Master of Wine and Expert Somm go Head to Head Blind Tasting Wine in Napaa

Wine World
13 followers
#wine #winetasting #drink #cocktail
Welcome to Blind Tasting sessions from SOMM TV. The original show about the greatest minds in food and wine, blind tasting wines against each other. In today’s episode, Master of Wine Vanessa Conlin and expert sommelier Amanda McCrossin go head to head. Who can get the wines right on today's episode of Blind Tasting Sessions from SOMM TV?
I am blind tasting with Vanessa Conlin.
She is the head of wine for Wine Access.
She is a master of wine candidate
who is in the final review process,
or final review stage,
and has already passed her exam
and is just waiting to hear about the research paper.
And what else?
Oh, she was a former opera singer.
So she's got an arts background, which is really cool.
And just a really fun person
who I enjoy tasting wine and hanging out with.
So I'm blind tasting today with Amanda McCrossin.
She is the wine director for a restaurant called Press
here in Napa Valley.
She's an amazing ambassador for the wine industry.
She's incredibly knowledgeable,
but incredibly humble as well,
and just has really a knack for presenting things
in a way that's very educational, but very accessible.
I mean, I think what she's done at Press is amazing.
They have probably the deepest list of old Napa Cab
of anybody, anywhere.
And she blows my mind.
I mean, I've tasted, you know,
a skosh of the older Napa Cab that she has.
So I love tasting with her because I always learn a lot.
So it's gonna be fun.
For the white,
I picked one of my favorite California Chardonnays.
It's got a great story
and something that I kind of fell in love with
upon first tasting.
This is the Edge Hill Chardonnay
from Bocce Gallupi Vineyard in Russian River Valley.
It's 2012.
And the really cool story about this
is this particular wine sources the grapes
from the vines that are the oldest vines
in the Bocce Gallupi Vineyard,
which are also the same as what was used
in the Chateau Montelena for the Judgment of Paris.
So a lot of history there.
Really, really beautiful wine that I think
is gonna show more Burgundian than Californian.
That said, it definitely has a ripeness to it,
but I think I've blind tasted a few people on this wine
and I think mostly across the board,
they've all blinded Burgundy.
So we shall see.
Yes.
This knows.
There's definitely some like richness and opulence,
but it is flinty and it is bright and it's like lemon.
She's a pretty good blind taster for Chardonnay.
So we'll see how she fares.
Okay, the red.
I'm so excited.
Wine nerd moment for sure.
This is a 1977 Joseph Phelps Isley Vineyard.
This is a fairly prolific wine in my career.
The 1978 was the wine that I served
to one of my favorite guests at the restaurant.
I still remember the night, I remember the table,
I remember what we were doing, why we picked it,
and it was the first time I had tried it
and it blew my mind.
And it was the first time I recognized Isley Vineyard
for my own palate as truly being
an incredible Grand Cru vineyard of California.
These particular wines come from a single vineyard
in Calistoga, the vine, the vineyard itself
has been in production since the 1800s,
but the vines are about 15 years old in this bottle here.
They're planted in the early 60s.
Look at it, oh cool.
Oh, can I, yes, **** yes, sorry, my mom's gonna kill me.
Oh, **** yes, that is so unbelievably aromatic, wow.
As much as it's giving you, it's also like you
kind of like leaning into it,
which is a really, really cool wine to me.
Wow, that is so dense and rich.
Incredibly soft, fine tannins.
The 78 shows a little bit more of that perfume,
but this shows an intensity and a depth and a finish.
Wow, this is gonna be really cool.
Are you ready?
I am ready.
Yes.
As I will ever be.
We're just gonna taste wine, it's gonna be fun.
Okay, all right, so any words of wisdom
before we start or just?
I mean, you've already passed the hardest tasting exam
there is anyways, so this is a walk in the park.
Let's go with that.
I feel it.
Okay, all righty.
Just you and me, we're just gonna taste some wine.
Okay, no, this is fun, I love it.
I can confirm that they are in fact wines.
Okay, perfect.
So we'll start there.
Sounds good.
And I think you can take it from there
to differentiate between the two colors.
So we'll start with the, what appears to be white wine.
What appears to be the white wine, okay.
