Consulting case interview demonstration and commentary - Growth strategy

Professional Development
12 followers
2 Video Views·Jun 25, 2025
Consulting case interview and commentary with BCG alumni, Shaun Glassman and David Ma.
The case analyzes a growth strategy for the 1930's era gangster, 'Hal Poneca.'
If you would like to see more case demonstration videos, check out http://consultingconfidant.com/practi...
Hi, welcome to Consulting Confidant's live case demonstration. I'm Sean Glassman,
the CEO of Consulting Confidant, and I'm here with Dave Ma. Welcome guys. All right,
so we are going to do a live case and then give some commentary throughout. So let's do it.
Are you ready? I am ready. Let's do it. The year is 1930. Your client, Hal Ponca,
is the leader of an organized crime group in Chicago. His organization currently participates
in multiple industries, alcohol bootlegging, gambling, loan sharking, and ice cream parlors.
Overall sales growth has remained constant at 20% per year, and Mr. Ponca wants to accelerate it to
over 50% over the next year. He has hired you to figure out how to accelerate his growth.
All right. Yeah, so after you hear the case prompt, that's a really great time where you
want to summarize what you just heard to make sure that you understood it correctly and you're
not missing anything. And just to reiterate, you definitely want to summarize. You don't want to
repeat the case prompt back verbatim. Yeah, so one of the biggest mistakes that I see with students
doing this is that they hear the prompt, and then they write down their notes, and then they read
the prompt back to me. I have the prompt. I know exactly what it says. You don't have to do that.
Just think of something original. Pick your own words, but definitely don't repeat it back. Yeah.
And it looks like we have a pretty diversified set of industries that we play in,
illegal alcohol, illegal gambling, illegal loans, and legal ice cream. And it looks like we're
pretty good at what we do, 20% CAGR, and we're looking to accelerate to 50%, right? So to me,
this sounds like a classic growth strategy case, just classic, 1930s classic as a matter of fact.
And so I'd like to explore how to do that. And so can I take a minute to think about
ways to expand Hal's portfolio and essentially grow our revenue? That'd be fantastic.
Yeah. So for those of you following on at home, I think it's a great time for you to just
create a framework, pretend you're the interviewee right now, and just write it
out the exact same way that you would if you were actually doing the case.
All right. So here's the way I'd like to think about our business, right? So it sounds like
we're trying to just grow, just make as much money as possible. The way that I think about
this, there's actually a couple of different ways we can do it. The first is which is grow
organically. So take our current four lines and just expand them, right? Ways that we can do that
potentially include jacking up the price, getting our distribution. I don't know if we're just in
Chicago. Maybe we've thought about Milwaukee. A lot of different ways to grow there, right?
Another way might be to enter new industries. And so there are a lot of illicit things that
we can do. It sounds like we're not selling drugs yet. So drugs could be a way to go.
And lastly, I think acquisition, inorganic growth, mergers and acquisitions.
That might actually be.
And so there's a lot of different things we can do, like merge with other famous families,
take them out and take their business. A lot of different things that we can think about, right?
So those are kind of the three areas I'd like to start with. From there, we can look at actual
competition, kind of examine the market potentially, look at different pricing schemes. And from there,
we should be able to come to a conclusion on how to grow our business. That sounds great.
All right. So where do we start, right? I'd say.
So typically in a case interview setting, the interviewee is not going to be asking the
interviewer where to start. It typically goes the other way around. As in those situations,
what you'll find is that the interviewer will actually ask and say, well, what do you think?
I'd say let's start looking into organic.
Okay. Organic growth it is. And so what I'd love to know then is across our four different
business lines, if you will, how are we doing in each, right? And so by how are we doing, I mean,
how much money are we making? What percent of the portfolio is it capturing?
Are we paying a lot more in costs? I mean, any of those types of questions would give me a little
bit of an understanding of how we're doing. Yes. So in this case, the first chart is often
the hardest chart to get. And you have a tough time knowing how exactly the chart's going to look.
