Here's a simple-looking maths question that might make you stop and think:
x + 3 = x
At first glance, it looks like an ordinary algebra equation. But have you ever come across a question that makes you question everything you know about solving equations?
In this video, I take on this unusual algebra challenge and explore the mathematics behind it.
Before watching the explanation, take a moment to solve it yourself!
YOUR CHALLENGE: What value of x would make this equation work?
Write your thoughts in the comments. Let's see how many people can figure it out!
This video is perfect for anyone who enjoys: - Tricky algebra problems - Challenging maths puzzles - Algebra for beginners - High school mathematics - Mathematical reasoning and problem-solving - Brain teasers and logical thinking
Subscribe to JJ Online Maths Class for more interesting algebra challenges, mental maths tricks, GCSE Maths tutorials and mathematics puzzles.
Many got this wrong. Why?
Welcome back to my channel.
Let's see why many actually got this answer wrong.
We are going to try to achieve this in six different ways.
Now, first of all, if x equals 0, right?
If we say that x is equal to 0,
It means that we'll write this as 0 plus 3 equals 0.
Now, 0 plus 3 is 3. This is equal to 0.
Is that true? That's not true. Therefore, our x is not.
Zero. Okay, now let's solve this again, the second.
the method we have x plus 3 equals
to x now let's subtract x from both sides
so we have minus x minus
so we have x minus x here
So we have 3 equals x minus x, which is 0, which is still not true.
It's still not true now. Let's see, actually, what
is actually the value of x right now, let's use
Another method, the third method we have, x
plus 3 is equal to x, but before I proceed
if this is the first time you are seeing
I clicked the subscribe button on this channel so I don't
Forget all that and turn on your notification bell
Then I need your comments, everybody, tell me
What do you think about this video?
and other videos on my channel, let me know what's good and what's bad
the ugly side of the whole thing
and if you have a better or faster way of solving it
Please help me in the comments below with solving this.
So now let's square both sides.
So if we square both sides, okay, there's no need for this one here.
so if we square both sides
remember that a plus b squared is equal to a squared plus 2ab plus b squared
a squared plus 2ab plus b squared, which means
that we can rewrite this as x squared plus 2
x multiplied by 3 plus 3 squared
is equal to x squared, so we have x squared
plus two times three is six, so we have six x
plus nine equals x squared. Now let's bring
On this side, we have x squared plus six x.
plus nine minus x squared equals zero
so we have x squared minus x squared, which cancels out, so we are left with
six
x plus nine equals zero; now, if we should transfer
to the other side, we are going to
have six x is equal to negative nine now let's
divide both sides by six divided by six divided by six
By six, now six, we go into itself once, so we have x.
is equal to minus nine over six now three we
divide this to give us negative 3
and three we divide this to give us two, is this really
The answer wow Now let's check if this is
Actually, the answer wow, so now we have that x plus
three is x, so we have minus three over two plus
Three is equal to x is equal to x minus three over two.
so let us write this as plus three
three
Negative three over two is equal to negative three over two
So we can write this as 6 over 2 minus 3 over 2.
is equal to minus 3 over 2.
So from here,
we can write this as 6 minus 3 divided
Divided by 2 is equal to minus 3 over 2.
Now 6 minus 3 is 3 over 2.
minus three over two, and this is wrong again
and we thought that we had gotten the answer
Unfortunately, this is not the answer.
Alright, let's use the fourth method; we must find this.
Answer: Let's graph this. Let's graph.
this is okay, so to graph
Let's draw a Cartesian plane.
This is y and this is x, right? This is zero.
the center now let's do this one two three four
negative one negative two negative three negative
four one two I don't think I need anything here
Okay, now to plot this as a graph, we had
to equate each to be equal to y, right, because
because each side needs to be a straight line.
so we can say that y is equal
to x plus three, the first line then
y is equal to x. Second line, okay.
now let's go ahead and plot if y is equal
to x plus three, let's get our coordinates right
y equals x plus three; it simply means let's say
When y is equal to zero, what will x be?
0 equals x plus 3, so if this crosses x, it becomes negative.
x is negative 3, all right. Now when x is 0, when x is 0
Our y becomes 3, right? If you put 0 here, your y becomes 3.
So we have two coordinates here: 0 comma negative 3
and 0.3, so let's plot that
So we have zero, negative three; we have a point here.
and we have zero point three, we have
Another point here, so we join.
these two points together, let me get
My lord, let's handle it that way.
Now, let's plot the second one.
If y is equal to x, it means that x is equal to y.
And the y-coordinate is the same thing, right?
Because if y is 1, x is 1
If y is 2, x is 2
If y is 0, then x is 0.
So, let's use 0, 0, which is here, and draw our straight line.
One, two, two
Let's join.
Please take care of this.
Now, you can notice something from this graph.
From this graph, you will see that they
are parallel, they do not intersect each other, and because
they do not meet each other, which means that there
There's no solution for this again, seriously
there is no solution using
the graphical method, now let's use another method, yes we have
There are countless methods to try before we finally give up—we must try.
as many methods as possible
Now, this method is the complicated method, isn't it?
Remember that we can say that x is equal to a plus b i.
So, let's write a plus b i plus 3
is equal to a plus b i, okay?
Now, let's transfer this to the other side.
So, we have a plus b i minus a minus b i,
then plus 3 is 0.
so a minus a b i minus b i, so we are left with three
is equal to zero, wait, don't go, we have another
Method to check: yes, we have another method
to check, we need to be 100% sure that this is not
Actually working okay, so the last
but not the least is the one we need to evaluate, you see
Okay, if this is our ruler now, and this is 1, 2, 3, oh, the ruler starts
From the beginning, the numbering starts from the beginning.
So, let's assume this is 0, this is 1, 2,
3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and it goes on, right?
If we choose any one to be our x, let's choose 3.
So, this 3 is now our x.
We are to add three meanings; we are going
to jump three times this is plus one plus two plus three
so it means that x plus three in this case
It's giving us six—remember, we started with three.
According to this, we were supposed to have three as our final answer.
but we have six, which simply means
There is no solution.
Yes, you cannot add something to something.
And that remains unchanged, okay. It's not possible, yes. Okay, thank you.
So much for watching
Tell me what you think about the video in the comments.
And I'll see you in my next video. Bye!