Should this missing tiki cocktail have stayed lost-

The World of Wine
6 followers
Apr 25, 2026
The Poco Coco Loco is a lost Trader Vic drink that I did not like. Found in a couple of newspapers in the early 1960s, this one jumped out because of the use of coconut water. While coconut water is abundant today, it wasn't in the 1960s and would have been extremely rare to find in the United States. But the rarity of coconut water is not the issue here; instead, it's the fact that this drink just didnt taste very good.
What you see before you is another unknown Trader Vic cocktail, the Poco Coco Loco.
Now, while Trader Vic had many books that featured many of his own creations,
there are occasions where we might stumble across some additional drinks in newspapers
and magazines that only existed there and were not ever in any of his many books.
The Poco Loco Coco is one of these drinks, and what might be the most unusual part of it is
it calls for coconut water. This is back from 1961, when you could not simply go to the grocery
store and buy coconut water. You would need to have a fresh coconut on hand that you could crack
open to get that coconut water, which is one of the main reasons that we pretty much never see
drinks with coconut water coming out of this era of tiki, where drinks are generally created in
California. This recipe appears to have been syndicated, but I only saw it in a couple of
places. The Twin City Sentinel in North Carolina, and the Miami News.
The Trader Vic's book of rum cookery and drinkery did have a drink called the
Coco Loco, which was light rum, Coco Lopez, and pineapple with some lemon juice, so a
pina colada with lemon. But the Poco Loco Coco not only contains coconut water, but it contains
Benedictine, which is very unusual. We do need a gold Puerto Rican rum,
and I'm using Bacardi 8, and then we need a Puerto Rican 151 rum. And yeah, I know
Guyana and Puerto Rico are not the same thing, and that a Demerara rum is not the same as Puerto
Rican, and I do have a bottle of Don Q 151 deep in the shelf somewhere, but we only live once,
and I know that will just be bad, and I just don't want to. Every time there's a cocktail
ingredient that I do not want to use, I just say it to myself in that Jerry Seinfeld voice.
I don't want to be a cowboy. So let's make another lost to time Trader Vic cocktail,
the Poco Coco Loco. I'm using a drink mixer, but you can always shake this one. I'm going
to start with two ounces of coconut water, a quarter ounce of cream of coconut,
one ounce of lime juice,
a quarter ounce of Benedictine,
one and a quarter ounces of a gold Puerto Rican rum,
and half an ounce of a 151 rum.
I'm going to garnish with some pineapple fronds and a lime wheel. So there you go,
the Poco Coco Loco, and yes, I have probably said that wrong at least multiple times here,
but as long as you get the Poco and the Coco and the Loco in some order, that's okay by me.
This was a challenging drink to research because if you look at the name of the drink,
Un Poco Loco is a song from Coco. So when you search for Poco Loco Coco, all you're going to
But that is not this. It has no connection to this. They didn't take that name from this either,
but let us try the Poco Loco Coco, a lost Trader Vic cocktail. Cheers.
It is like so much Trader Vic. It is too tart. It's that overwhelming lime juice
and overwhelming coconut water. We need more Coco Lopez here. So the Benedictine,
a quarter ounce of it. It's a very sweet herbal liqueur. I would probably,
maybe I'll do this in a moment, add some more cream of coconut and add some more Benedictine
because it just feels too diluted from the coconut water and the lime juice. It just feels,
it doesn't feel refreshing. It doesn't feel too creamy, just lacking. I did another quarter
ounce of Benedictine and half an ounce of cream of coconut. This probably could use a full ounce
of cream of coconut. It tastes better, but it's just unusual. It's just like the coconut water
with the lime juice and Benedictine, and it's not bad. It's just, I mean, maybe it was retired
or not printed in books for a reason. Maybe it's for this reason, because that recipe
that I shared doesn't work. Even had we used a Puerto Rican one, it wouldn't have worked.
It's just, it's, it's missing, it's missing balance. It's missing depth and complexity
and it's missing sweetness. Like if you want a sweet cocktail, like it's just,
it's not anywhere. It's just like a, a diluted muddy mess. So they're not all going to be
winners here, but you know, I'll take one for the team every now and then. If you're interested in
other Trader Vic cocktails that have been lost the time, then at the end of this video, I will
give a link to the Pacifica Punch, which I just shared recently, which is a large format punch
recipe. I recalculated, rejiggered into a manageable single serving cocktail. That one is
good. This one, it's, it's, if you do this, if you add more cream of coconut and you had more
Benedictine, it's not going to be a bad drink. It's just, you would probably enjoy the pina colada,
a painkiller or many of the other creamy coconut cocktails more than this one.
So the fact it didn't end up in the bartender's guide, didn't end up in a, you know,
Trader Vic's menu nowadays, it makes a lot of sense to me now having tried this. If you enjoyed
this video, please give it a like below, consider subscribing to the channel. And if you want to
this channel more, check out my Patreon page. Otherwise, see you in the next one.
