3 Video Views·Dec 4, 2023
Rock Shelters, Risk Perspective, Pitalkhora caves, Buddhist Architecture, Mahayana Phase, Tacheletic Basalt, Conservation.
To access the translated content:
1. The translated content of this course is available in regional languages. For details please visit https://nptel.ac.in/translation
The video course content can be accessed in the form of regional language text transcripts, books which can be accessed under downloads of each course, subtitles in the video and Video Text Track below the video.
Your feedback is highly appreciated. Kindly fill this form https://forms.gle/XFZhSnHsCLML2LXA6
2. Regional language subtitles available for this course
To watch the subtitles in regional languages:
1. Click on the lecture under Course Details.
2. Play the video.
3. Now click on the Settings icon and a list of features will display
4. From that select the option Subtitles/CC.
5. Now select the Language from the available languages to read the subtitle in the regional language.
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to the course disaster recovery
and mailbag matter my name is RAM Satish
I'm an assistant professor Department of
Architecture and planning Indian
Institute of Technology Turkey today
I'm going to discuss about a heritage
component how it is subjected to risk
and how one can analyze from a very
multi disciplinary perspective and also
how the conservation plan works along
with the risk management plan so this is
about rock shelters at risk and in the
whole world if we look at ancient man's
shelter the very basic form of shelter
is the caves
you know the cave dwellings and rock
shelters and different parts of the
world still carry some evidences that
how the earlier man have lived and some
images of their paintings there being
some images of their madacorp pastoral
life or hunting life you know so these
are all some learnings of today's how
the today's generation can also learn
from our historic historical records and
the anthropological aspect of human life
so when you see at this image so I'm not
talking about as an historian I'm not
talking about as an architect I'm
talking from a risk perspective how this
heritage component subjected to risk and
how one can look at from a
multidisciplinary perspective so when
you look at this image obviously one can
notice that there has been some kind of
liquid lava or something which has been
flown around this region and it has got
settled down and that is how from the
Google at map you can see that the whole
gradients and the slopes and aspects
which are formed by the way it has been
cool down and then you can see some
cliffs kind of environment here and a
valley sort of thing if you go little
closer the same cliffs it's
looks like this where there's a
mountains around it a very flat to sort
of mountains and if you go further
closer and this is what we can see the
Potala rock caves this is and western
guards in the SATA mala range of the
western guards in maharashtra state of
india and in fact i want to give a
credit off to important people like this
is most of the information there has
been from the source of Prabhakar Nanda
Gopal that time he was a soup ending
archaeologist in the Archaeological
Survey of India and his work has been
he's been working on this projects and
also Deshpande s work so this have able
to procure from Shiva do feasts who was
my student earlier in his paper but so
many of the photographs and many of the
details which are learning from their
work doctor Nandor gopis work and what
you could see is the cave villas
settlement and in fact this was also a
kind of excavation site and one where
people realize that there has been a
human settlement here and in this you
can find many nomadic tribes you know
room a roaming around and one is it is
also just not only in the name proximity
but they do travel if you look at their
networks the trade networks it goes back
to Marsh mati it goes back to Janeiro
Jain it goes back to Bhimbetka enmity
Pradesh you know so allora argenta so
like that there's been a network how
people have traveled and migrated and
settled in different parts of central
and western part of India and also their
expansion in the port cities like you
know on the western side of the posit is
how they have settled down and you can
see some similarities of how these cave
dwellings have some similarities and
African continent as well as
in the South American content or some
kind of similar and depictions of how
man has lived so this is the layout of a
Buddhist site which is a petal kora
caves which is in the district of orange
about now initially there's these sites
goes back to almost 3 250 BC which is
almost to the 3rd century BCE as well
and they're not done if you look at
they're about 13 caves which has been
discovered in the excavation process and
some of them have been discovered much
later and some were discovered in the
beginning and if you look at the phase
wise and what you are able to see here
is the the cave Nimbus which has been
written on one and two three four five
six seven nine and 6a and on the bottom
