of incredibly cool little details,
you know, switchgear and buttons and...
touches and I mean it was incredibly well made
but the problem is the driving experience wasn't
as much of a focus and the Zonda was simply a better
car to drive. I haven't driven the new
Pagani Utopia yet but the fact that they went back
to a manual transmission says to me that
they realized a lot of what made the Zonda special
and they went back to the driving experience part
of the thing and I have a suspicion that in time
the Huayra will be kind of viewed as the lesser
Pagani. The Zonda is the desirable one. It had a manual.
It was really low production. The Utopia
Well, it goes back to the driving experience.
The Huayra was the beauty one,
and it was not the driver's car that the other ones are.
Again, I say this without having driven a Utopia,
so I don't know, but I love the Huayra.
It was fast, it was cool, it was amazing.
It's only a disappointment relative
to the other Pagani models,
but I would say it is a disappointment
relative to the other Pagani models.
Okay, next up, most disappointing cars I have ever reviewed.
This one is an easy one, the Polestar 1.
The Polestar 1, for those of you who don't know,
was Polestar's first vehicle, and it
was a luxury coupe that was intended to kind of be a halo car,
but what ended up happening
was nobody bought it.
Um, the.
The Polestar 1 was supposed to be like,
the brand is being revealed, and so they're only
going to build 1,500 of these special cars,
fully electric, and it's going to be like
the launch of Polestar, and it's going
to show everybody that Polestar's here, and they
mean business.
Well, the problem was nobody wanted to pay.
It was $157,000.
Nobody wanted to pay that money for an electric
car from a brand they had never heard of,
which was also Volvo.
Like, it was just never going to be occurring.
And so we saw Polestar's here in San Diego
that had fleet license plates suggesting they
were part of a rental fleet, Polestar 1s.
It just wasn't.
It was a cool way to launch a brand,
but like start with the special car and then trickle down.
But there just wasn't enough interest
in Polestar that people even knew what it was.
And there certainly weren't people who were willing to pay that.
You know, with cars like the LFA,
you at least had old Lexus buyers who were like, you know what?
I've always had Lexuses and I have Porsches too,
but they're going to give this a try.
So I'm going to try the LFA.
Polestar didn't have any people who were like,
this brand I love is making an expensive car.
So I'm going to go out and do it.
It was just like, here's an upstart making an electric
car that's way too expensive for what it offers.
could not possibly be worth this and that's what people felt
and that's how it ended up and the
Polestar 1 was not well received it did
not sell well I guess they made the 1500 of them but it was
a disappointing car especially at that price point it
was really intended to be this special halo car
it just didn't quite have that effect the styling
was too restrained the performance was nothing
really special to write home about it just
wasn't special enough to justify its price tag
and it was this upstart brand
that just couldn't justify a car like this
Okay, next up, most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed.
This won't surprise people who know me
and I've talked about this a lot on the podcast.
The Singer DLS.
I drove a Singer 911.
Singer is this company that modifies Porsches
in an unbelievable way
that really dramatically improves
the older late 80s, early 90s 911s
and just puts a new engine in
and radically changes the switch gear
to make it incredibly gorgeous and wonderful and all that.
And Singer makes a cool car.
There's no doubt about it.
I drove a Singer DLS.
It was a two and a half million dollar car.
And I've never driven a better half million dollar car.
Like that's the thing about the Singers is they're amazing.
They're special.
They're absolutely incredible.
Awesome cars.
Really incredible.
But at two and a half million dollars, it's just hard for me.
I'm just not enough of a Porsche guy.
I'm not enough of one of those like watch enthusiasts
who loves like the little button,
how the machined face of that dial.
I just don't get into those little details quite enough,
I think, to appreciate what
the Singer is and what the Singer offers.
And as wonderful of a car as that is,
I just can't justify that price tag.
And so I wasn't disappointed in the car.
It drove well.
The stuff is cool, the way it looks, the way it feels.
But I'm thinking for $2.5 million, there are...
So many really truly amazing, F40s and Carrera GTs,
so many truly amazing special supercars out
there. It's just difficult to justify what is ultimately,
to me, a modified Porsche 911. Now,
there are people who wince at that and say,
this is not a modified 911. It is a 911 completely
reimagined in this incredible way
by this incredible company who takes this thing to a
totally different level.
