_In the Vastness of Space_ _ Boeing Age of Aerospace, Ep.

Tech Space
172 followers
Landing men on the moon was a singular achievement that established the 20th
century as the age of aerospace. It was the culmination of nearly a decade of
work by hundreds of thousands of Americans. A national effort called
Project Apollo. But what drove Project Apollo more than anything else was not
the desire to explore another world. It was the determination to defeat an
adversary here on Earth, the Soviet Union. People forget the enormous
antagonism between the Soviet Union and the U.S. at that time. When President
Kennedy set the goal to put a man on the moon before the decade was out, that
became a battle in the Cold War. The Cold War pitted Western democracies led by
the United States against the Soviet Union. It was a battle for hearts and
minds waged with technology and science as a measure of power. In 1957, the
first salvo of the Cold War's contest in space was launched by the Soviets on
top of a massive rocket. Until two days ago, that sound had never been heard on
this Earth. It's a report from man's farthest frontier, the radio signal
transmitted by the Soviet Sputnik, the first man-made satellite as it passed
over New York earlier today. I'll never forget Friday, October 4th, 1957. Our
neighbors and my parents and I gathered out in the backyard, and I remember that
no one said anything. We all knew where to look. And then it appeared, coming over
the trees, this star silently moving against the background of all the fixed
stars. We went back in the house after it was out of sight and asked my parents, why
were some of them crying? Because I thought this was the most magnificent
thing I could imagine. And they said, we're crying because it means the Soviet
Union could drop a nuclear egg on us anytime they want. Sputnik was pretty
terrifying, because it meant that the calculus of the Cold War had had really
changed, and that nuclear destruction seemed a lot more likely. Russia's
getting into space really bothered me. We are headed downhill to the status of a
second-rate world power. If Russia wins dominance of this completely new area,
well, I think the consequences are fairly plain. Probable Soviet world domination.
In 1957, when Sputnik was launched, I was teaching thermodynamics at West Point,
and I remember the impact that it had on me, because I thought this is a
game-changer. I was dismayed by the Russians being first.
Weeks after Sputnik, America's effort to launch its first satellite blew up on
the launch pad. The Americans utterly failed. It looked like the Soviets could
do nothing wrong, and we could do nothing right. It wasn't until four months after
Sputnik that the United States finally put its own satellite into orbit. Then, in
July 1958, the United States created NASA, the National Aeronautics and Space
Administration. NASA is a direct response to the Sputnik crisis that people felt
in the winter of 1957 and 1958. We had a sense that we needed to catch up. In April
1959, NASA chose seven men to become America's first astronauts. One of the
first questions came about was, how are we going to beat the Soviet Union to
putting the first man in space? And so NASA developed the Mercury program. It
was one man in orbit. That was its fundamental objective. To put a man in
orbit would require rockets and spacecraft. To build them, NASA turned to
the American aviation industry. NASA provided the guidance, but it was
industry that did the work. McDonnell Douglas, Rocketdyne, North American,
Boeing, all of them have been central to the space history of the United States.