You'll never guess exactly what it's going to look like. There are probably hundreds of ways
in which it could be presented. And so it's your job as the interviewee to essentially ask some
form of the right question to earn this chart. The way that I typically think about this is to
ask a general slash specific question. So in this case, general means thinking about how is the
business doing and specifically what are a couple of questions in which the data could be presented.
By asking that, it's hard for the interviewer to deny you some sort of information that you're
asking for. That sounds like a great idea. So we actually have the revenue by segment as well as
the projected growth for the Chicago market. OK. So when you receive your chart in a consulting
interview, sometimes it takes a few seconds to really understand what's going on. And you have
two options here. You can either sit there in silence and process everything, or the better
option is as you're looking at it, you talk through what you're seeing and start making
those connections on the fly. And as you can see, Dave did a really great job with this.
Looks like we're looking at here on the x-axis revenue by segment. So from that,
what it tells me is that alcohol is by far our biggest in terms of just raw dollars.
And it also tells me the bubble size here that it's also the biggest market. And that seems to
correspond almost perfectly. Yes. And then the projected market growth continues to essentially
lines up exactly with that as well. Right. Correct. And so to me, the way that I would
read this is that further along the right means that it's better. We're better at that. Right.
Further up means that it's growing more. Yeah. And the bigger the bubble size, it means that
the bigger the market is. Right. Correct. And so to me, it sounds like Chicago is a bunch of
growing fast. We're good at it and it's our biggest. And so it sounds like there's a lot
that we could potentially capture there. And so my first inclination would be to go
look at alcohol and see if we can continue to expand it. Sure. Because it's going to grow more.
It's already big and we're good at it. Yeah. Do we have a good sense or a game plan of how we
would think about tackling this? And is this the right direction that we would want to go
strategically within our organization? Could we even expand and ramp up our alcohol production?
Sure. Yeah. So I think at this point it feels a little bit like fishing where he wasn't exactly
sure where to go. Now, as the interviewer, I gave him a lot of credit for when he explained his
framework. He had a lot of the hypotheses of where the case was going to go. So I pretty
much gave him the credit for really understanding where the case could go. And then this point where
it was a little bit more shaky and less directed, I moved it along a little bit.
So expanding it out for alcohol production, I'd say one area that we've done a lot of research.
And so you said there is we can just generally grow. So expand our production, maybe flood the
market, maybe some type of marketing ideas. Now, what else, what other drivers might you want to
look at, especially in alcohol and loan sharking that we can, since we're doing so well, we might
So as you can see in this point, I said you mentioned it earlier and I was very specifically
referring to the framework. And a lot of times when you're in the middle of the case, you're
going down a certain path. It's really good to take a step back and revisit your framework and
say, OK, what were some of the things that I had mentioned earlier? And a lot of times that can
reground you and give you the traction you need to get to get back on track.
Um, so it sounds like, you know, I don't have a great sense of how the rest of this industry
looks, but organically we might start there. But, you know, if there are other players in
the market, I'd love to see what they're doing, see if there's anything that they're doing well.
And if they're doing something well and we really like it, maybe we could copy it or just
take them over. Got it. So I'd love to see what the rest of the industry is doing,
potentially. So I sort of point out one small and interesting element to this case that if
you look at the chart that has Chicago area revenue, a lot of times charts will have
some additional insights that are a little bit more subtle and difficult to catch.
So if you look here, let's look at particular loan sharking on the X axis. You have the revenue by
segment for house organization. So this is the money that he's making every year.
Now, the size of the bubble is actually the size of the entire Chicago market. And if you
look very closely, you can tell that the size of the bubble is about the same as the $10 million
legend where he's making $10 million. So a exceptional response to this chart would have
picked up on that and said, whoa, it looks like the size of Powell's organization for this product
is actually the same as the entire market. And that could give you the insight that he really
owns the entire market for Chicago, therefore limiting where he can go from there.
A very interesting point. We actually have one chart that not only covers the market size for
Chicago for many of these industries, it also covers the market size for some nearby areas
that we've been considering. Okay. So alcohol. Oh, got it. So we're looking at the size of business
here across different markets. Chicago, even in alcohol is pretty small. And I mean, that makes
sense given the size of the city, but it looks like there's a lot of other markets here that
we could potentially expand into. And it looks like for the most part, the trends mirror what
we see here. And so the first thought that jumps out on this one is that we're doing well in Chicago.
