There’s nothing like a tragedy to bring people together, and many films create a fascinating plot by showing how one traumatic event can cause very different individuals’ paths to cross. One such film is “Three Secrets,” a 1951 drama about three women from very different backgrounds who are brought together by the fact that each gave a son up for adoption on the same day five years ago. When the story hits the news that a five-year-old boy has been stranded on a mountainous cliff in a plane crash which killed his adoptive parents, the three women gather at the base of the mountain to await his rescue. These three women are a sensitive housewife (Jeanne Crain), a tough newspaperwoman (Patricial Neal), and an alcoholic convict (Ruth Roman). As the three women bond over their different but similarly ill-fated motherhoods, each wonders whether she might have a second chance to raise her son as her own.
Words are weak to pay my fears. Heartfelt anguish, starting tears.
Pest shall plead a mother's cross. Words are weak to pay my fears.
Starting tears. Pest shall plead a mother's cross.
Words are weak to pay my fears. Heartfelt anguish, starting tears.
Pest shall plead a mother's cross.
Words are weak to pay my fears. Heartfelt anguish, starting tears.
My cause is just below, my friend.
Is just below, below.
Uh-huh. Plane crash. Got it. What's the name of the place again?
Right. Thunder Mountain. Let me know if you get any updates on the rescue party.
Okay. Excuse me. Do you know if they've had any news about the little boy?
Well, hello. Do I know you?
The shelter. Five years ago. Don't you remember? Of course, but what are you...
You mean you think he's your child? You think he's yours?
The radio said little Johnny was born on September 15th. That's when mine was born.
Mine too. And we're not the only ones. There's a third woman upstairs who thinks he's hers.
Three babies, all born on the same day. Three mothers, waiting and wondering.
And three secrets.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Many classic films are based around the beautiful traditional values of the family unit.
True. Movies from the golden era were sure to uphold these traditional values of the family.
However, contrary to what you might think, there are many movies which show something that's not
quite as good of a family, or not the traditional mother and father relationship.
Absolutely. Whether it be an abusive parent, or a troubled, rebellious child,
or estranged siblings, family relationships in classics really run the gamut.
These difficult topics, such as that of unwed motherhood,
were handled masterfully in many old movies. For example, Three Secrets from 1950.
This film is a fascinating study of intersecting plots.
The start, a plane crash, takes the lives of a man and woman, and so that everyone thinks,
their five-year-old son. But photographs taken by planes flying over show that the little boy
is still alive. When it hits the news that he was actually adopted, it gets the attention of
three young women. A happily married housewife, who prior to her marriage made her mistake with
a young marine. A divorcee, who is now a successful newspaper woman, but gave up her
child when her husband divorced her. And a young woman who was led on by a wealthy older man,
and actually ended up killing him when he spurned her and spent several years in prison.
These three women come together at the base of Thunder Mountain, waiting for the rescue party
to find out if the little boy is still alive, and waiting to see which one of them is the real
mother, and hoping she can adopt him now that he is once again a family.
This is a Warner Brothers film, and it stars three great actresses. Eleanor Parker,
Patricia Neel, and Ruth Roman. It was directed by Robert Wise.
Just the genre of this film, which would be sort of a sentimental melodrama, I would say,
doesn't seem like the kind of film you would immediately say is something that's controversial,
or has a lot of difficult or scandalous content in it. But when you watch this film,
it deals with a lot of difficult subjects. You've got not one, but two unwed mothers,
divorce and remarriage, murder, attempted suicide. There's a lot of intense subject
matter going on that could be very inappropriate for younger audiences or more immature audiences
if they weren't handled correctly. But because of the standards that were upheld in Hollywood
at the time, it's handled really beautifully. That's right. From 1934 to 1954, the Motion
Picture Production Code was enforced by the Production Code Administration. Under the
leadership of Joseph I. Breen, the PCA really enforced the code, which is commonly but erroneously
called the Hays Code. And this code was a set of principles and values for what would make films
decent, acceptable, and ultimately entertaining for audiences of all ages, creeds, and backgrounds.
