Comparison of a 5W laser, 10W, and 20W diode laser. All these machines have their pros and their cons, but this is a quick comparison of their ability to cut and engrave. I do not have a lot of experience with lasers and have been learning through using these. The program I am running is Lightburn and I find it pretty easy to use with the help of the tutorials you can find on YouTube.
As a disclaimer I was given each of these machines to use and post about - I purchased the 10W upgrade for the Ortur. I do have an affiliate link for xTool but for most beginners I believe the 10W is a good starting point both in price and use.
Hi, I've got a small wood shop
and I've got three different lasers in here. I've got a 5 watt,
a 10 watt, and now a 20 watt.
Now I've used these to do a couple little engravings, but I thought
since I now have all three of these,
they're all diode lasers, I would do a comparison to see how
they can do different things.
I'm going to cut some material, some wood. I'm going to cut half
inch, quarter inch, and an eighth inch.
I'm going to cut all of these at a 50 speed, 100% power.
I'm going to cut this a little bit faster,
but I'm going to cut six passes at the 100%.
All of these, I'm going to cut through so we can see how deep they go.
And I'm going to do some engraving to check the speed.
I want to be able to compare these a little bit.
Now, I don't have a huge amount of experience with lasers.
My 5-watt was the first one I ever used.
Now I'm up to this 20-watt.
I just want to see what the difference is,
and I thought other people would be interested.
So stick around.
all right so the five watt laser i am using is the Atomstack
A5 M50 Pro laser 5.5 fixed focus you can see
that it has a little knob on the front that
you could use to adjust
which made really easy i accidentally set it up for two passes
so i did that for all of the cuts
this is a nice laser it's expandable you can make it longer
It has limit switches
and that front component has an emergency stop that you can depress and
stop it and then twist it and start it again.
So that's kind of a nice option.
The one thing I don't like about this is the height.
The space of the z-axis movement is nice
but that whole the stepper motor is on the top
which makes it really difficult to store it
because it is so tall. So the other ones have
the stepper motors below which makes it easier.
And here I'm doing an engraving test.
All of these are going to be at 1800 speed and 70%
power and there's a speed test as well
and I'll talk about that in a little bit.
For the 10 watt laser I am using the Ortur Laser Master 2.
It was a 5 watt. I
upgraded to the 10. One of the things I don't like about
this is that it requires two plugs.
and extra cords hanging all over
so all of these machines are really easy to set up they all
operate pretty well all of them i'm using LightBurn
for and they all have about the same cutting
area now one of the things that's different with the Ortur
and the Atomstack is you need a card
a piece of plastic to space the laser
so that's kind of a hassle you have to find it overall i
like this machine i like the size it operates well
and it's got nice markings on it
One of the things I'm not a huge fan of.
Again are the multiple cords I needed
and the thumb screw adjustment on the side. Now you can
see it cutting here again the mahogany.
I'm doing the engraving and here is just the speed test and
everything else that I'm going to talk about in a little bit.
So overall the 10 watt is a nice machine.
For the 20 watt, I'm using the xTool D1 Pro 20 watt laser.
Now it doesn't have a card for the spacer, you saw that lever
and you put that down and that laser that you were seeing going around
actually is to frame out and figure out where you're going to cut.
So in terms of the laser, it is a true 20 watt output,
which not all 20 watt lasers are. Sometimes it says 20 watt.
But that's the amount of power going in.
Now, this is a little bit more solid machine than
the other ones, which is nice.
It looks much better.
It still has that stop on the front.
It also has air assist, which is easy to set up.
And it is a really powerful machine.
For me, there are a couple of things that make the xTool
a little bit better than the other ones in terms of what you get,
whether it's the 10 or the 20 watt.
It also has its own software,
so you can use LightBurn or the software that they sell with it.
I do like the closed frame and the setup.
All right, so here are the results.
Now, I did change what I was going to do.
I ran a speed test, engraving test.
I did one eighth inch, quarter inch, half inch, and 0.27 MDF,
and I did an engraving. Now, the thing is, I ran out of time.
