Why It's Impossible To Live On America's Best Islands

Geography By Geoff
3 followers
Nov 18, 2026
What happens when a place becomes too desirable to live in?
Sitting off the coast of Washington
State is an archipelago famous for its stunning landscapes
and whale watching. This is easily
one of the prettiest places to live in the entire Pacific Northwest.
No, the entire country. But
these beautiful islands are becoming impossible to live on today,
and the people who actually keep
these islands running are being forced out.
So why are Washington's ultimate getaway islands?
Slowly dying, and what happens when they finally do.
I'm Jeff, and this is the tragic geographic story
unfolding on Washington's beautiful San Juan Islands.
The San Juan Islands are an archipelago scattered
between Washington State and Vancouver Island,
in the heart of the Salish Sea.
This narrow network of straits
and sounds is the heart of the Pacific Northwest, and
the sea's sheltered,
nutrient-rich waters teem with all sorts of marine life.
Dense kelp forests and rare sponge reefs crowd the sea floor,
while the waters are bustling
Wrestling with fish, sea lions,
and whales, most famously pods of orcas.
The Salish Sea is just one of those places
that provides an ideal habitat for marine life,
and it's attracted countless species to its brackish waters.
And right in the middle of this marine wonderland,
amidst a network of narrow channels, sits a stunning group of islands.
The San Juan Archipelago contains hundreds of islands and reefs,
with the three largest and most
populated islands being San Juan Island,
Orcas Island, and Lopez Island.
Together with other archipelagos to the east and west,
They form a maze of islands
and channels between the Strait of Georgia and the Strait of Juan
de Fuca, with only the narrow Haro Strait in the west
and Rosario Strait in the east
cordoning the San Juan Islands off from their neighbors.
Some of these islands are barely more than exposed reefs
or jagged rocks stabbing up
through the waves, but the larger islands are much more dynamic.
Most of the San Juan Islands are fairly hilly,
with the largest islands even having small
mountains lined with dramatic cliffs and steep slopes.
But between the hills and peaks is a
spiderweb of valleys and flatter areas,
leading out to forested coastal lowlands and long gentle
beaches. This rugged terrain is extremely beautiful,
but it also limits settlement and the
island's arable land to the valleys and the coastal regions.
And even more importantly,
They're pretty dry.
Since they lie in the rain shadow
of Vancouver Island's island ranges, the San Juan Islands
see substantially less annual rainfall than many nearby coastal cities.
To put this in perspective,
the San Juan Islands get roughly 20 inches of rain on average per year,
about half of what the city of Seattle, Washington gets.
It is, by all measures,
a veritable paradise in the middle of the traditionally rainy
and dreary Pacific Northwest
coast. Despite this, the islands are still immensely fertile,
supporting thriving ecosystems.
And it's not just the landscapes here
that are amazing either, the wildlife is too.
The San Juan Islands are heavily forested,
and its many conifers are home to the largest concentration
of bald eagles in the contiguous United States,
as well as many other bird species.
While the islands have had no predatory mammals
since wolves were eliminated from them
more than a century ago,
many land mammal species can still be found
on the San Juan Islands, including beavers and deer.
And of course, moving to the waters around the islands,
you'll find three pods of orcas
that call the archipelago home.
As do sea lions, river otters, and mink whales.
Logging, overhunting, and invasive species have damaged
the biodiversity of the islands
since settlers arrived in the 19th century,
but the San Juan Islands are still home to
a dense array of living things, from conifers to marine mammals.
Geologically, the San Juan Islands
are unique for their extreme topography.
The island's mountains can climb up to 2,000 feet or more,
while the surrounding straits
and channels can be as deep as 1,300 feet.
Which means the total elevation comes out to a staggering 3,765 feet
when measured from
the bottom of the sea to the top of the mountains.
And this is because the San Juan Islands
are much more than just regular islands.
They're actually the peaks of a sunken mountain range.
The San Juan Islands are part of a range
of mountains running northwest across the Salish
Sea, built up by millions of years of slow subduction
at the western margin of the North
American plate.
But this middle stretch of the range has been partially submerged,
turning its peaks into
islands and its lower valleys into channels.
Glacial erosion has also played a major role
in shaping these islands, which were buried under
the Cordilleran ice sheet during the last ice age.
Glaciers whittled down the island's mountains
and carved dramatic valleys through the hills,
and they left the flatter parts
of the islands covered in what we call glacial drift.
A fine, sandy soil left over from the grinding down
of the mountains by the mega ice sheets.
The result is the picturesque
but rugged landscape that dominates the San Juan Islands today.
But the fascinating geologic history
of these islands doesn't end there, because some
of these islands are made from one
of the rarest types of rock on Earth.
They're called Ophiolites,
and they're the result of a very common type of rock being
Being moved far from its natural habitat.
These are chunks of oceanic crust
that have become embedded in the continental crust,
allowing them to rise above the ocean surface.
Some of these ophiolite formations even contain peridotites,
rocks that come not from the Earth's crust, but from the mantle.
