LIVE: Canada PM Mark Carney speaks in China on the APEC CEO summit sidelines

Canada Prime Ministers
27 followers
Watch live as Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney speaks at a press conference after attending the opening ceremony of the APEC CEO Summit in Shenzhen, China.
#china #canada #live
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good afternoon everyone. Bonjour tout le monde.
Let me begin by thanking President Xi and the
people of Shenzhen for hosting our delegation
and for the leadership in the wider APEC community
over the course of this year.
These meetings are coming at a critical time with challenges
moving faster than any one economy can manage
and meeting them will take cooperation across every
configuration.
Canada is involved in a lot of configurations,
a relationship with the European Union,
the Francophonie, and, of course, APEC.
And APEC is one of the most valuable of those.
Thank you very much for those.
21 economies, different in size, different in systems,
different in stages of development,
working together on issues that matter to all of us,
economic issues that matter to all of us.
And this is what partnerships can do.
I would also like to thank...
President Xi Jinping,
for his partnership as Canada and China renew our relationship,
expand our trade, and pursue new opportunities in strategic sectors,
including financial services, clean energy, and technology.
Now, immediately after forming government,
we began to recalibrate our relationship with China.
Last January...
This year, I was in Beijing.
President Xi and I launched a new strategic partnership
to get trade back moving again, to work on building clean energy,
and to make it easier for peoples to travel between our two countries.
Less than a year later, this dynamic market of 1.4 billion people
that was all but closed to Canadian farmers,
fish harvesters, and businesses is open once again.
Our exports to China are up by more than one-third this year.
Two-way trade has climbed to $125 billion.
During our meeting yesterday, President Xi and I agreed to go further.
And with yesterday's announcement and the announcement
a few days prior by Minister Sadu and his counterpart,
we're now in a situation where Canada has restored market access
for more than 90%, 90% of the trade that was previously.
Subject to punitive tariff action.
Food exports to China are up by 20%.
I'm sorry, total exports to China are up by 20% this year.
And our food exports by more than 80%.
So, what does it mean?
Well, if you're a lobster fisher in Shelburne,
a canola farmer in Red Deer County, a cattle rancher in Saskatchewan,
it means new orders, it means better prices,
it means greater certainty.
It also means more jobs.
for workers in our energy and manufacturing sectors
and more opportunity for economic participation for indigenous peoples.
Next year, and this was agreed yesterday, next year will be
the Canada-China year of e-commerce
and what that will help do, along with
some of the other agreements we're working on,
will help small businesses from St. John's to Nanaimo
to reach customers from Shenzhen to Chengdu.
To build on all this momentum,
there will be a Team Canada trade mission in China next year.
So, we reinforce the bonds between our peoples.
Thanks to the trips, the studies, and the culture,
more than 1.7 million Canadians are of Chinese origin.
For many families,
this is the chance to no longer miss the great moments of life.
More flight, more bonds.
From next May, Air Canada will return to Vancouver and Guangzhou,
and Chinese carriers will also be flying.
This also means that more and more Canadians
will be able to discover China and find new partners,
new customers, and new ideas.
Culture is bringing people together.
Five Canadian cultural enterprises have just signed
more than $15 million in new agreements in China.
So there's some real progress in the bilateral relationship in trade,
travel, learning, cultural exchange,
and from restoring market access for more than 90%
of our trade that was hit by tariffs
to new flight scholarships, artistic partnerships,
our relationship is growing on every front.
Now, before I conclude and take your questions,
let me just take a step back.
We'll be right back.
Sovereignty, in other words,
the ability to live our lives as we choose,
is built on strength at home and diverse partnerships abroad.
At home, we're unleashing an investment super cycle,
launching the most ambitious workforce training in generations,
building on the strongest fiscal position, the G7,
welcoming foreign direct investment,
which is at its highest level for two decades.
Abroad, we're building a dense web of reliable partnerships,
creating more opportunities for our businesses,
more choice for Canadians, and less reliance on any single market.