Now, the code did talk about the handling of topics like, we mentioned, unwed motherhood,
murder, or manslaughter, whatever you want to call it in this case, attempted suicide, etc.
And interestingly, it didn't specifically forbid most difficult topics. That's right.
And I think that's where the code and the Breen era really differs from
the modern rating system. That's right. Because the rating system will simply look at a topic
and say, well, this difficult topic is in this movie, so that automatically makes it unacceptable
for younger viewers. Yes, if you look at a lot of code films that have now, for some reason,
been given ratings, most of them are rated at least PG, just because they have more mature
topics in it. There's this really bad mindset, I think, that is taken over, not just Hollywood,
but kind of culture, that family entertainment, something that the whole family can watch,
has to be very immature or just particularly geared toward children, rather than presenting
mature topics and very intelligent topics to young viewers in a way that is acceptable for them and
is not inappropriate in any way. I think the brilliant thing in this film, in particular,
is just a lack of a lot of detail. That's an excellent point. And that's really one of the
main things that made things acceptable under the code. You understand what happened or has
happened or is happening, but it doesn't happen on screen, and you just have to conclude what
happened. That's a good point. You just are aware of the fact that both of these young women
are expecting a child and are not married, so you can fill in the blanks. You know what happened.
And the attempted suicide scene, she's lying on the bed and breathing hard, and her mother sees
this bottle on the ground. You don't see what it is. And the aftermath isn't even really addressed,
but you get the idea. She says, why don't you just let me die, so you know what was happening there.
And the murder is not actually shown. You see the aftermath. Apparently, she hit him with a statue
that was on his desk, but nothing violent is shown. Because the important thing here isn't
the lurid details of these crimes or mistakes or sins or whatever you want to call these difficult
issues. It's about the journey which each of these young women experiences, and that they all bring
them here to this place at the foot of the mountain, waiting and trying to be brought together,
but also to realize what's brought them all here. And it is interesting how it's told in a series of
flashbacks. Right. Starting with the present, but then as each woman remembers her story,
we see what happened with her. And Eleanor Parker's story gets the longest amount of time
because the film starts with her. Right. Then Patricia Neal is the second longest, and then
Ruth Roman, who's the third character we meet, has the shortest amount of time. So she doesn't
even come into the film until about an hour into the runtime. Right. But her part is very powerful.
Yes, it is. I think that this movie is also a product of the studio that made it. It's a Warner
Brothers film, and Warner Brothers was noted for dealing with more controversial and even
dark subject matter. And even beyond the subject matter, Warner Brothers is never afraid to get
into the complexity of human emotions. The facets of love, or loving more than one person. In this
one, it's really focusing on maternal love and how strong that is. Even for, say, the Patricia
Neal character, she seems kind of hard. She's this businesswoman, this newspaper woman, and she
expresses that she hopes it isn't her child, because she doesn't really want anything to do
with her child. But she wouldn't be there if she didn't. She claims she's just a newspaper
reporter covering a story, but she's an executive. She works behind a desk. She doesn't have to be
there. She didn't need to be there. So that pull is there, and it's just really beautiful to see
how strong the maternal instinct is in all three of these women. I think this is the kind of film
that at the time would have been called a woman's weepie, because it's very much about these female
characters, and it's very sentimental, very emotional. And there are no really prominent
male actors in it, even. It's kind of an interesting thing to note. Two of the women have husbands at
one point. One's played by Leif Erikson, and he's more famous as a viking than as an actor.
