N.B. students weigh in on cellphone ban
1 Video View·Nov 21, 2026
Well, some students in New Brunswick
are taking action against cell phone bans.
Hundreds of students walked out
of high schools yesterday to protest the policy.
And here's what the government has asked schools to follow.
From kindergarten to grade eight,
no cell phones for students at all allowed.
For high schools this semester,
no cell phones during class time, but they can use them during
breaks. Next semester, though,
high schools will have to follow the same policy as K-8,
but it's worth mentioning some high schools
in Anglophone West have already
put a cell phone ban in place. Freya Painter-Bearden is in grade 10 at
École St. Anne in Fredericton.
Emmett Flores is in grade 10 at Leo Hayes High School.
They join me in studio, and over the phone,
we have another student, William Van Dusen.
He is in grade 10 at Moncton High School.
Good morning, everyone.
Good morning.
Good morning.
Good morning.
Okay, so let's start with this walkout yesterday.
Freya, did you participate in this?
I was actually away in Ottawa for the UNICEF Youth Advocacy Summit.
Okay, would you have participated if you were here?
Probably. I'm really happy that we were able to come together
and protest peacefully for what we want.
Okay, we'll get to your views in a moment.
I'm going to turn to you, Emmett. Were you at the walkout yesterday?
I sadly was not able to participate in it, no.
You sadly weren't, so you wanted to?
Yeah.
Okay. William, what about you?
Yeah, I was at the protest at the end there.
I was going to go to a different school's protest
because they were supposed to go to the office, the protest,
but I didn't go.
But when I did go to the protest,
my sign said, this protest is stupid.
Oh.
Stupid was spelled wrong,
which I feel it represents the education system in New Brunswick.
How did you spell stupid?
S-T-U-P-E-D.
Um, so yeah, when I got down there,
people saw my sign and they, um, they actually ripped it up
and they took it because they felt offended from my sign.
Wow. Okay. So were you among the
minority there at the walkout with your,
with your sign protesting the protest? I was the only
person there. Okay. And how did you feel when they ripped up your sign?
That's pretty aggressive.
I honestly didn't really care
because I feel like
It really represents what direction this province is going towards.
Okay. So, William, I want to get into your views in a moment,
but maybe I just want to back up and get, it seems like every school
is different, right, guys, with their policies
and the way they're handling cell phones. So, Emmett,
how does it work at Leo Hayes right now with the cell phone policy?
So currently, it mainly goes that you can have your phone
with you during your free time, but during classes.
What we call phone hotels,
so it's like different pouches where you place your phones in according
to what number in the class you are,
and you just leave it there for the class.
And afterwards, you just collect it at the end of the period.
A phone hotel?
Yeah.
So what is it?
Is it like a tower in your classroom?
No, it's like a set of pouches that are hanging against the wall,
and you just put it in your
number.
Okay, so you put it in your little pouch,
and do some people try to say, well, I don't
have a cell phone right now?
How often does that happen?
All the time.
And do they sometimes actually have a cell phone in their pocket?
I would say nine times out of ten they actually do.
So what can teachers do in that case?
It's difficult to say because obviously teachers can't
do anything physical to the student or anything.
But obviously at that point, what my teachers have started doing
is they just look over the phone things and they mark students
as absent if they don't go through, which gives them detention.
Okay. So does that work?
I mean, I think so, at least in my classes.
Okay. Freya, what about you? How does it work at your school?
Similarly, we walk into class,
put our phone in a little pocket on the wall,
sit down, and we don't have it for the entirety of the class.
Um
If, say, you say that you don't have your phone,
which to me doesn't happen often in my classes,
tends to be people who might actually just not have a phone that day,
then they're like, okay, but they do note it,
and so they keep track of if you don't have
the phone or if you do have a phone.
Um, yeah, and they also do use those to mark absences,
you.
but of course if you say that you're
there, they're going to mark you as there.
Right, and then after the class is done,
after the bell rings, you get your phone back for
the break, and that's going to change
in the new year where no school, no phones at all.
Um, well, what I understand is that phones are not visible,
which could cause quite a
lot of issues because, okay,
a teacher may not see the phone, but the phone is still
I'm still there, and...
Personally, I think it is better to be able to see the phones,
have them away from you, and it actually limits a lot more distractions
than if you had them on in your backpack.
Right. Okay.
William, how is it going to work at your high school?
Or how does it work, sorry, at your high school?
Well, currently, it's very confusing
because some teachers enforce it more than other teachers,
which I think it's because of their beliefs on it.
Um, but they all, they all tell us that we have to put them away,
right? Most people don't put
them away and they don't really care.
They don't mark, um, attendance off of what they see, um,
from the phones in the pocket,
even though there's pockets in every classroom.
Okay. Wow. What a range of, uh, the way schools do it differently.
So Freya and Emmett, you both
Sounds like you're kind of in support, or sorry,
not wanting to see a full cell phone ban.
I'll start with you, Freya. Why is that? Why do you feel that way?
Well, as we saw in the protest yesterday,
it's students' main way of feeling safe,
of being connected to their parents,
to their friends, to the world around them.
And also, this phone ban will take a lot of resources,
money, and time to enforce and police.
I feel like those resources would
be better directed towards positive investments for schools.
I'll give you an example. In my school, in my math class,
we have one copy of the textbook for 30 students and the teacher.
So having maybe more physical media in classrooms,
if you want to take us off screens, then you need...
Actual resources for teachers and students.
I've also heard the suggestion of let's go back to the paper agenda.
