New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani was born in Kampala, Uganda, and became a US citizen in 2018. Under Article II of the Constitution, only a "natural born citizen" can be president. So why does this rule exist, who else has it blocked, and what would it take to change it? A neutral, non-partisan explainer.
Should naturalized citizens be allowed to run for president? Yes or no in the comments.
CHAPTERS 0:00 Can Mamdani Be President? 0:27 From Kampala to City Hall 1:36 The Rule: Article II 2:24 Why 1787? 3:05 Who It Has Blocked 3:57 What "Natural Born" Means 6:11 Around the World 7:06 How It Could Change: Article V 8:21 The Arguments 9:03 The 2038 Math 9:34 What He Can Do 10:10 The Verdict
Sources: US Constitution (Art. II, Art. V, 12th & 14th Amendments), Constitution Annotated (congress.gov), US Senate, Congressional Research Service, AP, NPR, The Guardian, Congress.gov (S.J.Res.15, 108th Congress). This video takes no position on any politician or party. Some visuals are AI-generated illustrations (marked on screen).
TAGS zohran mamdani, mamdani president, can mamdani be president, natural born citizen, article 2 constitution, nyc mayor, constitutional amendment, us constitution explained, equal opportunity to govern amendment, schwarzenegger president, us politics explained, milo explains
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores why Zoran Mamdani, the Mayor of New York City, is ineligible to become President of the United States. Despite his citizenship and political success, the \"natural-born citizen\" requirement in the U.S. Constitution creates an absolute barrier for naturalized citizens, a rule rooted in 18th-century fears of foreign influence.
Can Zoran Mamdani, the mayor of New York City,
ever become president of the United States?
The short answer is no, not today, not in 2028,
not ever unless America changes its constitution.
He runs the biggest city in the country,
he's old enough, he's a citizen, so what's stopping him?
One sentence, written in 1787. To understand it, let's rewind.
Zoran Mamdani was born on October 18, 1991, in Kampala, Uganda.
His mother is filmmaker Mira Nair.
His father is Columbia professor Mahmoud Mamdani.
At five, his family moved to Cape Town, South Africa.
At seven, they moved to New York City.
He went to the Bronx High School of Science, then Bowdoin College.
In 2020, he won a seat in the New York State Assembly,
representing Astoria and Long Island City in Queens.
He served there from 2021 to 2025.
In 2018, he became a naturalized American citizen.
And in November 2025, he won the race for mayor of New York City.
On January 1, 2026,
he was sworn in at an old subway station beneath City Hall.
The first Muslim mayor of New York, the first South Asian one too.
His supporters call it a classic American immigrant story.
His critics question his politics and his experience.
But on one point, both sides agree.
The rulebook is clear.
Here's the rule.
Article 2, Section 1 of the U.S. Constitution.
It says,
No person except a natural-born citizen shall
be eligible to the office of president.
Natural-born, that's the key phrase.
You must also be at least 35 years old.
And you must have lived in the U.S. for 14 years.
The residency rule has a quirk of its own.
The text never says those 14 years must be in a row
Or the most recent ones.
The founders simply wanted a president
who had lived among the people he would lead
long enough to know them.
Mamdani passes the age test.
He passes the residency test.
But he wasn't born a citizen.
He became one.
And under the constitution, that difference is everything.
So why did the founders write this?
Picture the summer of 1787.
Philadelphia, the new country is fragile.
European kings and nobles still have money,
armies, and ambitions in America.
On July 25, 1787, John Jay wrote a letter to George Washington.
He asked for a strong check
on foreigners becoming commander-in-chief of the army.
Weeks later, the natural-born citizen rule appeared
in the Constitution.
The fear was simple.
A foreign power might plant its own man at the top.
That was nearly 240 years ago. The rule has never changed.
And it has blocked some big names.
Arnold Schwarzenegger, born in Austria,
Governor of California, the most populous state.
In 2003, people started talking about an Arnold Amendment.
It went nowhere.
Jennifer Granholm, born in Canada.
Governor of Michigan, then U.S. Energy Secretary, never eligible.
Madeleine Albright, born in Prague.
She became Secretary of State, the fourth in line to the presidency.
But because she wasn't natural born,
she was skipped in the line of succession.
Henry Kissinger, Elaine Chao, same story.
Even presidents have faced the question.
In 1880, rumors spread
that Chester Arthur had secretly been born in Canada.
He hadn't. He was born in Vermont.
But the rumor followed him all the way to the White House.
Now here's the twist.
The Constitution never actually defines natural-born citizen.
And the Supreme Court has never directly ruled on what it means.
So the debates keep coming back.
John McCain was born in 1936
in the Panama Canal zone to American parents.
