China’s High-Speed Rail Becomes a Financial Sinkhole, Many Ghost Stations | China Truths

China Truths
61 followers
Welcome to China Truths. In this episode, we will bring you the following story:
China’s High-Speed Rail Becomes a Financial Sinkhole with Ghost Stations Everywhere
Now, let’s dive into the details
#china #chinatruths #chinanews
Welcome to China Truths. In this episode, we will bring you the following story.
China's high-speed rail becomes a financial sinkhole with ghost stations everywhere.
Now, let's dive into the details. It's all covered in today's China Truths.
China's high-speed rail becomes a financial sinkhole with ghost stations everywhere.
The total mileage of China's high-speed rail is set to surpass 30,000 miles,
or approximately 48,300 kilometers. Foreign media report that this is the largest public
project in China's history but is gradually becoming a massive financial sinkhole.
The China State Railway Group, which operates it, is nearing a record-breaking debt of $1 trillion.
Across the country, numerous ghost high-speed rail stations highlight this growing crisis.
The Wall Street Journal reported on November 21 that when Xi Jinping came to power,
he inherited an ambitious plan to build 10,000 miles, or 16,000 kilometers, of high-speed rail
connecting major cities in China. The high-speed trains were named Fuxingheyo, or revitalization.
Now, China's high-speed rail network is about to exceed 30,000 miles, or 48,000 kilometers,
making it the largest and most unique high-speed rail system in the world.
This colossal project has incurred unimaginable costs. Over the past five years alone,
more than $500 billion has been spent on building new railways, trains, and stations.
Annual operational expenses to service the debt amount to $25 billion. Due to low operating
efficiency, many high-speed railways suffer from losses and significant financial deficits.
This unchecked infrastructure expansion has resulted in numerous underutilized high-speed
rail lines, pushing China State Railway Group's debt close to $1 trillion.
The annual debt servicing cost is $25 billion.
Nevertheless, the Chinese government plans to increase the mileage by nearly 15,000 miles,
or 24,000 kilometers, by 2035, which will require an investment of hundreds of billions of dollars.
The Wall Street Journal noted that China has recently cut management costs to reduce debt
pressure. In 2023, the railway system recorded a profit of $460 million but still could not offset
the $25 billion in losses incurred from 2020 to 2022 during the pandemic. Notably, the profit
included over $1 billion in other income, likely referring to state subsidies. The report also
pointed out that China has long relied on infrastructure spending to sustain economic
growth, even though much of the needed infrastructure is already in place.
This model has now created a massive sinkhole. It questions whether so many high-speed rail
are necessary. High-speed rail costs far exceed those of traditional trains or buses.
Many economists believe that traditional trains or buses would suffice for most of China's needs,
with high-speed rail being economically viable only in densely populated areas.
However, the high-speed rail network has extended into rural regions,
such as Fushun County in central Sichuan. This primarily rural county has a declining
population of only 700,000. Since opening its first high-speed rail station in 2021,
at least 12 stations have been established within a 40-mile or 65-kilometer radius.
Fushun station is often nearly empty, with just 20 travelers wandering a massive waiting room.
These underutilized high-speed rail stations have been dubbed ghost stations by netizens.
Xibo Jiuquan East Station in Shandong, built 15 years ago but never opened,
is the top-ranked ghost station in China. The second-ranked ghost station is Zijinqin East
Station in Jiangsu, idle for 14 years. Located in Nanjing's Qixia District,
it was completed in 2010 as part of the connection between Nanjing South and Xianlin stations but has
never been used. Together with Jiangpu Station, it is referred to by netizens as one of Nanjing's
two desolate stations. The third-ranked station is also in Jiangsu, Nanjing Jiangpu Station,
and used for 13 years. There are at least 20 ghost high-speed rail stations in China,
spanning Liaoning, Yunnan, Shandong, and Hubei, among other provinces.
Examples include Ningbo East Station in Zhejiang, which has been idle for 11 years,
and other stations like Yantai Shifu in Shandong, Shushan East in Anhui, and Shuangli West in
Sichuan. Some stations, idle for years, have reopened due to public pressure, albeit at
significant costs. For example, Hele Station in Wanning, Hainan, which was idle for 14 years,
reopened on October 15, 2023, following a $3.7 million renovation. Its long-term viability
remains uncertain. Similarly, Heidu Station on Hainan's circular high-speed rail, which cost
over $5.5 million, opened in July 2023 after being unused for over seven years due to low
daily passenger numbers and significant operational losses. New ghost stations are also
emerging. For example, Wanzhou North Station on the Hangzhou-Wanzhou high-speed rail line,
completed after seven and a half years of construction, opened on September 6, 2024.
However, issues have already arisen, with 10 daily trains to Hangzhou West being suspended
until December 21, with no explanation provided. On May 21, 2024, China Business Journal questioned
why many high-speed rail stations were built only to remain unused or be shut down. For example,
Guilin and Guangxi has nine high-speed rail stations, but Wutong Station saw less than
200 daily passengers before ceasing operations after just four years. The report questioned how
such expensive projects proceeded from design and planning to construction and were ultimately left
unused. Who should be held accountable for this ineffective investment? The responsibility seems
to lie with the government. According to designers at China Railway or UN Engineering Group, some
local governments prefer stations in suburban areas to reduce urban demolition pressures and
promote new land development. Local government officials revealed that, initially, most funding
came from the Ministry of Railways, giving the railway authorities significant say in planning.
However, as local investment in high-speed rail increased, local governments gained more influence.
Linking high-speed rail stations to political achievements, they actively pursued new projects.
China State Railway Group officials said railway departments rely on local governments for land
acquisition and relocation. If local governments propose building stations and connections with
their funding, railway authorities typically do not oppose them. However, if a station sees low
passenger traffic after opening, the railway department may reduce services or temporarily
suspend operations. Dr. Xie Tian, a professor at the University of South Carolina's Aiken School
of Business said that railway investment decisions often lack thorough feasibility studies and fail
to consider market demand. These projects are typically driven by the desire to boost GDP
figures and political achievements, even when wasting money. He characterized China's high-speed
rail network as an example of infrastructure fanaticism and blind expansion, intended to
create an illusion of rapid economic growth and attract international investments. However,
these railways often find little use. With the current economic downturn, fewer people can
afford to use high-speed rail. Dr. Xie also noted that China is suffering from widespread overcapacity,
with high-speed rail being another manifestation of this problem.
