MAJOR Mets Free Agency Update... Ty France Deal Incoming?

Mets Digest
1 follower
Nov 17, 2026
The Mets just finished last in the National League East
for the first time in 23 years.
And first base was a huge reason why.
Mets first baseman put up a .667 OPS all year,
and only two teams in baseball got less out of the position.
David Stearns didn't hide from it in September.
In this job, I don't get mulligans.
On Friday, the first real name for the fix showed up.
The Mets have shown interest
in free agent first baseman Ty France, per Michael Marino.
Today, John Heyman added that the Mets have checked in on him,
but Ty France is not the
name Mets fans were dreaming about.
That name is Teruaki Sato,
the Hanshin slugger who just won the Triple Crown in Japan with
39 home runs.
Stearns went to Japan to watch him in September,
and Sato hit his 32nd home run that night.
Now, the Mets are reportedly less inclined to chase Sato,
especially with Bo Bichette coming
back, per Will Salmon of The Athletic.
Did the Mets just pick the safe name over the star,
or is the safe name actually the
right one in this case?
Well, the Mets went 74-88 and got outscored by 32 runs,
and the trouble started with a
plan that never worked.
The plan after Pete Alonso left for Baltimore
was Jorge Polanco at first base, a position
he had never started a game at.
Polanco got hurt and finished with a .431 OPS in 145 plate appearances.
Alonso, meanwhile, put up a 148 wRC plus in Baltimore,
48% better than a league average
hitter. Jared Young and Mark Vientos ended up splitting most
of the job between them.
Young got hot late with an 802 OPS over
his last 59 games before a concussion ended his season.
Vientos, the right-handed half of that job,
had a .652 OPS in 295 plate appearances.
Add it all up, and the whole position hit 18 home runs.
Stearns put it plainly.
The totality of our production at first base wasn't good enough.
First base wasn't the only problem, though, for this lineup.
The bigger problem really was what they did, or should I say didn't do,
against left-handed pitching.
The Mets had a 6.87 OPS against lefties last season.
23rd in baseball.
Their top three home run hitters were Juan Soto,
Francisco Lindor, and Carson Bellinger.
Two lefties and a switch hitter.
Against a left-handed starter,
two of those three bats are hitting from their weaker side.
Not a single right-handed Met hit 20 home runs.
Bo Bichette led the righties with 18,
and he had a suboptimal 702 OPS doing it.
Marcus Simeon, the other everyday righty in the infield,
finished with a ridiculously bad 620 OPS.
Ty France hit 21 home runs for the Padres last season,
more than any right-handed Met.
France isn't the only first base name out there.
Marina has also tied the Mets with Alec Boehm,
and they've met with his representatives.
So I want to hear from you right now.
Ty France or Alec Boehm?
Who would you rather have playing first base for the Mets next season?
I know who I would choose, but you guys let me know in the comments.
France is 32, he bats right-handed,
and he just had his best full season at the plate.
He hit .295 with 21 home runs
and an .865 OPS in 133 games for San Diego.
Put that next to the .431 Polanco gave the Mets, and it isn't close.
His 139 OPS plus says he was 39% better than
a league average hitter after adjusting for
his home park.
It wasn't a platoon number either.
Against lefties, he had an .853 OPS in 138 plate appearances.
That's the exact split
the Mets couldn't find all year in their own roster.
Against lefties, the Mets as a team
were 166 points of OPS worse than France.
He also brings the glove.
In 2025, France won the American League Gold Glove at first base.
He led every first baseman in baseball
that year with 10 outs above average.
Now that part keeps this from being an easy call.
Before San Diego, France had been moved around for two straight years.
Seattle to Cincinnati in 2024, then Minnesota to Toronto in 2025.
In that 2025 season, he had a .680 OPS and just 7 home runs.
From 2023 to 2025, his OPS never got above 703.
And before 2026, his last 20 home run season was 2022 in Seattle.
The contact numbers say part of last season ran hot.
Based on the quality of his contact,
his expected batting average was .248,
not .295. He also chases a good amount.
He swung at 34.5% of pitches outside the zone,
a chase rate in the bottom quarter of the league.
Pitchers will notice where the damage came from.
A 1.057 OPS against off-speed pitches against .779 on breaking balls.
The power still does look real, though.
His hard hit rate was 47.4% in the 84th percentile.
His average exit velocity of 91.5 miles
an hour sat in the 86th percentile as well.
That's not a fluke swing.
That's a hitter who squares the ball up
and also chases pitches off the plate.
The Mets have liked him before.
They were linked to France back in February,
even after they signed Polanco.
They stayed with Polanco, and unfortunately, we saw how that went.
This time, the other option is a lot bigger.
Sato is 27, and his triple crown was the first
in Japan since Munetaka Murakami in 2022.
He hit .306 with 39 home runs, 106 RBIs,
and a .991 OPS in 143 games for Hanshin.
That's the upside,
and it's why Sato is the one I'd pick if money and fit here didn't
matter at all, and frankly,
I'd probably pick him even in spite of that.
The Mets have been on him for months.
Heyman first reported their interest in August,
when first base was already falling apart.
But numbers from Japan usually don't come over
to Major League Baseball one for one.