In 2008, the Senate passed a resolution saying he was natural born.
It wasn't a law, just a statement.
Ted Cruz was born in Calgary, Canada, to an American mother.
When he ran in 2016, critics questioned his eligibility.
No court ever ruled against him.
And Barack Obama faced the so-called birther claims.
He was born in Honolulu, Hawaii,
In 2011, he released his long-form birth certificate,
and in 2020, Kamala Harris faced it too.
She was born in Oakland, California in 1964 to immigrant parents.
A Newsweek opinion piece questioned her eligibility.
Within days, Newsweek apologized.
Under the widely accepted reading of the 14th Amendment,
being born on U.S. soil was enough.
So who counts as natural born?
Most legal experts agree on two groups.
First, anyone born on American soil.
The 14th Amendment from 1868 makes them citizens at birth.
Second, many children born abroad to American parents.
Federal law makes them citizens at birth too.
That's the group McCain and Cruz belonged to.
What matters is the moment of birth, not where you grew up,
not how long you've lived here, not how much you love the country.
A person who moved here at seven months
and lived here for 60 years still can't run.
A person born in Ohio,
who left as a baby and came back at 35 and lived here 14 years can.
Notice something, in all of those cases
the fight was over facts or fine print.
Mamdani's case has no grey area, born abroad, not to American parents,
naturalized as an adult, under every common reading he's out.
And here's something many people don't know,
at least 8 US presidents had a parent born
Outside America, Thomas Jefferson, Andrew Jackson.
James Buchanan, Chester Arthur, Woodrow Wilson, Herbert Hoover,
Barack Obama, and Donald Trump, whose mother was born in Scotland.
So the children of immigrants can reach the top.
Immigrants themselves cannot.
America isn't alone in this.
Brazil's constitution
also reserves the presidency for citizens born Brazilian.
But other democracies are different.
Britain has no birthplace rule for prime minister.
Boris Johnson was born in New York City.
In 2019, he became prime minister of the United Kingdom.
Quick question before we go on.
Should naturalized citizens be allowed to run for president?
Just answer yes or no in the comments, I read them.
So, how could it become possible?
There's only one road, a constitutional amendment.
And it's one of the hardest things to do in American politics.
Here's how Article 5 works.
Step 1, two-thirds of the House
and two-thirds of the Senate must approve the change.
Step 2, three-quarters of the states must ratify it.
That's 38 out of 50.
There's a second route, a convention called by the states.
It has never once been used.
Now look at the numbers.
Since 1789, members
of Congress have proposed more than 11,000 amendments.
Only 33 were sent to the states.
Only 27 became part of the Constitution.
And the last one was ratified in 1992.
Has anyone tried this exact change?
Yes.
In 2003, Senator Orrin Hatch, a Republican from Utah,
proposed the Equal Opportunity to Govern Amendment.
It would have let anyone
who had been a citizen for 20 years run for president.
Other members of Congress from both parties have offered similar ideas,
with different waiting periods. None of them ever reached a floor vote.
So what are the arguments?
Supporters of changing the rule say it's outdated.
About one in seven people living in America were born abroad.
Many have served in the military,
paid taxes, and lived here for decades.
Why should they be second-class citizens for one job?
Opponents say the rule still makes sense,
it guards against foreign influence, it keeps
the top job tied to lifelong roots,
and changing the constitution should be rare, not done
for one person.
And that's a real problem for any amendment today.
Once it's linked to one famous name,
people tend to vote for or against that person, not
the idea.
So let's do the math on the most likely version.
Say an amendment like Hatch's passed with a 20-year citizenship rule.
Mamdani became a citizen in 2018, plus 20 years.
That's 2038. He would be in his mid-40s,
still younger than most presidents.
But that assumes a two-thirds vote in Congress
and 38 states agreeing.
That's a level of agreement American politics hasn't reached
on any amendment in more than 30 years.
So what can he do? He can stay mayor. He can run for
governor of New York. He can run for the U.S. Senate or House.
He can serve in a president's cabinet
What about vice president?
Also no.
The 12th Amendment from 1804 says anyone ineligible
to be president can't be vice president either.
And even in the cabinet, if disaster struck,
he'd be skipped in the line of succession,
just like Madeleine Albright was.
To be clear, Mamdani hasn't said he wants to run for president.
This is about the rule, not about him.
So here's where we land.
One letter, one sentence.
Written in 1787 out of fear of foreign kings,
it has outlasted 239 years and more than 11,000
attempts to change the Constitution.
The man running America's biggest city,
home to about 8.5 million people, can't run the country.
Not because of a vote,
because of where he was born.
He arrived at seven, and even in the best case,
he'd be in his mid-forties before
the rule could change, if it ever does.