In this video Top Gear reviews the new Audi RS5 Avant, and pitches it against the super-estate to beat – the BMW M3 CS Touring – to find out which is the ultimate fast wagon.
00:00 Audi RS5 Avant & BMW M3 CS Touring Intro 00:55 RS5 vs M3 CS 01:59 What Is the BMW M3 CS Touring? 03:22 What Is the Audi RS5 Avant? 04:13 BMW Exterior Design 04:42 Audi Exterior Design 05:10 Bespoke Audi Sport & BMW M Styling 06:39 How Both Look From Behind 07:58 Exterior Design Winner 08:13 Which Is The Best Practical Estate? 08:30 The Best Feature Of The M3 Touring 09:12 Which Has The Biggest Boot? 10:29 Folding The Back Seats 11:53 The One Big Issue With The BMW 12:04 Practical Estate Winner 12:11 BMW Interior Explainer 13:40 A Good/Bad Steering Wheel 15:11 Token Lightweighting 15:58 Audi Interior Explainer 16:43 Too Much Plastic 19:26 Boost & RS Buttons 20:36 Best Interior Winner 20:48 Sound Test! 21:36 Sound Test Winner 21:48 Audi RS5 Avant Road Test Review 22:00 How To Drift An Audi RS5 23:20 How Does It Drive Below Ten-Tenths? 25:34 Where the Audi RS5 Really Shines 26:09 Three Reasons To Buy The RS5 27:07 BMW M3 CS Touring Road Test Review 29:47 RS5 vs M3 Verdict
AI Generated·May contain errors
One question kept Audi up all night
when it was developing the new RS5 Avant.
How do you make
a better all-round super estate
car than a BMW M3 Touring?
Welcome to one of the grudge matches of 2026.
Stick around and we'll compare controversial designs on the outside
and what they're like to live with inside
We'll delve into spec, setup, space, speed and soundtrack.
to live with inside.
Let's rock.
Along the way we'll figure out if Audi has built
a worthy successor to all those RS2 and RS4
fast wagon legends.
So get yourself comfy, get yourself subscribed and let's get stuck in.
Now, BMW M and Audi RS tribes people get terrifyingly passionate about
their beloved
brands. They're not fans, they're evangelical disciples.
So, everyone stay calm and play nicely.
Already, there will be Audi stans whinging,
saying, well, that's not fair.
That's an M3 CS, that's too expensive.
That's too extreme to go up against the RS5.
And there will be M3 lovers going,
well, why have you brought a CS?
You're gonna say that's too expensive and too extreme.
Relax, there is no ulterior motive here.
Perfectly simple explanation.
We told BMW that we'd like to borrow an M3 Touring to drive it
1,000 miles from where I live in England here to southern Austria
to meet an RS5 and they chose to supply an M3 CS Touring.
We said we're not going anywhere near a track,
there will be no lap times,
but they thought a CS gave the M3 Touring the best chance of victory.
In fairness, the CS, or Competition Sport,
is the ultimate version of the current M3.
More turbo boost and an ECU tune ups the straight six,
which is now bolted to stiffer engine mounts,
to 543bhp and 479ft-lbs of torque.
The dampers meanwhile get their own bespoke software.
Like all M3s that we can buy in Britain,
this is auto only and four-wheel drive,
but you can make it rear biased
or rear-wheel drive entirely by diving into the touchscreen.
Cynics will say it's marketing guff.
BMW's factory race drivers will say
the CS is five seconds quicker around
the Nürburgring than a standard M3 competition touring.
But it costs a horrendous £126,000.
in pounds.
£30,000 more than a normal M3 Touring just to save 15 kilos.
What exactly are you buying?
A big bad contradiction.
A four-wheeled hypocrite.
A rubbish tip chariot with a carbon fibre bonnet.
A dog carrier with a titanium exhaust under the dog bed.
This is the German car industry at its most gloriously illogical.
The Audi is controversial for different reasons.
What's now called the RS5, not RS4,
is still a twin-turbo V6, but it now has a plug-in
hybrid element, and that makes it about
100 horsepower better off than the M3.
Except it's also 445 kilograms heavier.
And because Quattro is sacrosanct,
you can't make the Audi fully rear-wheel drive,
but Audi says one of the hybrid motors
can bung all the torque at one of the outside rear wheels,
so that should quell Audi's understeer nemesis.
All that said, has the new RS5, which starts at £92,000,
got the M3 beat for raw, want-one desirability?
Well, that depends on whether or not you've forgiven BMW for that.
I know we've kind of got used to the M3 beaver-toothed nose now,
but getting used to something is not the same as liking it.