There's no reason to think that we couldn't necessarily do well in another market. So we
could look at expansion in New York. It seems like a pretty notorious city for this type of business.
Right. Same thing goes for loan sharking, which is big and growing as well,
perhaps not as big as alcohol. But I think any of these potential markets is a potential
entry in terms of probably not Newark, but that might just get lumped in with New York.
But to me, what I would start with is saying, if we're just based in Chicago right now,
let's look at what it would take to be in New York. Right. Absolutely. I think that's
pretty spot on. So if you were thinking about what you'd want to look at in order to decide
which city would be the best, what are some issues you might want to consider?
Now, one of the most common questions that we get at Consulting Confidant is,
how do I take my case performance to the next level? How do I go from good
to great? And what does that even mean? How do I know the difference? Now, if we look at this
chart of Dave's performance, he does a good job. He understands where the case is going.
He starts talking about the so what. So what's missing? The part that's missing is he doesn't
really hypothesize around how is he going to make the decision between which city,
how Capone should go into. He does notice the difference in revenue, but it's clear that's not
necessarily enough to get to the next step of the case. So the best way to go about it would be,
well, we can do this by revenue. I'd also want to understand risk and our likelihood of success,
how our supply chain would work in different areas. And in this point, I have to push Dave
to the next step. And he does a great job after he gets that. But this is one of those little
nuances that will make the difference between a good performance that will probably get you
to the next round and a great performance that will make you stand out. I'd be interested in
looking at competition. So if I were looking at New York, what does the rest of the market look
like for illegal alcohol? It sounds like there's $50 million of market size potential here in New
York. I don't know how fast it's growing, but if there's another famous family that's really
dominating that market, it doesn't necessarily make sense for us to go in there unless we kind
of strike a partnership or take them out or something of that sort. And so I would love to
see, you know, particularly in alcohol and loan sharking, what the rest of the market looks like
in some of these big cities. Absolutely. So you have competitors. I think that's really spot on
and fantastic. Anything else you'd want to look at in terms of what would be an issue with going
into a totally new region? We could look at potentially consumer tastes, right? So I know
that here in Chicago, there might be certain types of alcohol that we really like, Malort,
for some reason. We may be producing a lot of Malort and it may not be very... What hasn't
said about Malort that hasn't said about Fertilizer. So, you know, that's one potential
thing is to look at consumer tastes and just the profile of what people are actually drinking
there. I think that's something worth looking at. So is there anything you have on that? Yeah,
so we actually did a pretty in-depth market entry research project looking at all the different
cities. Okay. And yeah, I'd like to get your thoughts on what you see. All right. So
willingness to JVA, that's joint venture, right? Correct. And so it sounds like New York,
obviously, is not really willing to partner with us. Supply relationships looks like we're covered
there. Regulatory relationships. So tell me a little bit more about what that means.
So over the course of your career as a consultant, you're going to come across a lot of different
terms that companies have made up. You're going to hit a lot of different industries and there's
going to be a lot of terminology that you don't know. So if you don't know what something means,
always better to ask about it. Even if it's something that could be relatively basic,
it's better to get the clear definition as opposed to operating under the assumption of being wrong.
Regulatory relationships are how many of the corrupt politicians and police officers do you
have some type of relationship with? Got it. Okay. To get some cover. Yeah. All right. That makes
sense. One ruthless main player, Charlie Columbus, one minor player, Tony, unlikely to stay in the
business. One main player, Bucky, good relationship, dislikes Columbus. Los Angeles, very
fragmented. It sounds like no willingness. And so when I look at this, it sounds like
actually brings a couple of pretty interesting points. The first thing that jumps out to me
is that it looks like we have a willingness to partner here. Supplier relationships, yes.
