The debate is OVER...

Flames Digest
1 follower
1 Video View·Nov 18, 2026
It's funny to think back that not even two months ago there
was a great debate between
who should be relied upon more, especially on the power play.
Šimon Nemec or Zane Parekh?
Well, it's safe to say that for now the debate is over,
but healthy competition is
never a bad thing.
We're going to get to all that more in this video,
but first I want to welcome you to
Flames Digest.
I'm Mark Griffith.
If you're new around here and you love the
Flames, make sure to subscribe so you can
stay up to date on all the latest news, updates,
reports, and rumors revolving around your
Calgary Flames we would love.
Welcome into the Flames Digest family,
and the debate is kind of being relived a little bit,
but not opening up and saying, hey, there's a huge debate again.
It's more so, you know, kind of going between Parekh,
Nemec, Parekh has certainly been the one
that's been relied upon more, just has seemingly had a better season.
We're going to, you know, dive into the stats a little bit,
get into it a little bit more
because it's probably closer than it actually seems statistically.
But as we know, Parekh is breaking out and just becoming a star.
He's becoming so, so dynamic.
Whereas Nemec, a lot of the fan base
are saying he's not worth the picks.
And a lot of people are saying he'll never be worth the picks.
Some are saying, just give it some time.
Others are saying, you know, he actually,
if you watch the game, plays really well.
It's just the stats don't back it up.
And again, I'm not going to say anyone's wrong, but...
Let's talk about it a little bit more.
And normally I would talk about, you know,
the previous day's game, but I don't want to.
I just don't want to talk about what we witnessed last night.
I don't feel like it.
So let's dive into Zane Parekh's stats first,
as both of the players have actually played
every game this year.
So in 21 games, Parekh has eight points,
a couple of those being goals,
and has certainly been a big part of the power play.
He has absolutely taken that PP1, QB1 role.
Roll.
Which, again, was a point of debate during
the offseason as we headed through,
you know, even preseason in the training camp, who would get it.
We were going to start off with both
of them kind of auditioning for it,
and Parekh has absolutely won that role over.
The shooting percentage, not fantastic.
Not that you expect it to be great from a defenseman,
but a little bit more puck luck,
and Parekh would have way more points, to be quite honest.
Think of that beauty wraparound goal he could have scored against.
It was the Rangers, I think, wasn't it?
But blocks, he's up there.
He's thrown some hits as well.
Not too many, but good enough for where he's at.
Plays.
Not the most minutes, to be quite honest,
but we've certainly seen that go up
ever since the Kevin Ball injury.
Obviously takes some shots,
and the plus minus is not great.
either. As for Nemec, he has seven points.
So just one less than Parekh, but no goals. And I
think he's getting up there.
He has some of the most, who the heck is that in the photo, by the
way? Is that like Tage Thompson or something?
I'll have to get that fixed, get that sorted out.
That is definitely not Nemec in that graphic.
Who genuinely, who is that? That's actually so
funny. That's, that's the new Nemec.
But again, he has no goals on the season. He's getting up
up there in terms of players with the most
shots without a goal this season, but
But the stats aren't too bad either.
He also has quite a few blocked shots.
He's thrown quite a few more hits.
And time on ice for the season,
actually well above what Parekh has,
which is very interesting.
Again, plus minus, not too great.
But let's focus on Parekh's minutes here.
As I said, they have been going up a little bit lately.
The past two games, they have not been as high.
Maybe the Flames haven't had as many power plays
or something, but...
It certainly is going up, especially ever since the Kevin Ball injury,
which again was horrible.
But, you know, it does make sense why other defensemen
are just playing more now.
As for Nemec, he actually, again,
has more time on ice on average for the season than Parekh,
which is extremely interesting.
I think a lot of that has to do with who you're paired up with.
You know, Nemec technically
was playing first pairing minutes when he was with Ball,
whereas Zane Parekh was not, whether he was with Middleton or Kuznetsov,
which is something interesting, at least in terms of five on five.
But that's kind of the, you know.
You just want to go minute by minute.
That's how they've been doing.
The power play is where it mostly comes into effect,
where the whole debate began,
and it's not really much of a debate anymore,
but we still can relive it.
Now, Parekh, again, he has five power play points,
which isn't too bad.
He's got a goal on the power play as well,
and plays almost two and a half minutes per game
on the power play, which is very good to note.
The Flames have an excellent power play this year,
and Parekh's been a big part of that.
I wouldn't say he's been the biggest part.
You know, you gotta give credit where credit's due.
Most of that goes to Farabian Corp.
Tornado, who have just been outstanding.
Obviously, you can throw Frosty and Gridden in there as well,
but Parekh has kind of been the power play for that.