No, this is fun, I love wine tasting, it's like a puzzle.
So, all right, well, and so kind of the first thing
I noticed about this is, well, I mean,
I looked at the color, it's slightly golden.
So I would think like maybe it has a little bit of age on it
or possibly some time in barrel.
But then on the nose, it seems to be like fairly,
I would say like semi-neutral where I'm getting more
sort of like winemaking, secondary and tertiary
over like super primary.
I do get like some apple, some citrus,
some like kind of Meyer lemon peel,
but I'm definitely getting like that toasty oak character
and some of that sort of sweet spice,
like clove, nutmeg, vanilla.
I mean, the one variety that I feel like takes
on winemaking this elegantly,
but expressively would be Chardonnay is my initial thought,
but I haven't tasted it yet, so.
To me, blind tasting, in addition to like maybe going
through whatever your version of the grid is,
is also like about the feeling and the experience.
And I mean, there's no panel in front of us
that we can just kind of like walk our way through this.
I love it.
Do you like it?
I do.
Do you like the wine?
I would drink the, mm, out of that.
Yes, it's delicious.
Oh, I dropped the F bomb earlier,
so you can continue with that if you like.
What is this rated?
No, it's delicious.
So I think I'm sticking with my initial thought,
which is this like, to me, this like speaks of Chardonnay.
So if I was tasting this on the exam or just for funsies,
I would try to sort of consider all the places
it could be from and then try to sort of knock them out
one by one.
So start with like a large, sort of a large funnel
and then get smaller and smaller.
So try to like bring the world a step closer
or smaller with each step.
So, I mean, starting broadly, I mean, it could be,
obviously it could be California, could be Oregon,
could be obviously Burgundy.
You could think about, you know, Australia, New Zealand,
Chile, South Africa even.
But I'd say like, for me, there's a textural component
to Chilean wines.
And again, these are my personal markers,
but there's like a slickness of texture
that I'm not getting on this.
It has a good amount of richness to it,
but also like really refreshing acidity.
So, I mean, it could be Margaret River,
but I don't know, there's something about the like,
this, the core of this wine that to me
doesn't speak to Australia.
Again, there's sort of like a textural difference to it
that isn't speaking to me of Australia.
And you and I have been drinking.
A lot of Australia.
Yeah, yeah, there's sort of like a more,
what I find like in high quality, you know,
Australian, of which there is a lot.
Yes.
As we're learning every day.
But there's sort of more like a linear mouthfeel
than on this, where I'm getting, again,
that sort of like rounder mid-palate core.
So, and then I'm gonna knock New Zealand out,
I think because I always get like a juicier acid profile.
To New Zealand.
Like a bouncier fruit, like a.
Yeah, there's like, with New Zealand,
I usually get like a, and again,
I'm speaking very broadly, like it's obviously,
there's a lot of regions within the country,
but like this, like super pure fruit,
almost like squeaky clean fruit character.
And then this, yeah, just like really zingy acidity.
And this has really refreshing acidity,
but it seems more like mouthwatering and round.
So, let me do this again.
You did mention Burgundy,
so what would take you in or out of Burgundy?
Well, the quality is high, first of all.
Yeah.
I mean, there's something to like,
I mean, obviously we can talk about like minerality
of the old world, but I mean,
I feel like sometimes that's not a fair comparison
because I definitely get minerality
on New World wines as well.
But sort of like with Burgundy,
I get more of like a savory,
I almost think of it as like a,
sort of like a dried flower note to it
over sort of like fresher blooming flowers.
And I haven't quite narrowed this down yet,
so I'm gonna taste it again.
What are you?
I'm kind of torn between like a riper vintage Burgundy
or like a Burgundy and lookalike.
Because again, it has that acid,
but there's something about the texture,
again, that like, there's a stuffing.
Again, this is just like my terminology,
but there's something like when I taste Chardonnay
from California, huge generalization, right?
But there's like this stuffing to the core.
Oh, I like that.
That I find in, when I taste Burgundy,
even from a ripier, there's like a lacier sort of texture.
I don't know, it just like sits on my palate differently.
So again, I'm kind of torn,
because it's very like,
it's really beautifully made, it's high quality.