But there are definitely a lot of actors you'll recognize if you watch many old movies. But there
are no big names. It's really about these three actresses, and each one of them, it's fascinating
to look at where she was in her career. Definitely the reason why Eleanor Parker gets the most time
is she was the biggest star, by a long shot. She'd been featured since the early 40s, and she'd made
many very successful films up to this point, and played many different types of characters. Yes,
she had quite a range. She almost always was sensitive and sympathetic, but not always the
same type of character. So she really got to shine here as the young wife, who is torn between
the fact that she really loves her husband, she has a great life with him, but there's still some
regret that she didn't really want to give up her child. That's right. After she decided to live,
and she realized how much she loved him, she was very reluctant to, even though her mother convinced
her it was the right thing to do, to give the child a family where he could have two parents
together. She really still had that maternal heart, and she reveals in one line that she can't have
any more children. So the idea that her child could be out there somewhere. Right. And the whole thing
starts with where it's the anniversary of her child's birth, and her mother's wondering if she's
still feeling emotional about it. And she denies that she is, only to immediately hear that radio,
and all of a sudden, all those feelings come back as she realizes that little Johnny could be her
son. In fact, she's sure he is. She doesn't even consider the possibility that there could be other
women who had sons on the same day. Yes, her instinct is so strong that he's hers. And that
kind of leads into another interesting and very difficult topic, which is not broached in the film,
but easily could come into a story of this type, which is the issue of abortion.
Right. Any one of these women, you could see, wanting to take that path. And that was a very
taboo subject at the time. But not completely unheard of. It was approached in a few films,
and I suppose the fact that she attempts suicide is, it would have been a form of abortion. True.
I wonder if that is the reason that she can't have any more children. Because of her suicide
attempts? Yeah. That could have, or it could just be she's kind of weak. Yeah, they don't really
give you any details, so you don't know. After she had lost, maybe the doctor told her. So,
again, not a lot of details about a lot of things in this film. Yeah. But the interesting thing is
looking at the character of Eleanor Parker's mother, and, or rather her character's mother,
but she very much influences her daughter's decision. You know, she's not a teen mother.
She is a young woman. She's, I'm pretty sure, over 21, and she's capable of making her own
decisions. But her mother really strongly influences. Like, you've made a mistake,
but you shouldn't let it ruin your whole life. And it's not right for the child either. So,
he deserves to have a real family. Yes. And then you can just pretend this never happened.
And obviously, she means well, and there was such a stigma to being an unwritten mother at the time.
And even though she says, I could say that his father was killed and that we were married, and
she just as easily could have lied about that as she lied about never having had a child. Since it
was during the war. Right. During World War II. But her mother is certain that just basically
pretending this didn't happen is the best way to handle it. And that attitude that she takes
toward it is very similar to the attitude that a lot of parents now take of when they will convince
their daughter to get an abortion. Yeah. Especially the way she ends up changing her
mind after she's had the child. I don't want to give up my child. Just as many young mothers feel
great regret as they get closer to actually having an abortion. There's something about
a mother when a woman is going to have a baby or after she has had her baby,
even though she doesn't disagree with her mother that it's the right thing,
she wants to be a mother so much. And she does love her child. But her mother also is being
driven by maternal instinct. She's caring for her child. And she says, I'm fighting for my child.
And you can't blame her for being concerned about the stability of her daughter since she tried to
kill herself. Oh, yeah. Clearly, she's had a couple of acts of rebellion recently. So she's trying to
get her back on the right path. She probably doesn't think she's really stable enough to be a
mother at this time. It's out of concern for her new grandchild as well. She truly thinks it's the
best thing. And it's obviously a very difficult situation. Is there really a right or wrong way
to handle it? But obviously, if you don't want to have anything to do with your child, give the
child up for adoption to a loving family is obviously the right way to go so much better than
to get an abortion. And so her mother is really doing what she thinks is best for both her
child and her grandchild. And it's so interesting that this adoption agency in Los Angeles,
the shelter, has such a strict policy of anonymity, partly because of the stigma of
families not wanting anyone to know that perhaps there were, there was an illegitimate child,
and for the adoptive parents. So they wouldn't know what the background of that child might be.