These peridotites are mixed in with the oceanic crust
and hauled to the surface,
leaving these rocks from deep within the Earth exposed to the open air,
something we just don't see all that often anywhere else.
So...
From cool rocks and dramatic landscapes to pleasant weather
and abundant wildlife,
the San Juan Islands have a little bit of everything.
And honestly, they sound like one of the best places
to live in the Pacific Northwest,
which is probably why people have
been living there for thousands of years.
Navigating the hidden channels of the Salish Sea takes a good map,
but if you want to navigate the geography of the internet and
And actually get your website discovered,
you need today's sponsor, Ahrefs.
Have you ever looked at a successful blog or website
and wondered how do they get all of their visitors?
Ahrefs Free answers that question right now.
It's a set of completely no cost tools
that lets you peek behind the curtains
of any website that's out there today.
Using their traffic checker, you can drop in a URL,
yours or a competitor's, and see an immediate estimate
of how much traffic they're getting from search
every single month and which of their pages are winning.
Then you can use their keyword generator to find
the exact phrases people are typing into Google
or YouTube when looking for the topics that you cover.
You can even see exactly who is linking
to who. It gives you the exact data that you need to build an audience.
And it is genuinely free.
There's no credit card required, no hidden fees,
and definitely no trial countdown. So click the
Click the link in the description below
to register your free account at Ahrefs today.
For thousands of years, the San
Juan Islands and their neighbors
were home to the indigenous
Coast Salish peoples,
primarily the Northern Straits and the Nooksack groups.
And given the nearly perfect geography of the islands,
they built multiple villages
All across the islands.
Where they lived mainly as hunter-gatherers,
hunting the island's game and fishing for salmon just offshore.
The Coast Salish built a rich society all along
the coast of the Salish Sea,
benefiting greatly from the region's rich biodiversity.
For at least 10,000 years,
the Coast Salish on the San Juan Islands thrived.
Until, as usual, a visitor from the other side of the world showed up.
In the 1770s, even before Europeans paid
their first visit to the San Juan Islands,
The first wave of smallpox struck
the indigenous inhabitants of the archipelago,
Devastating the local population.
As the disease ran its course through the Coast Salish communities,
the first Spanish ships appeared over the horizon in 1790.
Sent from Mexico up the west coast of North America,
Spanish explorer Francisco de Eliza
was the commander of the expedition,
and it was he that gave the San Juan Islands their name.
But the Spanish weren't the only Europeans
with an interest in the Pacific Coast,
and a British expedition under George Vancouver followed in 1792.
Vancouver and the Spanish made contact and actually joined forces,
mapping out a lot of the Salish Sea together.
From that point on, the San Juan Islands
were known to European settlers,
but it would take a few decades before
the archipelago was actually colonized.
After all, this was extremely remote
from both the heart of New Spain and Mexico
and British Canada, 2000 miles east of the San Juans.
But when settlers finally came to the San Juan Islands,
they turned them into a conflict zone.
In the mid-19th century, American and British settlers
began moving in large numbers to the Pacific Northwest.
But hazy borders left the San Juan Islands in dispute.
The Oregon Treaty of 1846 had established a formal border
between American and British territory.
But the treaty left it unclear which side of the border
the San Juan Islands were on.
Both parties decided the islands were clearly on their side.
An international drama ensued.
On behalf of the British, the Hudson's Bay Company made the first move,
establishing Bellevue Sheep Farm on the San Juan Islands in 1853.
American farmers soon followed, drawn by the island's rich soil.
American and British authorities
then spent years squabbling over which colonists had
the right to be there, and in 1859, this escalated into a war, kind of.
Now, the Pig War, as it's known today,
is far from the bloodiest war the US has ever
fought, but it definitely makes for a good story.
As the name suggests, it all started with a pig,
specifically a British pig, owned by
one of the Hudson's Bay Company settlers.
One June morning, one of the American settlers found
this pig rooting up his garden and eating
his potatoes, and he shot the animal for trespassing.
But that sparked a dispute with the man whose pig he had just shot,
who then got San Juan's British authorities involved.
When the authorities threatened to arrest the man who shot the pig,
the island's American settlers requested US military support.
And believe it or not, he actually got it.
The US sent out a small force under Captain George Pickett
to back up their settlers.
The British then sent troops of their own, and before long,
there were thousands of soldiers on San Juan, all because of a pig.
While neither side ever actually fired a shot,
both sides spent months dug in on the island.
Fortunately, the leaders of the United States
and the British Empire were both unwilling to go to war over a pig.
And so they agreed to a joint military occupation
of San Juan Island until the border dispute was
resolved. Small garrisons of American
and British troops remained on the island until 1872,
when an international commission headed by the then-Emperor of Germany
finally resolved the dispute,
awarding the San Juan Islands to the United States.
American settlers finally, at long last,
had free reign to carve up the San Juan Islands as they saw fit.
Over the course of the next century and a half,
the largest islands in the archipelago were dotted
with small rural communities, mostly along the coasts,
where there was flat, arable land.