I feel like it could be, I feel like it could be either.
But you have to pick one.
But I have to pick, okay.
So I think then, there's a bit of,
even in a riper vintage for Burgundy,
I still get that sort of like restraint,
for lack of a better word.
And this has a little bit more of like
a forward fruit character to it,
which would take me to California.
So then I'd be considering different regions within,
is it Sonoma, is it Napa?
Again, like it's just my personal marker,
but there's something about like,
the core of this fruit has that really like dense,
sort of beautiful Napa ripeness,
but then still some acidity.
So I would probably consider,
Sonoma Coast, Russian River, Carneros.
I think it's a little bit too ripe for Carneros.
So let's say, let's say Napa.
Ooh, all right.
Okay.
Sorry, I didn't mean to make that face.
Either that was like good or like really bad.
I thought for sure you were gonna like stick in Sonoma,
cause you were like either Russian River or Carneros,
and then you're like Napa.
There's something about the, again,
like the sort of richness,
where as I get sometimes a little bit more acidity,
especially on the coast, like a different texture,
but there's like a really like beautiful lushness to this,
that makes me think further inland.
Okay, so Chardonnay, Napa Valley.
Yes.
Vintage.
It's still really fresh,
but it definitely has a little bit of
tertiary notes coming in.
I'd say, I don't know specific vintage,
but maybe within like five to seven years of age.
Cause it's still like, it's still like,
it has that beautiful like freshness and purity to it.
But you know what I mean?
It's starting to take on a little bit more of those like.
Yeah.
And sometimes it's harder for me to differentiate
between where age is the primary factor
versus maybe something like oak treatment.
Yeah, yeah.
So give me a vintage and you're sticking with.
What did I say?
Five to seven years?
Five to seven years.
Okay.
Sorry.
It's okay.
You can have coffee, you're fine.
I'm a wine person, I'm not an alcoholic.
Okay.
I think it's like 2013-ish.
Okay.
Yeah.
All right.
2013 Napa Valley Chardonnay.
Yes.
Great.
I'm not telling you yet.
Okay.
We're going to the red.
Okay.
So we'll table the white.
Okay.
And move to the red.
And I will say I'm actually selfishly very excited
to try this, but I'm also really excited for you
to try this as well.
And I'm very curious to hear what you think about this wine.
Okay.
Yeah.
Well, I'm intrigued already.
This has a lot of tertiary notes on it.
And color tells me it's more mature.
It's starting to get more sort of faded
from ruby more to amber.
And just have some like bricking at the rim.
It's like really fascinating.
This nose like crushes me in so many ways.
I get pyrazines.
So I'm thinking a Bordeaux variety or varieties.
So where are you from, mister?
It's a boy.
I guess it could, it does seem kind of masculine
to be honest, but that's not very PC.
Well, I actually think that's like a,
for me, those are markers, right?
When I say masculine, feminine in a very broad sense,
those are markers for me.
It's like super, it's both has this like beautiful
sort of like forest floor, like sort of mossy,
like tree bark, like older tertiary,
like church basement kind of notes to it.
But then there's like a very vibrant,
like black fruit, black cherry,
black currant note to it as well.
Bingo.
So you just got my seal of approval.
Ah, okay.
You're doing great.
All right, let's taste it.
Like really fresh acid, definitely more mature,
but does have that like, that black fruit note to it.
So the fruit hasn't faded.
Like it still seems like it has a lot of life.
I guess I'd be thinking older Bordeaux or older Napa.
Because you're in?
Because I'm in, I'm definitely in like a Bordeaux camp,
Bordeaux variety or varieties.
Okay.
Okay, so I should figure out what this is.
So, I mean, I could funnel within regions in Bordeaux,
but there's something about like,
there's a bit of a sweeter fruit core to this
that would take me to the new world.
Okay.
Again, like not sweet,
but like there's a sort of a riper element to it.
Again, like super high quality.
I wouldn't like drink the ---- out of this, but.
Are you in a particular vintage, decade, how much age?
I feel like this is like at least like 1980s, maybe.
How much, and I don't know this about you,
how much older Bordeaux versus older California have you had?
Like, what is the ratio?
I'm sure you've had way more
because of your amazing list than I have.