McDonnell Aircraft, known for its jet fighters, won the contract to build the
Mercury crew capsule. McDonnell really was the pioneer in creating a human
spacecraft. It was working with NASA engineers to develop something that
didn't exist before. You needed to have an environmental control system. You
needed to have a cockpit. So McDonnell became a really critical contractor for
NASA in the early space race. In April 1961, as the U.S. was preparing to send a
man into space, the Soviet Union shocked the world by getting there first. Man had
his first great success in space when the Russians pushed a man across the
threshold. He was Yuri Gagarin, the first to orbit the Earth. It was the propaganda
crew of the year. This is the reality that confronted the newly elected
president, John F. Kennedy. Kennedy came into office knowing very little about
space and basically caring very little about space. The flight of Yuri Gagarin
changed that. Kennedy saw the world reaction to Gagarin's achievement. Here's
the Soviet Union again doing something that the whole world admired. Then on May
5th, 1961, the United States was finally ready to launch its first astronaut, Alan
Shepard, into space. Alan Shepard's flight was not actually as path-breaking as Yuri
Gagarin's flight. Yuri Gagarin orbited Earth. Alan Shepard's flight was just a
up-down trajectory, but it was such a confidence booster after such a string
of failures. Shepard's 15-minute flight, short as it was, gave the Kennedy
administration the success it needed to talk about a grander vision for
Americans in space. And Kennedy decided that there was nothing more important
than figuring out how to get the United States where it belonged in space, which
was in the lead, and find, and I quote, a space program which promises dramatic
results in which we could win. And what the Kennedy administration proposed
would launch the largest scientific and technical mobilization in American
history. We shall send to the moon, 240,000 miles away, a giant rocket on an
untried mission to an unknown celestial body, and then return it safely to Earth,
and do all this, and do it right, and do it first. Before this dictate is out, then we must be bold.
It was a promise to outspend, outbuild, outdream the Soviets, to prove American
superiority by being first to the moon. President Kennedy's resolve was shared
by NASA's astronauts. We were Cold War warriors. It was an enormous challenge,
not just for the people that flew, but for everybody. There were 400,000
Americans that worked on that program, and they all were dedicated, and they
all wanted to win. That was the key. We win, they lose.
To win, the Kennedy administration had an asset waiting in the wings. The man who
had been the chief rocket engineer for Nazi Germany. In the closing days of
World War II in Europe, with Nazi Germany on the brink of collapse, the armies of
the United States and the Soviet Union were advancing into German territory.
The Third Reich had many of the best scientists in the world, and we wanted
them. Not only did we, America, want them, but we had to have them, otherwise the
Soviets would get them. The biggest prize was Werner von Braun. He had designed and
developed the world's first ballistic missile, the V-2 rocket.
Another launching, with a great weapon leaping 65 miles skyward, then reaching 3,000 miles an hour.
Germany launched more than 3,000 of them, targeting London, Antwerp, and other
cities. But it was not the destructive power of rockets that had first sparked
the fascination of Werner von Braun. Since boyhood, he had been obsessed with
space travel and dreamed of trips to the moon and to Mars. The rise of the
Nazi regime gave von Braun an opportunity to further his ambitions.
Now, in the spring of 1945, with his nation on the verge of surrender, he was
the object of a manhunt by both American and Soviet forces. Von Braun was a very
calculating person. So he moved his team and his drawings all the way from
Prussia to Bavaria, so he could surrender to the United States. And he told the
briefing officer, I've chosen to come with the United States because it will
allow me to go to Mars. Von Braun understood that he had found a powerful
new patron. The one-time enemy was now an invaluable ally. People thought the Nazis
are finished, they're gone, we're not worried about them anymore, we're worried
about the Communists. Von Braun and more than 100 members of his team were taken
to the United States, where they resumed work on the V-2 in the New Mexico desert.
While he was helping America arm itself against its new enemy, the Soviet Union,
von Braun was also advancing his own dream of rocketing to the moon and to
Mars. On October 24th, 1946, a V-2 rocket was launched with a movie camera on
board. These are the first pictures ever taken from space. By the 1950s, von Braun
had become the popular face of American space exploration, appearing in three
Walt Disney television specials. I believe a practical passenger rocket
could be built and tested within 10 years. As the space race heated up in the
1960s, the Kennedy administration turned to von Braun to help America beat the
Soviets to the moon. Von Braun was the chief architect of the new rocket
Kennedy was counting on, a rocket powerful enough to break free of Earth's
gravity and launch astronauts to the moon. It was named the Saturn V. For the
aerospace industry, the job of executing von Braun's vision would present
challenges on an unprecedented scale. The rocket, taller than a 30-story building,
had three stages. Stage one was made by the Boeing Company. Stage two, North
American Aviation. And stage three, the Douglas Aircraft Company. Three major
contractors, each supplied by thousands of subcontractors. The Saturn V had more
than three million parts, making up some 700,000 components. Engines, fuel
injectors, and turbopumps from Rocketdyne. Telemetry and guidance systems from IBM.
