Kinh Tế Học Tư Bản và Công Sản khác nhau ra sao?

KHUNG TRỜI MỚI - NEWSKY TV
3K followers
► FANPAGE KHUNG TRỜI MỚI: https://www.facebook.com/khungtroimoi.tv
Cảm ơn quý vị và các bạn đã quan tâm, yêu mến Khung Trời Mới.
#khungtroimoi #newsky #khungtrờimới
In today's Vietnamese community, especially young people, there is always a humorous saying to atone for the pressure and fatigue of work,
that is, being exposed to capital, but in the end, what is capital?
And the capital economic model has something to do with Vietnamese, why do we always criticize, but still force our descendants to sell their labor for capital,
while Vietnam still has an economic model according to socialist society?
I would like to say hello to all of you who are watching the Kim Sol channel on the new sky.
Capital economy and Communities
Ladies and gentlemen, unlike Mark's economic school, the school of economics in Western Europe and the United States cares a lot about the distribution of resources,
and has a history of people formed based on resource-sharing activities, that is, buying, selling, exchanging goods, not through class struggle.
Although the world economy has changed a lot since the time of Adam Smith, its core problems are still there.
How to distribute reasonable resources, that is, reducing the gap between rich and poor, helping the poor to access the resources they need to get out of poverty.
Even when humans have created virtual products such as video games or bitcoin or a cyber company,
we still define them as assets and still use the principles learned in economics to distribute them.
We provide the internet service as if we were providing clean water to the people.
Next, we will analyze the differences between the two economic models, total assets and capital.
The difference between the two systems
Before we get to the main issue, let's find out a little bit about the nature of economics.
What can be called economics as a science?
Both yes and no.
Why?
First of all, let's find out what a science industry is.
A science industry is a research industry that explains the natural phenomenon of society.
Why is the water frozen?
Why is the earth hot again?
And the steps to research science are
to find data, analyze data,
create an operating principle model of the object,
and check that model again.
If that model fits the reality, it is correct.
If it's wrong, do it again.
Similarly, economists also collect data, draw a theoretical model,
study and check the model.
But there is also a sad thing,
their model is rarely predictable.
In physics, you can change the data in any way,
you can also predict the result,
such as the speed of an object,
or the explosion of a bullet,
or the time of boiling water.
But economics is a little different.
With that model,
but every time you enter data from reality,
the result is completely contrary to prediction.
Humans are too sophisticated,
difficult to predict,
that is, it cannot be described by a few lines of the city.
Therefore, although research is carried out like a science,
economics is not predictable in natural sciences.
So it's pretty tough.
And people call it the hidden science industry,
because it often predicts the outcome of events.
It's sad, isn't it?
But human nature always wants to predict,
it needs to be known,
and help people know where they are going.
So, despite the difficult nature of economics,
people still like to predict,
and so there are dozens of different theories
to express the same thing.
Explanation of Capitalism and Communism
The core of economics is to study
the distribution of wealth in society.
So how is distribution reasonable?
In the previous century, there were two theories
to solve this problem,
Capitalism and Communism.
Many of us have been taught
about Communism in political science
at the University of California.
However, in this article,
they approach the problem
in a slightly different way.
First, economics,
like any other science,
is also predictable,
not certain.
When economists like Adam Smith,
Newton, Freeman, Friedrich Hayek
write economic books,
they give their theories.
They explain why they think it's right.
They don't say they're sure they're right,
and they're ready to accept criticism,
even in the natural sciences.
For example, Einstein said
that if someone finds evidence
that rejects his theory,
he will immediately accept it.
And because of that,
sometimes we read an article
saying that scientists prove
the speed of an object
faster than the speed of light.
That's why you can find
a lot of books criticizing
Newton, Friedrich Hayek,
or theories about the free market.
So I don't agree with the approaches
Second, we have to understand
that scientific research
has no emotional part in it.
In our society, we are often
sensitive to this.
Just listen to the words
of the US or the West,
we connect them with
all kinds of bad ideas.
And if they criticize us,
we say they're bad, propaganda.
Maybe that's why the scientific
spirit is still weak,
because people think that
we should understand that
the scientific community
works very seriously.
