00:00 The Life Story of Confucius 00:29 Introduction 03:03 The Life of Confucius 04:55 The Analects 08:38 The Cultural Revolution and Anti-Confucius Campaign 10:17 CCP’s revival of partial Confucianism 12:14 Confucius, The Brand 14:00 China’s Soft Power 15:39 My Final Thought
For centuries, Confucius was arguably the most influential philosopher and teacher in the history of China and perhaps of East Asia. His teachings focussed on moral aspects of humanity such as virtue, filial piety, wisdom, etiquette, righteousness, loyalty, and harmony. After denouncing Confucius and his teachings during the Cultural Revolution, the Chinese communist authorities are now turning to Confucius to help sustain its totalitarian rule at home and to gain influence overseas through installing the so-called Confucius institutes on foreign soil. Let us explore who Confucius truly was and why Beijing is using his name for its influence operations overseas.
You may have noticed that
there is one man whose words of wisdom
often appear in my YouTube videos
and social media images.
I think it's about time that I pay my tribute
to this legendary man,
which is why I made this episode.
Dubbed the Uncrowned King,
the founder of ancient Chinese philosophy,
and whose teachings are observed
by nearly a quarter of humanity,
ladies and gentlemen,
may I present to you,
Confucius.
Welcome to Tea with Erping.
In case you are not familiar
with Confucius' quotes
and have the thought of Confucius who?
Is he an ancient Chinese man
who invented Confucian?
Allow me to recite a few of his famous words,
and I'm sure you would have heard
at least one of them,
somewhere and somehow.
Our greatest glory is not in never falling,
but in rising every time we fall.
Indeed,
interest in Confucius' teachings and philosophy
seems to be only growing
both in and out of China.
More people are following his beliefs
on being a junzi,
translated to English
as the demeanor of a perfect gentleman.
Such a noble and superior man
is not a ruler of inferior subjects,
but rather a moral person
who lives by his character and conduct.
Confucius was born on September 28,
551 BC in the year
known in Chinese history
as the Spring-Autumn Period.
His home was in Zhou,
or the modern-day Shandong province.
This area was controlled
by the kings of Zhou dynasty.
But was effectively independent
under the local lords of Lu kingdom.
He was born into the class of Shi,
which is a class between the aristocracy
and the common people.
They are what western society
would claim as knights of a kingdom.
His father,
Kong He,
also known as Shu Liang He,
was an elderly commandant
of a garrison in eastern China.
His ancestry traced back
through the Dukes of Song
to the Shang dynasty,
traditional accounts of Confucius' life
relate that his great-grandfather
migrated the family
from the Song kingdom to the Lu kingdom.
Confucius' father died
when he was three years old,
so he was raised by his mother,
Yan Zhengzai,
in poverty.
His mother passed away
before she was 40 years of age.
At the age of 19,
Confucius married Lady Qi Guan,
and a year later,
the couple had their first child,
a son named Kong Li.
They also had two daughters,
one of whom is thought
to have died as a child,
another named Kong Jiao.
Confucius was educated
in a school for commoners
where he studied
and learned the six arts,
the basic education
of ancient Chinese culture.
It includes learning
writing,
music,
archery,
territory,
calligraphy,
and mathematics.
During the era in which
Confucius lived,
China enjoyed no political unity
and suffered from the warfare
among small states,
remnants of the once great Zhou dynasty
that collapsed
after the barbarian invasions
in 771 BC,
for more than 300 years
since Confucius' birth.
The Chinese would fight each other
for control of the empire
left behind by the Zhou dynasty.
In the process,
life became difficult,
especially for the Shi class
that Confucius belonged to.
Who lost their jobs
as their feudal lords,
were defeated in battles
and fell into poverty.
The knowledge of
aristocratic traditions,
however,
was valuable to competing kings.
Who wished to learn
how to regain the unity
imposed by the Zhou dynasty,
they sought to emulate the Zhou culture
such as its court rituals
and other institutions.
Thus,
a new role for the Shi class
as antiquarians emerged.
In such roles,
these knights found themselves
in and out of office
as the fortunes
of various patron states ebbed and flowed.
Confucius held office
for only a short time
before withdrawing
into scholarly retirement.
While out of office,
veteran knights
might gather small circles of disciples,
young men from the Shi class backgrounds,
who wished to succeed in public life.
It's precisely such
master and disciple exchanges
between Confucius and his students
that the Analects of Confucius
claims to record.
The Analects,
traditionally known in Chinese culture
and history as Lunyu,
is an ancient Chinese book
composed of an extensive collection
of sayings and ideas
attributed to Confucius
and his teachings,
compiled and written by his disciples.