So like, I definitely, when I was sitting the exam,
it tasted a lot of different vintages side by side for that.
But then, you know, for the exam,
it has to be a wine that you can still find commercially.
So realistically, throwing something on from like,
you know, the early seventies or something
is not going to make it on the exam.
So I did taste a lot of vintages,
but definitely I have not had as much experience with you
with like older Napa.
Okay.
And are you for sure in Cabernet land?
I am for sure in Cabernet land.
I think it's got that, the acidity, you know, to it.
With Merlot, if it was like a Bordeaux blend
with some Merlot in it, I definitely would,
I get sort of a broader, like a breadth of palette
with Merlot.
I mean, I guess there could be a sprinkle in here,
but I'm definitely getting like Cab dominant.
And again, that like, that just sort of like
really firm tannic backbone
and all that like great like blackcurrant fruit.
So I am in Cab, Cab dominant for sure.
So I'm not going to say I can differentiate
the latter vintages of the seventies.
Let's get it into a five-year bracket.
Okay.
So like...
Well, then I would go like later,
if it's seventies, because it's so, it's so really,
it's just, there's like,
there's a really fresh youthfulness about it.
I hear ya.
That like, I mean, honestly, like,
that's even surprising to me.
Not that we don't taste beautiful wines, you know,
but this is like, this is an outstanding wine.
It's really, really holding up.
And we've, I've tasted much younger wines
that are not doing as well as this wine is.
Yeah.
So give me one final conclusion and then I'll tell you.
Okay.
Let's go.
I want the whole like, I want variety.
I want...
Okay.
I'm going Cabernet Sauvignon.
I'm going Napa Valley.
Okay.
I'm going to go with sort of your guidance,
late seventies.
Again, I can't differentiate, so I'm throwing a dart,
but let's just say like 1979.
Okay.
Final conclusion.
Okay.
Final conclusion.
All right.
How do you think you did?
I have no idea.
I feel like we might be in Bordeaux actually, but...
It's too late.
You're here now.
No, but it did have that like, that like,
riper fruit core that I get from New World over Bordeaux.
But yeah, it's just, it's a really beautiful wine.
I kind of can't wait to hear what it is.
I was going to say, I was like, are you ready?
All right.
Well, we'll start with the white.
And I think you'd, I mean,
you did brilliantly with both of these wines.
Okay.
No one is surprised because you're a brilliant taster.
But I think they're probably two wines
that you've not had before,
which is also why I chose them.
And I selfishly chose them
because I love both of these wines.
Okay.
So the Chardonnay, it was a Chardonnay.
Okay.
I felt pretty good about that.
Yes.
So the Chardonnay is a 2012 Edge Hill,
Bocce Gallupi, Russian River Chardonnay.
So have you had this?
No.
Okay, cool.
So can I tell you about it?
Please.
So this is, shoot, I considered Russian River,
but I didn't.
Well, I mean, truthfully,
this is like a slightly unfair wine in some ways,
because this is very, very old vines.
This Edge Hill had the long lease on the oldest vines
of the Bocce Gallupi Vineyard in Russian River,
which were the same vines used
in the Chateau Montelina Chardonnay
for the Judgement of Paris.
Okay.
So it makes this one extra, extra special.
I think this wine in its youth
has an incredible flintiness and reductiveness
that as it ages, it sort of starts to take on,
it starts to dissipate a little bit.
But to me, there has always been a certain,
and I hate to say this,
but like a certain Burgundian-esque quality to it.
That's why I was kind of wavering between the two.
Exactly.
I think that was a really fair assessment.
I think to your point,
the stuffing of this wine is there,
and there is a ripeness.
And I think having tasted producers like Kongsgaard
that make very, very high quality Chardonnays
from the Napa Valley,
I think that was a really fair assessment as well.
And especially if you're tasting something
like Judge Vineyard,
which is a little bit older vine on some rocky soils.
So again, I think that was a fair call for you.
Okay.
And you did really well.
And it's delicious.
It's really good, right?
Yes, okay.
This one, I'm like.
I know, this one, okay.
So this one was like a,
I didn't think that I would get this wine.
And I had reached out to Antoine at Isley
and said, I'd really love to blind you on Isley.