This year alone, we've signed seven new trade
and investment agreements.
We've launched negotiations towards seven more.
Our goal, as we've said for over a year, has been to double.
Our exports beyond the United States by 2035.
We are well ahead of that schedule.
Now, one in three Canadian export dollars comes from non-U.S. markets.
That's our highest share in 40 years.
After only eight days in four countries,
our partnership network is stronger than ever.
In Dublin, at the European political community summit,
we have consolidated our alliance for the future
with the European Union, the second largest economy in the world.
In Manila, we have concluded the negotiations
for two new free trade agreements with the Philippines.
This will allow us to triple, triple our exports by 2035,
and with the ASEAN, which will open up more market doors
for nearly 700 million people.
In Phnom Penh, more than 90...
Members of the government have reaffirmed
their commitment to a living language,
a language that Canada will defend and will continue
to defend when it acquires Francophonie in 2028.
Here at APEC,
we're working with partners
across 21 economies
to make trade faster, simpler,
and more reliable.
Over the next day, we'll renew APEC's connectivity blueprint,
a plan to connect APEC economies through infrastructures,
institutions, and peoples.
That's what we've been doing at home in Canada.
We're fast-tracking major projects across the country.
including trade corridors
and doubling the capacity at the Port of Vancouver
and building energy infrastructure to Asia.
Our landmark Canada Strong Act includes digital trade legislation
that will enable our businesses to move goods with less paperwork.
Tell us once, tell us digitally is the framework.
It's exactly the framework that APEC is moving forward together.
And we're making it easier for Canadians and travellers
to go across the Pacific, tourists students and businesses.
Strengthening flights, building scholarships,
and building connectivity.
20 free trade agreements across 60 countries.
Preferential access now, if you're keeping track,
to over 2 billion consumers, representing two-thirds of global GDP.
Canada is now the best connected economy in the world.
We're just getting started building that strength
so we can live our lives as we choose.
And now you get to choose your questions, and I look forward to them.
I believe we'll start with Mr. Chase.
Thank you, Prime Minister.
We'll now begin questions.
On va commencer les questions.
Première question.
First question.
Good afternoon.
Stephen Chase with the Globe and Mail.
I'd like to cast our minds back to Canada
for a minute and advance there.
Is your government open to going back
or reverting to a national telecom market with only three players?
So that's the question.
But also I'd like you to reflect on whether the threat
of foreign competition from Starlink requires a new model
or structure for the industry.
Thank you.
Thank you for your question.
Obviously, we're aware of the developments
for some of the telecom players,
and I just want to underscore before I go
into detail on the overall structure,
the responsibilities of the authorities related
to any potential transactions,
so the CRTC, the competition authorities.
Obviously, the government takes a direct interest.
It's a federally regulated area.
And that interest starts with...
It starts with and ends with Canadians,
it's about affordable access to telecom services,
Today and in the future, so cutting edge services,
investment to continue to provide Canadians with the best,
you need a competitive market structure that provides that competition.
We have seen the costs, for example,
of broadband come down significantly over the last years,
but technological developments, including some
of the ones you referenced, has the potential to further that progress.
So we will be looking, the relevant authorities,
CRTC, competition authorities,
Depending on how any transaction unfolds, and I won't give
specific judgments about that transaction at this stage,
they will be discharging their responsibilities.
In parallel, we are in the process of updating
our perspective on the broader telecom services market
because of technological change,
because of potential changes in market structure.
The objective will always be best service for Canadians
at the most competitive prices today and in the future,
and we'll have a chance to speak more to that.
I'm not going to make a direct comment about
the number of players in the market,
which would necessarily imply
a conclusion about any specific transaction.
Next question.
Prochaine question.
Bonjour, Monsieur le Premier ministre.
Bonjour, Monsieur le Premier ministre.
Antoine Trépanier, La Presse.
You're concluding a journey where you've asked
a lot of people to stay close to you.
Il y a des gens très fatigués pour accomplir de grandes choses
et pour le Canada en quatre pays, trois continents.
