Win Extraterrestrial Metal: join my mailing list 💥 https://briankeating.com/yt 💥 Can one small inconsistency tear down an entire scientific theory? In this episode, I debunk a claim made by the @astrumspace channel about the "lithium problem" and the real threat to the Big Bang theory. Astrum presents this discrepancy as a major flaw in the Big Bang model, but this is more clickbait than science.
The lithium issue isn’t anywhere near as catastrophic as it’s made out to be. The lithium levels might not match exactly what we expected, but that’s one small piece of a much bigger, well-tested puzzle.
It’s like finding one odd fossil and claiming it ruins the entire theory of evolution.
I also take a closer look at how these claims (mostly used to sell products or generate views) mislead the public and create doubt where there’s no reason for it.
We’ve got mountains of evidence backing the Big Bang, and cherry-picking data to suit your narrative just doesn’t hold up.
Let’s set the record straight. Keep an open mind, but not so open that your brains fall out!
Key Takeaways:
00:00 Intro 01:23 The lithium problem and Astrum's claim 02:05 Explanation of the Big Bang model's predictions 02:48 The role of lithium in Big Bang nucleosynthesis 05:32 Critique of Astrum's presentation 08:24 The importance of other supporting evidence, like the CMB 10:26 Lithium discrepancy as a minor issue, not a crisis 12:31 Call for better scientific communication 14:40 Comparison to other science denial movements 16:28 The danger of cherry-picking data to discredit theories 17:58 Outro —
welcome back to No the lithium problem
didn't just kill the big bang or liar
liar big bang denier part two today's
target the inconvenient truth that
breaks the leading big bang model a
supposed devastating takedown of the Big
Bang model courtesy of the enormous
channel Astramm now I like Astramm it's
a great channel they have some great
content on that channel i was really
quite surprised by this so-called
takedown of the entire big bang
framework which he claims is occurring
because of the so-called lithium problem
now spoiler alert I already took down
Eric Learner who does much more divisive
and intrusive work on his channel where
he hawks his fusion research and appeals
to you to support it today's video is
slightly different because the content
is much richer it's much more well done
and it's much more persuasive which also
leads it to being much more problematic
in some sense and I'm hoping Astram will
see this video and maybe take the time
to react to it from a working
professional and consult with working
professionals not just me but my
colleagues who work on the lithium
problem and the CMBB both of which are
in conssonance with the leading big bang
model and there's a slight of hand that
Astramm uses at the end that I'll be
talking about where he brings in the
work of Stephven Hawking in a way that's
completely irrelevant to the point that
he's trying to make so today's supposed
theory wrecking inconvenient truth is
you guessed it lithium cuz nothing says
universe shattering discovery like the
metal that they won't let you bring on
airplanes according to Astramm the Big
Bang model is in serious trouble it's
like a giant cosmic jigsaw puzzle and
guess what we found a piece that doesn't
fit in well that would be bad if it's
one of my kids 10 piece puzzles but in
this case it's one piece out of
literally tens of thousands tens of
thousands that fit perfectly the
translation is we found a minor
inconsistency and let's pretend that the
whole thing is under question and
crumbling down that's more of what
Learner does in the video that I did
previously this one's more subtle first
of all where's all the lithium great
question and actually Astramm does a
wonderful job illustrating animating and
displaying what lithium is and how it's
predicted to be formed in trace amounts
after the Big Bang now trace amounts is
much much smaller than you could even
imagine because the abundance relative
to hydrogen and helium which make up
over 99% of what's produced in the big
bang process and their isotopes lithium
is fractions of parts parts per million
even less parts per billion and clearly
modern cosmology just by fact that it
can make predictions of an abundance at
the parts per billion level is a
spectacular success and not the fraud
that Eric Learner and others make it out
to be but there might be more to the
story and I think it warrants further
exploration let's do a quick chemistry
lesson as Astramm does very well in his
channel and I want to recommend his
channel overall except for this one
problematic video which you should watch
in order to see how the science
communication can sometimes be used to
slip in some pieces of disinformation or
doubt rather and stay tuned for later
when I'm going to explore where he
actually tries to bring in and evoke
past guest Roger Penrose in front of the
show to substantiate that this is
actually a big problem it's not so
lithium is formed in tiny amounts during
big bang nucleiosynthesis right along
hydrogen and helium and their isotopes
there's three isotopes of hydrogen
so-called proteium with one proton no
neutrons dutaterium with one neutron and
tridium with three neutrons and then