Right. That the mother signs away all right to have any contact with her child or know who he is
or anything. And that becomes quite a point of contention after there's this news story. Everybody
wants to know who Johnny's real mother is, and they don't want to tell anyone. Looking at the
other actresses, this was early in the career of Patricia Neal. This was only her second year in
Hollywood, but it was her seventh film because she made a lot of movies. After having a little
experience on the stage, she was signed by Warner Brothers and started making all these movies.
Remarkably, she was only 24 when this movie came out. She looks so much older than that because
she's very tall, has a deep voice, very strong features. It's very mature. And her character
certainly is supposed to be a lot older than that. But you see the strength of character and the
dynamic range she had as an actress already. And she gives a very multifaceted performance. As like
you said, this newspaper woman, this woman who seems like she wouldn't really care that much
about any individual, but she loves her husband so much that she is willing to give up her exciting
journalism career for him until there becomes too much of a choice between these important wartime
assignments and he's just done. He's just fed up waiting for her. And the person sort of driving
her in her story is her editor, who basically comes in and breaks up her marriage because she's
decided she's not going to take any more of these assignments where she has to be gone for long
periods of time because her husband basically told her, you have to be my wife and be committed to
that or I'm gone. She had to really talk him into taking her back after she was gone on this
assignment for a year. And then the editor comes in again and talks her into taking another assignment
and that is what breaks up her marriage, only for her to then learn that she's expecting a child.
So you certainly can understand why she wouldn't want to have this child. Especially when she
finds out that her husband, who has divorced her, has remarried. She was hoping to get back together
with him and maybe he would have been interested. But since he's remarried, she doesn't want him to
even know so that he'll maybe feel regret because he's moved on and she thinks maybe he's found
someone who's a better wife to him than she could be. And then Ruth Roman had been making movies as
accredited actress since around 1944, working at a few different studios. But in 1949, because her star
was rising, she signed a long-term contract to Warner Brothers and this was one of her first
really starring roles at the studio and it helped cement her fame there. So you see three very
different actresses. You've got the very delicate, gentle Eleanor Parker, the strong-willed, very
confident Patricia Neal, and then the more, I think, typically seductive, almost, Ruth Roman,
sort of a bad girl type, similar to an Ava Gardner. Right. She's a very complex character as well.
Yes. That she did start out as this rather innocent young woman. She was a dancer and she really
thought this man loved her and obviously she gave herself to him a little too much. That was
not in the best judgment. But the papers, after the whole scandal, painted it as just she was after
his money. But that really wasn't it. She really loved this man and she thought he loved her and
the shock of realizing that he'd just basically taken advantage of her and just now was just going
to throw her over, toss her aside, was just sort of too much for her. So she's a very
fragile character. When we first meet her, she's been drinking too much and she's causing a scene.
So she's really, in a way, the most affected because she was not resigned to it. She was
basically forced to give up her child because she was in prison at the time she had her child. They
let her out of prison to give birth in a hospital, but then they said, you don't have any friends or
family you can entrust the child with. So they said, you really have to give up your child. So
she was really forced to do that. It wasn't really her free will. So she even more so has
been dying to know about her child all these years. This story was based on a real news incident that
took place in 1949. Really? Yes. When a three-year-old girl named Kathy fell in a well in
Los Angeles and was stuck down there for three days and television and radio came around and
tried to get her out. But when they found her, she had died. And that was the same news story
that inspired the movie Ace in the Hole at the same time. But because this took place in Los
Angeles, that's largely why this movie also takes place in California near Los Angeles.
And they did some location footage for this by Lone Pine, California and in the Angeles Forest
near the mountain there. A big part of the story is this rescue party, this hiking expedition that's
trying to scale the Thunder Mountain to rescue the little boy. And in one scene you see this reporter
going around and interviewing all these different members of the Sierra Club.
And there actually were 10 members of the real-life Sierra Club. And you can just tell
these men are not actors because of the way they talk. They have sort of different accents and
they don't speak that well. They don't seem that comfortable talking into the microphone. So
they have that very real quality which you see when you occasionally can witness real people
from back then. Right, definitely. And the man interviewing them also was sort of playing himself.