Maintenant, vous allez livrer ça aux Canadiens,
et les Canadiens doivent participer à vos grands projets.
Il doit y avoir une cohésion, il doit y avoir une collaboration entre
votre vision et ce que les Canadiens peuvent accomplir
pour justement répondre à vos ambitions.
What do you say to Canadians so that they can actually deliver
cette vision que vous avez pour le Canada à long terme ?
First of all, the vision is not mine.
It's a vision of Canadians.
Thank you very much.
Thank you.
And I can say it like that because we had an election.
Thank you.
An election 18 months ago,
19 months ago, probably 20 months ago.
An election with a very clear platform.
To build what? To build what type of Canada?
A strong Canada, to diversify our partnerships, to invest
in exchange corridors, to become an energy superpower.
Okay, that's the first thing. The government follows,
the government respects our commitment to Canadians.
Our commitments that we have unveiled during the election,
from the first day, I believe,
that I presented myself as perhaps the leader of the Liberal Party,
I said, we must concentrate on what we can control.
We must become, put at home.
So that's the plan, first point.
Second point, around Canada.
I didn't say that.
And I'm on the ground, across Canada.
Canadians are positive.
They are proud. They are proud of our country.
They are proud that we are building
a more independent, more resilient, stronger country
in order to be equitable,
in order to have solidarity with our neighbours,
in order to have...
So, for me, it's not...
It's not my vision, it's the vision of Canadians
and we're putting it into practice with a bit of success, I think.
Thank you.
Next question.
David Akin, Global News. Good afternoon.
Good afternoon.
I'd like to follow up as well on what Mr. Chase was asking about,
but really thinking about consumers as they look to the headlines.
Obviously, you're not going to talk about the deal at hand,
but can you tell us a little bit more about your thinking?
How does a federal government continue
to improve affordability for telecom?
It may have come down, but to international prices,
it's still too high for a lot of Canadians.
Well, let me start by acknowledging what you just said
as part of your question.
There has been improvement, but we need more improvement.
That was, and let me give you one example of something we did,
I guess it would have been about 14 months ago,
which is that we allowed, on the advice of the CRTC,
we allowed, and against the lobbying of many vested interests,
Thank you, Chris.
we allowed access to...
And I...
Well, access effectively to broadband in other markets
at a fair reselling price, my terminology, there's a more specific term
which I've lost for the moment, but at a fair reselling price,
and because that would lead to more competition.
And actually, that's part of what we're seeing.
That's part of the dynamic that we're seeing now.
Now, there's lots of other, Mr. Chase referred to another aspect of it.
There's lots of other ways that we can get more
of that competition into the market.
And we're going to continue to look for those.
At the same time, at the same time that we recognize that there needs
to be significant investment in, broadly speaking, telecom services.
Thank you.
We come, and there was a bit of this you would have seen
in the budget across financial services
as well as telecom services,
other areas where the federal government is directly implicated.
We have a competition lens, a pro-competition lens,
because that's what's going to drive affordability for Canadians.
And so if you want to have an overall sense
of the orientation of where we're going to go.
And now I'm going to, it's going to hate me for this,
but it's too late now, I'm going to say it.
Thank you.
Depending on the market structure,
the form of oligopoly can lead to more competition.
With fewer players under certain circumstances,
and that's the kind of, and so it depends
on the market structure aspect of it,
and we need to take informed decisions on that,
but when push comes to shove on any decision,
if we can have more competition, lower prices,
better service for Canadians, that's where we're going to land.
Next question?
Push, I guess.
Mr.
Hello, Mr. Carney.
Excuse me, Christian Noël from Radio-Canada.
You said, no more, no less, in front of the people
of APEC's business, a few minutes ago,
that Canada is open to business,
what you've been saying for a long time.
At the same time, if we look at recent events in Canada,
sometimes when there are foreign investments, there are risks.
So, in the big projects, the big ports, for example,
in which we want to have foreign investments,
how are you going to make sure
That Canadian sovereignty will
not be threatened inside the Canadian borders.