Let's be honest, that is a truly horrid face
and the CS doubles down on the agro with these
nose-piercing front struts,
the red pin striping and the all-agro carbon fibre front splitter.
Whereas the RS5, well if anything, it's even more grill.
So much grill the badge is trying to escape.
Now I know the radar and sensor gubbings,
that's a bit of a mess and black paint slightly dulls the
overall impact but one of these in green
or red is a genuinely terrifying sight in your rear view mirror.
Where this RS5 crucifies the old RS4
is showing you where your money goes.
Have a look, there's barely a single panel
on this that's carried over from a normal A5
and they've even crafted bespoke rear doors just for the RS model
just so they flow nicely into these solid topped arches.
Why have they done that?
It's because Audi has finally remembered
what BMW's known for a very long time.
The stance adds menace.
How a car sits on the road is worth many tens
of thousands of pounds of the asking price.
So to make an M3,
BMW adds 75mm of track width to a normal 3-series,
but it leaves the normal 3-series doors on.
That's where you get this sense that the wheel arches
are bursting out the side of a normal car.
But Audi's completely overdone it.
They've added 90 mil.
to the width of an A5 and when you compare
that huge front wheel arch vent to this cheap and nasty
bit of plastic it's hard not to conclude
that that is an absolute brawler and it's left looking the
much more desirable bit of kit.
Part of me misses the days when fast Audis were subtle Q cars that
you could de-badge and pretend were a diesel
but you have to admit this new RS5 looks the business.
But at the rear the M3 fights back.
The Touring just wears the M division suit so well with the
wider arches, that rude diffuser
and the exhaust back box dangling out from underneath it. I don't
know of any car really which is so handsome from the back end
and yet so ugly at the front.
Now to be fair, Audi also nailed the back of the RS5 Avant,
it's a more raked,
window line which makes it a genuinely quite pretty fall away shape
but might harm the practicality.
Obviously light bar because 2026 car from Germany
and the exhausts are worth having a talk about
as well because for a start
and usually for an Audi at the moment they're not completely fake look
These surrounds are obviously a bit dressed up
but there's a real metal pipe there
with the butterfly valve in it.
But why are they also so much closer together
than fast Audi pipes used to be?
Well that's because modern cars have to have so much emission
filtration. This thing has to have
a speaker dangling out of its bottom to
make a little EV warble noise when you've got it in battery only mode.
All that's got to be packaged somewhere
and Audi's had to force the exhaust pipes closer together.
In the metal, having spent a few days with them both,
I like the BMW from three sides,
but the Audi from all four.
Thanks to that immense presence on the road, it's one point to the RS5.
But to win the beauty pageant, has it sacrificed practicality?
Now this is so much more than just what has the biggest boot.
Any soulless AI chatbot can tell you that.
But what I'm looking for are those clever features
that make your life easier.
Stuff like this.
The split tailgate. A piece of BMW genius.
Apparently they're thinking of getting rid
of this. They've already not put it on the M5 Touring
because it's heavy and it's difficult
to engineer and BMW says that lots
of its customers don't even know it's there when
they ask them in customer clinics. Completely oblivious.
I think that's insane. This is a reason
Reason to buy any 3 Series Touring, let alone an M3.
So much quicker to just throw stuff inside than waiting
for the main tailgate to open.
If you're a budding photographer or videographer,
this is a really safe place to shoot from.
It's just a great piece of packaging.
Then, when you open up the main boot,
the M3 really gets into its estate car stride.
See, in here, you have 500 litres.
Open up the back of the RS5 Avant, a mere 361 litres,
and that's where things start to go badly wrong for the Audi.
You see, there's no storage to the side,
whereas the BMW has extra wells of space behind the footwell.
In the Audi there is no underfloor locker to kind of hide valuables.
You pop this off and it's just
where you find the towing eye.
Whereas you jump over into the M3, locker here with wells of
storage for your first aid kit,
another one under there with a handy stand to keep it out your way
and then you've got the breakdown kit,
the tyre inflator, all of that gubbins and
These rails are built so you can slide things in easily
and then once the car recognizes that
you're on a slope it raises the rubberized bits in the middle,
stops stuff sliding around. The
Audi doesn't have any of that but BMW
is thinking about looking after your shopping.
And then there's this.
So both cars have handy switches in the back that flip the
seats down. There go the BMWs and if I pop over here and do the Audis.
Then now I've got 1510 litres in the BMW
and just 1302 litres in the Audi, so why has it lost
a third of the boot space the old RS4 had?
