Swivel Pipe or Level Sill Spillway- Which Should You Use for a Swale

FFG - Food Forest Garden
176 followers
13 Video Views·Mar 15, 2026
When designing a swale, choosing the right overflow system can make the difference between a resilient water-harvesting earthwork and a damaged one.
In this Q&A, Geoff explains the difference between a swivel pipe and a level sill spillway. Learn when each option makes sense, how they handle water flow, and the simple maintenance needed to keep your swales functioning during heavy rains.
When is a swivel pipe more appropriate
than a level-sill spillway, and vice versa?
What circumstances do you consider
which sway your decision, one way or the other?
Is there any special maintenance required for either,
or is upkeep pretty easy?
Well, you can always put a level-sill spillway in.
There's one just behind me I'll show you in a minute.
If you think there's an excessive catchment flow,
so you wouldn't use just a swivel pipe
unless you are pretty sure that you have a very small flow
because that volume there of that pipe,
when you swivel it down or you take it off,
that's all you've got.
You know, that's a very small constricted pipe.
And if you haven't got a spillway
to take the big charge of water,
there's a good chance it's going to go down
the outside of this pipe
and blow out the swale at this point
because once water finds it hasn't got an exit point
and there's a hard surface on the outside of the pipe,
it'll go past it.
Now, that's not a great drama on a swale
because it's not like a dam coming down.
The swale mound is uncompacted, it's easy to repair,
and almost any material will repair it.
So I would only use simply a swivel pipe
if I was sure we had a very, very small amount of catchment.
Now, I'd have to question
why you're putting a swale in there as well then,
but it might happen.
So really swivel pipes are an afterthought to swales
because the spillway sets the height in the swale.
We can move the swivel pipe down below the height
of the level sill spillway,
even down to the base of the swale just about,
and empty the swale.
It allows you to change the height of the water in the swale
if you want to drop it lower.
It doesn't gain you any height.
It just gives you the ability to drop lower if you want to.
So in some ways,
the swivel pipe is a flood mitigation system.
When installed well,
there is no maintenance on the swivel pipe.
I mean, I doubt that that's going to wear out
that sort of unglued fitting.
It's just simply a fitting that hasn't been glued in.
There's no pressure on it,
but there's a very low pressure of water.
But if we go over here,
behind me is a level sill,
and this level sill is one of three level sills
on this particular swale.
This is a very long swale,
goes right around our campsite,
starts off at Paradise Dam,
goes through Mafia Dam,
and through Camper's Lagoon,
and right out the other side.
There are actually four swivel pipes on it,
and three spillways.
One's an emergency spillway,
and it's about that much higher
than this particular level sill.
So one's set a bit higher for an emergency flow,
and the swivel pipes can help drain it off
if we get very large flows.
Now there is some maintenance on level sills
because they need to be weed-free,
so they don't choke.
So you don't want lots and lots of weeds
on your level sill spillway.
Now here, this one happens to have been fitted up
after this dam behind me was put in,
because it was all swale once,
and this level sill was in function
a bit further over where the dam is,
so we reconstructed here.
We have a bamboo on the downhill side,
and a mulberry,
and they're more or less keeping it weed-free,
so we've almost, by accident,
made it a maintenance-free level sill.
Perfectly level, the dam wall's there,
the swale goes on for nearly half a mile or so,
500 meters plus.
And we've only got a little bit here
of pinto peanut growing,
which is a perennial ground cover legume.
They're one or two arrowroot that might come up,
so we would, if there's any weed growth
that might choke the flow,
we'll maintain it by cleaning this off,
cutting the weeds or cutting the grasses,
and keeping it nice and low,
particularly when we know rainy season's coming
and we're likely to get some big,
solid rains in quick bursts.
And that's it, there isn't anything else to it.
I really almost always install a level sill
just to make sure that we can discharge
very large volumes,
especially with climate varying so much,
more than it has before, it seems,
in living memory.
Normally, we'd only get half an inch of water across this,
an inch would be a massive flow,
but it could take five or six inches,
which would be enormous,
it would be absolutely massive.
There's no way the swivel pipe will handle that.
It's only this little section
in this big, long length of swale,
level sill spillway.
Level sill spillways are a security for a swale.