Steamer projects Sato for 23 home runs
and a .782 OPS in his first Major League season.
That OPS would be lower than the 8.55,
I should say 8.65, that France actually put up.
It's still a real bat though.
23 home runs would have led every right-handed Met by five.
Steamer has him at 1.9 WAR in his first year.
A solid regular, not a superstar though.
And the Mets wouldn't be bidding alone.
The Yankees, Dodgers, Phillies,
and Padres are all believed to be interested per Mark
Feinstein.
The Blue Jays and Rangers have reported interest this month,
and Jim Bowden named the Red Sox
as a fit.
With that many teams in,
the price is only going to go in one direction.
Kyle McDaniel projects 5 years and $115 million.
Jim Bowden has him at 5 years and $180 million.
Keith Law has him at no less than $25 million a year for 4 or 5 years.
On top of that, the Mets would owe Hanshin a posting fee,
about $19 million on a $115 million deal.
Even at McDaniel's number, the cost is about $134 million
for a player who has never taken an MLB at bat.
At Bowden's number, the fee climbs to about $29 million,
and the total passes $200 million.
He bats left-handed, so on this roster,
he'd already add to the lefty lean
instead of actually fixing it and adding what this lineup is lacking.
Soto, Benj, Brett Beatty, A.J. Ewing,
and Jerry Young all bat left already.
The position is a question, too.
He's played mostly third base and the outfield in Japan,
and the Yankees have reportedly been skeptical of his glove at third.
With Bichette back at third after exercising his $42 million option,
Soto would be learning first base in New York.
There are swings and miss concerns too.
The same ones Murakami carried before he signed
a two-year $34 million deal with the White Sox.
And the clock is short.
The CBA runs out December 1st and a lockout looms.
So Soto may need to agree to a deal by then.
That's 16 days to commit more than $130 million.
Which brings it back to the money that the Mets have already spent.
The Mets have already guaranteed themselves about $235 million for 2027
before any arbitration raises.
Soto, Lindor, and Bichette alone take up $127 million of it.
They're also still paying Polanco $20
million next season after that .431 OPS.
Spotrac projects France at three years and $49.3 million.
That's about $16 million a year,
against $23 million a year for Soto at McDaniel's number,
before the posting fee.
The years matter even more than the money, though.
France's deal would run through 2029.
Soto's five-year deal would run through 2031.
If France's bat slides back towards 2025,
a three-year deal is a mistake that you can live
with. If Soto doesn't hit an MLB and he can't play defense either,
the Mets are stuck with
with a real problem on their hands
for multiple more seasons at a higher price tag.
And of course, the Mets' number one priority right now
is adding a top-level arm.
And Tarik Skubal is obviously the name
that the Mets keep getting tied to for good reason.
So, a short-term deal for France would fix what
the lineup the Mets have currently is
lacking the most, and would still leave them
with the flexibility to go after a top-tier
pitcher, or even two.
It also gives manager Andy Green more options.
France could play every day,
and Jared Young's left-handed bat could still make it into the
lineup as a DH, and giving France an occasional day off.
The catch is the time.
Will Salmon says several teams are in on France
and he could sign quickly,
with the Diamondbacks also shopping for first base help.
And what about Alec Boehm?
Boehm hit 15 home runs with a .698 OPS for the Phillies,
and he's played third base most of his career.
John Heyman calls him, quote,
a nice righty bat who finished very strongly in rakes versus lefties.
The Phillies also didn't give Boehm a qualifying offer,
so signing him wouldn't cost the Mets a draft pick.
France still out hit him by 167 points of OPS
and comes with a Gold Glove at the position.
If the Mets want a righty first baseman, it's easy for me.
France is the better option.
And unlike Soto, he can sign this week without
a 45 day posting window hanging over it.
My call is France. It's not the flashy pick,
but it's the right one for this team.
Righty Power for a team that was 23rd against lefties
as he provided a .853 OPS versus Southpaws last year.
What I think they'll be getting him
for is about three years at $16 million per season.
And that'll keep the Steuben money more than alive.
There is significant doubt, though,
and that is that Ty France is coming off a career season.
He's in his mid-30s, and last year,
the sabermetrics did not support the extent to which
he succeeded.
He had a .248 expected batting average,
and he also had a .680 OPS as recently as 2025.
That's why I give him max three years
and not anywhere close to a five-year deal.
Obviously, Soto is the dream,
and I'd be more than happy if the Mets go after him,
even if he is a left-handed hitter.
I think he clearly has the most potential here.
But given the reports that the Mets are less inclined to sign him,
and the Mets are very focused on adding a top-level arm,
I believe between Boehm, between trading for a guy like Torkelson,
or rolling out Mark Vientos again,
I'd much, much heavily prefer just signing Ty France.
Soto is the dream, though.
If his price drops closer to December 1st, go try to get him.
I don't have a problem with that at all.
In fact, I encourage it.
But if France signs fast, I should say,
the Soto talk is over for the New York Mets.
Ty France or Juan Soto,
who do you guys want playing first base for the Mets in 2027?
Comment below, let me know.
And as always, guys, subscribe
because we have the best quality Mets content on YouTube.
As always, guys, let's go Mets.