side you have ten eleven and twelve and
thirteen there is also they're not the
same form they are not of the same
alignment like you can see from number
three which is a kind of choice ort of
thing and here again in 13 as well you
can see a kind of choice and we heard as
for Buddhist style and whereas where we
talked about number one which is of a
very rudimentary stage of a cave which
is about dates back to pre 250 BC and
then the phase 2 which talks about the
1c and 2 and 3 which is a smaller one
and the third one is a kind of a ChaCha
which is an elongated corridor so that
is again goes back to 250 bc's whereas
number 4 which is supposed a huge square
base which is between 250 to 200 bases
whereas in 7 which has a similar which
has again a smaller components smaller
compartments around it and that is
dating back to phase 4 which is about
200 280 BC and similarly you have number
6 and 2a
they're all again getting back 200
to 160 BC and if you come like that
number 11 and 12 where you can see on
the bottom side on the other side of the
caves you can see that their beds back
to first century BC and first century AD
as well and number 8 9 this also again
goes back to 13 which is more refined
stage in the second century AD so this
is how it took almost about from pre 250
BC onwards till the 2nd century AD
so that is the kind of timeline of how
these cave dwellings have been developed
in this region in the satyr mala range
of Western Ghats in Maharashtra now how
do they able to figure out this process
you know there have been evidences
there's been some iconographies who have
studied how their paintings were done
how the symbolic representations on
their pillars who have donated it when
it was donated so there's been a
linguistic understanding there's been an
artistic understanding in it and you
know the style represented
interpretation of it now for example
when we talk about how they have
identified on the right hand side in the
photograph you can see some small text
which has been written in other poly or
and this is saying that the pillar is
the donation of meted eva which is a
mitra dev of the god iike family a
resident of pati Tana which is practiced
on and the modern Python so in fact this
is these inscriptions is telling
actually about who is the family who
have donated the contributor
construction of the villa so which means
and from where they belong to so all
this process has been become a very rich
evidence to know that what kind of
families used to live around how they
are connected what kind of time they
were talking about and like that if you
look at it the phases we find nearly
five phases of inscriptional records at
the talc or
one is the me today bond Sangha cassia
Rajaraja family dhenuka katha calm and
Booth are Akita and whereas phase 4 it
talks about noon and can Hadassah and
phase 5 are they say now so this is how
some of the evidences and similar to
this you can see that this is also
donated by the Sangha Kapoor the
resilience of Patti Tana and the whole
and if you look at the panoramic view of
the whole caves what you can see is
small small caves which are actually
located in a very linear pattern and has
been embedded under this mountain big
mound which has been covered and there
are also some iconographic aspects of
science and symbolic aspects of it where
you can find some sculpture as well
where in their time elephant is referred
to the conception bull is referred to
Nativity horse is referred to great
departure line is referred to secure and
the same ha you know so like that there
are some different meanings associated
to these symbolic expressions and
Buddhism one of the important phase we
talk about the Mahayana phase of
Buddhism at petal crop it is also the
paintings which also depicted the time
like if you see the left hand side one
which actually both of them they are
talking about the paintings of the
Mahayana phase were drawn where the
caves were occupied the followers for
the Mahana sect but you can see the time
different style of buddha both of them
or talking about the buddhas where it is
that the higher style have been
different and as artistic style is also
very different and in fact some point of
the time people also used to make it it
is a kind of beetle kora style of
hairstyle you know these are all some
representative skills which has been
developed through time
now this is a brief about the caves and
their historic aspect like the Buddhist
sects and how they have been represented
but then I'll also touch upon that the
geotechnical aspects of it the Jim
morphological aspects of it now in
battle Korra
we actually notice a very thick layer of
- alak basalt at the lower proximity of
the hell which have restricted the scope
of excavation as per projected plans
because you know this is about this
basalt which actually sometimes it
becomes a very soft material when keeps
making an excavation it breaks into the
pieces you know that's how there is a
chance that the evidence will also be
losing will be losing some evidence like
now what you see here is a kind of lava
where we talk about the R which is the
