Iran’s nuclear knowledge can endure any US strike | Fareed Zakaria
Nov 16, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis analysis examines a hypothetical 2026 scenario where Iran survives massive US and Israeli military campaigns. Despite severe infrastructure damage, leadership losses, and economic strangulation via naval blockades, the regime persists. The conflict results in a strategic stalemate, highlighting the failure of military force to eliminate nuclear knowledge or resolve political instability.
At the beginning of 2026, Iran seemed weaker than
at almost any time since the Islamic Revolution.
Just six months earlier,
massive American and Israeli bombing had crippled its nuclear program.
Israel had decimated two of its key regional allies,
Hamas and Hezbollah.
Its closest Arab partner, Assad's Syria, had been toppled.
By January, Iranians had poured onto the streets
and squares to protest their rulers.
The regime responded with brutality,
killing thousands, perhaps tens of thousands, of its own citizens.
The Islamic Republic seemed increasingly isolated,
its legitimacy battered, and its military power severely diminished.
Then, on February 28, the United States and Israel attacked again,
this time with the apparent aim of toppling the regime altogether.
It didn't work.
The bombings destroyed most of Iran's air defenses,
hammered military installations
across the country, and killed many of its senior leaders,
including Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.
Yet the Islamic Republic managed to install a new supreme leader
and continue fighting.
For a regime whose overriding aim is to stay in power,
surviving an assault by
two of the world's most formidable militaries could
be counted as a victory.
And whatever their anger at their rulers,
few Iranians would welcome their country being
bombed by foreign armed forces.
Meanwhile, Iran learned to wield another weapon.
And unlike a nuke, which is actually hard to use,
this one could be deployed easily.
For decades Tehran had threatened to shut the Strait of Hormuz,
through which roughly
one fifth of the world's oil normally passed.
Now it followed through,
disrupting energy supplies and sending prices soaring.
Washington responded with a powerful weapon of its own,
a naval blockade that proved far more effective than many anticipated.
By October, reports suggested
that Iranian crude exports had fallen to zero,
even as oil shipments from other Gulf countries were recovering.
The result is a strange stalemate.
Even as on-and-off war could persist,
Iran can threaten the world's energy supplies,
but at huge cost to itself.
The U.S. can choke off Iran's economic lifeline,
but it cannot get Iran to surrender.
Neither has found a way to turn their military advantage
into a lasting political settlement.
And what has all this achieved
when it comes to Iran's nuclear program?
American and Israeli attacks have set back Iran's program,
possibly by years.
We still don't know exactly what survived the bombing,
how much nuclear material Iran possesses,
or most crucially, how quickly it could rebuild.
After all, destroying nuclear installations does
not eliminate the knowledge to rebuild them.
Nuclear technology is now more than 80 years old, easy to acquire.
And Iran has spent decades developing it,
training scientists and engineers,
and building a substantial scientific and industrial base.
Its nuclear facilities can be bombed,
but its experts cannot be made to forget what they know.
One also has to wonder what lesson Iran's leaders have drawn
from this experience.
After surviving two major rounds of US and Israeli attacks,
including an apparent attempt to overthrow their government altogether,
They may now be more convinced than ever that only
a nuclear bomb would guarantee their survival.
Some might conclude that Iran's greatest mistake
was not building one years ago.
There is an obvious deal.
Impose strict limits on Iran's uranium enrichment,
account for its existing nuclear material,
and implement an intrusive inspection system to verify compliance.
In return, Iran would get real relief from sanctions,
and some assurance that abiding
by an agreement would actually improve its security.
Now that sounds remarkably like
the nuclear deal Barack Obama agreed to in 2015,
which Donald Trump recklessly abandoned three years later.
But who would trust such an agreement?
Iran remembers that Washington walked away
from a deal Tehran was complying with,
and that this year the US attacked even
while negotiations were underway.
Washington, meanwhile,
has good reason to insist on highly intrusive inspections,
given Iran's long history of hiding its facilities.
Neither side believes the other will honor its commitments.
And without some degree of trust,
even the most carefully negotiated agreement will be hard to sustain.
The Shah embraced nuclear technology
because he believed it would help restore Iran's place
as one of the great nations of the world.
The Ayatollahs who came after him eventually pursued
the same technology
to protect Iran against its enemies
and guarantee its independence from foreign domination.
For all their differences,
the Shah and the Ayatollahs ended up with a similar conviction
that nuclear technology was essential.
Yet after more than half a century,
Iran has attained neither the greatness the Shah promised
nor the security his successors sought.
Its people have instead endured decades of sanctions,
isolation, repression,
and now devastating wars.
The pursuit of nuclear power, intended to make Iran stronger,
has brought it into confrontation
with the world's most powerful nations,
leaving it poorer and weaker.
The U.S. and Israel's military strikes have
not solved the fundamental problem either.
Iran retains the knowledge to build nuclear weapons.
While its leaders have more reason than ever
to believe that they need them,
at the end of this war,
the task will be for diplomacy to achieve what the bombings have not,
pressure and persuade Iran that it will
be safer without a nuclear bomb than with one.