Gyroscopes and sensors from Honeywell. The Saturn V would be the most complex
machine ever built. Each one of those parts has to meet a tremendous number of
individual specifications and requirements to make sure it does its
job, that one part. And then all those parts have to come together, and you've
got to make sure that as each one of them does its individual job, that
they're also allowing the other adjacent part to do its job. And they all
have to work together without fail. Wernher von Braun and his team had
always had near total control of rocket building. But the astonishing complexity
of the Saturn V meant they were now forced to cooperate with industry. When
the rockets got to the Marshall Space Flight Center, the Germans would take
them apart. In order to make sure that industry had done the job the right way,
because their attitude was, these are pupils, they're just learning. And Jim
Webb, who was the NASA administrator, called in Wernher von Braun and he said,
you've got to trust industry. You've got to quit taking these rockets apart. Just
accept them from the factory. Von Braun knew the conversation was coming, so he
reached into his back pocket and he pulled out a rag and waved it in Webb's
face and says, this is what we find in the rocket. The workmanship isn't up to
our standards. It was a great cultural fight between the old guard, that was
accustomed to doing things in-house, and industry, which was having to take on a
larger and larger share of NASA. The challenges of managing Project Apollo
were not limited to the design and construction of the Saturn V. The crew
capsule, the lunar lander, guidance, communication and life support systems,
much of the technology had to be invented. And getting it all built would
require the mobilization of industry on a scale not seen since World War II. At
its height, Project Apollo employed more than 400,000 people in every part of the
country. George Miller managed NASA's office of manned spaceflight. When you
have 400,000 people working on one project, you got to make sure they all
know what project they're working on. And that's a real challenge all by itself.
It's extraordinarily complicated because it's decentralized. At one point there
were more than 20,000 private contractors involved in building systems
for Apollo and its components. And that's a lot of different players to try to
keep track of things. It was the extraordinary logistical and technical
complexity of Project Apollo that made it vulnerable to human error. In 1966,
NASA selected the crew for Project Apollo's first manned test flight, which
became known as Apollo 1. The plan was for three astronauts to orbit the Earth
for 14 days. Astronauts were fashioned as heroes. But this is an inherently
dangerous enterprise. The risks of failure were quite high. As far as we're
concerned, it's a success if all three of us get back. Forty-year-old Gus Grissom
would command the mission. He was one of the original seven astronauts. Ed White,
36, had taken the first American spacewalk. Roger Chafee, 31, had not yet
flown in space. Grissom, White, and Chafee would be the first crew to test the new
spacecraft designed to bring the Apollo astronauts to the moon. North American
Aviation was the principal contractor for the spacecraft, known as the Command
and Service Module. Dale Myers was the program manager. We had 10,000 people
working on the Apollo Command and Service Module. And those people
reported me. It seemed like an important goal for the country, and I think
everybody on the program got that idea. Ten thousand people building something
of extraordinary complexity to take the Apollo astronauts to the moon. But during
months of testing, NASA had discovered problems in several systems in the
Apollo Command Module. Problems that were widely reported in the press. Gus, you
expect there are going to be a goodly number of slips and pre-launch delays
before you do get off? Well, I think we've had them. The spacecraft systems all
look pretty good to us now. They've been through a check out at North American
and have gone through initial series down at the Cape. And as soon as we get
it out of the altitude chamber, I think that a good portion of our problems are
over. There was a natural tendency on the part of the public to expect things to
go perfectly. But we understood that this was a research and development program,
that things could happen. Bad things could happen. On January 27th, 1967, less
than a month before the scheduled launch of the mission, the crew went to the
launch pad to run critical pre-flight tests. The tests took several hours. At
540 p.m., the astronauts had problems with their communication system. And then
at 631 p.m., something went terribly wrong. This is Peter Jennings at ABC News in
New York. The three astronauts for America's first manned Apollo spaceflight
have been killed. An electrical spark apparently shot out and ignited the
100% oxygen in the cabin that they were breathing as in a real spaceflight. The
Cape was in complete disarray. A lot of the people that had been working on
rockets had been involved in failures, but not in failures involving human
