The Law Is Not Being Used Properly’ When It Comes To Protecting Women And Girls | Maggie Oliver

VERTEX News
1 follower
31 Video Views·Nov 16, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
The issue is that the law's not being used properly.
It's being cherry-picked about who we decide to throw those charges at.
For me, every 50-, 60-, 40-year-old man who's having sex with a 12-,
13-, 14-year-old child...
Should be charged with rape.
I think the key thing for people at home listening
is that obviously we all agree that this grooming gang scandal
was an absolute stain on our country.
You know, hundreds and thousands of young people affected
and families affected by this.
You're talking about a seven-year public inquiry
costing over £200 million.
£1,000,000.
Under different governments,
different prime ministers, different home secretaries,
20 recommendations, and only seven have been implicated.
And I think why what you're doing
is so important is, as you say,
what is the point of having a public inquiry
if it's not worth the paper it's written on?
I think what you're doing is incredibly important
because so much energy goes into a public inquiry,
so much money goes into a public inquiry, so much
of the victims' mental and emotional labour goes into a public inquiry.
What is the point of doing this if nothing comes of it?
Yeah, that's exactly the question we're asking.
You know, this isn't just about grooming gangs,
but that is obviously a key part of it.
Okay.
But as we go into another statutory national inquiry,
this time led by Anne Longfield and my charity and myself,
we are helping in every way we can.
But as we go into another statutory inquiry,
the question has to be asked, why are we?
If those recommendations as well will lie on a shelf gathering dust.
And, you know, Louise Casey came out this week.
I met Louise Casey last year.
We helped with her audit.
She said that she is getting very frustrated.
I am very frustrated because I've been on this treadmill for 15 years
and I'm not seeing any progress.
And I think the thing to say, Ayesha, make your listeners aware,
is that what I heard in court this week.
Absolutely shook me to my core.
The barristers representing the government were saying,
basically, well, when it came to the implementation
of the recommendations of ICSA, well, kind of so what?
And their words are, there is no detriment to those 7,500 victims
by non-implementation of these recommendations.
They said...
That when it comes to pain compliance techniques against children,
that Alexis Jay and the ICSA inquiry described as torture,
that actually it doesn't matter that much
because it's not used very often.
They are the arguments
that the government's lawyers were making in court.
And I think it's really important to say that they are using, again,
hundreds of thousands of pounds of public money.
To fight a little charity like mine who's had to raise that money
to fight against what the public, what victims are demanding,
which is change, which is an improvement in how children of today
and the future are protected from abuse.
And they have complete contempt for that.
And I don't know why.
I mean, that is just incredibly disappointing to hear
because just the phrase, no detriment.
I was privileged enough to meet
some of the really incredible brave survivors
that you work with.
We had an event in Parliament a while ago
and I'll never forget meeting those women
and the idea that no detriment.
I mean, those women.
are going to be battling what happened to them every day,
every minute for the rest of their
lives. And we know the mental health implications.
Sadly, some women have taken their own lives.
You know, they often, the abuse never leaves them.
That leads to very chaotic, difficult lives,
mental health issues, addiction issues.
The idea that there's no detriment now is just
sounds so crass. It does sound so crass. So in terms of what
Obviously, you're going to be taking the government to court.
The other thing I would just say on all of this as well
is public inquiries, of course,
cannot compel politicians to do anything.
But surely it does feel, what about trust in politics?
You know, we have politicians talking about these issues.
What is the point of commissioning these inquiries
if you're not going to take forward the main recommendation?
Fully agree, Ayesha. And what the government barristers spent
a whole day, a whole half a day
on Thursday trying to say was that promises made
in Parliament are protected by parliamentary
privilege and mean nothing.
What we've had to show is that those promises were actually repeated
outside the House of Commons.
But, you know, if you can't trust a Prime Minister,
When they say we are going to bring change, who can you trust?
So I would like to see statutory inquiries and their recommendations
be implemented, you know, not just sit on a shelf.
I don't think even I knew that that was the law until over
the last three or four years, but I do now.