basaltic lava which is characterized by
a rough or a rubbery surface and these
lava blocks also we actually extract the
clinker from this kind of rough and
rubbery surface lava
it's called AA this is a very smooth
surface which is unbroken lava it's also
a basaltic lava that has a very small
below undulating or a ropey surface and
this is called a hole aho and this is a
Hawaiian meaning which is well smooth
and unbroken always just floats in a
very smooth liquid like you know when
the mercury starts flowing down when
these kind of molten lava gets cooled up
that is where it develops the structural
forms whether structural joints are
developed and some hollow spaces are
also developed and this is where the
hollow spaces becomes eventually man
have made his shelters now what we can
see is the layers of the horizontal
layers of one over the another so these
layers also talks about these beds which
are talking about so a set of lava have
come down
and gradually another set of flour and
the by the time it cools down the
another set came another set came so
this is how this horizontal layers
started developing one over the another
and this - oolitic basalt which is not a
conducive rock for cave excavation as at
chemical properties react sharply with
moisture and disintegrate into pieces
the moment you are making an excavation
process it gradually Brooks into small
small red shaped pieces you know that is
one of the important aspect in the
excavation challenges and excavation
challenge especially with this kind of
material there's another form of curve
and we talked about the ropey structure
so that is where there's again a poly
sort of thing which actually trade
twists into a reign of ropey format and
you can see also as time passes on the
spiri oracle period and weathering takes
place because this layers on the top
layers keeps coming like a chip by chip
and this is again an ass periodical
manner this is called periodical
weathering and on the left-hand side you
see an example of the how the whole the
rock formation and because of the
weathering prior aspect how it ships
down on the right hand side what you see
is a kind of bull beds which is actually
look at the time intervals of how these
successive lava flows have been trapped
in the Deccan trap we know and as the
time passed on obviously there's been
some water bodies a small waterfalls or
they keep channeling it as per does the
slope and the gradient which has been a
natural form but then it has been there
for ages and until people have
discovered no one have realized it and
it's been there since many decades now
things are the water is following on the
seepage has started it in the caves and
this is one aspect now what the did was
the jewel the archaeologists team they
have actually mapped down they have
actually documented the whole set of
caves including the analysis of the
crack
there is where they talk about a
geological mapping of the ceiling of the
caves and this is one of the church
where they have documented where are the
cracks coming into it
what are the categories they classified
the categories of the risk so depending
on the nature of the crack and from the
stable to the most in stable level so
that is how they loved crack one
category one two three four five and
that is where they classified and
categorize these risk aspects and
similarly this is again they again
categorize with what are the different
aspects of the risk one is the slightly
weather weathered vesicular basalt and
also water sleep aid Jones which are
more of this dotted aspects of it and
where the edge of the broken ceiling you
know or the roof and this is where they
try to again classify all these aspects
and also where the cracks are also
appearing continuously not only in a
horizontal in the ceiling level but
throughout the cave structure how this
vertical cracks are also coming up and
after having this I showed you only a
small set of analysis of how one have
able to document all these caves and how
they were able to map down from a
special point of it and analyze what are
the root causes for it where are the
material aspects into it where are the
water seepage issues where the ceiling
has been broken down or if there's the
pillars have been broken down whether
the floor aspect which has been chipping
out because of weathering aspects or
during rainy season what kind of impacts
it is having so all these document
issues have been done so but then when
you look at the set of activities which
has been taken as a part of the
conservation plan from 1954 to 2008 you
see a huge span of time but then a very
limited work what we can see but then
one has to understand it is not a
regular building project it was a
conservation
project so it normally takes time
because even analyzing to make a small
scaffolding how to do it is also a big
task
you know because you might destroy the
evidence like in 1954-55 this has been
completely blocked up to the big
boulders and debris so they have started
clearing it and then there already some
fallen and collapse parts of rock
playing in front were removed and the
area has been leveled up and in 5556 so