Really, I had three machines in my
shop, and I don't have any place to build anything
or anything like that, so I had to do some stuff.
Cut short all the tests I wanted to do,
but these are the results. Let me show them to you.
All right, 1/8 inch plywood, roughly 3 millimeters, 5, 10, and 20.
Now, I accidentally
set this up wrong. Somehow or other, I hit two passes instead of one.
Did not pay attention.
Took roughly five minutes.
Now, I want you to see one pass. I'm sorry, two passes,
two passes, and I only did one pass
with this because it cut through it too quickly.
So you can see some charring here on the second.
It would have made through on the one.
You can see charring on the back side.
Up to the quarter inch, 5, 10, 20.
Again, with 20, I only did one pass.
Notice the charring.
Now with the 5 watt,
it didn't even punch through the other side at all.
And you can see the amount of charring on the side.
Ideally, this would have been slowed down.
And the 0.27 MDF.
So two passes, two passes.
I only did one pass again.
Notice that we're almost through.
Lots of charring with the two passes here,
and this is the half inch with two passes.
Again, one of the things I want to show is I'm going
to cut this in half and show you what it looks like,
but notice with these two, we're almost through with two passes.
and the amount of charring. So here's that piece cut in half.
Notice that the 5 watt barely even
punched through the top.
The 10 and the 20 watt both did a really nice job almost all the way
through. We finish up with the 0.5 with six passes.
Not even mark on the other side. Both
of these cut through. Notice the amount of charring.
That was impressive. I didn't think
I don't think it would cut through that.
Because I tried with another one.
You can see the amount of charring likely to start a fire.
Air assist would be good.
And then let's look at an engraving.
I just did a simple engraving.
So all of these, 1800 speed, 70% power.
Took roughly the same amount of time.
But notice how deep this one.
This one's pretty clean.
I wouldn't mind this.
A lot of charring here.
I could have slowed it down or sped it up or decreased the speed.
And I'm sure once I sand that it would look nice.
There's a lot of detail on that as well.
Key thing to learn or know is that I could
do these much faster if I had a multitude of them.
And last I did an engraving test using eighth inch plywood.
This is the five watt.
The speeds of the material are on the side 500 to 2500
and the percent power 10 to 100.
You'll notice the striking difference between these two.
You can see we're almost through on
I'm going to ruin a couple of those, and this is the
20 watt, and you'll see that we did go through on most of these.
Again, somehow or other, I inverted
this. I don't know what I did, but notice again,
500 to 2500, 10 to 100% power. You can see how
much faster the 20 watt is compared to the others.
All right, so my opinion. You can see that the 5
watt did a lot of nice things,
but it just doesn't have the same power or speed as a 10 and a 20
watt. The 10 watt and the 20 watt,
very similar in terms of some of the stuff they could cut out.
The 20 watt is obviously going to be faster.
When it comes to the MDF, it did not cut out as nice.
Even, I think having air assist would help, but not enough.
I have started making and selling
these MDF templates for cornhole boards.
It takes me 21 minutes to cut and engrave this
with a 20 watt. So it works out really well.
In terms of engraving this,
The 20 watt obviously is much faster and better
so that's really the key difference is that the
20 watt is going to be much faster and be able to cut more.
I just did this engraving. Here it is.
I did that as a commission piece. I did it with a 20 watt.
It took me two and a half hours to
cut that. If I'd done it
with a 10 watt it would have taken me much longer. So again
My suggestion, if you are buying an entry-level laser,
you're just getting started, skip the 5-watt.
It's going to frustrate you
because there's a limit to pretty much anything,
and it'll take way too much time.
The 10-watt will allow you to do more,
but it'll take a little bit longer.
The 20-watt, if you want to do any sort
of production capacity for yourself,
small shop-wise, I would go with a 20-watt.
Obviously, a 40-watt or larger would be better.
I don't have a 40-watt.
But the diode lasers have a lot of capability
and do a really nice job cutting out stuff.
And I'm really happy with the 20 watt.
So that would be my suggestion if you're making things to sell
and time is a factor.
Probably my best thought.
Have a good day.
Thanks for watching.