there's helium 3 and helium 4 with
either one or two neutrons respectively
now we don't find one of the isotopes of
lithium the two isotopes lithium 7
lithium 6 we don't find them in the
exact right amount so not only is the
Big Bang under attack but because the
Big Bang is one of the most
spectacularly tested theories in all of
science all of science could be under
attack let's rewind a bit and go back
the Big Bang model is based on physics
i'm an astrophysicist my degree is in
physics experimental physics to be exact
astrophysics is the application of the
laws of physics which cover everything
from quantum mechanics nuclear physics
thermodynamics solid state physics
condensed matter physics and many many
other subtopics the only part of physics
that's not contained within cosmology as
I joke with my students is biopysics and
even if we search for aliens and alien
life potential maybe I'll throw in some
bioysics as well but the big bang model
predicts the abundance of hydrogen and
helium at just a fraction of a second
some 1 millionth to 100 millionth of a
second after the big bang now the
foreshadowing to Stephven Hawking is
when there's a question of whether or
not the big bang was a singularity
that's completely irrelevant to the
question of lithium production the fact
is all scientists that work in cosmology
and astrophysics both theorists
observers and experimentalists agree
that the universe is extremely hot and
dense at an earlier phase whether or not
or if the universe had a big bang
singularity or not is irrelevant to the
production of the nuclei that come a
microcond after that's an eternity
compared to the 10 theus 36th of a
second for example that inflation
predicts when we would be in a purely
quantum cosmological epoch but the
establishment of the abundances of the
isotopes of helium and hydrogen and
lithium are established during a much
more classical evolution it's basically
chemistry nuclear chemistry we know a
great deal about that and the abundances
of most of the isotopes and elements
burillium hydrogen helium match exactly
and that's why cherrypickers like Eric
Lerner and unfortunately in this video
Astramm himself are so quick to pounce
on lithium and one of its isotopes not
matching the Big Bang prediction but
they're ignoring the spectacular match
not only from nuclear physics
calculations done by my incredible
geniuses who work in laboratory and
nuclear reactor experiments to get
cross-sections reaction rates etc
particle collision rates and so forth
not only do they have to ignore those
great triumphs but they also have to
ignore the cosmic microwave background
which occurred 380,000 years later which
also predicts the abundances not only of
photons and hydrogen atoms where
hydrogen bonds when a proton bonds with
an electron to form the first atoms in
the universe as I said that happens
380,000 years later that also is a tight
constraint on how much dutyium and how
much isotopes therefore of hydrogen
helium etc are present in the first
micros secondsonds of the universe's
existence again none of this is
predicated on whether or not there was a
singularity in the universe prior to the
nucleiosynthesis epoch that occurred at
essentially almost infinite temperatures
if there was a singularity and much much
later do things like electroeak
decoupling strong and weak nuclear
forces decoupling etc those occur much
much later and the universe can be
thought of as evolving without the need
for quantum gravity which was the
complaint that Hawking talks about in a
brief history of time in his work with
past guest and friend of the show Sir
Roger Penrose so that's totally
irrelevant the physics of the early
universe when the early universe was a
few fractions of a second old is well
understood physics well within the reach
of modern laboratory experiments it's
actually quite within the realm of
fusion reactors on Earth let's get back
to astronom not only is the total
lithium amount too low but the ratio of
the two isotopes of lithium lithium 6 to
lithium 7 is way out of whack now is
that enough to cause the entire edifice
of the Big Bang to collapse hardly
that's like finding a skeleton of a
Neanderthal that happened to only have
four fingers and saying that invalidates
the theory of evolution okay maybe he
got his finger chopped off in a club
battle with his wife the ratio being off
is important it's interesting and there
are many legitimate scientists that are
studying this fact the existence of the
abundance of lithium 6 should be a
thousand times less abundant than it is
observed to be so clearly according to
these people that try to take a takedown
is that everything we know about the
entire big bang all the observations
from Baron acoustic oscillation to the
cosmic microwave background radiation we
have subten of a percent precision and
accuracy unlike the detractors who are
wrong at the hundreds of percent not
hundreds of percent but hundreds of
percent level they failed to match
predictions they failed to match the
basic observations that would occur say
in Eric Learner's favorite model
so-called tired light which he's been
hawking since the 1990s completely ruled
out by all observations at all
wavelength scales to date so it doesn't