For example, when you read
a scientific journal,
remember that it is a scientific journal,
write that why the ABC economic model
failed. It's not because they
hate that economic model
or the money of some agency
to write that article,
but because they have been
studying that economic model
for decades, collecting thousands
of scientific papers.
And if they pass that test,
they will be disqualified.
Of course, when the article
is posted on Facebook,
through a message,
there will be a team
behind going to comment
that it is a lie,
a fake news,
then a bunch of memes
are sent in.
We should not be like that,
but we should look at the
scientific community,
the scientific community
as a whole,
Economic model of capital and common property
These two different perspectives lead to two different economic models.
Capitalists support the policy of free market.
They believe that when resources are distributed
freely according to the rule of law,
everyone will get what they want
in their spending ability.
But this capitalist supports the free market.
Everyone can sell what they want to sell,
buy what they need.
Free trade between countries,
such as in the ASEAN,
and Europe,
and then when they talk about freedom,
these are the concepts they mention
to ensure that freedom.
Capitalist countries allow everyone
to own their own property,
such as their own lands, their own crops,
and are allowed to own their own properties.
And the people in capitalism
can acquire wealth
to become rich.
For the people who support the free market,
there is another perspective.
They do not look at the economic problem
that is, conflict between people of different classes.
Here are the workers and the employers.
The employers do nothing but own capital and production tools to make a living.
Despite the exploitation of workers, they believe that when there are no more private corporations,
when goods are distributed equally to each person, there will be no more class struggle,
that is, society will be peaceful.
To do that, we must get rid of the free market,
the state must control everything in the economy,
that is, the economy must focus on supply,
and the state will replace the market to distribute resources in the country.
For example, the state will force Coca-Cola to produce 120,000 cans a day,
then the state will calculate how many barrels to produce 120,000 cans of Coca-Cola,
and order the machine to produce according to the number calculated.
In addition, the state also has to calculate how many weeks to paint the Coca-Cola cans,
and similarly to the machine, they order the machine to upgrade each week for Coca-Cola.
So before, everything was calculated by Coca-Cola, now the state will calculate.
After 120,000 cans of Coca-Cola have been produced,
the state will distribute them to those who do not pass the tax system.
Thus, the state ensures that everyone will be able to drink Coca-Cola like each other,
no one more and no one less than others,
it will be an equal opportunity.
In addition, the communist regime also removed the private ownership,
that is, the ownership of private property, because people can own private property,
or they can use it to enrich themselves, and thus lead to injustice in society.
In Vietnam now, the state does not allow people to own land.
In the Land Law of 2013, Article 4 of the law also clearly states that
the land belongs to the whole nation,
because the state represents the owner and unifies the management of the state over the land.
So no one in Vietnam's society owns land, people only have the right to use the land.
The social consequences
A problem of survival for the state to supply in the communist regime
is how to calculate the needs of the whole society.
This is difficult because, first, the social needs always change.
For example, the story that happened in Vietnam,
there was an incident in Dr. Thanh's water bottle,
Vietnamese consumers immediately stopped using the product of the new law.
So only within a month, the social demand for the product of the new law has changed.
So how will the state react?
This is a difficult issue because the production organization's plan is difficult to change immediately.
In addition, because all decisions are focused on the state,
including Hanoi, so the change will be slow.
We should remember that the larger the organization,
and the center of the organization, the further away the work will be, the slower it will be.
Second, the demand of society is too great, too much ability to calculate for the government.
If the state wants to calculate the needs of society,
it will have to calculate each bag of instant noodles produced,
each piece of pork exported to the market,
each ball for each house.
Therefore, in the 1960s,
the government mobilized the most experienced mathematicians to create supercomputers
to calculate the needs of society, but they failed.
The third problem is that not everyone wants to be fair.
In society, there will always be people who want to rise above others,
make more money than others.
These people will break the law when trying to get rich
and will be convicted of cybercrime
and handled according to the law of that country.
And the fourth problem,
which is also the most serious problem with the total economic model,
is to determine the price.
Marx's theory says that the value of goods
is a reflection of the value of labor
that workers put out to create those goods,
not because of the market demand.
But in fact, if we ignore the market demand,
we can hardly accurately determine the value of goods.