This book often reminds me
of the writings by Plato,
who recorded the dialogues
of his teacher,
Interestingly,
Confucius and his mentor Lao Tzu
lived in about the same era
as Plato and his teacher Socrates.
Back then,
these sages didn't have an iPhone
nor the internet
to communicate with one another.
But they shared much in common
in terms of great ideas.
For instance,
both Socrates and Lao Tzu
held that the purpose of man
is to return to some
original higher state of being.
In Plato's words,
this is to return
to one's original true self.
Confucius' Analects
was written during
the Warring State period
and was finalized
during the mid-Han Dynasty.
By the early Han Dynasty,
the Analects was considered
merely a commentary
on the Five Classics.
Still,
the status of Analects
grew to be one of the central texts
of Confucianism
by the end of the Han Dynasty.
During the late Song Dynasty,
the importance of Analects
as a philosophical work
was raised above that
of the old Five Classics
and was recognized
as one of the Four Books.
The Analects has been
one of the most widely read
and studied books in China
for the last 2,000 years
and continues to have
a substantial influence
on Chinese and East Asian thought
and values today.
Its overseas influence
is only shy of another book
that was actually written
in our current day,
an original Chinese book
that holds the record
of having the most translated version
in the world.
The book is called
Zhuan Fa Lun,
a top 10 bestseller
already back in 1996
according to the Beijing News Daily.
Look it up if you're interested.
It's a book that teaches
spiritual enlightenment
through practicing the principles
of truthfulness,
compassion,
and forbearance
in our daily life.
Back to the Analects,
its central theme
can be summarized by his belief
that a country's welfare
depends on its people's moral cultivation.
Beginning with the nation's leadership,
individuals could begin to cultivate
an all-encompassing sense of virtue
through Ren,
roughly translated as being altruistic.
And the most basic step
to cultivating Ren
was devotion to one's parents
and older siblings,
in current terms,
filial piety.
Confucius taught that
one's desires need not to be suppressed,
but that people should be educated
to reconcile their desires
via rituals and forms of propriety,
through which people could demonstrate
their respect for others
and their responsible roles in society.
Confucius taught that
a ruler's sense of virtue
was his primary prerequisite for leadership.
His primary goal in educating his students
was to produce
ethically well-cultivated men
who would carry themselves
according to traditional moral values,
speak wisely and truthfully,
and demonstrate righteousness
in all aspects of life.
In sum,
central to Confucian teachings
are five moral codes.
For thousands of years,
Confucius has been regarded as a symbol
of China's traditional culture,
but was denounced by Mao Zedong,
founder of the PRC,
as a regressive pedant and a feudal
during the Cultural Revolution.
As part of the anti-Confucius campaign,
Red Guards destroyed
the Temple of Confucius
and vandalized Confucius' cemetery.
Traditional Confucian values
such as filial piety
and living in harmony
were acted against to the extremes.
These values were deemed to be inferior,
and citizens were encouraged
to turn against each other
through betrayal and violence.
China expert Anne Thurston
of the Johns Hopkins University
described it to be
a period of an extreme situation
characterized by
loss of culture and spiritual values,
loss of status and honor,
loss of career,
loss of dignity.
The Cultural Revolution
dismantled China's ancient belief systems.
And the economic revolution that followed
could not rebuild them.
Economic prosperity was not enough
to define the ultimate purpose
of the nation and the people.
The authorities have now urged people
to forget the tumultuous past.
The older generation
dare not look back,
while the younger generation
doesn't have the slightest idea
of what went on
and tends to have
a romanticized view of it.
These days,
there is a spiritual void
in the hearts of the Chinese people,
and Confucianism resonates well
as they search for
the spiritual nourishment
they feel is missing in their lives.
Now the Communist Party
is turning to China's ancient past
to draw inspiration from.
But the version of Confucius they use
is not the same as the original teachings
of the Confucius written in the Analogues.
The Party is taking
a very narrowly defined selection
of Confucianism
to push ideas
for more useful political purposes.
For instance,
the Communist Party's version of harmony
is a society where there is
no dissent from Party rule,
whereas in Confucian teaching,
a harmonious society
is where everyone,
including the leadership,
fulfills their responsibility
in a moral way
to create a harmonious
and prosperous country.
Many would agree that
current-day China
is having the worst moral crisis
with immense top-level corruption,
widespread fraud,
pollution and environmental degradation,
and a massive violation of human rights.
