Malik Muhammad’s murder conviction vacated after judge finds rights violations

Fox - 32 Chicago
8 followers
1 Video View·Nov 18, 2026
Welcome back. A man convicted of a murder,
he says he wasn't even in town to commit,
is finally getting a chance to clear his name.
Malik Mohammed was arrested in 1999,
but always maintained that he was innocent.
15 years later, he filed a police torture claim,
and a judge reviewed the evidence
and agreed that his constitutional rights were in fact violated.
A hearing today will decide whether he'll be able to walk free.
We want to introduce you to
to the author of that book.
It is called Crime Fictions by Professor Nicole Gonzales.
Gonzalez Van Cleve, Nicole, thank you for coming in,
talk to us a little bit more about
the update on this case.
Yeah, so Chicago, as many Chicagoans know,
is the wrongful conviction capital of the
nation.
And Malik Muhammad is one of the signature cases in this book.
I met him in a prison education program
and he kind of yelled out from the Zoom room from
it's a Northwestern prison education program and said,
listen, I'm innocent, they've been
They've been burying files, and I was thinking.
What is this, right? I didn't believe him,
but I kind of leaned into what he was saying.
And he always maintained his innocence in his case.
In fact, he was visiting his grandmother
in Seattle on the night of the murder that he was convicted.
What they found is that officers
were bearing evidence that.
People had not identified him at the scene or as the killer,
and that evidence was buried.
And so the judges now vacated that conviction
because all that evidence should have gone
to the defense attorneys.
Malik had said this all the time.
I investigated in crime fictions,
but now a judge is really vindicating that truth in
a court, and he may see freedom.
Tell me about really your journey of investigating it
because somebody could yell across the
room and you think, there's nothing to this.
Right.
Tell me all that you had to go through
to really uncover what was the truth.
Yeah, so this book is really the culmination
of a decade long study of the criminal
justice system here in Chicago.
I started as a Northwestern undergrad
and I was embedded in the prosecutor's office
and I saw how sloppily they were handling these cases.
Officers would come in and they would lie on cases,
prosecutors knew about it, judges
told me about it.
And that led me to think about wrongful conviction
as really an epidemic, not a set of accidents
or misfires, but a patterned way.
We have cases flowing through our criminal justice system
and that a realization from
being embedded in the system led
to this research where I looked through the wrongful conviction
of exonerated people.
And saw that there were patterned ways.
Police lying in the court, lying on the stand,
bearing evidence, roughing suspects up or
torturing them, and tricking people into false confessions,
even a child as young as seven
years old.
That's sick.
What was the motivation by police to do this?
Was it pressure to close a case?
Was it like a top-down situation?
Where did that all begin?
There's a lot of...
Politicking around these high profile cases.
So one case that's profiled is the Ryan Harris case.
And if you remember and had been a Chicagoan,
it's a horrendous case where this young girl
was murdered.
And there's so much pressure on police to clear the case,
which means just basically
charge anybody.
There's no measure of accuracy in this.
And so with that pressure,
police are not even that good at clearing cases, sometimes
the measure is 50% and for African American victims, it's much lower.
And so by just naming anyone
and being absolved of any responsibility, they basically just
pass the buck then to prosecutors and the judges
and often the prosecutors work hand
in glove with police.
If they don't try these cases or if they stand up to police,
it's like career suicide.
Prosecutors have a lot of pressure to go along with police
and that's how we get this
kind of assembly line of errors that's kind
of going through the system as we have it
in Chicago.
That's interesting because the clearance rate
in Chicago has always been a topic of
discussion and it's always been considered low.
Yeah.
So it's interesting that you would be pushing
for this when the clearance rate isn't
improving based on doing this.
Yes, it's not improving
but also the question is that we don't know and as a researcher
And a professor.
I cannot tell you how many errors we have in the system.
What I can tell you is when a young man like Malik yells out
and says, listen, they're
burying evidence in my case, talk to my attorney,
you kind of start to see a groundswell.
That same attorney is now representing
multiple defendants that all have had.
Evidence buried in their cases,
it almost feels endless, like it's a bottomless hole.
And that part is the scariest part of crime fictions
is that there are fictions written
about innocent people and we just accept them as truth.
I wanna ask you about the cover.
I don't know if we can pull that back up,
but I think the cover was intentional for
a reason.
And I wanna ask you the idea behind the cover,
the person with this hood on, you can't see
their face.
What was the ideology behind that?
These cases that are profiled in crime fictions
are Chicago cases that start in the 60s with
a young man named Lee Hester
who was basically framed for the murder of his teacher.
He was disabled all the way until the present day.
And I call them brothers through time
because no matter if you're studying it in the 60s,
the 70s, the 80s, all the way to the present day,
these kids, regardless of who is behind this hood
They all share this common journey of injustice,
being in prison for something they didn't do.
It's hard enough to be in prison in general,
but we usually blame people. Well, you're there for
something. It's hard to rationalize being there for nothing, right?
Just being the kid. Malik was
framed because his name was the same as somebody in his neighborhood.
George Jones is another kid.
He was a George and there was other Georges in the neighborhood.
So sometimes even sharing the
He links these kids and gets them to be pointed or profiled.
And so this hood is kind of symbolic.
It's mostly black children and they're all kind of brothers over time.
Or perhaps living in a certain zip code.
Yes, absolutely.
Englewood is definitely almost like a character
in this world of crime fictions where it's
a centerpiece.
But also the police station of 51st
and Wentworth is where they buried 500 case files of possibly
innocent people.
And Candace Gorman...
As an attorney, that was central to unearthing that.
They were in the boiler room.
Wow.
We don't have any time left,
but how has Cook County State's attorney Eileen O'Neal
Burke responded to some of these accusations?
Well, the hard part is that she is coming in new, right?
She could in some ways admit that her predecessors made mistakes,
but she hasn't done that.
She's been endorsed by the Chicago police
and she's even tied to a wrongful conviction
case in this book.
She has not appropriately apologized
or created policies that would change the possibility
of that happening.
The kid that was wrongfully convicted was only 12.
And so I would like to see her look at a case like Malik's
and say, is this worth?
Pursuing, we have no physical evidence tying him.
He has an airtight alibi.
We know police officers were dirty in this case.
That's the type of case that seems like it's low hanging fruit.
Let's create some goodwill with people and let's try to do better.
So I'm hoping and I'm hopeful that if she takes these cases
and this research in good
faith, then maybe it would create a new day in Chicago.
Well, thank you for the work that you're doing.
Hopefully she heard you loud and clear
because she was supposed to be better than Kim Foxx.
That's how it was built.
Let's watch and see what happens. Right.
Thank you, Nicole. Thank you so much. All right.