scrap the big bang at all all it does is
illustrate something very funny must be
going on with lithium and we can't go
back to the big bang and obviously
measure the abundance of lithium with
some lithometer but we can measure it
locally and in some cases that local
amount and abundance of the two
different isotopes in the ratio between
lithium 7 and lithium 6 as Astram
beautifully demonstrates could be
different but it would evolve with say
galactic evolution and so it may not be
a tracer today at the age of the
universe being 13.8 billion years that
could be very different from the way it
was at time close to zero and so this is
a very tricky thing to do not only do
you have to understand the chemistry and
evolution of chemical abundances and
their ratios within stars you also have
to understand how local galactic media
may change the abundance ratios because
these stars suck up material from their
local environment and yes there may be
quantum effects that are in play that
cause us to re-evaluate the first
moments of the Big Bang's production of
lithium but that won't change it's very
strictly controlled the amount of
hydrogen and its and its isotopes those
are very strictly nailed down those
won't change at all and that's a big
problem for the detractors of the big
bang they cannot explain it they try to
explain it but they can't produce enough
of the dutium and helium within stars
because stars eventually die and so for
a universe that's infinitely old and
never had a big bang as Learner
postulates these stars would die out and
he'd have to find some mechanism
completely unknown to anyone else but
him apparently of producing not only
lithium properly but every single
element on the periodic table while
we're depleting stars via the supernova
mechanism that gives rise to things like
these meteorites which you can obtain
for free i don't give these away i don't
sell these i'm not sponsored by Big
Meteorite unlike my friends at Astramm
who has a lovely skincare product that
he's happy to sell you and sponsor his
video he does a completely enviable
product placement in the middle of his
video i urge you to check it out if
nothing else but for a laugh that you'll
get when he's talking about the lithium
present in the sunscreen from his
advertiser but anyway there's nothing
relevant about the lithium discrepancy
that poses a problem for the
cosmogenesis event nothing about it is
an open question open wound or open sore
when it comes to evaluating whether or
not the universe began with a
singularity or not there are many models
including very reputable scientists like
my friend Paul Steinhard Anna Eegis Neil
Turac and many others who have been on
the show that don't go through a quantum
phase of the universe's early phase at
all in fact they have bouncing and a
purely classical phase and that's great
because we should have as many models as
possible the one thing that they do that
that Astramm and I don't give him any
grief for this because he's not a
practicing scientist but Learner claims
to be and if Learner was a proper
scientist he would realize that the most
important thing about a scientific model
is that you can prove it wrong not that
you can prove it right now he thinks
he's proven it wrong through one piece
of data out of a near landslide of data
supporting the Big Bang model this one
lithium discrepancy he's hung his hat on
completely while it's not exactly clear
how at all lithium can be produced in
his model and he actually agrees that in
his model of lithium production you can
see the earlier video lithium is
produced through cosmic ray spellation
and other processes and he gets the
ratio wrong too so he admits that but he
of course says this is more of a
devastating blow to the Big Bang than it
is to his model which again is partially
related to what's called tired light
which is invalidated and disowned by its
creator Tolman and others as far back as
almost 80 90 years ago and certainly by
the time of the cosmic microwave
background there's no evidence for it
and the evidence from distant quazar
observations are suggestive that light
does not get tired because we don't see
these fuzzy galaxy shapes this is a
common trope that is afflicting modern
society goes along with something called
Brandolini's law which suggests that
it's tens or hundreds of times easier to
create a BS as Brandolini called it
theory or conjecture than it is to
refute it so the world is left with the
mountains of unrefuted BS and that I do
find is quite troubling now these videos
have been seen by over half a million
people the two that I've described in
the short series on the lithium problem
and the problem of big bang denialism
while they're not hawking skincare
products or nuclear fusion there are
troubling problems that are common
between these two types of videos again
I have more of an issue with learner
than I do with Astramm because Astramm
is not claiming to be a proper scientist
he claimed to report on it but there is
an obligation Astramm if you're
listening to report accurately and
actually interview and discuss these
things not as a collab or something like
that but you should have actually
reached out to the scientists that are
working on this problem and I can give
you a handful of people that would be