You know, we, I grew up with that where everything goes
in that paper agenda and you physically
write it down instead of putting it into a Google calendar or,
you know, Outlook calendar.
Thank
That's what you're kind of talking about, right?
Like physical.
No, I'm mostly talking about.
Textbooks, being able to work on paper.
Teachers have a limit of how much paper they can use.
And students find it difficult when they have to answer math
worksheets on a computer.
Or it's also a lot easier to cheat,
you.
and therefore you're not really retaining the information.
And paper is a lot better for education, for learning,
and it's been proven.
And other countries are going back to paper,
and I think that it would be beneficial for us to.
Thank you.
Thank you.
And it would probably improve New Brunswick's education quite
a lot more than banning phones,
while also not infringing on students' rights.
Okay. Emmett, how do you feel?
So, I mainly have, like, three big reasons, I could say,
as to why I think this isn't really going to work.
So my first reason is, in history, just in general,
People rebel against what is handed to them.
If they're getting taken away, what they believe is theirs,
they will do something about it.
And we saw it yesterday with the walkout,
but it will only incite more
if it actually gets implemented as in students
will, who knows what they will do.
What if they just say no and just bring their phones anyways,
what are they going to do?
Are they going to the whole school of 2000 students at Leo Hayes high
school? Are they going to just, what are they going to do?
There's like a hundred teachers and.
There's just a point of students can just
do different things to just try and incite
rebellion with others that will not really help
the cause that the government is trying
to put forward.
Thank
Another reason I have is through the,
again, through like the paper thing, right?
I was talking and with a few people in my school
and we were discussing the fact that
what if we just go back to how it was,
like how we were just talking about.
Um, but the issue with that is that in New
you.
Brunswick schools don't have librarians anymore.
So we aren't able, like my school has textbooks in every class,
but we don't have, you don't
have a librarian, a librarian.
And it's how that is in New Brunswick.
I don't, I'm not sure for every school,
but I'm pretty sure for every school that there
aren't librarians anymore to help us
with those kinds of things that schools from not
many schools there aren't.
Yeah.
I think there are still, I'm sorry.
Go on.
Yeah.
From like 10, 20 years ago, who used that as a resource.
But because we don't have that, we can't utilize that.
And another issue that we have is I don't personally believe it's
the phones that are the problem.
Because prior to 2009, 50% of NB literacy rates
were at literacy rates of 1 and 2 prior to 2009.
Phones weren't actually a big thing.
And according to Statistics Canada,
50% of New Brunswickers between the ages of 16 and 65
Do not have the necessary literacy levels
to compete in the workforce.
So it's a big issue that we have,
and I don't think phones are the reason behind this,
but instead of going after the thing that isn't the problem,
they should be working towards different ways to help us.
Okay.
Do you have another one more point to make
before we go to William?
No, it can wait.
William, I want to bring you into this.
Where do you stand on this issue or your arguments?
Thank
I did two hours of research last night on this, and my stance before
this is I feel like we should have it in our free time.
Now, after I've educated myself on it,
I think we should just ban the phones completely.
We see a bunch of other countries doing it,
and they are all top 20 in education in the world, right?
you.
Netherlands, New Zealand, Finland, Australia,
they all have some sort of phone ban in their country.
And I think it.
If it applies in the Netherlands,
they have a whole different system than us, right?
The New Brunswick education system is just terrible as it is,
and I feel like it cannot support a phone ban, right?
We have, like, two landline phones in the office, right?
And I don't know if they expect the 1,400 kids in our school to,
if you need to call your parents,
you need to go on one of those two phones.
I feel like we need to put the money that the ed tech.
It's worth billions of dollars, right?
We need to put that money towards helping make it easier
for students to not have their
phones in school.
Okay.
This is fascinating, guys.
And I just want to bring it back to you,
Freya, because, you know, he's talking about,
William is talking about the research he's
been doing about cell phones and their effect
and how we should maybe outright ban them.
A Harvard study that was put out this week.
It says that school bans might actually reverse some learning losses.
What do you make of that research?
You know, that's not the only study we've seen
that say cell phones are bad for us.
Yes, and what I've heard, that is from the United States,
and I think they're in a very different situation for us.
I also...
Like William had said, it would take
a lot of money to enforce this ban.
And I think that money would be much better directed
towards positive investments in students,
in teachers, in resources, in librarians,
in nurses in schools, in textbooks, in actual
physical resources for students to actually learn.
Emmett, do you want to add anything to what you just heard there?
I mean, like, in our current English department,
right, which teaches our whole school, again,
like around 2,000 students,
we only have around 60 laptops for every student to work on.
I just feel like if we are to implement this,
there has to be alternatives, because especially
after the pandemic, students are really,
you know, connected to their devices.
So if they don't have an alternative to that,
it just won't help the situation.
We just have like 30 seconds left here, guys, but quick speed round.
William, how will you be treating the cell phone ban in the new year?
Will you be keeping your phone at home?
No, honestly, I'm completely fine with not having my phone.
I mean, I think it's a great thing for the education of New Brunswick,
and I think it won't go the best in the first few months,
but I feel like people will get used to it.
Quickly, Emmett, are you going to be
complying with this ban come the new year?
I believe not.
Oh, okay.
I think I'll have my phone with me.
Yeah, in your pocket?
Oh, not in my pocket, but yeah.
Yeah, in your backpack.
Hey, I will keep my phone with me at school.
I have a minute for after school and before school
and do a lot of work in the middle of the day.
Okay.
I've got to get my phone.