And that's, you know, it just makes sense to keep it rolling
since it is working so well.
Top five in the league.
If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
Parekh's, you know, there to stay.
The results as well.
I mean, it speaks for itself.
With that unit.
They have been so successful.
They see most of the power play time.
It just does make sense.
Unfortunately for Nemitz, the second unit isn't as strong.
It has some guys on there that are a little bit more questionable
as to why they would be on a power play.
Let's play.
So you're probably not expected to get as many points,
but I would like to see Nemitz break through on this second unit
and at least get, you know, a goal or something.
Back to Parekh a little bit with the shots, like I was saying.
Pukluk, he does have a couple goals on the season, unlike Nemitz.
He's been throwing more shots, which is, you know, great to see.
You can see there where his couple of goals did come from.
And they were beautiful goals, both of them, so far this year.
So hopefully, again, with a little bit
more Pukluk, he can get them going.
But he has been shooting, which is great.
And he kind of spreads it out too,
which I thought was interesting to take a look at.
It's not all from the point, like a lot of defensemen.
He's getting into the slot a little bit
and a little bit just outside as well.
So he's not afraid to throw the puck around from wherever.
And hopefully more of these can go in or be tipped
in as well as always a point as well.
Now, back to the point of who do you play with?
It kind of matters in terms of...
You know, more of the ice time, especially five on five.
Now, Parekh has definitely been finding his groove
a little bit more as he has been paired
with Kuznetsov.
You think to start the season that he was with Middleton,
and it just really wasn't working
out all that good for five on five.
They were on the ice for three of our goals,
but on for seven against, which just wasn't great.
That has improved with Kuznetsov.
Still at five on five.
They're in minus two.
And then the pairing that everyone would have loved to see
coming into the season,
but of course was never going to happen,
was Ball with Parekh.
They actually have a positive goal differential.
And if much.
larger share of the shot attempts at 64.3 percent at five on five
when they were on together
obviously ball out for the season
but that's something hopefully for the future we can see
a little bit more of there is a little bit
of uncertainty as to who will actually be flames
once we head into next season kind of will white cloud
be there will even middleton be there you
know there are some question marks
but that is a pairing that we would like to see
moving forward because it has been quite successful
and that just makes sense for Parekh.
Another thing on Parekh here is, you know,
I guess the hard minutes because defensemen aren't just
all offense. I know some of the guys in the league
are kind of like that and Parekh is definitely the
offensive type, but he has been, you know,
doing the hard minutes as well. As I said,
he's actually thrown a few hits this year,
which is difficult for a guy who's a little bit
You know, lighter, I suppose the best way to put it.
But he has been blocking some shots, has some takeaways.
The only glaring part of his game is the giveaways,
where he's the 27th most in the NHL.
A reason for that is just
because he's relied upon with the puck on this team.
It's the exact same as Johnny Gaudreau was.
He was always high up there in giveaways,
but it's because he was always relied upon to have the puck,
which just kind of makes sense.
So I still think in terms of the debate relived.
No, not all of Zane Parekh's stats are going to be great,
but he has taken it on way more.
He's becoming so dynamic.
He's breaking out.
It just does make sense why he has been given,
you know, more of an opportunity
and just being relied upon more,
especially on the power play.
But this isn't a hate on Nemetz video.
Let's focus on him as well.
As we go back to the shots here,
again, we go to his shot map.
There's no goals.
He has 2.3 expected goals this season,
but, you know, he doesn't have a goal.
He has the zero shooting percentage.
Which, again, isn't fantastic.
The thing for him is that he isn't getting as close to the net
when he shoots as Parekh has been.
He also, as you can see, way more of his shots are from one side.
Compared to Parekh,
who seemed like he was just shooting from everywhere.
So we'd like to see Nemec maybe get a little bit closer to the net.
I remember the very first game of the season,
he did get very close to the net
and almost scored on one of the first shifts of the game.
And we honestly haven't really seen
that since from Nemec, to be honest.
Now, in terms of who he's been playing with a little bit more,
as we know, he was playing with Ball a lot,
recreating that Devils chemistry.
And it wasn't too bad.
They were on for five on five.
They were on for five goals.
And on for six against, which wasn't too bad.
With Hanley, it hasn't been as good.
They have not been a successful pairing,
to be quite honest with you, five on five.
I know, obviously, Hanley scored a goal and whatnot,
but less than 40% of the share of shot attempts
is not good at all.
And a minus four together in just 75 minutes
is, again, not fantastic.
With Kuznetsov, not bad as well,
but we obviously prefer Parekh with Kuznetsov compared to Nemec.
But it is something, you know,
if both these guys are playing with the same guys, you have
to compare them.
