Slow-Cooker Black Magic Pot Roast Will Put a Spell on You | Food Wishes

Delicious Meat
141 followers
Nov 17, 2026
This slow cooker black magic pot roast uses black beer, black pepper, black garlic, black vinegar, and other dark and delicious ingredients to create the best pot roast this side of the Mississippi. Serve it shredded over mashed potatoes, ladled with its dark, complex, and delicious looking sauce, and this tender braised beef will put a spell on you and your guests. Enjoy!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedChef John demonstrates how to make \"Black Magic Pot Roast,\" a rich and complex slow-cooker meal. The recipe utilizes a variety of \"black\" ingredients—including black garlic, dark beer, and balsamic vinegar—to create a deep, savory flavor profile. The process involves searing the meat and charring onions to maximize depth before a long, slow braise.
Hello, this is Chef John
from foodwishes.com with Slow Cooker Black Magic Pot Roast!
That's right, we're using black beer,
black pepper, black garlic, black vinegar,
and other dark and delicious ingredients
to create the best slow cooker pot roast
this side of Mississippi.
And if you get that reference, you know your pot roast.
And if you don't, that just means this is extremely delicious.
And to get started we're going to blacken some onions
which I'm going to do on a lightly
oiled foil lined baking sheet
and what we'll do is pop those under the broiler on high
for a few minutes or until they literally turn black
which I know looks like a mistake but it's
not right those will provide
a subtle smoky bittersweet note in the background without
actually tasting burnt and once those are set we'll go ahead
and sear our pot roast over high
heat and a little bit of vegetable oil
and no we don't actually need to season the beef at this point
We're just going to brown that very well on both sides,
plus if you want for extra credit,
once the flat sides are done,
we can pick that up and we can try to sear the sides a little bit.
Alright, as you know, the more surface browning you get on meat,
generally the more flavor you produce.
Although having said that, the Mississippi
pot roast I referenced earlier is often
not browned before it's put in a slow cooker,
which I guess makes this step optional,
but I'd do it and think you should as well.
And once we pull that out of the pan,
we'll turn off the heat and splash in some water,
which is going to deglaze any
of that caramelized goodness from the bottom.
And as you'll see, we'll add
that to our cooking liquid. And once that's set,
we'll move on to the blackest
and possibly most magical of the ingredients,
which is going to be a head of black garlic.
And I'm going to go ahead and cut that in half
so we can take a look.
And this is not fermented garlic. It's actually just
simply aged until it turns black.
And to use it, we'll just pop it out of those skins.
And the taste is relatively mild and sweet and very savory
and a little bit tangy and absolutely perfect for pot roast.
And then what we'll do next is go ahead
and transfer our blackened onions into our slow cooker
and then we'll sprinkle over one packet of onion soup mix
which isn't black
but for slow cook and pot roast is magical.
And then we'll go ahead and transfer in some garlic powder
followed by our black garlic
that I smooshed up with a spoon a little bit.
Although this is going to cook so long that probably doesn't matter.
But either way, we'll follow
that with our final four black ingredients,
which includes some freshly ground black pepper,
some balsamic vinegar, some soy sauce,
and then last but not least, a bottle of dark beer.
And I'm using Deschutes Black Butte Porter,
which brings rich notes of coffee and chocolate
that are going to work beautifully here.
But any porter or black lager will do.
And what we'll do is give that a stir.
And then we'll add that to glazing liquid
from the pan we seared the beef in.
Oh yeah, don't forget that.
And then we'll transfer in our pot roast along with any
and all accumulated juices and we'll
go ahead and toss that back
and forth to give it a nice coating with that cooking liquid.
Oh and in case you're wondering thanks
to that extremely salty soup packet and that soy sauce
we might not actually need to add any extra salt
to this so be careful about just tossing
that in out of habit and of course as usual later we'll taste
and adjust if necessary.
And that's it we'll go ahead and lock on the lid
and on the low setting I'm going to set this to
go for eight hours. All right this usually takes between 8
and 10 hours depending on
all the usual variables and we can pretty much leave this alone.
Although about halfway through
I do like to uncover it and give it a basting
and just kind of take a look at things.
And I know you're a little worried about
those blackened onions but please don't be.
We're actually going to strain those out
of the sauce after they've worked their magic.
But anyway, after a brief basting,
we'll cover that back up and let it cook for another three
or four hours, or until our beef is just about fork tender,
but not yet fallen apart. Okay,
the fork should go in fairly easily,
but the meat will mostly stay intact if moved. And once it does
get to this point, we'll scrape those onions off the top,
and then we'll remove these chunks of
beef briefly to a plate or bowl,
which is going to make it a lot easier to ladle out
and strain our cooking liquids,
which by now have pretty much turned into our sauce.
Which, by the way, we could thicken if we wanted,
with like a roux or a cornstarch slurry.
But it is so rich and so savory, I don't think we need to,
and I really do think it's better used as
is. But in any event, once that's been strained,
we'll transfer our beef back in, and we will pour
our now much better looking sauce over the top,
and then we'll cover this, and continue cooking
on low for another 30 minutes to an hour,
or until that meat is very tender and shreddable.
Okay, so don't worry about the times I give you.
You're going to have to decide when this is done,
based on how it feels. I mean,
you are after all the Edgar Allan Poe of how long this should go,
but what we're looking for is something that shreds nice
and easily with two forks,
and we'll go ahead and break it up so it's easy to serve and eat,
and also so it easily absorbs the sauce,
which I don't think could look any more beautiful.
Thank you, Blackened Onion, and all your other dark friends.
And not only does this look amazing,
it's also going to be one of the most flavorful beef
pot roast you've ever tasted.
Using all those black ingredients just wasn't a gimmick. Each
and every one of them worked perfectly with the others
to create a very complex yet comforting
braised beef which we could serve in so many wonderful ways.
Over rice, on noodles, or even
served as tacos. But my recommendation would be on top
of some mashed potatoes piled up high and proud.
And once I was done making that magnificent mound of meat,
I spooned around some glazed carrots,
which I thought would make a great pairing,
then I finished with some snipped chives.
But no matter what you decide to pair this with,
you're going to want to finish off
by drenching everything with the sauce,
and you should have plenty for both soaking them
and for spooning over the top when you plate up,
which by the way I'm not going to do.
Okay, I was just too hungry, and this looked and smelled too good,
so I just grabbed a fork and went at it.
And I am a big fan of the shredded beef presentation here,
but classically pot roast is not shredded.
It's just served in big chunks or thick slices.
So if you'd rather do that, go ahead. But no matter how you serve this,
if you're a fan of pot roast, I think you're really going to love this.
Oh, and as I suspected,
I did not need to add any additional salt, but you might.
So after you shred that in your slow cooker, be sure to give it a taste
and adjust if you have to.
And while this would have been fine with just regular garlic,
I do hope you find and use the black garlic,
since it really is such an interesting flavor.
But as I said, very subtle,
so if you're worried about it being overpowering, don't be.
But if you enjoy the flavor of roasted garlic, you will like it.
And as far as other tweaks go,
this should be great no matter what beer you use,
or which vinegar you use,
or whether you experiment with some other spices.
So feel free to play around. Although, if you do use what we use,
You get to call it black magic pot roast.
Which you have to admit is a pretty cool name,
but even if the name was uncool,
this was easy to make and incredibly delicious.
Which is why I really do hope you give it a try
soon. So please follow the links below for the ingredient amounts,
a printable written recipe, and much more info as usual.
And as always, enjoy!