has been very little known group of
caves were affected by the construction
of steps to the caves from hilltop and
removal of huge boulders fallen from the
ceiling and other debris in the vihara
are joining the main Chaya
so in 57 and 58 clearance in front of
the church and we Hara Caves reveal some
unique futures and Scotch as that is
where I showed you the line and the bull
the horses and 5859 there's again cave
for revealed to more elephant carrot
rights and like that one by one they
started discovering and they started and
they again in 1959-60 by this time it's
almost six years to even taking the
debriefs
from the hillside opposite k12 for you
know that is how there's a six-year
project only just to clear the deborah's
and whereas in 6061 a rock third cistern
was cleared of debris for the storage of
water and the excavation of rock cut
drain on the top of the cave was started
the work is so in that way they started
the cistern as well as the water storage
and 1995 this is where they started
about a mile steel footbridge to for the
because the tourists start pumping down
and in order to channel them without
destroying the evidence that is where
they try to keep some kind of axis
whereas there also in 2001 onwards the
deposit work is awarded to GSI
Geological Survey of India towards the
cost of geological and geotechnical and
geophysical and geo environmental
studies of the spittle coral caves and
the surroundings
whereas here it's not only that how a
set of activities are related to there's
a different
I mention of technicality comes into it
now it is not a story of a conservation
architect it is not only a task but how
his analysis works with the geotechnical
and the Jew environmental studies also
collaborate in it because Dave becomes
the base now in order to understand the
impact aspects of this kind of case what
is risk aspect now inside the caves
following all these analysis what kind
of modifications has been done so now
you can see that they have started
looking at how the edges of the roof and
the structure of the vertical aspect and
the roof aspect or nudging that is with
a lot of damage have occurred and there
might be a chance that it might collapse
at any time so that is where they
started giving some kind of support
system at the edges so that there is a
you know the balance of the structure as
well also what you can see here is
whatever the columns they already have
and now retrofitting them and giving the
kind of support to the ceiling as well
so now you can see the scaffolding
process because in the scaffolding
process is a very important task because
you don't need to like in a normal
building project you hit the wall you
put a puncher it and then you try to
keep a support system but here in
conservation project it doesn't work
like that
you have to because each and every
evidence is much more important
significant and it is very critical to
understand that so this is how the
restoration process has been done and on
the flooring part you know because
there's been some times it has been
chipped out so that is where they start
making some kind of flooring restoration
has been done and similarly they also
given some support systems where there's
been cracks and there is a possibility
that this this may not bear the load
after some time that is where they
started giving some kind of huge rubble
masonry wall not masonry it's a kind of
dry stone wall which they have able to
sub give a little support on that so
without giving any additional material
or a render to it but just keeping as a
stone
while also the paintings are most
important elements that is where they
keep subject to the risk so how to
restore these paintings that is one of
the biggest challenge and that is where
you have to work out with people from
chemistry with people from
archaeologists because you need to see
that there is a material scientists
could also be involved in it how we can
actually protect them it's very
important now what you can see is a
small canal but after having a thorough
understanding of the topographic aspects
and after having a understanding of
where the water seepage is are coming
they understood the root cause of the
water is not just not it in the cave is
somewhere beyond the mountain so then
they started making a kind of channel
you know how to divert this water so
that at least it can protect the water
seepage in caves so this is it could be
a very small intervention but then a
thorough analysis has to be done in
order to protect these heritage
structures in fact one of the scholar
who actually worked on this particular
structures Amen - bundle and where
there's been many names of this potala
repeat all Correa
shalini Cora so divine a gorge or a Jane
and Sinclair leve which is a present
line pal Cora which is of freaker's
religious of it is a Bodhi tree which is
reflected the Buddhism and you know that
is how a lot of disciplines come
together and they work on these kinds of
assessment of the risk as well also the
conservation but how you manage it is
also an important aspect I hope this
helps you thank you very much
[Music]