Finding an AEO agency that delivers real results requires asking the right questions. Avoid bad hires by checking their work.
Many businesses struggle to identify an AEO agency that actually understands AI-generated optimization. This video outlines the specific questions you need to ask to verify their experience before signing a contract. You will learn why looking at finished examples and seeing how they answer real prompts is the most effective way to judge their skill.
We also cover how to evaluate their performance metrics and determine if their execution team has the technical capability to handle your project. By focusing on these indicators, you can ensure your budget is spent on a team that does the work instead of just promising results.
Which vetting questions have you found most useful when hiring? Let me know in the comments, and subscribe to Shafin Tech for more software reviews and tutorials.
Your buyers are already asking ChatGPT which tool to use.
Most AEO agencies will sell you a dashboard that shows you losing,
but a dashboard can't change the answer.
So how do you hire an agency that can?
Here are four questions to ask before you choose.
AEO, sometimes called GEO,
is about helping your company appear in answers generated by AI tools.
Those answers draw on pages
that rank, citations, and third-party mentions.
An audit can show you where you're missing,
and that can be useful. But if the agency stops there,
it hasn't changed the sources
AI can find and cite. You need a team
that can turn what it learns into real work.
That distinction matters because a single screenshot
or one-time check can give you
an incomplete picture. The questions buyers ask can vary
and so can the sources behind the answers.
When you compare agencies,
look past the dashboard, find out what they'll do,
who will do it, and how you'll know whether
the work is making a difference.
First, link building.
Ask how the agency finds places to earn links and mentions.
The strongest opportunities are relevant sites
that AI engines already cite
when people ask questions in your category.
Citation data can help the agency find those
sites and choose where to focus.
Then it should be able to explain why each site makes sense for
your product and your buyers.
This is where a simple link count can be misleading. A large
number may look impressive in a report,
but it doesn't tell you whether those sites are relevant,
whether AI tools cite them,
or whether they help build your authority in the areas you care about.
Ask the agency to show how it chooses targets
and what it plans to do to earn placements there.
Ask which sites and why.
A red flag is links sold by domain rating scores
with no clear evidence that the sites are relevant or cited.
Second, content.
A good agency should turn buyer prompts
into published pieces that answer real questions,
describe your product accurately,
and make useful information easy to quote.
For a technical product,
that takes more than putting keywords into a template.
The content needs to explain what your product does,
who it helps, and how it fits into a
buyer's options.
Ask to see a finished example.
Look at how it answers a real prompt,
whether the product details are right, and whether
Whether a reader can find the answer quickly.
Then ask how the agency went
from the buyer's question to that finished piece.
You should be able to follow the reasoning,
not just read a list of recommended topics.
A deck of recommendations isn't the same
as useful content that's been written,
reviewed, and published. Ask, show me one for a technical product.
A red flag is decks only,
with no clear process for turning recommendations
into accurate published content.
Third, author hiring.
Technical content needs people who understand the subject.
Ask whether the agency hires subject matter experts for your account
and gives them real bylines.
For developer tools, it helps when an author
also works as a developer and understands how
people use products like yours.
Find out who will write for you, what experience they bring,
and how they'll learn about your product.
Ask how the agency checks technical details.
And make sure the writer's knowledge
comes through in the finished piece.
Your team should be able to see whose expertise is behind each article,
and your readers should be able to trust
that the person writing understands the topic.
That's different from sending every assignment
to whichever generalist is available.
Ask, who writes for us?
A red flag is one generalist writer pool
with no account-specific experts or real bylines.
Fourth, analytics.
Ask what you'll see in the first month's report.
Useful measurement can include
your visibility across a defined set of prompts.
Citation share compared with competitors,
AI referral traffic and signups,
and before and after logs for each page the agency changes.
Those measures help you understand what
the team did and what happened afterward.
A useful first report should give you a starting point,
record the work completed, and make the next steps clear.
You should be able to see which prompts were checked,
which pages changed, and what the agency learned from the results.
A ranking snapshot on its own won't
show whether AI tools are citing you,
whether the right visitors are arriving,
or whether the work is contributing to signups.
And if the report doesn't help you decide what
to do next, it's not doing enough.
Ask, what's in the month one report?
A red flag is rankings only without prompt visibility,
citation share, referral traffic, signups, or page level change logs.
If content execution is your priority,
here are three AEO agencies worth shortlisting.
This isn't a definitive ranking.
Compare the people who will actually work on your account.
First, AUQ focuses on complex GEO for SaaS products,
including developer tools and fintech
startups. It hires developer authors to write technical
and marketing content and support
startups end-to-end. From strategy
and content to development and mentioned building, ask who
would write for your product
and what work is included beyond publishing. Second,
Draft.dev may fit developer tool companies
that need technically credible content.
Its team includes software engineers,
developer marketers, writers, and editors,
and it offers support for content aimed at answer engines.
Ask to see a sample for a
product as technical as yours and find out
who checks the details. Third,
Foundation works with B2B tech
and SaaS companies combining AI visibility strategy
with on-site content planning
and distribution through channels like Reddit.
Ask who creates and publishes the content
and how the team measures whether it's being cited.
Whichever agency you consider,
meet the people doing the work and review a relevant sample.
Ask how they measure visibility
and connect it to qualified traffic or signups.
If the pitch is clear, but the execution team isn't, keep looking.