Oh, okay.
So it's 1977.
So well done.
It was 70s, okay.
Joseph Phelps, Isley Vineyard.
Wow.
Yeah.
Have you ever had this?
No.
Ah, I love that.
It's awesome.
No, no, I haven't.
So again, another selfish pick.
Hey, it's not selfish.
I got to taste this.
Yeah.
I guess I'm on the hot seat next, right?
You are in the hot seat.
I'm really excited to see what you brought.
No tricks.
Just really, really wines that I'm excited to share with you.
We're just going to drink wine.
No, we're just going to drink wine.
Yeah, cool.
Okay.
So, because Amanda's list is predominantly Napa
or all Napa, I thought we'd taste some old world stuff
just to keep her on her toes.
So I didn't choose anything that would, you know, trick her.
I think these are pretty classic representations
of the variety in the region,
but I chose a 2017 Gigalle Conjure La Dorian.
So this is Viognier,
and I was at the property earlier this year
and I tasted this in the cellar.
It blew me away.
I think that if she were to confuse it with anything,
maybe Chardonnay.
It does see a hundred percent new French oak,
which is sort of unusual for Conjure,
but Gigalle, they have their own cooperage.
And so they're able to really control the toast levels,
but that might throw her,
but I do think it's pretty classic.
So I think she'll probably nail it.
Just to be sure.
Tastes like Viognier.
So again, because Amanda's list is so deep with Napa,
at Press, I thought it would be fun to taste some old world.
So I chose the 2010 Chateau L'Evangile.
This is Pomerol.
This is a vintage I really like.
You know, 09 and 10 were two great vintages.
09 tends to be sort of more open and forward, new worldy.
10 is my preference between the two.
I find it more classic.
I think it'll be fun to taste with her.
And the pedigree is amazing.
It's neighbors with Cheval Blanc and Petrus.
Planted to 80% Merlot and 20% Cabernet Franc.
And I can't wait to try this with her.
It's gonna be fun.
Okay.
All right.
I feel like it's easier being on this side.
Yes, I would agree.
Because sitting in the hot seat, it's very hot.
Yes, yes.
But definitely not trying to trick you
or anything like that.
So just fun wines
that I think I'll be enjoyable to talk about.
Cool.
So.
All right.
Let's go.
All right.
I'm very excited, actually.
You always pick great wines.
Thank you.
So I'm not, I think if anything, they'll be delicious.
Well, no.
Even if I don't know.
Okay.
And there was a method to my madness today.
So it'll be fun to discuss.
Well.
Okay.
This is wildly aromatic.
So thank you.
Yes it is.
The worst is when you stick your nose in a glass
and it's like, I'm not getting anything.
Yeah, yeah.
No, this is jumping out of the glass with intensity.
Tons of flowers.
And all different kinds,
everything from honeysuckle to acacia.
Really kind of perfumed,
maybe even like a little bit of like a Clementine Mandarin,
something more citrus.
Wines that are this aromatic,
definitely I gravitate towards,
you know, things like Pinot Blanc,
Gewurztraminer, Viognier.
Definitely doesn't smell
like the 2012 Bocce Gallupi Chardonnay that we just had.
So I think we can like rule that out.
Yes.
Let's take that one wine off the table,
but everything else is great.
But I am getting like a little bit of ripeness.
And in some of those fruits,
I'm getting like an intensity of fruit.
Like a forward fruit character.
No evidence of oak that I can tell.
I'm not getting a ton of like vanilla,
cloves, cinnamon, cardamom.
Not getting a ton of like minerality,
whatever that means.
So primarily fruit driven.
Are you getting like anything tertiary
or you feel like this is a pretty youthful wine?
Pretty fruit flower wine.
I really like wines like this.
I think we've talked about,
I'm a sucker for an aromatic white.
And back, I think I had a Godeo
that was featured on Wine Access
that was not as aromatic as this is,
but jumps out of the glass.
And I was like, yes, this is everything I want.
So I love whites like these.
And just kind of closely,
just looking briefly at the color of this wine.
Definitely has some like golden hues to it,
but it's fading towards clear, towards the rim.
You know, a little bit of greenness.