No regulatory, but it sounds like this main player, Bucky, might have some considering that
Buck is operating in Newark. And what I like about Newark is its proximity to New York City,
right? Absolutely. Which is that if we can get into Newark and kind of test the grounds there,
it might make a lot of sense to have a strategic alliance here to go into New York City and take
out Charlie because it looks like there's a little opportunity here with Tony potentially
leaving the business, right? Correct. And so my first potential thought here is that
though Newark is smaller by a lot, by proximity and by its market dynamics, we could use that
as a first entrance. But the long plan here is to go into New York City, which is much bigger
and eventually take over that market, right? I think that's a fantastic idea. And I'd say
for the long term strategy, that's spot on. Now, we actually talked to Bucky Johnson yesterday,
and he gave us a proposal for a deal. And the conditions were that Al Ponca would get...
Now, while you're often going to get data in the form of an exhibit or a chart, sometimes you're
not going to get data in that format. Sometimes the interviewer is just going to read off a bunch
of numbers, and you're going to need to write them down and start doing calculations. So that's
coming up next, and I suggest you practice and follow along with the video. Now, we actually
talked to Bucky Johnson yesterday, and he gave us a proposal for a deal. And the conditions were that
Al Ponca would get 30% of all alcohol, loan sharking, and gambling business.
He'd pay a $3 million fee for this opportunity. Anything else you'd want to know about this?
You know, in order to figure out how well we do, we'd have to figure out what we plan to make in
that market. So it looks like we get a share of something, and let's call it X. We don't know
what that is. Our costs are $3 million. Are there any other costs that we would think about there
in terms of what we go after? And the last piece is probably what is just our margin on that. So
we're taking X dollars in revenue, right? We're going to take a 30% cut. So the one thing that I
want to emphasize here is that there's a temptation to sit there and just put your head down and start
doing math for a little bit. And that's probably the easier way to do math, but it buys a lot of
time when you're actually speaking out loud, and it shows the interviewer what type of logic is
going through in your head when you're doing the math. And there's a lot of value to that,
because remember, part of what they're measuring is not just what you're doing,
but how you're thinking about it. So talk out your math.
And one additional point on there is at the end of the day, consulting is a client services
business. The more client-friendly you can be in your case interview, the more that your interviewer
is going to think, yes, I'd be really comfortable putting this person in front of a CEO or a senior
manager at one of our clients. So this is a really good skill to have, and it's a really good thing
to practice that's going to pay dividends in your interview.
And we have to pay costs, some cost value, right? And then we have to subtract this flat fee of $3
million. And so it looks like the missing pieces are what percent of the market we think we can
capture in revenue, what our cost structure is, and then subtract the $3 million fee to see if
it's profitable in the short run. Yeah, I think that's spot on. I'd say for the revenue side,
once Bucky Johnson and Hal Ponca got together, they'd basically take over the entire market.
Okay. It'd just be a clean sweep. So that means that in alcohol, gambling, and loan sharking,
there's a combined $40 million to take here. Correct.
At 30% of that, 10% is four, so we'd make $12 million just in revenue. So take away the $3
million flat, and we're at $9 million. Before that, just so our variable margin, which includes
labor, supplies, distribution, 75%. 75%. Margin is 75%. Gross margin is 75%.
So that's $9 million that we'll just make in revenue. And then our fixed cost of going into
there. So our overall labor, weapons, bribes, warehousing and supply chain, office space,
comes to a total of $2 million. $2 million. Okay. So another two from that. So we start with this
$12 that we're going to make, and then we take away our cost, the $3 million, to get us to $9.
And then you said there's a $2 million fee in fixed costs, which brings us to $7. And then
there's this $3 million entrance fee from Bakke, which brings us to $4 million that we could
potentially enter. Correct. It's a small piece compared to our overall portfolio, but it's still
almost a fourth, not quite. And so to me, that suggests that it would probably be worth doing,
especially since it is positive off the bat. It's a worthy investment in making, and this
obviously pays out over time, and it gives us the opportunity to play in the long term. So
the first conclusion that I draw here is that, yes, it does make sense.