lives. I went directly to the Cape and I saw the wives of all the astronauts and
really had a difficult time. I knew the astronauts and I knew their wives. Oh, it
was terrible. And we commit his body to the ground, earth to earth, ashes to ashes,
dust to dust. Not long before the fire, Gus Grissom had written these words
about the dangers of space travel. There will be risks, and sooner or later
inevitably, we are going to run head-on into the law of averages and lose
somebody. I hope this never happens, but if it does, I hope the American people
won't feel it is too high a price to pay for our space program. In the wake of
the fire that killed three American astronauts, the Apollo manned flight
schedule was put on hold. NASA appointed Frank Borman and eight others to a
review board to investigate the fire. Well, the inside of the spacecraft was
charred beyond recognition. We spent several months trying to find out exactly
what caused it. We think there was an insulation problem with some electrical
wires near Gus Grissom's foot down the lower part of the spacecraft that arced
and started the fire. We had overlooked the fact that in 100% oxygen, almost
anything burns. And we had allowed too much flammable equipment to get into the
spacecraft, so it was a real burned-out halt. Almost six years had
passed since President Kennedy had committed the nation to sending a man to
the moon by the end of the decade. But the nation had changed. Kennedy had been
assassinated. The United States was bogged down in a war in Southeast Asia.
Protests against it were growing. America's expansive dreams and
ambitions were being questioned. And Project Apollo was no exception. The
Apollo fire, it was a disaster, both internally and externally. You have to
ask, well, why did you have the problem? And it was simply because we believed
that we understood what we were doing and then discovered we didn't, really.
There were recriminations everywhere. This was really a wake-up call to
everyone involved that perhaps things were being pushed a little too fast. And
with the Apollo 1 fire, everyone kind of had to take a step back and stop and ask
what had gone wrong and what needed to happen to make sure that this wasn't
gonna happen again. The investigation by Borman and the review board revealed
that serious mistakes had been made in the design and construction of the
Apollo command module. I think we all knew it was a dangerous business, so it
was unreasonable to expect that we wouldn't have a problem, but I don't
think any of us expected to have a problem on the ground. The review board concluded
that NASA had failed to properly oversee the work of North American aviation and
that this was a reflection of a broader problem. NASA had done a poor job of
coordinating the huge number of contractors working on Project Apollo
and of integrating all the different systems they were designing. And Jim Webb,
who was the NASA administrator, made a phone call to the chief executive
officer of Boeing and said, we need help. We need help with systems integration. We
just need more people who are experienced systems analysts. And Boeing
had that capability. For the past eight years, much of it working in secret, Boeing
had been the main contractor for the Minuteman missile system. It had
overseen the work of numerous other contractors and the production of nearly
2,000 missiles ready to be launched at a moment's notice. Their technique grew out
of the Air Force ballistic missile program. Boeing, they're very, very good at
making parts fit together and work together in concert. And if you can do
that, you can gain control of very large technological systems. In 1967, soon
after the Apollo 1 fire, NASA and Boeing initiated a program called Apollo
Technical Integration and Evaluation, or Apollo-TIE. The Apollo-TIE program was
designed to get the various parts and pieces coming from different suppliers
all to work together. It is a classic piece of large-scale integration. Boeing's
responsibility would be to coordinate the work of the Apollo contractors. The
company assigned some 2,000 people to the task. You have one subsystem, another
subsystem, you put them together, you want to make sure that they work according
to expectations. Learning how to do that was the greatest organizational
challenge that the United States faced with respect to Project Apollo. NASA
resumed work on manned missions in April 1968, more than a year after the Apollo
1 fire. NASA and Boeing, in an advisory role, helped us go through every system
and make sure it was as reliable as it could possibly be done. Things changed
dramatically. With the new management, I had enormous confidence. People make a
difference. Managers make a difference. But Project Apollo now had just 14
months to fulfill the late President Kennedy's pledge to put men on the moon
by the end of the decade. Nearly 50 years since the end of the space race, many
have forgotten that the first manned mission to the moon was Apollo 8. NASA
scheduled Apollo 8 to fly in early 1969. The original mission was to have three
astronauts orbit the earth for 10 days. It would be commanded by Frank Borman.