Now, in terms of his hard minutes, he's more of,
you know, I guess he has more of a defensive
game to him.
Again, maybe that's just because he plays more minutes,
but he has more hits, more blocked
shots, less giveaways, but still way more giveaways than takeaways.
That's just how it is in the NHL, of course,
especially for someone who's expected to be
a puck moving defenseman.
But in terms of the hard minutes, his stats,
yeah, they might be a little bit better.
In terms of the special teams, again,
he has no power play points.
He doesn't have a goal this season, as we know,
but just doesn't play as many power play minutes.
And it makes sense.
Parekh is the guy you do want doing that.
So it overall, you know, obviously does make a difference.
Now, in terms of the contract,
you always gotta talk money here.
He has signed for quite a while here,
up until 2031 at 7.25 mil.
The reason I bring this up is because Perec,
guaranteed, will get more than that.
We know how just insane the market is.
Who the heck knows?
Perec could demand 20 million.
Someone, some GM might give it up to him
just in the way the market is.
But I think overall,
Perec definitely will see way higher than 10 million.
That's obviously a discussion for a later time.
And the stats will have to back it up for sure.
But.
Right now, the contract doesn't look amazing.
It could look way better
once the Flames just build a little bit more
of a strong team.
Not that I'm saying they're bad now,
but a real contender.
And maybe Nemetz does look a lot better
and the stats will come.
I mean, it can only go up from here,
especially in the offensive production
for Nemetz with the Flames.
Just in terms of five on five as well,
I thought this was interesting to take a look at.
Um, this is a weird stat.
I don't know if I've ever really seen this,
but on the ice for goals against, and the
main column is against an hour.
So every 60 minutes played at five on five, how many goals are you on?
You know, when the other team scores and both Perec
and Nemetz are up there again, that's
because they play so many minutes
and that doesn't mean you're a bad player, of course,
but Perec is on for 3.41 goals every 60 minutes at five on five
and Nemetz is just at 2.97
less than three, which isn't.
You know, terrible.
The team at five on five is 3.03 against an hour
and 1.814 just because we're obviously
a much better power play team than we are five on five.
But I thought this was a very interesting stat
to take into consideration as well.
In terms of the Perec contract, again,
he's still on his ELC for up until the end
of next season as well.
And then he'll probably want something big.
So if we do want to relieve this debate,
the kind of way to do it is I'm thinking
almost like a one.
Month plan here.
So what to track for a month.
We can keep tracking Perec Powerplay 1 share
and five on five minutes,
especially with who he's playing with.
Also the shot share with each regular partner
for both of these guys is something we can definitely,
you know, take a look at the data,
see what's working, see what isn't.
And then we can relive this debate once again.
And then obviously Nemec exits under pressure on video.
Taking a look at that.
You know, I think could be something very interesting
for Flames fans to do to really
decide if Nemec is worth the contract,
not the contract, well, the contract for sure,
but also worth what we traded for him.
Because a lot of people just look at the stats and think
this guy stinks, whereas he's actually not all that bad of a player.
So the final thing we can
do here is where should Calgary add
responsibility first for both of these guys?
Should we, and these aren't the only options,
but should we give longer power play one shifts for Parekh
just because he's been more successful on there?
More five on five minutes for Parekh
because as we've seen,
Nemec plays a lot more minutes than Parekh,
but maybe Parekh deserves more five on five.
And then more special teams minutes
for Nemec alternatively.
Should we give him more of a chance on the power play
since he hasn't really gotten it
and maybe test him out on power play one?
I don't lean towards that, but there are options
and there's more options than just that.
But overall, it is a debate we can definitely talk about.
As you know, the season carries on.
Now let's get into the comment of the day
to wrap up this video as we love to do here on the channel
comes from yesterday's video, of course.
And this is a good one here from DeChapelle
just because it's a little bit interesting
and we can talk about it.
It says, Flames just gonna keep beating
the bottom 10 teams to draft 12th.
And yeah, it's a funny comment.
It goes with the irony of we're always gonna end up
in the mushy middle, especially if we beat the bad teams
and then we're still not gonna make the playoffs.
But you do gotta remember,
the Flames are in just such an interesting spot
where the youth is carrying us.
We have beaten teams like Carolina
Minnesota this year, arguably the top two teams in the NHL.
So it is interesting the way that they're doing it right now.
They win a good game and then they get smoked
and then they play a good game and get smoked.
And sometimes your goalie is unbelievable
and sometimes they're terrible.
It's overall just really interesting.
But yeah, it does seem like we're kind of destined
to draft 12 once again, if we look at it in a humorous light.
Thank you so much for watching this video.
Please subscribe if you like what you saw here today
and have a wonderful rest of your day.
