'She's doing abominably' | PMQs analysed
Nov 19, 2026
I've been speaking to Andy Burnham, James,
about our favourite topic, which we love to discuss at PMQs,
which is will the UK go back into Europe at some point?
And this is obviously going to be a huge debate
for the Labour Party going forward.
We had David Lamb in this morning, which you've been speaking about,
about making the case that he thinks it should be on the next ballot,
should be on the next manifesto for Labour to put to the public.
And, obviously, Andy Burnham privately agrees with him.
He does want to do that.
He said, I want to rejoin the EU in my lifetime.
But now, after some of his cabinet have...
I think he is a little bit more nervous about having
that conversation quite so openly.
But we've got this big Brexit summit on Friday.
He'll be flying to Brussels to sign a series of new deals,
youth mobility, a new food and drink deal, EU passports,
lots of things that he hopes will bring down bills
and bring some benefits back and bring us closer to the European Union.
But Andy Burnham also facing far more questions about what comes next,
what happens after the next general election.
He's opening this conversation up.
He told me when I spoke.
I spoke to him yesterday that this conversation is all about growth,
and he says the British public do want a closer relationship.
My mission here is to get more growth into the British economy,
to add to UK GDP, and all of these things are possible
from the deal that's on the table.
You have a retailer like M&S saying that it will bring down
the cost of the weekly shop.
Now, why wouldn't I face that and try and land it for...
For Britain, because that's exactly what people need right now.
So, you know, we're not in the right position in relation to Brexit.
I think the British public support closer,
a closer working relationship with the EU.
That's what I'm seeking to achieve.
And James, I think...
What Andy Burnham is most worried about
is sort of opening the box too early.
So he obviously has set out his stall and what he does want.
But he is worried about what that Brexit argument means.
But as he was talking about just then with me,
it's all about the economy, right?
He keeps talking about growth
and he says the government needs to get serious on growth.
So I asked him, well, if that's true,
the biggest thing you could do is go back into the EU.
Is that still your preference to rejoin the EU in your lifetime?
Well, we shouldn't get ahead of ourselves here.
So first of all, we've got to conclude this deal at this summit
and then take stock after that.
But I do see a second stage process where we look at the options.
But we need to realise that Britain
is different in 26 than it was in 2016,
but so is the EU as well.
So those options could look very, very different.
But I just think we have a calm and considered debate
about what those might look like.
I am bringing forward a 10-year plan for Britain.
I'm determined that the next decade ahead of us
is going to be better than the one we've just lived through.
It's been a decade of drift and division,
and I'm drawing a line on that.
I'm trying to make the country feel more hopeful,
giving young people that sense of possibility for their future,
but also getting more growth into the economy.
And all of that, I think, will help turn things around.
And as part of that.
I have to address the question of what
is our long-term relationship with our largest market.
If I didn't address that question,
I don't think I would be bringing forward a 10-year plan worthy
of the name. So we will consider that carefully.
And when the time is right, we will set out those
options. But the British public will be the boss here.
I won't be jumping ahead of public opinion.
I just want all possibilities to be explored
so that we keep the British economy growing in the
And we do everything we can to address these cost
of living pressures that people are facing.
He's not remotely frightened of the conversation, is he?
He's coming alive. He actually wants to talk about it.
He wants to have that debate.
That's the big shift since Starmer.
Yeah, it definitely feels...
Here, Starmer was scared of it.
Andy Burnham is embracing it.
It's clear that he does want rejoin on the cards.
There is a question, of course,
about what those options are going to be,
but we don't know that yet.
But we have talked as well, James,
about how the moon music's changed,
people are feeling differently,
the polls are showing that people are feeling differently.
And finally, the Prime Minister had one message
for one former Prime Minister,
some Boris Johnson.
He thinks the public would vote again.
Well, I don't think he's an authority on these matters because,
you know, we ended up with a Brexit deal that I think has left
Britain losing more than it gained over the last few years.
And we left with bridges burnt and bad feeling.
And how does that help when you're still talking about
a European Union that's our largest market?
I mean, clearly, you've got to get closer.
And that's what I'm doing.
Be more constructive.
Reach out.
That's what I'm doing.
You know, if he says that wrong, well, he can have his view,
but I won't be listening to it.
Hallelujah. Hallelujah.
Somebody finally putting Boris Johnson in his box.
If he didn't surrender any right whatsoever to speak
with supposed authority on this subject
when he was chased out of Parliament by his own party,
then I don't know when that would happen.