He was the radio and television personality Bill Welsh, who was present at the incident with the
little girl. Was the three mothers issue inspired by that or did they make that? They just made that up.
Okay. But the idea of how all these people gathered around in the television and the radio. Via circus.
Yeah, for the rescue of this child. That was what inspired it. As well as the California setting.
So it is interesting how you can see some real location there. One of the oddest things to me is
that they are very much showing real cities. They talk about San Diego. They talk about Los Angeles.
And then they made up this mountain. The only Thunder Mountain in California is the one in
Disneyland, right? Yeah. There was a real mountain. It had a much less exciting name. So it's just
Thunder Mountain. It's just good for drama. Disneyland wasn't around yet.
Disneyland got the idea from this. For the most part all the women look more simple and
there aren't a whole lot of different costume changes for many of them. In the present each
of them only has one costume but you'll see some extra outfits through flashbacks. But even then
you see a good example of simple yet always stylish fashion of the early 50s. My outfit
is based on the costume which Patricia Neal wears in the present as she's reporting on the story.
It's a simple black pencil skirt with sensible black shoes, a white or cream
sweater and then a rather tailored dark coat over it. In another scene she wears a simple gray hat
like this. My outfit is inspired by one worn by Ruth Roman during the flashback sequence.
It is a pencil skirt with a gathered blouse underneath and a black coat and black gloves,
a simple black hat. Although it has three big name actresses and a very well-known director,
Robert Wise, this isn't a popular film. It's actually kind of obscure. I was surprised I'd
never heard of it before a couple of weeks ago. Right. But it has such an intriguing story that
I think it's very real and dark enough that people who are not as accustomed to old movies
will be impressed by it because classic movies, especially of the more romantic comedy variety,
tend to be very light compared to modern films and just so pleasant they could seem almost silly to
modern viewers. But if you look a little deeper, especially at movies by maybe studios like Warner
Brothers, you'll see there are some very serious films which, although maintaining that clean,
high moral standard, tackled some really difficult topics and did it brilliantly. Yes, people think
of it like the bright technicolor kind of pop flavor after and a lot of that was actually
MGM films because Louis V. Mayer, the head of the studio, always wanted a happy ending. Right. So
if that's not really your cup of tea, you might try Warner Brothers because they a lot of times
don't have happy endings or it's sort of bittersweet. Yeah, it could be complicated. I would say the
ending of this film is a little bit bittersweet. Some people are happy and some people maybe have
found a new sense of peace. Yes. A sort of resignation and acceptance. It's a beautiful
ending. You know, everyone doesn't go off into the sunset smiling, but it's a beautiful conclusion
and really a testament to the power of love in many different areas. I think it's being so obscure
is kind of interesting because there are those classic films that most people have at least heard
the title and most of the time, if you're speaking in the what's a good first classic film to watch
kind of genre, a lot of times I would say don't watch a really famous one first. Watch something
that's a little lesser known like this. A lot of times those ones I think are better as your gateway
sort of. There's something about, I can't really put my finger on why that is, and I know there are exceptions
to that rule, but a lot of times like try just maybe you have, if you've heard about a really
famous film, maybe you have some kind of preconceived notions about it and going into one that you
haven't heard of before, I think you can come into it with a little bit more of a clean slate.
Now this movie is available for free on YouTube. Just look up Three Secrets 1950. There's several
good copies, so it's very easy to find and enjoy and of course you can find it on DVD as well on
Amazon or Walmart, but if you look it up on YouTube, it's a fun free way to get started on
your classic film journey. As we said, this film could really be considered a women's weepie, very
much a woman-centered picture with only a very small part for the little boy. Join us next time
as we talk about a film entirely centered around a little boy played by a very talented young actor
who, somewhat spoiled by too much money and a somewhat distant father, really
learns what it is to be a man when he meets a kind fisherman. Thank you for watching. Goodbye.