That's a very important question, and it's one of the aspects.
If I may, Mr. Noël, answer in the context
of the Chinese-Canada relations.
At the first meeting,
as Prime Minister with President Xi,
We've been talking about
guardrails and what
industry is Canada open
to Chinese investment in?
And what is so important for...
For him, and for the Chinese government, and the Chinese companies,
and to be clear in which sectors.
So, for us, we said, OK, there are agricultural sectors,
food security, energy security,
clean and conventional,
a few aspects of financial services.
That's in a sense, in the whole.
And there are possibilities that still exist in the case of investment,
for example, in the field of automobiles, electric vehicles,
if we have enough value additions in Canada and,
of course,
the standards for high-level Canadian workers.
But there are other sectors.
Minerals, for example,
are not part of Canada's national security.
So, we have to be clear, we have to decide,
and we have to justify for Canadians
for the government to focus on national security.
As far as ports are concerned, yes, it's a fundamental question.
There are partners abroad who are big investors in Canadian ports.
You know.
There are several examples, including at Contrecoeur, for example.
Probably, on most occasions,
there are Canadian partners at the same time.
I know it's a complex response, but...
But I'm trying to describe how we work
with other countries.
We're trying to be clear with them.
There are opportunities to negotiate for investment,
and there aren't any in other parts of our economy.
Thank you.
And the calibration depends on the values
that we share with the countries.
No, no, no.
Next
question.
Ian Austin from the New York Times.
Let's sort of move on to trade from investment for a second.
There was that poll that showed enormous support
for expanding trade ties with the European Union,
58% or something.
When it came to China, though, the support was dismal, 14%.
Why are Canadians so anxious when it comes to China?
And what does the government need to do to sell Canada in China?
Well, I think there's aspects of that.
I'm not familiar with the specific poll that you're citing,
It's exciting, but I'll take it as...
It's directionally indicative.
That's indicative.
I'd say a couple of things.
One is Mr. Noel's question about, you know,
which areas, national security aspects,
and the government being very clear about that.
So that's one aspect.
You know, we've had challenges in the relationship
in the past for obvious reasons,
and we're working to rebuild that at a mature level, an open level,
addressing issues directly with the government.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
There are areas, I will tell you,
if you are a farmer on the prairies,
your biggest concern was that we did not have trade with China.
If you're a fish harvester in Atlantic Canada, and more broadly,
your biggest concern was that we were shut out of this market.
So we have pursued a stabilization of the relationship first.
And a gradual opening of the relationship,
and we've made a lot of progress on the areas
that where there's trade restrictions.
But relative to many other countries,
our trade with China is quite modest and the breadth
of it is quite modest.
Next question.
Hi, Prime Minister.
Brian Platt with Bloomberg.
This is the second deal now you struck with China
this year to reduce tariffs, and you've
got what you call a successful partnership, momentum, growing trust.
Why do you think it is your government's
been able to achieve this with China
and not, despite an intense effort,
especially this summer, the United States?
Well, our trading relationship with the United
States is much larger, much more complex.
There's a wider range of issues.
The United States fundamentally changed its trade objectives.
Thank you.
And we are focused on getting the right deal for Canadians.
Now, we have been making progress, I would say,
with some two steps forward, one step back type thing.
But we have been making progress.
We have long said and believed and still believe that there is a
mutually beneficial agreement between Canada and the United States.
In the context of the new U.S. trade policy,
I will be meeting with President Trump later today.
We'll have discussions on that.
Um, and
And we will do what's necessary
in order to achieve that deal,
but only that deal that is in the interest of Canadians.
Thank you.
Next question.
Hi, Prime Minister. Tom Parry with CBC.
I know this is a perennial question in China.
Did the topic of human rights come up
in your discussions with President Xi? And also,
you've said that we've got to take the world as it is.
And so I'm wondering if your thinking now
is that questions around free speech, human rights,
that if you're looking for investment,
you're looking to do business in China,
that it's just part of the cost of doing business?