But Burnham quite rightly suggesting
that Boris Johnson would do well to...
Observe a period of self-imposed silence,
although he can't because the Daily Mail is still paying him hundreds
of thousands of pounds a year to print and write absolute bilge.
I enjoyed that. Good interview. How long did you get with him?
Yeah, about 10 minutes, yeah.
He was really relaxed.
I think he really opened up on that.
Is he enjoying himself?
I think so, yeah.
Because Farmer never gave the impression of enjoying himself.
I think he is.
I think he is enjoying it.
And yeah, he seemed pretty relaxed.
He seemed pretty happy.
And like I say, engaged in that Brexit debate,
engaged and wanted to talk about news
and what the government are doing.
Fascinating development.
I think that's where we will see that Andy Burnham,
you know, the true Andy Burnham coming out
in the months to come as he wants to talk about that.
So that could come up at PMQs today,
as we'll be hearing in a few minutes' time.
It's going to be interesting, that,
because Lammy makes this point in his piece for The Times today.
Leaving Badenoch and Farage to fight over
the residents of Idiot's Corner
is probably quite a clever thing to do.
It is, yeah.
But what does Badenoch do with it in the context of PMQ?
It's a really tough one because...
I think she and everybody knows
that the move music has changed around this,
and especially in terms of business,
which the Conservatives have been traditionally stronger on,
the economy and on businesses.
So is this something that she feels
like she can change the position on?
At the moment, it doesn't look like it.
Her other options, of course, going in on the NEETs crisis
and whether the government would accept
that it's made mistakes on the Employment Rights Act,
which Alan Milburn said yesterday essentially it has,
and of course the National Insurance
Cup, which I did press him on as well,
Well, and he definitely opened the door to me that he.
He did think that Rachel Reeves was wrong to put up national insurance
and that he wants to do something about it
when he's got some more money to do so.
And he can, of course.
He wasn't even in the government when that policy was introduced.
But it's hard to attack your former colleagues, especially Labour ones.
You can't disown their policy.
And he decided not to do that,
but he took a very large intake of breath before replying.
So I do think I know what he thinks about that.
And finally, energy bills.
I was quite shocked to see the reports we've just
been seeing this morning about them.
Oh, 26% in January.
That could be something that Kemi Badenoff
will really give the government a whack on.
Despite knowing that it's all Donald Trump's fault.
Exactly.
And Andy Burnham will have a really great response.
Because you wanted to be in that war, Kemi Badenoff,
although you have subsequently claimed that you didn't,
despite the fact that you were on tape saying that you did.
So Andy Burnham has got some lines ready to go on that, I'm sure.
He's got three big lines, hasn't he?
He's got the fact you had 14 years to sort this out.
He's got the fact that I'm not...
Keir Starmer, and I'm perfectly free to move away
from some of the things that he did.
You can't hang them around my neck.
And then he's got the fact that Badenoch
and Farage were so far up Trump's fundament
when he launched this ludicrous war against Iran
that you could only see their feet.
And none of them can get off that hook, however hard they wriggle.
And he's got a great story to tell already on energy bills,
because that was the thing he did
the moment he came in, was cut VAT on energy bills.
That's now come in. Of course it's not going to...
touch the sides if we're looking at these kind of increases
but he's showing his direction of travel and he wants
to do a bit to help that
so I think that that is a really good story
for him to at least tell. He's already done some things
to help with energy bills already so
it's a good start but
people are going to be really suffering come January
if these predictions come true.
Did I imagine it or did Cammy Baden not just
essentially say to Andy Burnham, I know you are
but what am I?
She did.
Yeah, okay.
She did.
Okay.
And what's this new category of unemployed people
who are unemployed but not unemployed?
But not unemployed.
Yeah.
So I think what she was trying to say was that you can go on to...
benefits where you then don't have to look for work.
I'm not quite sure how that happens.
But not two years of being unemployed
and then suddenly you go on to a disability benefit. I
don't think it works like that.
But hey-ho, anyone suggest that she doesn't understand things? Because
if you suggest that she doesn't understand things,
she will say, I know you don't, but what am I?
He doesn't understand. You don't understand.
No, I don't understand. Yeah, interesting PMQs there.
Burnham confirming, as he did when I was speaking to him yesterday,
that he'll look at that national insurance tax cut on NEETs.
We would consider the Melbourne report and all of its proposals.
But really, as we were just discussing,
really having the fight there on Brexit and on growth.