I don't know if that's coming
from these really beautiful lights
that are on our face right now,
but I think it's a white wine
and that's where I'll stand.
Yeah.
Well, well done so far.
Thank you so much.
Okay.
But it smells great.
I'm really excited to try it.
Tons of viscosity, like coats your mouth, really rich,
but there is like, there is some acidity there.
It's maybe a little bit masked
by how much unctuousness there is.
And I don't get any residual sugar,
but I definitely get like a richness from this wine.
It's starting to dive into something more savory
than it is into some of those more
like honeysuckle, acacia, peachy flavors.
And there is this sort of, yeah,
sort of savory thing that I'm getting on this.
I feel like the acidity is, to your point,
it's sort of like, it like creeps up on you.
It's not that kind of acid where it's just like jagged
or immediately your mouth is watering
because it is kind of enveloped
in this sort of rounder palate feel, but.
Okay.
So I think we're still maybe in like,
I don't think it's Gewurz.
I don't think it's bright enough
or light enough to be Gewurz.
Could still be like a Pinot Blanc
because it definitely has that unctuousness.
Could definitely be Vionier.
You're leaning like-
I don't know from New World or Old World.
Okay.
I'd say the alcohol seems pretty moderate.
I don't get a burn.
I mean, there's viscosity,
but I think that viscosity is maybe coming more
from the varietal than from climate or from style.
Still not getting any sort of sense of New French oak,
maybe a little bit of like neutral barrel,
maybe some concrete, I don't know.
I think when it comes to blind tasting,
I don't pay enough attention to you
and I don't give enough credit
to when a personal preference is involved.
And so when I'm tasting a wine and I really like it
or I want to go back to it,
or I'm starting to think about what foods I want with it,
I think there's a lot you can tell from a wine
by kind of involving-
Whether you particularly gravitate for it?
Whether or not I actually really like it.
And I really like this wine.
And so there's a few varieties
that I nationally gravitate towards.
There's a few varieties
that I almost categorically don't like.
I'm inclined to like aromatic whites,
i.e. Pinot Blancs, Gewurz, Viogniers.
I've always loved Viognier
and I'm definitely leaning towards some sort of Viognier
based on the intense aromatics
that I'm getting out of this wine, the viscosity.
The acid's there, but it's not overwhelming.
And I still don't know whether I'm in New World or Old World
because I have had a ton of really great California
and Oregon Viogniers that have kind of blown my mind.
Yeah, so-
Okay, do I have to dive?
Yes. Okay.
Okay.
I think it's Viognier.
Okay.
New World or Old World?
I keep thinking about the Criston Viognier
that I've had from Oregon.
Yeah.
And I mean, I haven't had, you know,
a wide array of like country Northern Rhone Viogniers.
One more sip. Okay.
Okay.
It's too savory and it finishes too clean.
Meaning?
Old World.
Okay.
Because of the savoriness.
Okay.
So final assessment was Viognier.
Viognier.
I'm gonna give you Northern Rhone.
I'm not gonna give you more specific than that.
And then three to five years of age.
I'm gonna probably conjure you,
but three to five years.
Okay.
Yeah.
Okay.
Did you feel this good after your first wine?
No.
Oh.
I felt terrible.
Cool.
Yeah.
All right, red.
Okay.
The color is fairly opaque.
Not a ton of rim variation, a little bit,
indicating a little bit of age.
You know, very, very garnet in color.
Moderate viscosity.
Well, in a good way.
No.
I mean, like we just went from a 77
to something that's definitely newer.
Yeah.
But ripe.
I'm not getting any like purisine.
Okay.
No greenness.
I'm getting just tons and tons of stewed fruits.
Okay.
I think that tells me a few things.
One, this wine is not terribly old.
It hasn't really migrated into secondary and tertiaries.
I think it definitely tells me I'm,
you know, I've got a little bit of red fruit,
a lot of red fruit, maybe a touch of black fruit,
definitely more stewed.
Currants, plums, prunes, things like that.
I'm in Bordeaux varieties.
Okay.
But this is ripe.
So I don't know.
Would you give me a California wine?
Would I?
I don't know.
Let's find out.
Blind the Napa girl on the Napa wine.
