Does building more JWSTs for different parts of the spectrum make sense? Are star types predetermined at their birth? Can you cook a pizza on the Sun? Why is the Sun's corona hotter than its surface? Are there binary supermassive black holes? Answering all these questions and more in this Q&A show.
00:00 Start 00:25 Does it make sense to have JWST in a different spectrum? 04:07 Are star types determined at their birth? 07:50 Thoughts about the flat Earth? 09:57 Can we see the light from the Big Bang? 11:54 Are there binary supermassive black holes? 13:59 What would a pizza cooked directly on the Sun taste like? 15:17 Why is the corona of the Sun hotter that its surface?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
should we make more James webs for other
wavelengths why are there different
types of stars how do I feel about Flat
Earth claims and are there any binary
super massive black holes all this and
more in this week's question show it's
time for the question show your
questions my answers as always wherever
you are across my channel if a question
Pops in your brain just write it down
I'll gather them up and I will answer
them here all right let's get into the
questions restoration Shaman would it
make sense to make more James web
telescopes in different Spectra it
depends on what you're trying to do so
James web was built with a very specific
goal which was to observe the earliest
times in the universe and so the
universe has been expanding the light
that has come from the early Universe
originally these were galaxies very
similar or you know primordial galaxies
similar to what we have today with stars
that were shining in bright blue and
pumping out ultraviolet and you know
with gas clouds and red stars and all of
this but then over the lifetime of the
universe as the universe has expanded
the wavelengths of that light has
shifted from what was ultraviolet and
visible light into near infrared and far
infrared and so James Webb is designed
to see into those wavelengths and
perceive those galaxies they would be
invisible like if you went if you know
if we showed you a picture of these
early galaxies invisible light they
would be invisible ible you couldn't see
them but because James web can see in
infrared this is possible now the
problem is that the other telescopes at
different wavelengths are getting old so
the Hubble Space Telescope has a 2.6
meter mirror James Webb is 8.5 it is
much bigger and Hubble probably isn't
going to last too far beyond the end of
the 2020s so we've really only got like
maybe six to8 years left for the Hubble
Space Telescope and then there will not
be a large large visible light
ultraviolet light
telescope in space now there's going to
be some monster ground telescopes like
the extremely large telescope the mellan
telescope like there's a bunch of big
telescopes that are in the works on the
ground but there will be no space-based
telescopes the plan for the next great
space Observatory is called the
habitable world's Observatory and it's
going to be in many ways a twin of James
web it's gonna have probably the same
size mirror so a 6.5 meter primary
mirror but it will be a visible light
telescope and its job is to try to
observe the surfaces of exoplanets and
try to allow astronomers to be able to
measure the atmospheres of these
exoplanets Earth siiz worlds orbiting
around sun-like stars but once you move
into other wavelengths if you Tred to
make something like like yes you could
make a a web version of
ultraviolet but once you move into other
wavelengths like EXT rays and gamma rays
you can't use telescope mirrors in the
same way that you can't bounce xrays off
of a curved mirror and then focus them
in to an instrument to be able to make
your image they work differently they're
too high energy and so a lot of the
X-ray telescopes and gamma ray
telescopes are more like cones where
they collect a large area x-rays come in
and they sort of Hit the side of the
collecting area and then they're they
Ricochet down into the instruments that
are trying to watch the sky and so they
work very differently and so it just
like it wouldn't make sense to make a
x-ray or a Gamay version of James Webb
and it wouldn't make sense to make a
radio waves version of James Webb either
I mean there are radio telescopes they
work really well just make them bigger
so uh so we could use more James webs we
could definitely use James web sized
Hubble space telescopes but those are
sort of the only wavelengths that really
make sense for a Space Telescope to have
that configuration shaa Ellis when stars
are born do they know what kind of stars
they'll be for example red giants well
the kind of star that you get is purely
based on the amount of material that
went into the star it's the mass and so
there are a variety of masses of stars
that we can get on the smallest side are
the red dwarfs and really it's the the
very beginning the smallest possible
star is what is the smallest amount of
hydrogen and helium you can have in a
ball where there's enough temperature
and pressure at the core of the star
that he that hydrogen Fusion can begin
that there's enough pressure to Smur and
this is the technical term hydrogen into
helium and that releases a tremendous
amount of energy and that sort of makes
the star shine and that amount is a
about
7.5% the mass of the Sun and sort of the
other way to look at it is about 80
times more massive than Jupiter and
Jupiter is like made of star stuff so if
you went and found 79 more Jupiters and
mash them all together then you would
have enough material that you would have
a star the the smallest possible star
and that's the Red Dwarf now you can
have larger and larger red dwarfs and
eventually you can move into other types
of stars and then when you end up with
about the amount of material like the
sun has right one solar mass um then you
get a star like the sun and really you
know if you collect together the amount
of material that makes the Sun and you
line them all up they will be roughly
the same kind of star they will appear
mostly identical they'll be about the
same temperature they'll have about the
same kind of atmospheric composition
they will put out about the same amount
of radiation but then you can add more
material you you could Mash those