No, look, well, the first is that issues of human rights,
issues of foreign interference,
Thank
Transnational crime, narcotics, trade,
we raise them with our counterparts,
you
including part of my discussions with President Xi.
Thank you.
very
My experience has been that the most effective way to deal
with these issues is to have open, frank conversations,
much.
not to give a running dialogue on them, on those conversations.
Thank you.
And to move to, you know, on specific issues and make progress.
We've had some success both here
and elsewhere around the world on specific issues of consular issues,
I'll call them, but human rights and other issues.
Thank you.
So, and let me go back to something I said as, I forget,
part of the earlier question, the question about vision.
Let the guest show.
Thank you very much, Joe.
We calibrate our relationships, it was the same on the foreign
investment, based on the values that we share with our counterparties.
So there are markets where there are enormous opportunities,
but we don't share the same perspectives,
so that means that there's a series of...
Of commercial activities that we just wouldn't do.
And in some cases, none.
Russia, none.
I'll take an extreme to prove it.
And so that's the way we're addressing it.
Engagement can help.
And we will continue to engage.
Let me make the last point.
Part of what we've been doing and deepening our relations
with those with whom we are most like-minded,
that will add to our weight.
In some of these issues and some
of these circumstances around the world.
And I'm going to give you one example
which may seem somewhat counterintuitive,
but I just want to draw out the point,
which is some of the Gulf states who are very influential
actually and potentially in resolving some
of the world's worst conflicts.
And we candidly did not have dialogue with these states. We do now.
We do have some trade and commercial relationships,
again, calibrated, pardon me,
and that that is helping us to play a role in, we hope,
contributing to resolution of issues from Gaza,
Iran, and Ukraine.
That's different than us issuing statements about them,
but ultimately what Canadians want to see is progress
in these situations of intense human suffering.
And that's the focus, where we can have those outcomes.
Thank you.
Next question.
Prime Minister, in the Canadian readout of your meeting
with President Xi, you talked about coordinating on global governance
of artificial intelligence, whereas they simply talked about
that they look forward to cooperation on AI with Canada.
And I'm wondering, do you think that they have
the same understanding of your guardrails on that issue?
And can you explain what the guardrails on AI and critical minerals
are exactly? Does it mean no cooperation on those fronts?
What does it mean?
Well, I think, let me address the AI question because it's fundamental.
We are of the view, and many others share this,
that the absence of any global governance
around AI is an enormous risk.
It is an enormous risk for,
if you want to just put it in economic terms, it's an enormous
economic risk, but it's a biohazard risk and it's a risk to democracy,
human dignity, other
factors.
It's an enormous risk.
That isn't just our view.
That is the view of the individuals who run the World Frontier Labs.
You know who they are.
They express this view.
They express this view in public, they express this view in private.
It is exceptionally rare, in my experience,
that leaders of an industry are amongst the leaders
of those warning of risks in their own industry.
So it is past time to develop global
governance frameworks for these sectors.
We had discussions of this at the G7.
President Macron,
Prime Minister Stora convened a virtual discussion a few
weeks ago which we fully participated in.
I've had a number of discussions with
the incoming chair of the G20,
the United Kingdom, Prime Minister Starmer.
I took the opportunity in the discussions with President Xi yesterday
to share our views on a model for how
this governance can be developed and
With respect to China,
that is the principal area of cooperation,
which is how do we draw on the resources of Canada,
other leading countries that have expertise in AI safety,
and develop, at a minimum, ways of monitoring.
Sharing lessons from incidents and incidents response.
And, you know, one of my past,
I chaired something called the Financial Stability Board,
which did that in effect for the financial sector,
which brought groups together.
It wasn't a treaty-based organization.
It wasn't a requirement to follow the conclusions.
But actually, when you got everybody around the table
and they talked about where the risks were
and what could be done about it.
Most of them went home and did it,
and that's part of the reason, in my judgment, why the
financial system has not toppled over
when it's had a series of other big shocks from COVID to
what we've seen in recent years.