Well there's a clue, look at this, see how the BMW
seats when they're laid down they are sort of flush and semi-flat,
you can slide things in easily.
Nice idea, nice feature.
It's not the same in the RS5.
Look, I'll pop round and you'll see there's a huge shelf.
There's a ledge here.
And that's because under here...
There's a battery, a 25.9 kilowatt hour battery,
so your 52 miles of silent all-electric range
certainly doesn't come for free. It's adding loads of weight,
it's eating up tons of space,
there's nowhere to put your charging cable. God that's heavy.
And it's kind of embarrassing for Audi isn't it?
The inventors of the small-ish fast estate car
have now been outdone for common sense practicality
on BMW's first attempt.
One problem, be very careful sliding in your lengths of timber
or mountain bikes
because they'll make a right mess of your glossy carbon seat backs.
Otherwise, the M3 Touring is the superior estate car.
That's one point back for the BMW.
So the Audi is prettier,
but the BMW definitely has the better sorted boot.
Which then would you rather while away the miles in?
We'll start with the BMW's interior because it is more familiar to us.
This 3 Series has actually been with us since 2018
and they facelifted it in 2022
when they added this big multiplex curved screen
and deleted quite a lot of the buttons.
The big theme of this interior is a mixture of brilliant ideas
and banging your head against a brick wall stupidity.
Let me show you some of what I mean.
So, unlike a lot of modern BMWs, you don't have to go
into a touchscreen to change where the air is blowing.
Good, still got a toggle for that.
But you do have to go into this little submenu here
to actually change things like fan speed and more detailed stuff.
And the Audi is better in that regard
because its climate functions are always on the screen.
Still not as good as a button, but they are always within reach.
Then there's the instruments which are hopeless in the BMW,
it's like Pablo Picasso designed them
when he was feeling a bit poorly.
The rev counter's going this way, the speed's going that way,
there's multiple modes to change the displays
and all of them are awful, they're just a mess. Why is
there not an option to simply have E46 M3 dials,
the clearest instruments ever applied to a road car?
The steering wheel continues the theme
of snatching defeat from the jaws of victory,
so I've always loved these M1 and M2
Shrek ears because they mean that after just
a few minutes of setting up your favourite settings,
In the screen, configuring perhaps a B-road mode and a motorway mode
or school run mode and Nürburgring mode, it's all there at a thumb tip.
I can't believe that only Hyundai has copied
these shortcuts for the N cars. It's brilliant.
But then they're attached to a steering wheel
which is just unforgivably thick and overwrought.
I mean, why do BMW customers long to grip something girthy? Poor them.
Down here I mean we should celebrate
this because it will probably be the final BMW ever to have
the iDrive click wheel.
Now everything's going into a Neue Klasse touchscreen and what's
brilliant about that in here is because you can click one button here
and make two clicks on there
that's all it takes to make the lane keep assist
and the speed bong shut up.
Until you turn the engine back on anyway.
That is an absolute godsend. Engine start button
and then make the bongs go away.
These shortcuts having one button here to turn the traction
control off. People like that because it tells them
the M3 is a serious driver's car.
But then the CS takes itself too seriously
with its token light weighting.
I mean I've got no hidden storage here
because I've lost this cubby hole and no armrest.
I mean if you wanted
to save weight just take it off the steering wheel.
Okay otherwise it's a great seat,
you sit a lot lower in the M3 than you do in the RS5
and the visibility is noticeably less pinched.
So while it might be ageing,
I think with all these fillets of carbon fibre, the real metal
and the tactile buttons,
the M3 does actually hold its own feeling like an expensive car inside.
So the Audi is at a major disadvantage here
because it is the newer, fresher,
more recent interior and as we know
car interiors are all getting worse.
It's a pixel hellscape out there and it is no different in here.
Starting with this.
As usual a pointless passenger screen.
These are the biggest con in the car industry right now
because no passenger is going to spend more than 10 seconds swiping
at that before they go back to
using their phone which they're holding
so it's not moving about all over the place like a car.
It's signed into all their apps already
and it reacts faster than this so that's pointless.
So are these elephant's ears on the end of the main display,
these pointless thick plastic bezels that make
the whole cockpit feel like a toddler's laptop.
And then you start looking around
and you realise that that rich vein of form that Audi used to be
in for materials that made them the envy of the world,
that ended a long time ago.
I mean my volume knob, I've got one but it's plastic,
it's not knurled metal.
My starter button is plastic not metal,
my mirror controls and my lights down here it's all on this
glossy black touch pad.