And actually using the argument there that I think we sort of just
touched on, the argument that the Tories were the party of business.
And how can they not support getting close to Europe
when it's going to be better for them?
I like this tactic.
He's not sort of hitting anybody over the head with it yet,
but it's popping up, isn't it, frequently,
where he suggests that there is a case for consensus
or cross-party agreement, not on everything,
but there'll be, I presume there is still some vaguely sensible
and thoughtful people left on the Conservative benches,
albeit it's hard off the top of my head to name any,
but there'll be people sitting there who are just thinking,
well, we don't have...
...disagree with everything that's going on just
because they're wearing red ties and we're wearing blue ties.
Why are we just fighting everything for the sake of it?
And I like this. I think it plays well with the public as well
because the voters will be the same.
They'll be like, I don't know that I would vote for him,
but they're right on this.
Whereas Bailinock doesn't seem to have it in her DNA to...
Consensus or compromise.
Yeah, and Andy Burnham has reached out on that, hasn't he?
Yeah, on a couple of things.
On Brexit, on social care.
But it's really hard for her.
In the same way it's hard for Andy Burnham to admit that Rachel Reeves
may have been wrong to put up national insurance,
it's really hard for Kemi Bade not to say
the Tories got it wrong on Brexit
or got the wrong deal.
And Andy Burnham says, you know, these are the facts,
the deal wasn't good enough.
I don't know if she's going to be able to...
To admit that as being part of that last government.
I like it, though.
It's hard.
This close to saying that's not an opinion.
It's just counting, isn't it?
I mean, literally this close to saying it.
So Boris Johnson back in your box.
And Brexit, the Brexit deal we signed was bad.
These are not opinions.
He's had some Weetabix today.
Yeah, exactly that.
But where Kemi Badenoch was, I think,
a slightly stronger one was on...
This idea that what are you actually going to do with the NEETs crisis
because there is this big plan from Alan Milburn
But he is saying it's going to take a long time
and maybe that is just government
Maybe that's the argument that you can
say when you're outside of government
You can just throw it saying speed up speed up
We want you to do things faster faster,
which is what the public say all the time, don't they?
But actually when you are in government,
it does take longer to do things
But there are lots of decisions that we are waiting
to see Andy Burnham's government make some
decisions on and make some moves on.
And her argument is you keep saying everything's going
to be 10 years. We're waiting for your 10 year plan,
which we do expect to come in a couple of
weeks time. But people need support now.
And, you know, try saying that to the people that
need a job now. And that's an argument I think resonates.
with some of the public there.
But Andy Burnham, on the other hand,
having some really good soundbites, I thought, this week
and some good sort of messaging.
He said, we won't let the letdown generation
become the lost generation, I think was what he said.
And he also had some really good fighting talk on the Tories.
They slashed youth services, they cut EMA,
they tripled fees, they took hope back.
From a generation, we will give it back to them.
That was quite a nice moment, I thought.
Again, just facts, not opinions.
They did slash youth services.
They did triple tuition fees.
I suppose it's an opinion to say
they took hope away from a generation.
Yes, I think you'll probably say that's not it.
That bit is an opinion.
If we still have the Burnham Optimism barometer,
I think it might have just...
That was 10 out of 10 for the Burnham Optimism.
And again, I don't know.
I find it interesting, and it's my show,
so I can indulge this.
This, I find it.
It's really compelling that he is enjoying himself.
I mean, I think she's enjoying herself as well,
which is psychologically a slightly more complicated process.
But Burnham wants to be there, doesn't he?
Whereas for the last 12 months or so of Keir Starmer's premiership,
he gave quite a strong impression of...
Of not wanting.
Yeah, I think you're right.
And I sat next to a sketch writer at the Melbourne speech yesterday
who said, oh, it's really annoying, Natasha,
when I think that Andy Burnham
and Kenny Baden are both doing a good job
because I don't have anything to write.
And I think they are both doing well.
She's doing well at opposing.
And I think he's doing well and, again, enjoying himself in that job.
So, yeah, maybe politics is going to get boring.
Yeah, well, I mean, I think she's doing abominably, for the record.
And I wouldn't embarrass you by asking which scap tricer it was,
but I imagine he works for a newspaper or she works for a newspaper
where he wouldn't be allowed to say
that Cammy Badenoch was doing abominably.
Actually, you'd be surprised.
I won't reveal my sources, but you'll be surprised.
They've taken all the chips off Nigel Farage now
and they've got nowhere else to put them.
But until next week.