sunlike stars together and they start to
get hotter and they start to get bigger
and they instead of shining in say white
light or yellow light they start to
shine in blue light and the most massive
stars are monsters these are stars that
can have say 60 times up to a 100 times
the mass of the Sun and the problem is
that when you have those stars that have
a lot more mass than what our sun does
then they live very short lives they go
through the material in the core they
die within about a million years and
part of that process is that star
changes from this blue super giant into
a red super giant and it expands outward
while say a blue super giant is going to
be definitely a lot bigger than the Sun
you know maybe 10 times bigger than the
Sun a red super giant the kind of this
the final phase of one of these Stars it
could be 2,000 times bigger than the Sun
and so really you know back to your
original question do stars like know
what kind they're going to be it just
depends on the Mass
if you have a little bit of mass you get
a red dwarf if you have a Suns worth of
mass you get a starlake the Sun and if
you have many times the mass of the Sun
then you get these ludicrous blue super
Giants if you want to support the work
we do at Universe today consider joining
our patreon club your support lets us
have a minimum of ads and no sponsorship
messages patrons get no ads on
universe.com for Life want the extra
parts of the live stream that aren't in
this edited version you can sign up for
a special Patron only podcast feed get
the overtime segments as well as other
special behind the- scenes episodes
including our monthly Patron only
question show thanks to everyone who has
already subscribed and Welcome to our
recent newcomers Angel Luis figuro
Jordan Turner Dan Thompson New Zealand
astrophotography competition Ronald
Schmidt and David Shawn join the club at
patreon.com Universe today Ronnie
Coleman I'm just going to be a little
silly and ask your thoughts about Flat
Earth I don't have any thoughts about
Flat Earth the Earth is round uh the
scientific consensus is
overwhelming and uh and anybody who
makes the claim that the Earth is flat
uh you can safely ignore uh they're
either trolling you or they're unwilling
to put in the very base level of
research to find out that the Earth is
indeed round uh we've known about this
for thousands of years and the flights
that we take every day around the planet
confirm it the ability to see different
constellations from the Northern
Hemisphere than what we see from the
southern hemisphere confirms it so uh
you know
I get tons of comments on my videos
about people who are flat earthers and I
just ignore it uh I don't need to have
that conversation I don't care you know
if and I and I don't think you need you
don't you shouldn't feel the need to
defend the scientific consensus that we
live on a round earth instead enjoy
having conversations about space and
astronomy with other people who are as
passionate about this as you are so
filled with wonder at the discoveries
that are being made about the universe
and you don't have to feel the need to
have arguments with trolls about these
like fundamental issues that were
cleared up thousands of years ago we've
moved on to other things like what is
the true nature of dark matter and dark
energy um you know what happened in the
earliest moments of the universe what is
the source of the highest energy
radiation that is striking the Earth are
we alone in the universe will we find
other civilizations out there what is in
in the interior of even planets here in
the solar system like NE in Uranus how
many exoplanets are out there what kind
of exoplanets can we find out there
across the universe uh what are the
processes that caused planetary systems
to form like these are the kinds of
questions that are interesting and
fascinating and real that people don't
know the answers to so uh no don't pay
any of don't pay it no never mind um
just have you know follow your curiosity
about the universe light dark is it
actually possible to the light from The
Big Bang or is it too late well it's not
too late the light from The Big Bang
could have and would have made it all
the way to us in fact it would be very
bright but the problem is that after the
big bang you had this time when the
entire universe was opaque to light and
so we can't see it because then there's
this intervening time where everywhere
in the universe there was essentially
the entire universe was like the
interior of a star incredibly hot and
dense compressed down and then the
entire universe was like the surface of
a star still opaque that we couldn't see
it it wasn't until about 370,000 years
after the big bang when the universe
finally became transparent and light was
able to escape and that's the first
light that we can see but gravitational
waves probably happened right with the
big bang and those could pass through
the material that made up the universe
at the time and so there are plans to
build much more sensitive gravitational
wave
observatories even more sensitive than
Leisa which is sort of one this in the
works for 2035 you know one possibility
it's called The Big Bang Observer and it
would be 12 Lisa satellites in this
giant do decahedron which are sending
their signals back and forth and in
theory uh a space telescope like that
would be capable of detecting the
ripples of SpaceTime that came from the
Big Bang itself and so it's a
interesting question because then you
know I don't know it's like if you can't
see something but maybe you can hear it
or you can feel the vibrations of
something moving towards you that you
can't see so right now we can't see
right back to the Big Bang but with
gravitational waves and maybe even
neutrinos uh we might be able to
eventually probe that time in the
history of the universe Bob H blorf are
there any binary super massive black
holes
yes uh astronomers have identified
several examples of super massive black
holes that are orbiting around each
other now just to sort of understand how
this works right you have two galaxies
that merge and both Galaxies have a
super mass of black hole that is at the
heart of them and then as the galaxies
merge they sort of tear each other apart
and they merge into this larger Galaxy
and the super massive black holes that