And that is true, but I just think a lot of that stuff is lost on me
at that price point. So again, this is my list
with my subjective opinions of cars that disappointed
And that's where I fall on that.
It is definitely not necessarily an opinion
that is shared by everybody, but it's just
how I feel.
Okay, two more most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed,
and they're both Toyotas.
Uh, one is the new Land Cruiser.
I actually did a video solely devoted
to how much I dislike the new Land Cruiser, and you
can go watch that, I'll link it below.
But the general thought is, the general gist is,
it's just not a Land Cruiser, it's not
particularly compelling compared
to other Toyota models, I don't really like how it
looks, I don't really like the powertrains,
I don't think that the seating configuration
is great, they don't offer third row, there's,
there's a lot of disappointing things about
the new Land Cruiser, and I say this as a guy
who had two previous Land Cruisers, and
has a brand new Toyota Sequoia,
I am a Toyota truck guy through and through, I've had three
Like, I am into this market segment,
and the new Land Cruiser really, really disappointed me.
Clearly, the Sequoia TRD Pro and Platinum have moved
into the segment where the Land Cruiser used to be,
and the new Land Cruiser is really kind of just a gussied-up—I mean,
it's a gussied-up 4Runner.
It's not literally, but, like,
the 4Runner offers basically everything the Land Cruiser does,
except the Land Cruiser has this brand name,
and so some people will pay more for that, but not—
Not the most educated people, I would say.
It's people who want to look cool.
People who actually believe in off-roading and capability, etc.
will either get a Sequoia or a 4Runner, depending on their point of view.
Land Cruiser is just...
It's not the car that I was hoping it would be.
When they took it away, it went away for a few years.
They announced it would come back.
I had really high hopes, and they didn't deliver.
And the other most disappointing
car I've ever reviewed is also a Toyota.
This is an obvious one.
The Toyota bZ4X and its twin, the Subaru Solterra.
Toyota has been very slow to enter into the electric car world.
And I think one of the big reasons
for this is that they don't necessarily think that electric
is going to be the story of the future.
That could be true. They finally had to enter into
the EV space for compliance reasons.
There were various governments that forced them to. And so
they came out with this BZ4X. It is ugly.
It is poorly named. It's a lowercase b, uppercase z,
number four, uppercase x.
Uh, the body cladding is a disaster.
The price is way too high. The electric range is terrible.
The cars are only selling with massive discounts and incentives.
And Toyota is using this as an
example to say, well, see, nobody likes electric cars.
We don't need to make an electric car.
We're being forced to make one.
And it's like, um, no, you made a bad one. Like people buy
Teslas because they're good.
Like they are good cars and good values. You just made a bad one.
In fact, the worst one. And I think the BZ4X
and the Solterra are the worst electric cars on sale,
or at least up in the top five, and it's very disappointing.
I didn't go in thinking they'd be great,
but I was hoping that Toyota, a company that really makes great cars,
would have their take on an EV also be great.
It was like we waited a while for the Toyota EV. It finally came out.
I was really hoping for the best, and we did not get the best.
We did not get a great effort from Toyota for that car.
It has been a disappointment, no question about it.
They are the only Toyotas sitting on dealership lots.
Toyota is in a huge hot streak right now
with a lot of great cars that are very successful.
And most Toyotas are selling tremendously.
Except for the BZ4X and the Solterra.
Just very disappointing, not successful cars.
And it's a shame that after all that waiting,
that is what Toyota decided to do with the EV.
They could have taken their brand name,
the name that gave us the Prius,
one of the first hybrid cars,
and really given us like an amazing electric car.
And they decided not to do that.
They really mailed in the development
and gave us a mediocre car.
And I think it's a shame.
So there you go.
My most disappointing cars I've ever reviewed.
Obviously, I'm aware this list
is going to be tremendously controversial
and people will hate me.
So be it, bring on the hate, I can take it.
And remember, these are my opinions,
I'm not stating any of this as fact, it's just how
I feel.
I'm sorry if you own a Subaru Solterra.
I'm really sorry actually.
Bye bye!