The Best Crème Brûlée and Millionaire's Shortbread: Our Favorite Desserts | America's Test Kitchen

Foods Short
5 followers
1 Video View·Nov 16, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedIn this video, the hosts prepare two classic desserts—Millionaire Shortbread and Crème Brûlée—alongside a celebratory \"ATK Red\" French 75 cocktail to honor long-time colleagues and the 25th anniversary of the show.
Get ready for the grand finale,
because we're going to finish on a high note with,
I'm not going to say our oldest colleagues, because you guys.
What?
Original, please.
Original colleagues from way back when we started the TV show.
These guys have been on camera with us since the very beginning.
It's the OGs.
It's the OGs.
Adam, Jack, and Becky.
We're going to cook dessert for you.
Yeah.
All right.
We've got some great desserts coming up, too.
Joy is making a creme brulee.
This recipe's really withstood the test of time.
Yeah.
Now I'm going to make a millionaire shortbread,
which is one of my favorite things to bake
around the holidays.
And I give them as gifts.
All right.
So very easy to do.
I'm going to start off with the crust.
So I've got some all purpose flour.
This is 12 and a half ounces or two and a half cups.
I've got a half cup of granulated sugar and a little bit of salt.
This is three quarter teaspoon of table salt.
I always like to use table salt when I'm baking.
Just whisk this together.
I've got two sticks of butter here,
so 16 tablespoons of unsalted butter.
I'm going to combine this.
All right, that looks good enough.
So now this is going to go into a 9-by-13-inch baking pan.
Gonna crumble this mixture in there.
Lined it with foil.
Now, the foil sling, as you guys know,
gotta love the foil sling, right?
Game-changer.
Yeah, it was a game-changer.
It's great because it makes everything basically
a springform pan, right?
Removable bottoms, fantastic.
Even like brownies, I always use the foil sling
because why not, right?
So I'm just going to dock this about every inch or so.
And that's just to keep it from puffing up too much.
All right this is going to go into a 350 degree oven.
I want to leave it in there until it starts
to get a little bit tawny brown.
That's only going to take about 25 maybe 30 minutes. All
right so while she's baking that I'm going
to get the creme brulee started. It is the best
creme brulee recipe. The reason is the ratio
of yolks to cream is really incredible. And also
use a real vanilla bean which I think is really important here.
I think you can tell the difference.
Yeah oh you have to use the bean here.
I've probably made this recipe 50 times.
Oh wow.
Like, you can't make it with vanilla extract.
I mean, first of all, you do eat with your eyes, right?
It's painful, but yes.
Yes.
It makes the dish that much more special
when you see the vanilla seeds,
you know, gathered at the bottom of the ramekin
when you go to dig into it, so.
Yeah.
So that was two cups of cream, two-thirds of a cup of sugar.
Lengthwise down the bean.
You want to split it in half and open it up
so you can really get to all those seeds.
And I'm going to pop the beam right in here, too.
We'll strain any bits out later.
So sugar, cream, vanilla, a pinch of salt.
Ha ha ha.
So I'm going to whisk this together.
Bring it to a boil over medium heat.
That's just to warm it up to help get the flavors out of the vanilla.
Then we're going to set it aside, let it steep for about 15 minutes.
The cream has steeped, and now it's time for the yolks.
An incredible amount of yolks, a whole 12 yolks.
So that's the yolks.
I'm going to add about half of this hot cream.
Temper, temper.
Oh yeah, it smells delicious.
Now I'm going to add a little bit more cream.
Two more cups of heavy cream.
I'm going to strain it.
Just get out the seed pods, any bits of egg yolk we don't want.
All right, so I divided this mixture between these ramekins.
It's in a pan.
I lined the bottom of the pan with a dish towel,
which is a trick I learned here.
Prevents the ramekins from sliding around in the oven.
Into the oven it goes 300 degrees with a water bath.