Okay yes I've got some grotesque but at least semi-expensive sort of
kitchen worktop chopped carbon going on down here to smash my knee on
but the main fascia of the center
There's a console that greets you, you guessed it,
Piano Black, the scratch and dust magnet supreme.
While the BMW gives you that bespoke M
car shift lever which you can change gear on,
which you can actually switch the shift speed on,
in this I've got a cheap plastic lozenge
out of an A3. So where has Audi actually spent the money
and the time? Well,
There are some things in here that I do like.
Firstly, the steering wheel is the shape that
a human can grasp. That's progress.
I like the fact that you get a round rev counter. This is
a very busy screen. There's a lot of information coming at you,
particularly as this car has
two power sources, petrol and electric,
but at least I've got an old-fashioned rev needle.
And there's also more practical touches.
So stuff that matters, you have
Two USB ports to the BMW's one, you have generous cup holders,
you have an armrest with hidden
storage and although these seats are nothing like as special,
they don't have the sense of occasion
as the BMW's glossy carbon buckets,
they're actually squidgier, they're much much easier
to get in and out of without giving yourself a hernia and if you slide
you know big lengths of timber
or mountain bikes into the boot you're not going to scratch up the
back of these like you are the M3s
so you feel less guilty using this car as a wagon.
The details that I'd like to change,
I want the seat just to go a bit lower,
I do feel like I'm sat on top of the battery
which I'm not because as we've seen it's
under the boot floor robbing the space but I want to drop the seat down
And I'm not a huge fan of the way these buttons have been configured.
I don't think this works as well as the M3.
I've got a boost setting that's like maximum overtake mode,
which, I mean, just floor the throttle, right?
And then the RS button takes me to an RS menu
where I can select RS individual or RS sport,
but not RS torque rear because that needs a touchscreen intervention
because I'm...
Doing something that's not strictly allowed on the road.
So it's like a legal disclaimer thing.
And then I have balanced mode.
But to get into dynamic or comfort, again,
I'm having to go into the screen too often in the Audi.
But the Audi wants me to go into the screen, doesn't it?
Otherwise, why would they have given me the option
of a light submenu where I can choose my LED light signature?
How many do you think there are?
One, two?
No.
Try eight.
Eight different choices of animated LED greeting for your RS5.
If that's not evidence that car designers have run out
of things to muck about with,
I don't know what is.
By a worryingly slender margin,
the Audi just beats the BMW for overall interior common sense
and nabs the point.
But now, which car sounds the best?
Quick sound check then.
Let's fire up the quattro.
Always wanted to say that.
Oh yeah, that'll be electric mode.
Let's try RS Sport, please.
At last.
Bit of a V6 warble,
but it definitely sounds fruitier back here than it does inside.
And let's give the BMW the beans.
Such a hard-edged
metallic rasp.
That is only a pop and bang map
and a decat away from being perfect for the intended audience.
No contest there, the BMW sounds rude and raw and much more angry.
It has to win the sound check.
To all then, the decider will be in the driving.
Not sure what I was expecting from the RS5 but it
wasn't this, actually a fairly brutal experience.
The M3 is your classically trained drift artist,
the rear drive purist which slides
around when you apply traditional techniques
passed down through the generations.
This responds to brute force and algorithms.
You jab and stab at the touchscreen
until it gives you RS torque rear mode.
You treat the throttle pedal like it's a foot pump
and you have a bouncy castle to inflate.
Give it all the leg muscle you can.
Kind of chuck it in and hold on.
There you have it.
Some power oversteer on demand in an Audi.
But wow, does it just feel brutal.
I mean, it's not one for the mechanically sympathetic,
this.
You're aware that the car, this hugely heavy 2.4 ton
lump, is slewing sideways, but also it's
pulling so much traction and so much acceleration out
of the surface.
Feels like it's going to ripple the road up underneath you.
I mean what it's doing to drive shafts and tyres I dread to think.
What it's doing to fuel consumption
in your hybrid is single digits.
So it's massively more leery and exciting than the old RS4
and the current RS6
but when you back off from complete lunatic mode I'm not as convinced.
Because you've got petrol
and electric having this arm wrestle to deliver the usual Audi
teleportation, the car accelerates almost in a series of lunges
and when you're in a section of
twisty road and the corners are coming thick
and fast the whole car kind of jiggles and
jinks and wrestles from side to side.
It is exciting but it doesn't feel especially cohesive.
Then when you break it down, the steering,
the wheel is better, but the amount of feedback
isn't as crisp as the M3s and neither is the gearbox.
It is so easy to snag the rev limiter.