happy to talk to you about it so this is
a sign that the standard model is better
than ever however there'll always be
questions in it and the common trope
that I always find is that one
measurement out of place does not
invalidate an entire scientific field in
fact it's a sign of healthy academic
research there are mountains of evidence
that converge upon an explanation from
multiple different avenues that's the
way science works but if you find one
missing piece you may use that to sell
skincare products or a nuclear fusion
but it's not actually going to make a
big difference people don't believe
there's a motivation for the universe to
have started with the big bang as a part
of a hoax or a cabal it bears
explanation it's a trope that people
from big bang deniers to round earth
deniers to evolution deniers to vaccine
deniers as dangerous misinformation that
follows a predictable pattern first
someone will cherrypick one unresolved
question ignoring overwhelming evidence
they'll latch on to that like a dog on a
bone they'll ignore the evidence that
supports the model at their own peril
then they'll misrepresent the nature of
scientific progress implanting doubt
where there is none throw in an ad for
your favorite product product placement
and you get this complete package of
either grifting or clickbait depending
on your perspective so one piece of
discrepant evidence doesn't invalidate
the established models that have stood
the test of time for over 70 years now
that the Big Bang happened we still
don't understand the initial conditions
we may never understand the initial
conditions but it would be akin to
denying evolution because it follows the
same logic as the so-called missing link
argument where we have failed to find a
missing link between early primate
ancestors common ancestors to humans and
primates and so because we don't have
that the whole edifice of evolution
ignoring everything that we know about
genetics and molecular biology to things
as esoteric as linguistic evolution to
the entire flora and fauna common
ancestry that has been held up in the
archaeological record for the last six
or seven decades but sure it makes for
entertaining clickbait and I don't fault
people for trying to get those clicks
and likes but I just fault them for the
comments in the sections below their
videos where they hear people saying "I
knew they were lying to us thank you for
telling us Eric Learner now we know the
truth." So will they now reject germ
theory will they stop getting vaccinated
now I know you're out there saying "Well
what about CO?" Well what about CO did
you have on Dr j bonacharia any of you
out there and give him prominence in
2022 when he was being attacked by the
likes of Tony Fouchy and Francis Collins
the leader of the NIH threatening and
hoping for a devastating takedown by the
Washington Post and major media outlets
of his research that suggested that we
were incorrect to be trying to vaccinate
and the entire population rather than
achieve her immunity so f off if you
think that I'm not a stalwart defender
and questioner of following the science
that's not what I'm saying here i'm
saying when there's overwhelming
abundant evidence when it doesn't have a
monetary or political bent for example
as the flat earth or the moon landing or
big bang does you shouldn't reject it
because it makes you dumber and it makes
society dumber as a whole part of the
mission of these channels that I
represent is to educate for free i'm not
selling it there's no sponsors on this
video but the point is I really want to
make sure that we have a belief and
faith in science when we need it because
as I asked Dr jay Badachari in our
interview what happens when the next
pandemic comes along and it's much worse
and we do need to achieve her immunity
through vaccination people won't trust
science because of the abuse of science
that many like Fouchy and Collins seem
to have indicated during the shameful
COVID 19 lockdowns not the pandemic it
was the lockdowns that were so
devastating according to Jay Badachari
who is now by now hopefully the National
Institute of Health director save the
comments about you know Keing being a
shill there's nothing for me to shill
there's NASA doesn't pay me to make
these videos there's no cabal behind Big
Bang like Fizer you know is going to
sponsor this video because they have
something to gain from giving out
prescriptions for lithium even though
they do probably do that for some of
their medication but it's off brand or
it's off off patent so if you wouldn't
reject the theory of evolution or the
theory of Newtonian gravity even for one
piece that's discrepant oh okay don't
get me started on gravity you shouldn't
neglect the big bang model either
because of this missing so-called
lithium problem if you are you might
just be a big bang denier science
actually is a collaborative
self-correcting process and scientists
more than anyone should be willing to be
proven wrong because that's the way that
we make progress to get closer to truth
i'm Brian Keing Chancellor's
Distinguished Professor of Physics at
the University of California San Diego
and until next time keep an open mind
but not so open that your brains fall
out of your skull