So I have a kettle full of water here.
All right.
I'm going to pull this out for you.
You're giving the task to me.
Oh yeah.
I've learned my lesson.
I don't do this.
All right.
The full thing?
Well, you know, about halfway up thereabouts.
All right.
So about half an hour thereabouts.
I'm going to give you that because I think the crust is ready.
Ready?
Oh!
That smells good. I'm getting like the aroma is the wafting this way.
That's right.
Smells terrible. You won't like it. I have to eat it all.
It doesn't smell good at all.
It does smell good.
It smells like shortbread. How about that?
You can see it's tawny brown. If you press on it,
it's a little bit firm. While that is cooling,
we're going to make our toffee. We're going to
start with sweetened condensed milk.
This is a 14 ounce can. All right. Now we want some brown
Brown sugar. This is a cup or seven ounces of brown sugar.
You can use dark or light.
We've got a half cup of corn syrup.
This is just really to prevent any crystallization.
It's also a little less sweet than sugar,
so I'm gonna add that in there. A lot of people
don't think that. A half a cup of heavy cream,
all right, and eight tablespoons of butter,
half a teaspoon of table salt. So I'm going to turn this to medium.
So we're gonna let this go.
I'm gonna keep an eye on it and stir it pretty frequently.
It's gonna go between 16 to 20 minutes.
But what I'm looking for with my instant read thermometer,
can't live without this thing,
can't bake without this thing for sure.
I'm looking for a temperature between 236 and 239.
So we're not looking for a hard toffee here.
This is a nice, soft, pourable toffee.
It might stall.
This is what I have found.
There's always a stalling point anytime
that you're making caramel or toffee.
It just stops raising in temperature until the water's boiled off.
And then it just shoots right up.
Oh, it's absorbing all the energy.
Yes.
It can only stay under 212 until the water's gone.
Ah, that makes sense.
Yeah.
Again, it's only going to take 16, 20 minutes.
Nice.
All right.
So we are near the end of this process here
of making this beautiful toffee.
I'm looking for 236 to 239.
Right.
Softball stage.
Exactly.
All right, we are almost there.
Oh, you can see the color just changed.
Yep.
It just got a shade darker.
I see it.
All right.
Thanks, Jay.
This is going to go right over.
Oh my God.
That is beautiful.
It is so hot.
Now I'm going to use a little baby offset spatula
to kind of level it out.
We're going to leave this for about an hour and a half minimum.
So let that cool completely.
All right, let's go check those creme brulee.
Oh, it looks sick.
Made it.
The old school way to tell if these are done
is you just shake one
and it should look like that.
It should just sort of shimmy like Bridget.
Urgent.
So again, you're looking for a temperature between 170
and 175, 174 on the nose.
You do want to get these out of the hot water,
and I have a quick tip I'm using, and Adam,
this I learned from you.
I remember when I was doing the quick tip,
a reader sent that, and it's like, that's
brilliant.
Yeah, so on tongs, you just put rubber bands.
It gives you a little extra grip
when you're working with a ramekin that could be a little
wet or a little slippery, and it just gives you a little more purchase.
These have to cool obviously at room temperature, about two hours.
Then we're going to cover them, put them in the fridge.
You want them really cold before you
brulee the top, at least four hours.
But you could easily do this a day
or two in advance if you're throwing a party.
Love what you're watching?
Take your cooking to the next level with our essential membership.
Get instant access to thousands of recipes, tips,
techniques, product reviews, and step-by-step videos.
Our Members app allows you to search by ingredient.
Set dietary preferences and save your favorite recipes.
For those looking to level up, our newest feature, ATK Classes,
offers more in-depth instruction led by ATK experts,
so you can gain greater confidence in the kitchen.
Start your free trial by visiting the App Store
or going to americastestkitchen.com slash YouTube today.
Time for the veneer of chocolate.
Before I pour it over the caramel toffee here,
I'd love for you all to touch the toffee, please.