were at the you know at the center of
the different galaxies they both sink
down into the middle of the Galaxy and
then they start to orbit around each
other and eventually they merge and you
know we see very very massive super
massive black holes and they must be
made up of the mergers from smaller
black holes and so this is the process
that must be happening so about a week
ago when I'm recording this we reported
on Universe today the story about the
discovery of a an object called at 2021
HDR and this was known to have like a
flash of radiation every couple of weeks
and astronomers have realized what this
actually is this is two super massive
black holes that are orbiting around
each other and they only take 130 days
to go into orbit around each other and
they estimate that it is sort of a
combined mass between the two super
massive black holes of 40 million times
the mass of the sun when you think about
the Milky Ways super massive black hole
U three and a half million times the
mass of the Sun so this is a lot of mass
and yet they are orbiting each other
very closely and it's estimated that
they're probably going to merge within
the next uh 70,000 years or so and so
this is an example like wouldn't it be
great if we could just stick around and
watch that merger happen as those black
holes come together and turn into this
future 40 million solar mass black hole
and then maybe they'll find another one
and merge with that and that's how you
get black holes with billions of times
the mass of the Sun just merger by
merger
catlord 25 cats hi what would pepperoni
pizza taste like if it was cooked on the
sun let's say you want to cook your
pizza at 500 fenit which is 260 degrees
cels and like that'll give you like a
really nice crispy crust you'll get the
melty cheese you'll get the pepperoni
will be kind of crispy it's going to be
really yummy and so the sun is 5,500
Celsius so that is hotter and so I don't
know if you could get your pizza onto
the surface of the Sun quickly enough
and remove it again that it would cook
it would definitely be burnt so what do
like burnt pizza like I'm sure you've
had burnt pizza it's not great but as
you get farther and farther away from
the Sun then the temperature is going to
drop and there's going to be this sweet
spot there's going to be this perfect
distance from the Sun that matches the
temperature of your oven and it's not at
the Earth uh so it's going to be
somewhere in between the Earth and the
Sun maybe like around Venus or something
I haven't done the math exactly but
there will be this place where you could
take your pizza put it in a glass box
put it in an oven float your oven in
space and and it would cook and it would
be perfect so you just need to find that
perfect spot in the solar system to cook
your space Pizza Kip neelson isn't the
corona of the sun much hotter than the
surface absolutely so the corona is the
atmosphere of the Sun and when you see
say a total solar eclipse and the disc
of the sun is blocked by the moon then
what you get is you can see the corona
these amazing wisps of gas that are
going out into space and it's like
bigger than uh sort of the size of the
moon it's incredible and the temperature
is ludicrously high like it is into the
millions of degrees when the surface of
the Sun is only 5,800 Kelvin the corona
can be millions and this was a huge
mystery in astronomy like why is the
Corona so hot compared to the Sun and
for the longest time we didn't know and
nobody really had a good concrete reason
to explain this and you know we know
that there are Corona Mass ejections
there flares that happen on the surface
of the Sun and they must contribute in
some way to this material and the
magnetic fields that are snapping and
popping around the surface of the Sun
but it wasn't until probably the last
five years or
so that astronomers finally figured
figured out what it was and it was
predicted a long time ago that there
would probably be the presence of what
are called Nano flares that there would
be these tiny versions of flares on the
surface of the Sun and that all of them
would contribute to heating up this
atmosphere around the Sun so you
wouldn't get one single event you just
have this combined heating from all of
these little flares and thanks to the
Parker solar probe thanks to solar
Orbiter thanks to other earth-based
observatories they're actually able to
confirm that now I'm not sure how well
it would cook pizza though so I'll have
to look into that
all right those were all the questions
that we had this week thank you everyone
who uh asked the questions in the
YouTube comments everyone who joined us
for the live stream there's going to be
the upcoming date and time for the next
show somewhere here on my channel they
change now so I'm not sure whether which
which time stream is going to be the
next one now I'm going to chat about our
presence on Blue Sky but first I'd like
to thank our patrons thanks to Abe
Kingston Adam Schaefer Andre gross Barry
Lake griffing David Gilton and David mat
Dennis alberie Dustin cable James Clark
Jeremy M Jim Burke Jordan young Josh
Schultz Paul robok spiders swap. and
Steven fer Munley who support us at the
master of the universe level and all our
patrons all your support means the
universe to us so I finally got around
to setting up our presence on Blue Sky
and this is of course the new social
networking application like threads like
Twitter like Facebook and so uh we're on
Blue Sky I was able to sign up with our
own domain name and so now the main
Universe today feed is just
universetoday do.com on Blue Sky and
then I'm fc. universetoday do.com on
Blue Sky and so that's their version of
being verified so you know it's actually
me and it's actually Universe today and
so I'll be posting on the universe today
feed just it's automated it's a robot
beep boop just going to be publishing
the stories that we're posting on
Universe today and then for my own
custom feed I'm just sharing a bunch of
stories that I'm working on interesting
observations Astro photos that I've been
taking and participating in the
conversation so if you want to connect
with me in another way uh you can find
me over on Blue Sky as well in addition
to all of the other social media
applications all right we'll see you
next week