Well, I think there'll be a lot of people, actually,
in terms of not just the grooming gang scandal, but,
you know, the Grenfell inquiry, other scandals as well.
Look, I suppose, you know, if I was a government minister sitting,
I'm trying to put the other side, they would probably say,
look, Maggie, we were very committed to this.
We know it's terrible. We respect you.
We've put in a hundred million pounds in terms of safeguarding.
We've brought in a mandatory reporting.
We're bringing in tougher sentences.
You know, we'd like to do everything. We can't do everything at once.
You know, you have to you can't
do everything you want to do in government.
What would you say to that argument?
I would say that that is nonsense.
They haven't done anything in relation
to the main recommendations in court.
They were saying that it was a political argument, not a judicial one.
They haven't even published a timetable.
But the big recommendations have not been implemented.
And what price can you put on child safety?
You know, I've spoken to hundreds,
if not thousands of victims over the years.
They've been re-traumatized by putting their hope into ICSA,
into Louise Casey's audit.
Why should they engage with another inquiry?
I do honestly and truthfully, Ayesha,
believe that when there is a huge public outcry,
a government says eventually, OK, we'll have a public inquiry
because the public wrongly believe that that will lead to change.
What I have seen is that it is a political tool, as I've just said.
It is to escape accountability to, you know, ICSA.
And Theresa May first made those promises in 2014.
We are still we are now 12 years on still waiting
for the main recommendations to be brought in. You know, these are.
I mean you mentioned mandatory reporting.
My response to that would be if you're a teacher
or you're a social worker and you know a child is being abused,
you shouldn't have to be told to report that. That is part of your job.
We need to take personal responsibility for acting
when we see something wrong.
What we should be doing, I mean we mentioned, we brought up in court.
You know, there is no joined up system that measures and records,
say, sexual abuse, because that's what we're talking about.
But I will go right back to 2005 and the Soham murders and Ian Huntley.
Right. He was from the northeast, from Borderland.
And he got a job as a teacher in Soham.
And because he'd never been convicted,
a DBS check won't show that he was hugely dangerous to children.
And he moved. And it was said back then,
we need a national system that speaks to each other.
You know, we have kids that were abused. I knew in Rochdale going,
you know, a couple of miles into Lancashire police.
Greater Manchester Police doesn't talk to Lancs Police
unless there's a conviction.
Telford kids were being taken to Birmingham.
West Midlands don't talk to the police in Telford.
We need a national system.
And in these days of brilliant technology,
where you can't even say something out loud
with the following day your feed being filled
with things that have picked up your voice.
What are we saying? That we can't invest in proper systems,
that we can't gather the data because without facts,
without data, we are never going to solve this problem.
We will never do away with child abuse, 100%. But if we have systems
and services and policing that doesn't deal with it properly,
there is no deterrent there to prevent paedophiles today. No.
I mean, Maggie, you've spelled it out so clearly.
I mean, that's such a good example about Ian Huntley
and about the, I cannot believe we're here all these years later
and this is not a joined-up system.
I'm just conscious of time, and you've kindly agreed
to come back and speak to me for...
The next national inquiry, the hearings start.
So we are going to have another conversation with you.
But I just want to sort of pivot to another conversation
that I think is beginning to be had nationally.
And this is something that you have been talking about
for years, decades even.
And this is about consent and the age of young people
having sex, particularly with older people,
particularly older men.
Men, of course, in the light of this.
The stories this week, particularly
around Russell Brand and allegations,
there is a conversation now about what's known as staggered consent,
but there's a much bigger cultural conversation now going,
hang on a minute, is it really okay even
if somebody is just about legal
and sort of older men having sex with very, very young women,
some of them 16, some of them much younger, some of them children?
What do you think about this conversation about consent?
You know what, Aisha,
I'm actually really angry about it because we get these, you know,
celebrities and suddenly we get a feeding frenzy around one case.
The children that, you know, I mean,
you even we can even go back as far as Andrea W,
who was shouting out about this at the turn of the century.