That's pretty.
That's really pretty.
Rich.
Acidity is moderate.
Ripeness is there for sure.
The, all of those stewed fruits,
those, that plummy pruney thing,
definitely continuing.
I'm getting a tiny like burn.
Okay.
I don't think it's an out of balance.
I just think that it's something that I'm more aware of.
And so I'm leaning towards a warmer climate.
Okay.
Do you have a variety in mind or a variety?
Well, here's the thing.
So I'm calling like prunes and plums, right?
Which Merlot, right?
But I'm also getting a lot of different things in here.
And so maybe it's a blend.
It could be a couple of different things.
I think there's maybe some Cabernet in here.
Okay.
So are you leaning new world, old world?
I think I'm leaning new world.
It's pretty ripe.
The tannins are super soft.
I mean, they're there, but it's round, it's plushy.
It feels like this, not like this.
Finish is very long.
I'm gonna call Merlot blend.
Okay.
I think this is fairly,
I'm getting like a touch of tertiary,
but like fairly new.
So I'm gonna call like 2012.
It's a warmer-ish vintage.
So are you in Napa?
I'm in Napa.
Okay.
Okay, so final assessment.
Merlot-based blend.
Merlot blend.
I'm trying to think of like producer
because who does a Merlot-based blend in Napa?
That's, and this is pretty high quality.
You know, like Heidi Barrett does the Mousse Bouge,
which is really good.
Merlot dominant.
I'm actually loving all of the,
oh, Arietta.
I looked at Arietta.
I did.
Oh, scoundrel.
Yeah, like I've had some like really great
Merlot-based wines from Napa Valley
that have had Bordeaux qualities
that have sort of tricked me.
So yeah, I'm gonna go 2012 Merlot blend, Napa Valley.
Okay.
Yes.
Awesome.
Okay, shall we reveal?
I think you have to now.
Okay, first of all, I love tasting with you.
Me too.
Yes.
So you were like,
Yes.
Spot on.
Wow, thanks.
I'm gonna drink the rest of it.
Yes.
Okay, yeah.
Can I come?
Yeah, I thought of you when I tasted with you
because you had mentioned,
we haven't actually tasted a Viognier together before,
but I know we discussed it,
and I feel like whenever I'm with you,
I'm always ordering like really high acid,
like Chablis or something.
And so I thought, let's do something like
off the beaten path.
And I didn't want to trick you,
but I was like, not Napa.
Like, let's kind of.
Yeah, no, this was like,
for me, this was very, very textbook.
Well, you called the like apricot, peach,
the texture, that kind of acid that's like,
for me, like, it feels like this,
like it comes on after.
It's kind of stealthy, huh?
Yeah, it's like a stealthy acid.
I loved that.
Okay.
I love both of these wines, actually.
I would drink these on any day with you.
I feel like you did really, really well
on this wine too.
It is Merlot-based.
Oh my gosh!
But.
Okay.
Bad border.
2010.
But you were like.
Okay.
No, no, no.
You were like, you were right there.
Okay.
Because, I mean, you called Merlot,
you got like the plums.
Yeah, wow.
And I think though, like.
Okay.
2.10, like not quite as ripe as nine in Bordeaux,
but still like a riper.
Yeah.
A riper vintage, and of course, it's right bank, so.
Right.
This is really delicious.
And I still like, even going back to now,
knowing that it's La Vangile, it's,
I don't know, it's still kind of like,
feels kind of new world.
Although, the lines are so blurred anymore that like,
I don't know, I have a really tough time
differentiating between the two.
I completely, I completely see where you got that.
And like, it has that sort of really fine grain,
like pixelated tannins of Bordeaux,
but they're super supple,
more so than I get a lot of times from Pomerol, so.
Awesome.
All right, well, we have four wines to kind of like.
Crush.
Crush over the next few hours.
Still.
You're not doing anything, right?
I'm canceling my plans.
Good.
Well, that was super fun.
Thank you for choosing these wines.
Thank you.
Yeah, I love.
Yeah, it's really rare that I get to taste something
that old from Napa, so thank you so much.
Oh my gosh, my pleasure.
Yeah, what a fun treat.
Yes, education.
Great, thanks.
Great.
