Reaction: VAR audio released from Liverpool's disallowed goal by Luis Diaz in defeat at Spurs

Sky Sports News
24 followers
Oct 4, 2023
Our chief reporter Carvey Solicol has come back on set. Carvey, oh my goodness, how do
you react to that? Well look, the first thing you should say is that referees are human
beings. They make mistakes like everybody else. They were working there in a very highly
pressurised environment and they made a mistake. And it was a big mistake and the eyes of the
world were on them and now they are paying the consequences. And the mistake they made
was that they thought they were checking a goal that had been allowed. And you heard
that in the audio there and the video that we saw. They worked very, very quickly. Some
people may say they were working too quickly because they're under pressure to make these
decisions quickly because when they take a lot of time, people complain that they're
taking too long. But I think once you watch and listen to that audio, you realise just
how quickly they are making these decisions and why there is the possibility of mistakes
being made in these kind of situations. I think one thing that will be worrying for
supporters who listen and watch this audio and video is the fact that the video operator
was the person who seemed to be aware of what was going on before anybody else. And he was
the one who was saying, look, the PGMOL hub operator, Ollie, is telling us to delay,
delay, delay the game, which I think he means that we need to stop the game because a big
mistake has been made. But then you heard the VAR coming in sounding more and more panicked
and saying, look, we can't. There's nothing we can do. The game has started now. We can't
do anything. They've restarted. We can't do anything. We can't do anything. He kept
repeating. So I think there's still a lot of questions. I don't think this audio clears
everything up, but it gives us an insight into just what a highly pressurised environment
these referees are working in and the video operators and the hub operators as well. And
unfortunately, VAR is not foolproof. Mistakes will be made. But of course, lessons have
to be learnt from this. And I'm sure new protocols will be introduced to make sure that if mistakes
are made, they're not mistakes that are as big as this. But he says that that, you know,
the game's restarted. We can't we can't delay the game now. But if they had delayed the
game, nobody would have complained, would they? Because they'd have got the right decision.
They would have just put their hands up. We got that wrong. Actually, it's a goal. And
away we went. Well, they would have been breaking the laws of football. If you stick to the
letter, they wouldn't have had all this, would they? If you stick to the letter of the law
as laid down by the IFAB, who make the laws of the game and the VAR protocols, once the
game has restarted, you can't go back and stop the game and change the decision. Now,
a lot of people are arguing today that that is exactly what they should have done. And
I'm sure a lot of people will agree with you as well. This could have all been cleared
up if they'd done that. And I don't think FIFA or IFAB would have thrown the book at
them if that is what they had done. But unfortunately, they decided to stick to the letter of the
law. And as you heard the VAR, Darren England, saying there, we can't do anything. They
restarted. We can't do anything. We can't do anything. Of course, with the benefit of
hindsight, they could have done something, but it would have involved breaking the laws
of the game. Now, you say lessons have got to be learned. What can they learn? I think
the first lesson to be learned from listening to that audio is that it's got to be clearer
exactly what the VAR is checking for, because it wasn't made explicitly clear that that
goal had been disallowed, that goal had been ruled offside. That wasn't made explicitly
clear. Everybody seemed to be in too much of a rush. So I think going forward, that
is one of the things that may change. Protocol may be introduced to make it absolutely clear
to the VAR, even if it needs repeating a few times. So people get annoyed about the
fact that, oh, look, it's obvious. Why do you need to keep saying this? But just to
make sure that this mistake isn't made again in the future, it needs to be crystal clear
what the VAR is checking for.