It's not a perfect analogy, but it's a good start for how
we should think about global governance for AI,
and I'll just underscore that ourselves,
a number of our G7 partners, a number of G20 countries.
And we would like to, I mean, there is not going
to be a global solution, to state the obvious, without
the leading countries in Frontier Labs, which very much includes China,
which is why we're having those discussions with them.
Thank you.
We're out of time.
I'll take the last.
I'm sorry.
Dylan Roberts, Canadian Press.
Thank you very much.
Given your focus on deals,
why has the Taiwan deal sat unsigned for more than one year?
Or does our ability to choose
not make it possible for Taiwan and the mainland?
I would not, I don't recognize your characterization of that.
Thank you very much for that.
There's been good progress on the economic cooperation agreement,
and we're hopeful that that will be signed soon.
Why is it set for a year?
I just said I don't recognize your characterization.
Next question, Professor Gissom.
Graham of CTV, Prime Minister.
Thank you, Minister.
Mr. Putin, President Putin said today or yesterday,
sanctions are a thing of the past.
He said that here.
I'm going to stop here.
I'm quoting a former prime minister quickly.
I guess I'll shake your hand, but I only have one thing to say to you.
You need to get out of Ukraine.
Will you be that blunt with him?
Well, look, we're very blunt.
First off, sanctions are not a thing of the past.
Canada has thousands of sanctions
on individuals in Russia, entities in Russia.
We're continuing to widen that sanction list,
for example, with the Shadow Fleet.
We're in close cooperation with our partners
in terms of real-time update of those sanctions.
And, you know, Mr. Putin can ask his financial institutions,
he can ask his oligarch friends, he can ask his hockey players.
Whether or not sanctions are a thing of the past,
I think you'll find out that they're very real, they're biting,
they're absolutely necessary
because it was an illegal and unjustified war.
And, you know, Canada's speaking with action.
In terms of direct conversation with Mr. Putin,
I mean, I fully agree with what Mr. Harper said in 2014.
This war started in 2014 in Crimea.
It continues.
And, you know, I don't think...
The President of the Russian Federation
is in any doubt about Canada's position and yes,
if I have the occasion to be next to him, I will make that clear,
but it is already clear and you know, not for the first time,
Vladimir Putin is lying about the situation on the ground.
Sanctions are very real
and they're going to continue to increase as long as this war goes on.
Last question.
Sir, there have been people very close to advising Mr. Trump on trade
that think that you're getting closer to China as a real threat
and they don't want to see that.
And I wonder in your conversations with the President,
have you detected that he himself is very uncomfortable
with Canada getting closer in all these ways that you're describing?
I, uh...
You know, we are exporting canola.
We are exporting pork, we are exporting halibut,
now is this, we have, we're exporting LNG,
we're exporting oil, we're exporting iron ore, some other aspects.
These are important industries,
these are not cutting-edge semiconductors, these are not
The types of trade relationship that the United States has with China
and I think that puts it in and nor is the content or is the orders
of magnitude of the trade that Canada has with China anywhere similar
relative to the size of our economy as the United States has.
Fully respect the United States engagement with China
and the efforts of President Trump.
To stabilize that relationship and use that relationship.
For positive outcomes, such as the initiative,
and I'm going to say something positive here
about the initiative around denuclearization,
the trilateral meeting that is going to happen.
Guess what? Canada's in favor of denuclearization.
If the relationship can be used in order towards that end,
we're very much supportive of it.
In my conversation with the president, he's tried to understand.
Where we are with China, where we're going with China,
but it's not, I wouldn't, I shouldn't speak
for him, but in his hierarchy of issues, it's not the top issue at all.
So, and at least because
if we make a small comparison in terms of the commercial,
technological, strategic relations
between the United States and...
And China, there are no comparisons in terms
of the commercial relations of China-Canada,
which is more of a relationship
of agricultural products
and natural gas and all that.
That's different from semiconductors and all that.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