So a lot of times at the end of the case, you're going to find you made a conclusion,
you did some math, you synthesized your findings, and now you're sitting there wondering,
am I done? What's going on? This is a great point to look back at the original question and say,
did I answer this question? Do I have enough information to go to my conclusion? And for
this specific case, if you remember, the original question was, how do you help Halponka increase
their revenues by 50%? So now I have to take all the work that we had done previously and tie that
back to the original question. So is this getting us to the 50%? So if we were to look first,
if we were just going to go with just kind of let everything run, how much growth do you think
we would get? Got it. So would we get to 50%? Okay. So as it stands right now, we're at 20%,
right? And so our current business makes 20, 30, 35, and basically zero, right? And so
35 million a year annually, right? So growing at, you know, essentially, you know, this 3 million
in cost is not, is that an annual cost or that's just a one-time cost? That's just a one-time.
One-time cost. So really what we're doing is we're making 7 million a year or not, sorry,
that's in profit, right? We're actually looking at revenue here, which is actually this 40 million
initially times the 30%, which is that 12 million. Correct. So we'd be hitting the 12 million here
annually. So would we be able to grow at 50%, at least in the first year? You know, half of 35 is
17 and a half. And so we wouldn't be able to hit it initially in that first year. But it's tough
to project out second and third year from there. I think it's a great point, but we also have the
organic growth just from each one of those industries. That's correct. All right. So we
have the 20% already growing, right? Correct. From here. Yeah. So that gets stacked on 20%,
10%, 3.5, it's 7, right? So it's actually 19 million. And so combined between the two sources
of business, we do have enough to cover the essentially 17 and a half needed for the 50%
that we're looking for. Absolutely. So Hal Ponca just came from picking up some supplies
and he's on his way over and he'd love to hear your final recommendation. All right. So what I
would tell Hal. All right. So the final moment, the conclusion, the opportunity to impress, right?
So I actually have a five point framework here that I like to use for conclusions that works
pretty much in every single case. And so the conclusion looks like this, right? First,
repeat the question back, but don't spend a lot of time on it, like maybe one to two sentences.
Second, immediately go into the recommendation and state it out front. Third, back up your
recommendation with some of the data or some of the facts from your case. Fourth, take a step
back and think about some of the secondary implications. What are some other things that
we should think about? And then fifth, restate the conclusion or recommendation and close strong
with a final point. All right. So what I would tell Hal is that, you know, we need to expand
immediately. And we were in Chicago. We like it, but we need to go to Newark. The benefits of Newark
is that, you know, we can strike a partnership with our good friend Buck Bucky that would net
us probably twelve million dollars annually in the first year. And on top of our current growth
in Chicago would allow us to hit our target of 50 percent annual Kager, probably with even more
opportunity for expansion once we take over New York in the long run. And that's kind of the next
consideration. So the overall thought here is let's go to Newark. Let's do it. Let's go to
Newark. All right. All right. The case is over. It looks like we're going to New Jersey. Dirty
Jersey. Dirty Jersey. So overall, it was a solid performance. Yeah. So my take on this is that I
think the fundamentals were mostly there. You know, that includes coming up with a framework that's
logical and fits the case and is customized. That includes reading the charts and actually
deriving insights from the charts and driving towards the next steps, doing the calculations
and arriving at a conclusion that makes sense for the problem at hand. I think there were a couple
areas that could have been better in terms of fishing a little bit for information when I wasn't
sure what was going on. But the really important point to remember here is that a good recovery
oftentimes trumps any kind of little stumbles. That's a great point. A great recovery can offset
those minor stumbles. So that's our case. Thank you for watching our live case demonstration.
So we will be uploading additional case demonstrations over the coming days. So
if you'd like to see more, please subscribe to Consulting Confidant's YouTube channel.
And lastly, if you're curious about how you'd stack up against other consulting candidates
from the perspective of a consultant at a top firm, check out ConsultingConfidant.com. Here
you can schedule a live case or mock fit interview with a consultant from a top consulting firm like
BCG, McKinsey, Deloitte, etc. After the case, you'll get customized feedback that can take
your case performance to the next level. So thanks again and good luck.