Those children were 11 and 12.
The children I resigned over from the police
were being made pregnant at 11, 12 and 13.
This is not a new conversation.
So, you know, this week,
all our media has been flooded with Russell Brand and David
Williams.
I think the media needs to really wake up.
It is not a celebrity story.
This is a story about children everywhere.
And, you know, we do have to have conversations about it.
Even Louise Casey last year was saying that the, you know,
many of the children that I've helped over
the years have been 14 and 15.
The law says under 13, there's no argument.
Up to 16, there is.
We were having this conversation last year
and in Exeter and 20 years ago.
I'm glad that we're having the conversation again.
I do think the time comes though
that as a grown woman in your 20s,
we also have to accept personal responsibility
for our actions and what we do.
So the conversation when we're talking about children
is a very different conversation.
Thank you very much.
And young teenagers are out of their depth.
That's why they are targeted.
That's why they're groomed.
And that's why they're exploited. And that's why government,
police, social services must act to protect children.
Thank
And so Becky would you I mean, you see, I know this is very frustrating
for you because you've been having these conversations for a long time.
But is it, do you think, time for a bit of a change
in the law in terms of like some kind of staggered?
consent, maybe up to the age of 18,
if let's say the older person is a lot older than the younger
you.
person? I mean, it's a conversation, Aisha,
that I've been having for years. You know, Ruby, for
instance, from the drama Three Girls, yeah,
she was made pregnant at the age of 13, just 13. We
had a fetus, we had DNA, we know who got her pregnant.
The law was there to charge her abuser
And yet at that point, Keir Starmer
was director of public prosecutions.
Nazir Afzal was the head of the CPS.
They chose to charge that man with conspiracy
to commit sexual activity with a child.
It's not that the law doesn't exist.
It does.
For me, the issue is that the law is not being used properly.
It's being cherry picked about who we decide to throw those charges at.
To me...
Every 50, 60, 40-year-old man who's having sex with a 12,
13, 14-year-old child
should be charged with rape.
What about, let's say,
an older man having sex with a 16-year-old, 17-year-old,
let's say somebody in his 50s having sex,
so that legally, the law says they're legal,
but many people would argue you're still quite young at that point.
Yeah, you are, and I think you've got
to look at the whole surrounding situation
because the law says that you
are actually still a child up to the age of 18.
I think once you're 18, then you are an adult,
we have to view it differently, we have to take
into account that people also have personal responsibility,
but children are out of their depth with an older man
who is manipulating, in my opinion, a child, if it was an older woman.
Probably that woman wouldn't be able to be manipulated in the same way.
But the law does allow for charging in those circumstances.
For me, it's just that the law
is not being used effectively and properly.
That's the issue for me.
And do you think there's any world in which,
because I discussed this on my show last night,
and a couple of, quite a few of my listeners messaged in saying,
Is it time to raise the age of consent to 18
or do you think that's not appropriate given
the reality of when people become sexually active?
You know, I do, obviously, I believe in protecting women and girls,
but I also do believe that
we have to protect young men as well.
I've got three sons, so, you know,
it's not a black and white scenario when you are
While looking at older
For teenagers, I think the age difference is very relevant,
but I do think you have to look at each case on its own merits
and to do a blanket ban, I don't think would work.
I think we've got to be careful what we do here.
You know, I don't want us to criminalise.
young men for having sex with somebody
because that is part of growing up it is part of life
it doesn't make you a paedophile
because you are in a relationship with somebody who's a little bit
younger the very big age differences really concern me
but you know it is it isn't that
these things aren't known and anybody a police officer
or a public official going into these
scenarios should be able to see what's going
on and I think you have to take each case
On its own merits, when you're looking at adults.
Well, look, Maggie, I mean, I could speak to you for so much longer.
You know, so many interesting angles and all of this.
And you've kindly agreed to come back
and speak to us before the national inquiry and public hearings begin.
But I know you're incredibly busy at the moment.
Thank you so much for speaking with us, Maggie.
Thank you for having me, Aisha. Much appreciated.