Eventually, people started coming to the islands
for their natural beauty and small peaceful
communities instead of for the rich farmland,
which is where the island's problems began.
In the present day, the San Juan Islands
are a major tourist destination with people flocking
to the islands year after year for things like kayaking,
whale watching, or just general sight
seeing. But towns all across the islands
are still overwhelmingly rural. A collection of
villages knit together by mostly dirt roads,
with most only having a few hundred residents apiece.
There are also no bridges between the islands and the mainland.
Requiring residents and tourists alike to use ferries
or air travel to get to and from the archipelago.
All told, the San Juan Islands have
a combined population of only about 18,000 people,
mostly on San Juan Island itself, Orcas Island, and Lopez Island.
And thanks to the archipelago's natural beauty
and quiet rural communities,
that population has been steadily increasing for decades.
And that's starting to become a real problem.
You see, if we go back to 1970,
the entirety of San Juan County, which comprises these islands,
only had about 4,000 people living on them.
It was small, quaint,
and very rarely visited by anyone from the outside.
But since then, the islands have experienced rapid growth.
Every decade since has seen it grow by thousands of more residents.
This isn't an issue if you're a big city like nearby Seattle,
but for small rural communities,
That kind of growth is difficult to manage.
All of this is compounded by the fact
that the San Juan Islands have never really been
a cheap place to live.
Because the islands need to import most goods,
and those goods only arrive by air or sea,
virtually everything is at a premium.
But now, the cost of living is getting even more unaffordable,
especially the cost of
housing.
The islands are suffering from a catastrophic housing shortage.
affordable housing and even just available housing is extremely scarce.
Driving housing costs up across the board and to make matters worse,
huge numbers of homes have been bought up by people
who don't even live on the islands
and who don't work there or otherwise contribute to the community.
And as more and more homes become vacation rentals,
the people who actually keep
the San Juan Islands running are being forced out.
This sort of thing is happening all over the US,
but on the San Juan Islands,
it's severely exacerbated by the island's geography.
None of the San Juan Islands are very large and their rugged interiors,
there just isn't all that much space to develop.
Solving the housing shortage isn't
as simple as just building more homes.
There isn't really much more land to build
on and not nearly enough to replenish the housing stock.
It doesn't help that we're talking about
fairly spread out rural villages here,
communities that weren't designed for dense populations anyway.
And even if just building more housing was an option,
the geography of the San Juan Islands limits growth in other ways.
Any piece of land can only support
human populations up to a certain size.
And the San Juan Islands are no exception.
Freshwater availability is severely limited,
especially because of the low rainfall the islands receive,
which already means that the residents
of the archipelago have to conserve water carefully.
And as if the price of essential goods isn't bad enough as it is,
more demand would only make that problem worse.
When humans push past the limits of what a place's physical geography
and local community can support, it leads to disaster.
And that's exactly what's happening on the San Juan Islands.
As the beauty of the San Juan Islands has attracted tourists
and new residents alike,
the local community has been pushed far beyond its limits.
As a result, life is becoming completely unaffordable
for the average person,
and the people who actually live on the islands
are at increasing risk of going homeless,
or even having to leave.
Not even most professionals can afford to move there either.
The middle and working class people
the islands need have almost been completely priced out.
According to a recent report by Redfin,
the median price for a home in San Juan County eclipsed
$1 million. As a result,
many vital industries on the islands have severe worker shortages.
Nurses, teachers, firefighters, police officers,
government workers, road maintenance and
construction workers.
These people can't afford to live on the San Juan Islands in 2026.
But without these people,
the San Juan Islands as a community simply can't exist.
Eventually, this will hurt absentee property owners and tourists too.
Tourism requires local communities to support it.
And as those communities collapse, so will the tourism industry.
Washington's most beautiful island getaway will suffocate under
the growing demand that's being put on them.
And a whole archipelago's worth of communities will be devastated,
both economically and demographically.
And so, the San Juan Islands' problems come down to a mix of factors,
but at the root of them all is a single critical failure.
A failure to respect the hard limits geography imposes on growth.
The problems afflicting
the San Juan Islands have already reached critical mass,
and it remains to be seen
if the island's communities can turn things around.
The Salish Sea's most beautiful archipelago may be dying,
but it's not dead just yet,
and it's still just as stunning as it's always been.
Big news! I'm launching a brand new channel here
on YouTube called Bite-Sized.
I cover so much geography on Geography by Jeff and GeoLax,
but there's one thing missing,
amazing geographic stories.
That's why I'm launching Bite-Sized. Every week our mascot will
take you on a mind-blowing journey.
We're covering everything from Pacific Vikings reclaiming their
island, to the forgotten Chinese titanic survivors,
to crossing Australia's legendary Nullarbor.
So head over to the Bite-Sized YouTube channel and subscribe.
New episodes launch every Monday.
I hope you enjoyed learning all about the San Juan Islands.
If you did, be sure to check out
this video all about America's secret island in the
Indian Ocean.
Thanks for watching.
Thanks for watching.
See you next time.