But the mission changed. The Central Intelligence Agency told NASA that the
Russians were about to go to the moon. That was a forcing function, there's no
question about it. I was told that we were going to try to do it in December
because we wanted to beat the Russians. And I said, that's fine with me,
let's do it. George Miller sent out a letter to all of us contractor people
that were involved in the Apollo program saying, what do you think about going to
the moon with Apollo 8? Is it ready? Are we reliable enough to do it? And boy, I
spent a lot of hard thinking about that issue. We got all my top guys together, we
really worked hard on whether we were ready to go, looked at all the data,
decided yes, we were ready to go. The six-day mission with its crew of Borman,
Jim Lovell, and Bill Anders, atop a Saturn V rocket, was scheduled to lift
off just days before Christmas in 1968. The mission was to circumnavigate the
moon. In other words, go to the moon, go into orbit around the moon, and then fire
the service module to come home. Pretty special mission, a lot of things had to
work right. We, of course, held our breath. And we were going a long way into space,
so we had to make it right. And that's what that two years after the fire was
all about. I never really sat down and tried to calculate the odds of getting
back. I know Bill Anders said he thought that maybe a 30% chance we wouldn't get
back. I don't know. I was convinced I was coming back or I wouldn't have gone.
Wernher von Braun's massive rocket, the most complex machine ever built, had
never been launched with people on board. Apollo 8 was a really bold decision on
the part of NASA. The fundamental decision was made to send human crew to
the moon on the Saturn V. No American or Russian had traveled further than 850
miles from the earth. The crew of Apollo 8 would be attempting a journey of nearly
a quarter of a million miles. The Saturn V was an enormous vehicle. I remember
getting out of the elevator and walking over the catwalk into the spacecraft. It
was awe-inspiring just to look down and see how high up you were before it ever
started. An estimated 200,000 people converged on the Space Center to witness
the launch. This is Apollo Saturn launch control. We are still go at this time.
T minus 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, 9. We have ignition sequence start. The engines are
1, 4, 3, 2, 1, zero. Hung there, you'd say, is it really going? And it was very slow and
very majestic in lifting off the launch pad. It was just a remarkable experience.
A machine of that size, of that scope, working perfectly. Unbelievable. The noise
was overwhelming and a lot of vibration back and forth, but the second stage
smoothed out. As soon as you got past the speed of sound, it became quite a
pleasant ride. After a three-day journey, Apollo 8 entered lunar orbit on
Christmas Eve. From their spacecraft, Borman, Lovell and Anders saw something
no one had ever seen before. Planet Earth alone in the vastness of space.
Oh my God, look at that picture over there. Wow, that's pretty. You got a color film, Jim?
Hand me a roll of color, quick. Oh man, that's great. Where is it? Quick.
Grab me a color. A color exterior.
As they orbited the moon, the astronauts read the first ten verses of the Book of Genesis.
Hundreds of millions of people around the world watched or listened to the broadcast.
In the beginning, God created the heaven and the earth.
The Word of God moved upon the face of the water.
You think of 1968, the political assassinations of Martin Luther King, of
Robert Kennedy, urban riots in the United States, the endless conflict in Vietnam.
To have the year ended on this kind of magic moment, certainly in the United States,
put a very positive end to what had been a horrible year.