And if the value of goods is wrong,
then the economy will develop sluggishly.
For example, an iPhone costs 100,000 VND per unit,
but rice costs 500,000 VND per kilogram.
But why? Let's take a look at the following example.
Mr. Nguyễn Đình Chính spent 2 billion VND
as well as many years to create this scooter,
hoping it would be used in the Vietnamese People's Army.
According to Marx's formula for currency,
this scooter must be worth more than 2 billion VND
and the labor value of Mr. Chính must be included.
But in the end, its value is just 0 VND.
Why? Because there is no demand for that scooter,
the army does not need that scooter,
the people in the country do not need that scooter.
So when a person produces a product
that does not meet the market demand,
no matter how much money is spent
to create that product,
no matter how much capital is spent,
its value is still 0.
In countries with a focus on economy
before 1991 or before 1986,
in Vietnam, society constantly faced difficulties
in buying and selling.
The price of goods is very random
and does not reflect the social demand.
What about the state?
In theory, the perfect free market is the best,
but in reality, it is difficult to create
a perfect free market.
The reason why the market is not perfect
is the lack of information.
For a perfect free market,
people and sellers have to understand each other,
but this is impossible in real life.
For example, when you choose a university,
you cannot be 100% sure
right from the start that this school suits you.
Or many people go to export to work,
until they go abroad,
they discover that they are sold as slaves.
Therefore, the free market always needs
interference from the government
to avoid social accidents
caused by misinformation.
Currently, countries including the US,
France, Singapore, Australia,
and Vietnam all maintain
a market economy with government interference.
The difference between countries
is the level of interference
as well as the way the government interferes.
In the US or UK, less, but in Vietnam, a lot.
For example, the US government
will lower the oil price in the market,
while in Vietnam, the government
will lower the oil price.
But there is a strict reality
in the issue of market economy,
which is income inequality.
To understand this issue,
you have to imagine that you are
a wealthy investor.
One day, through an acquaintance,
you find out that the government
has built an electric train
running through your district,
a poor district.
Therefore, you decide to invest
in real estate in your district.
You save 1 billion VND,
buy 10 acres of land,
each acre 150 million VND.
Because it is a poor district,
there is a lot of empty land,
so the price of land is very cheap.
In 2 years, the price increases
to 250 million VND per acre,
you still don't sell to anyone.
Then in the 3rd, 4th, 5th year,
the price of land increases
to 500 million VND per acre,
you immediately sell.
So you lose 5 billion VND,
5 times the original profit.
You make money completely legally,
not cheating anyone.
But your way of making money
has economic problems.
First, for 5 years,
people who have not been able
to live on the land for 5 years,
shops, movie theaters,
can be built here.
So instead of using it
to contribute to the family economy
and provide accommodation for many people,
10 acres of land has been lying around
for 5 years.
The second problem is that your land,
also known as the head of the family,
and many other people have created
a state of poverty.
The result is that the price of land
is pushed up high,
so the price of the house
is also pushed up high.
Low-income people cannot own a house,
rich people like you can get rich,
and poor people are difficult to get rid of poverty.
But that's not your fault at all.
The current economic model
After 1991,
the centralized economic model
has almost completely disappeared from the world.
Countries following the old centralized economic model
such as China and Vietnam
have switched to a complex economic model
The economy is still a market economy,
but the state holds the main industries.
As in Vietnam, there are shipbuilding companies,
financing companies,
power companies,
oil and gas companies,
VVN are all state-owned companies.
But even though it is complex,
the main model of the economy
is still a market economy.
This market economy is now becoming complicated
when people today,
with the help of advanced technology,
can do business in all forms.
10 years ago,
we didn't have Uber, Grab, or Tiki.
These new business models
help us in many ways,
but at the same time also raise
more complex issues than the government,
such as inequality, poverty,
information theft, unemployment for robots.
All these issues,
although different in nature,
are still distributed throughout society.
Ladies and gentlemen,
this is a long-winded perspective.
I would like to talk about the economic model
of capital and real estate.
If you can take the time to watch this video,
we would like to sincerely thank
your attention and love for the channel.
If you don't mind,
please leave your comments below
for everyone to discuss together.
And now, I would like to say goodbye
and see you again in the next programs.
