Feeling Uncomfortable About A Family Gift

Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today. My husband's grandpa wants to buy us a car and my husband thinks this is a great idea to help us on our financial journey and I think it's a bad idea. He says I'm just being too proud. Why is it a bad idea? Well, he would, the stipulation on this purchase is that we would have to buy it from a dealership so it would have some kind of warranty. We don't have any money to contribute to this purchase because we just replaced the main water line to our house. Is he buying it in cash? I believe that's the plan. He would be willing to spend $19,000 and I'm just worried. That's a very precise, weird number. It's the amount that he was told by his financial person would not put him at risk for taxes or something. I'm not sure. Oh, it's a gift tax. That is correct. Okay. Is he married? Oh no, you're married. So it could be double that. His financial person's wrong. He could actually give you $38,000 because he could give you $19,000 and give your husband $19,000. Is he wanting you to finance this or he just wants to give you the cash and he wants to go buy a car? He wants to go buy the car. Okay. What is the downside of this for you? Why are you saying this is not a good idea? I'm concerned that I, I guess it does sound silly that it's not going to be a car that I'm really going to like. I've been trying to save up for a nice car. I want to get a big SUV and I don't want to have a car that I feel like I have to keep driving year after year because it was a gift. Are you a two-car family? My point in asking that is what stops, my point in asking that is what would stop the car that grandfather buys reverting to your husband and then you when you're ready to buy the car you want, buying the car you want? The car that we have right now barely fits all of us and so we could get another car. Yeah, my point is whatever car you get now is probably better than the cars you have. Jenna, there's something else going on. You're not telling the whole story. Guy's trying to give you a $19,000 car and you're bitching about it. Do you not like him? I can't figure out why. You don't like him? Is he, is he going to come over to your house and visit to make sure you shine the car? Yeah. Is he a jerk? What's going on? No, he's a nice guy. He has been a little critical lately, but I mean, I don't know. He's been critical, unsolicited critical. Yeah. And yeah, you're afraid that if you take a car from him, that gives him permission to be all full on critical. Yeah. Yeah, that's fair. That's a fair concern. You don't have to take the gift. If you think there's going to be strings attached, if you think it's going to add strain, you don't have to take it. But at the same time, if somebody is just blessing you and it's, it is your pride or it is something that you're coming up with in your mind, that's going to block this. Like we want to see, see that clearly with you. Uh, wait a minute too. Um, when you're talking about buying the car you want, are you talking about buying that car on payments? I'm sorry, what was that? When you're talking about buying the car you want to buy apart from grandpa's gift, we're not taking grandpa's gift and we're not taking it because he's critical and he'll be hypercritical if he gives you a gift and because you want to go buy a car that's big enough for your whole family because the car you have barely now holds your family and you want to buy a car that holds your family. Are you talking about taking out car payments? No. You're going to pay cash for the car of your dream that you were talking about a while ago. Yeah. I would like to spend about $30,000 on a car. You don't have $30,000. How close are you to saving that? We are set back to zero after replacing the main waterline. So you, how, I would like to spend $30,000. I have no money. How does that compute? No. So what I wanted to do was get a small car for my husband now and then sell it in a year or two when we have more money as we've been saving. But I'm worried that if we want to sell a car, especially if it's the car that we've been gifted in a year or two from now, that that's not going to happen. I'm going to be honest with you. I think that there's just as much issue on your end as there is on grand dad's end. I think you both have something that is contributing negatively to this equation. I, I, I have to say, I don't want to take grandpa's $19,000 gift cause I want to buy a $30,000 car, but I have no money. This is not a logical sentence. Okay. That's fair. That's fair. I, you know, my, that's my husband's concern is that I'm it's not pride. So here's what I would do with what I have heard. And I'm not sure, still not sure I got all of it, but, but with what I have heard, um, I would suggest that you either don't take the gift and just start saving and work your plan and say, thank you, grandpa. I appreciate that very much. Uh, or you visit with your husband or your husband visits, not you. You don't say a word. He visits with his grandpa and says, grandpa, we would like to take the gift, but we have to be able to, and we have to know that it's a true gift and the gift can not come with criticism from you. Are you critiquing everything we're doing in the future? You can't come over here and tell us how to live. If that's what comes with the gift, we can't take the gift and we have to be able, grandpa, appreciate the gift and honor the gift. But if we take the gift, it's a gift. And if I want to sell it a month later, I might. And so if you, if you're not good with not coming over and sticking your nose in our business, grandpa, and you're not good with the fact that I own a stinking car, and if I want to trade it later, I feel free to do so. If you're not good with those things, if that's not going to go over well to use your phrase, grandpa, then I can't take your gift. That's my two stipulations. And I do appreciate the offer, but if the offer comes with me being trapped in the car and you coming over here and sticking your nose up my business all the time, this ain't gonna, I don't need the car. Now you can be a little bit nicer than that, but that's the message needs to be delivered. And if grandpa goes, no, you honey, y'all do whatever you want. I just got some extra money. Y'all are struggling young couple. I love you. And I just want you to win. And I'm trying to help you. If you want to sell it next day after I give it to you, that's fine. And, but I want you to get a good solid car. Those babies can ride in and be safe. I want it to have a warranty. I don't agree with that. It's a dumb idea, but if he wants to do that, it's his gift. That's fine. Is the husband concerned whatsoever that this is a bad idea? No, he's used to this family script where people stick their nose in where they're not supposed to. So he didn't bother him a bit. Yeah. No, it doesn't bother him at all. Yeah. Got it. Got it. You get used to your family's dysfunction and you don't smell it. Right. Yeah. We all do. I mean, we all have that. And so, yeah. But if he, if your husband is willing to do that, you don't need to say a word because you'll be the wicked witch of the West. You'll get painted up as the ungrateful little woman that married his grandson. Right. You don't, you don't need that paintbrush. So just, just. I think she might already be painted up like that. Just be very, very quiet. Yes. There's wabbits. Yeah. Be very quiet. Things are getting better. Good. Okay. Okay. So anyway, yeah, I think you just back off, but also not taking it. And it's not because you're prideful. It's because I see boundary danger. You want to preserve the relationship. Both things are boundary violations. I'm not allowed to sell a car I own. That's a boundary violation because it won't go over well. And I, and, and you're going to come over here and tell me how to live my life because you gave me 19 whole thousand dollars. No, thank you. I'll pass. That's not pride. That's wisdom. So walking away from this, unless those two things are cleared up, I is a good idea. I agree with you. And it's not because you're prideful. Create your free every dollar budget today. The simplest way to budget for your life.