And from the crew of Apollo 8, we close with good...
I remember we got all kinds of telegrams after the flight.
And the one that impressed me the most was,
Thank you, Apollo 8. You saved 1968.
On July 20th, 1969, Apollo 11 landed two American astronauts,
Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin, on the surface of the moon.
The United States had beaten the Soviet Union in the space race.
The moon landing was a singular achievement for both America and for humanity at large.
But for NASA, the question became, where do we go from here?
It was more than a decade before NASA would again capture the public's imagination
with the launch of the first space shuttle in 1981.
The shuttle was the first reusable spacecraft.
Launched as a rocket, the winged vehicle glided back to Earth.
Starting in 1998, the space shuttle began the mission it was designed for,
facilitating the construction of the International Space Station, or the ISS.
The shuttle made 37 trips over more than a decade,
hauling components, cargo and crew to the ISS.
This is Mission Control Houston. As you can see, we're seeing live video from the International Space Station.
There is Commander Chris Ferguson greeting Commander Andrei Borisenko.
The primary builders of the ISS were Russia and the United States,
no longer competitors but collaborators in space.
The space station is made up of more than 30 major components,
from laboratories to habitation modules to solar arrays, all joined together in space.
It is one of the great engineering achievements of all time.
And Boeing was the systems integrator.
Boeing made sure that when you plugged in the Russian modules with the U.S. modules
and the nodes in between, that they didn't catch fire,
or that they didn't start to send errant signals to each other.
The ISS is where astronauts are learning how to survive for prolonged periods in space.
What is learned here will make possible the trip to our next destination in the solar system, Mars.
A journey to Mars will be a round trip of at least 70 million miles,
and could take longer than two years.
A mission so long and so ambitious that its challenges would dwarf those of Apollo.
On the most basic level, the human body is not designed to survive for long periods in a microgravity environment.
We have bone loss, which we can now control.
We have muscle wasting, which we can kind of control.
The immune system gets degraded in space.
So we see the human system react to the microgravity environment.
We want to use Space Station to make sure that there's not a problem
when we're going distances as far as Mars for two or three years,
that the human body will not have any detrimental effects from the journey.
A voyage to Mars will require a rocket even more powerful than the Saturn V that took men to the moon.
NASA has contracted with Boeing and other companies to build the Space Launch System, or SLS.
I wish it could be publicized more, because even when I talk to my friends and I tell them,
hey, I'm working SLS, they're like, are you working on the Mercedes-Benz?
Like, what is a SLS? Like, what is that?
And I have to tell them it's a Space Launch System.
And they ask me, can you talk about it?
And I'm like, you can Google Space Launch System. NASA has a whole website on it.
But getting to Mars will require much more than a massive rocket.
You're going to need a habitat while the crew is traveling to Mars.
You're going to need a Mars lander to land on Mars.
You're going to need a Mars ascent vehicle to get off of Mars.
And then you're going to need a way to get back home.
So I would call it the most challenging mission in history.
Whether people today have the will to take on the risks and the hardships of going to Mars,
as well as its massive costs, is an open question.
There's many activities we can spend our resources on, but why is space important?
And we really are toying with the big questions.
Are we alone? Why are we here?
Is our planet unique?
Those are big questions.
And I think as a species, it's ingrained in us to try to answer those questions.
We'll go to Mars someday with man.
It's going to happen.
I think man's DNA is built on exploration and he has to do it.
So I think he'll eventually go.
But 50 years after reaching the moon,
space exploration is no longer driven by a global power struggle.
If it hadn't been for the Russians, do you think we'd have gotten to the moon in the 60s?
No way.
Competition is an extremely important part of any human endeavor.
And it's probably because I'm an old guy now, but I don't believe it could happen today.
How and when humans will set foot on the red planet is unknown.
But one fact is clear.
In the same way that Project Apollo came to define the 20th century as the age of aerospace,
a journey to Mars will almost certainly be the defining moment of the 21st century.