Confucius stretched compassion,
ritual,
and duty,
while the Party stayed focused
on imperial Confucius,
which was all about
their obedience to the emperor,
hierarchy,
and loyalty to support
their authoritarian rule.
By misconstruing Confucian teachings,
the Communist Party is making a point
that China has its own political culture
rooted in past history,
fending off Western ideas
of democracy and human rights.
Other Asian countries
that are highly influenced by Confucianism,
like South Korea,
Japan,
and Taiwan,
have proven that
it is possible to uphold Confucianism
and be democratic.
Pro-democracy advocates in Asia
believe that Confucius gave people
the right to choose their leadership,
and also overthrow a leader
who was immoral and tyrannical.
Confucius believed that
people should do the right thing
because it was the right thing to do,
and doing the right thing
will have a ripple effect through society.
In the past decade,
China has opened
more than 400 Confucianist institutes
around the world
to teach the Communist version
of Chinese language,
culture,
and history,
with controversies arising
from these institutes
and pressures from the government.
By the end of 2021,
104 of the 118 Confucianist institutes
that once existed in the United States
have closed
or are in the process of doing so.
I've touched upon this issue
in my previous video,
Why Should Confucius Be Upside?
Kindly take a look.
Yet,
a recent detailed report
by the National Association of Scholars
confirms that
not a single one of these institutes disappeared.
They were just rebranded
under a sister university arrangement
with universities in China,
given a different name,
or moved to a different sponsor school.
For example,
the Confucius Institute
at the University of Washington in Seattle
was spun off to
Pacific Lutheran University
in Tacoma, Washington.
The Confucius Institute
at Western Kentucky University
wound up partnering
with the county K-12 school system
in Simpson County,
where it continues to be run
by the same people.
These American schools
continue to receive funding
from the Chinese government agencies.
The report also highlighted
that the Chinese government
renamed Hanban,
the arm of the Chinese Ministry of Education,
to the Ministry of Education Center
for Language Exchange and Cooperation.
A separate organization
called the
Chinese International Education Foundation
was also established
and continues to fund
overseas Confucius Institutes
and their replacements.
The Confucius Institutes,
the Southern Talents Program,
the Chinese Students and Scholars Association,
and many other
Chinese government-backed programs
came with strings attached.
Beijing spends approximately
10 billion dollars a year
on these initiatives.
In 2010,
a Chinese state-run People's Daily article
wrote that
the Chinese propaganda minister
Liu Yunshan said,
with regards to key issues
We should actively carry out
international propaganda battles
against issues such as Tibet,
Xinjiang,
Taiwan,
human rights,
and Falun Gong.
We should do well in establishing
and operating overseas culture centers
and Confucius Institutes.
There are many examples of universities
withdrawing invitations
to controversial speakers
under pressure from Beijing
or removing certain publications.
In 2014,
at an European Association
for Chinese Studies conference in Portugal,
Han Ban director-general Xu Lin
confiscated all the printed programs
and ordered pages of advertising
of Taiwanese co-sponsors to be removed.
After receiving pressure
from the Chinese government,
Israeli Tel Aviv University
closed an art exhibition on Falun Gong,
a Buddhist spiritual practice
that is ruthlessly persecuted in China.
The independent Canadian documentary
in the name of Confucius
has exposed in detail
how Confucius Institutes
infiltrate foreign countries.
I highly suggest that you watch it
on the internet.
I came across a China-made blockbuster,
a movie,
Confucius.
It was made to commemorate
the 60th anniversary of the founding
of the People's Republic of China,
as well as the 2560th birthday
of Confucius himself.
Sadly,
I found it to be
least entertaining nor inspiring.
As an avid student
of Chinese history myself,
the image of Confucius
is one that is filled with wisdom,
having less concern
with the humanly material gains,
let alone lust.
He was on the endless journey
of perfecting one's moral values.
This movie,
however,
starts out with gory war scenes
and depicts a tradition
of killing a whole household
from wives,
children,
concubines,
and servants
when this great master passes away,
a tradition that
Confucius would never agree upon.
After seeing the trailer,
Confucius's descendant,
Kong Jian,
sued the filmmakers
and demanded some of the scenes be deleted
as they seemed inappropriate.
It came as no surprise
that Chinese authorities
reportedly pulled out the movie Avatar
from cinemas all around China
and made sure
the government-sanctioned Confucius movie
was placed as number one.
Again,
I believe that
Confucius would return in his grave
had he known what the Communist Party
had done in his name these days.
For now,
I should just get back
to my good old classic,
The Analects,
alongside a cup of green tea
and be reminded of
how beautiful and profound
the teachings of Confucius are.
Until next time,
peace and tea be with you.