Plus when you lift off, and you really notice this at night,
the brake lights are immediately
illuminating even when you're just trying to coast because,
of course, the powertrain
strategy is now to harvest and regen electricity.
That's not really the inheritance from Audi F1 that we wanted.
So this is a car that doesn't really flow
and coast on a twisty road like this.
It's more lunge, slow, lunge.
Now, unusually for a fast Audi with ceramics,
we haven't actually set them on fire yet,
so that's an improvement, but because, again,
you're balancing physical braking and regen,
the feel is a little bit spongy.
Speaking of lacking the feedback you're after,
this engine, it's a supporting actor, it's
not the star of the show like the M3 where it's vibrating
and straining against those
granite engine mounts, this is prime mover,
it's, what do they call it in Formula 1 again,
a power unit, not very romantic is it?
So it's brilliant at being a yob.
But when you fall off that plateau,
I'm not enjoying the RS5 quite so much just as a
fast road car. Where the RS5 really scores again
is when you drop all the way back down
to what I'm doing now. EV mode, daily drive.
Then this becomes a really compelling all-rounder.
The ride is a lot more relaxed than the BMW in any of its modes.
There's less tyre noise.
It just feels like the car has more soundproofing.
Right now I'm sitting in a ventilated massage seat
and it's just simply a more luxurious experience than an M3 CS.
Plus let's not forget three very big ticks in the plus for Audi column.
Number one, if you're buying a super estate car through your company,
as some people are going to want to,
you have to have the Audi because it's a hybrid.
So in Britain and Europe, you get clobbered way less on tax.
Number two, if you regularly leave your house very early in the morning
or you're prone to getting home late at night,
then you have to have the Audi because
It can get on and off your property silently
and third of all I wouldn't blame a single soul if they
said I bought the Audi simply because of how it looks.
This is a great looking car
and when you compare it to the BMW I mean
that thing has a face they used to carve
on churches to ward off the devil.
It's a lot of money to spend on a gargoyle.
Lots to like then, but also some frustrations.
Can the M3 follow that?
Um, yes.
Yes, sir.
But the M3 doesn't just look alarming.
Each one actually comes with a jump scare as standard.
You see, you're driving along, minding your own business,
and then you momentarily check the rearview mirror.
Oh my God, it's a wagon.
Because it has this intent
and sense of precision you automatically assume
you're back in a two-door track coupe.
You forget it has a 500 litre hole in the
back. I thought the CS might be a step too hardcore,
I thought it might be too
extreme but no,
this is the best riding G80 generation M3 that I've driven.
It's just got so much control of its body weight, of its wheels,
and it deals with any road that you can put underneath it
so expensively, which is just as well, because the price is bananas.
If it was my money, personally,
I think I could make do with a standard M3 Touring and 30 grand change.
Maybe, I don't know, the CS's steering is so crisp.
It's the perfect speed.
The brakes are mushy in the comfort setting,
but you can put them in a sport mode
and the pedal feel is absolutely spot on,
consistent every time.
Don't get me wrong, it's taut, you know, it's firm,
we're not going to ever mistake this for a normal 3 Series,
it's unyielding, it's selfish, you know, I would feel guilty putting
my lovely Labrador in the boot, but that's only
because after a couple of minutes I would presume I'm in a Porsche GT3,
I'm in a Black Series, because it has that amount of poise,
if not that amount of outright performance.
We're not talking about a downforce meister here,
we're talking about a two-tonne family estate.
I'm in love with the M3 CS,
some of the interior is mind pulverisingly stupid
and it has the face of an evil warthog,
but it can do precision and speed, it can do misbehaviour
and it's daily usable.
The M3 CS Touring just doesn't do weaknesses,
poor Audi.
I think you can see where the scoreboard is heading,
but let's pull over because my real message is...
Buy a fast estate car and kill all SUVs.
That's actually the verdict here.
But if you want to choose between these two,
well, the RS5 is a fabulous looking car with a delightful interior.
It's an accomplished daily driver with a slightly undercooked boot.
And ultimately, it's not as fun to drive as the awesome M3 Touring.
The BMW is just that bit more exciting and
More practical, which makes it more versatile,
so it has to win for now.
You see, don't forget this car is about to bow out
and it will be replaced by two M3s,
a turbo hybrid petrol of some description
and this all electric iM3 and they'll be touring
versions of both of them and let's have a think,
they're going to be heavier than this
car, they're going to be more complicated
and they're going to have fewer buttons.
So while this M3 Touring can retire
with its head held high as a winner.
That might not be the case the next time we meet
an RS5 here for the rematch.
Thanks for watching.