What message is China sending with its recent deployment of thousands of fishing boats to the East China Sea, and how could that play into a Taiwan contingency and a U.S. response? Joining us to unpack all of this is retired Marine Colonel Grant Newsham. He is a senior fellow at the Center for Security Policy and the author of When China Attacks.
What message is China sending with its recent deployment of thousands of fishing boats to
the East China Sea? How could that play into a Taiwan contingency and a U.S. response? Joining
us to unpack all of this is retired Marine Colonel Grant Newsham. He's a senior fellow
at the Center for Security Policy and author of When China Attacks. Grant Newsham, thank you so
much for joining us. Great to have you back on the show. I'm always glad to be here. Now, China has
deployed thousands of fishing boats recently, forming floating barriers that stretch about 200
miles long in the East China Sea. First, how are you reading this? What could China be practicing
for here? Well, they're practicing using their fishing fleet as a barrier, an obstacle for
anyone who might try to get in and help Taiwan. They're also sending a message to the Japanese,
as they've done before, actually, in 2014, 2016, saying that anytime we want, we can flood your
territory with our fishing boats, say the Senkaku Islands, parts of the Ryukyus, the Okawasara
Islands south of Japan, and there's nothing you can do about it. And they're sending a message.
But what they have done is demonstrated an even higher degree of ability to weaponize their
fishing fleet to command and control it, put it where they want it. And this does cause a lot of
problems for the United States Navy. You might think a fishing boat versus a US Navy destroyer
isn't much of a match. But when there's a couple thousand fishing boats out there, it makes life
more challenging. Plus, there's a real usefulness for anti-submarine warfare. It makes it harder
for submarines to operate in the region when you've got a lot of Chinese fishing boats out.
And particularly when the Chinese put certain sensors and other hardware on them.
I want to get to the US part. But first, this scale this time seems kind of unprecedented.
I know in the past, there's been hundreds, but maybe not thousands like we saw here.
What do you see in terms of the timing of this? Why now?
Well, it's just part of the larger intensification on the part of the Japanese,
excuse me, of the Chinese to use every resource they've got from their Navy to their Coast Guard
now to their maritime militia, the fishing fleet, put it all together, make it so that you can
operate it in a coherent fashion and apply pressure. In this case, it's largely Taiwan,
which is the main target. But the Chinese are obviously looking farther afield. We've seen them
operating similarly against the Philippines in recent years. And the Japanese, as I mentioned,
are very much in the Chinese crosshairs. But the Chinese are indeed thinking very closely about how
you prevent, say, an outside military, and they use the word external force, but they mean the
Americans, how you keep the Americans from getting in close to Taiwan. Having your fishing fleet
weaponized like this is one sort of one aspect of the strategy that the Chinese will employ.
I want to dig into that potential gray zone warfare area that we're seeing there. Because
in terms of, say, a Taiwan contingency, if the U.S. is trying to come in, you're talking about
how this is already going to embroil that. But there are some raising the concern that this
would become a moral dilemma for the U.S., striking, say, civilian boats. How do you see
that aspect playing out? Well, it's as moral a dilemma as you want it to be.
The Chinese are clearly not just skirting the edge of the law, they've gone well over it. And
they're using this as a tool of their military that renders it a lawful target. And the Americans,
however, other Westerners tend to tie themselves in knots when presented with this situation
and say, oh, there's nothing we can do. Someday we need to wake up and say,
we're not going to hold back. And that's always been one of the solutions to this,
is to tell the Chinese, we look at this the same way we do the People's Liberation Army Navy.
And we will defend ourselves. Now, it wasn't just these fishing boats. We also saw China
flew a drone directly into Taiwan's airspace for the first time recently.
What is China signaling with that move? Well, as I said, it's this intensification
of move and pressure against Taiwan. And to see what the Taiwanese reaction is,
see what the Western, the American reaction is to it all. Also, you're wearing down your opponent
at the same time. And they're just getting so used to this gradually turning up the heat
that you don't realize just how dangerous the situation is and how extreme the threat is.
One thing I would like to go back, and when you talk about the fishing fleet,
there's also a maritime militia, which has worked in with the fishing fleet. And these are
parts of the People's Liberation Army Armed Forces. And they are sort of double-hulled,
stronger, more powerful engines. They're armed, often have surveillance equipment on them.
And they function as sort of the muscle of the fishing fleet. So that's in there,
mixed in there. And that makes it even more of a lawful target. But this is, once again,
Chinese very comprehensive strategy that they've got to use every tool of their resources to
overwhelm and just sort of overpower the opponents.
Well, Grant Newsham, as always, thank you so much for joining us.
Well, glad to be here. Thanks for having me.