Me too.
It looks like it would be super soft.
Yeah, it's harder than you think.
It's just a little bit soft there.
It's a little bit dainty.
You can press it, but don't press it too hard, Becky.
No, no, no.
Yeah.
I'm kidding, Mom.
All right, here we go.
Pouring that over.
Mmm.
Mmm.
I'm just going to continue smoothing this out.
Mmm, I know.
This is going to go into the fridge.
You only want to let it be in there for about 10 minutes just
so that the chocolate is set
up a little bit.
Okay.
I love how turbinado sugar melts.
A little more even.
That's about half a teaspoon.
Is this the cutest little torch?
Oh, yeah.
A little baby torch.
I know.
Look at my stogies.
Exactly.
This is what you would use if you have a cigar.
I like using...
I actually have a bigger one at home.
Jack, I'm scared.
I know.
So we're going to use this one.
Some of these you can hold upside down, some of them you can't.
Like starting on the outside.
That is a lovely sight.
Oh, right?
See, you get dessert and a show.
Everyone has a different doneness level.
This is mine.
This is perfect.
So we're just going to finish these, then
we're going to pop them back in the fridge,
let them really chill so that the top stays crisp,
but the custard is nice and cold.
Oh, it's gorgeous.
Finally, time to cut the shortbread.
That is gorgeous.
Yeah, it was just in there for 10 minutes.
Looks like a mirror.
Oh, it does.
Huh.
Bye.
And this is where the foil sling really comes in handy.
There we go.
If you wouldn't mind moving that pan.
You bet.
Ba-boom.
Just like that.
All right, so I'm going to cut this crosswise in half,
and I'm using a serrated knife,
just getting through the chocolate. You don't want to press too hard.
I'm going to start dispersing these.
Okay.
Miss Becky.
Oh, thank you. Look at this.
Mm-hmm.
Wow.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you, Julia.
Yes, my pleasure.
All right.
Two for us.
There we go.
I did work on something a little special
for this. It's kind of a surprise.
You know, I thought we should have a cocktail to celebrate ATK25,
and when I was thinking about this,
I was thinking about one of my favorites,
and Julia and I like to drink this, the French 75.
This is still London dry gin,
and we've got some pomegranate juice in there,
homemade grenadine, yeah, lemon juice, of course,
and champagne, and you can get all of that on the website,
That was a little loud, I have to say.
so recipe's right on there.
That's about two ounces of champagne.
Oh, that is going to be so pretty.
And it's ATK red.
It's ATK red.
Oh, all right.
I'm just going to put a little lemon twist on there.
Bridget, this is gorgeous.
There you go.
Thank you, Bridget.
All right, before we tuck into the cocktail,
how about we try our desserts?
Before we tuck into the cocktail?
Okay.
Yeah.
What are we going for first? How about the brulee?
Yeah.
We got to do the little...
The little fast back.
Back.
Oh.
Gorgeous. Look at that custard in there.
Oh, yeah.
It really is the best creme brulee.
Oh, my gosh.
And the top is perfectly crisp.
Oh.
Oh.
The texture of the custard is just velvety.
Yeah.
Oh.
And the seeds on the bottom.
Mm.
Yeah.
I was just going to say, this is velvet that you can eat.
And it's good.
Mm.
Break me off a piece of that millionaire shortbread.
Thank you, Fred.
You can see just that fudgy toffee in there.
It's not runny at all.
This is incredible.
Wow.
Oh, this to me is just perfect with a cup of coffee after dinner.
It's perfect.
Or with an ATK 25.
Well done.
Cheers to you all.
Cheers.
Your favorite test.
Cheers.
To you all.
If you're ready to take your cooking to the next level,
head over to americastestkitchen.com
and get a free trial of our ATK Essential Membership.
While you're there, you can sign up
for our free email newsletters and download our app.
So, what are you waiting for?
