Exclusive: How rapist Russell brand is being forced to shut up | The News Agents

Global - The News Agents
2 followers
1 Video View·Nov 18, 2026
Is it about him profiting,
or is it about him causing deep distress to victims?
Was this a prayer, or was this a podcast expressing a viewpoint?
People in the MOJ and prison service are frankly pissed off about this.
The massive coverage it got, it clearly caused distress to these women
who had just gone probably through one
of the worst periods of their entire lives.
What part of the law has actually been broken here?
The News Agents podcast is brought to you by HSBC UK,
opening up a world of opportunity.
We'll
This is a global production.
The sentence I pass on count six, rape, is nine years imprisonment.
be
So the total sentence is one of ten years, six months.
right
Oh, he's so record!
This is not his permanent base here at Wandsworth,
back.
but yesterday he was brought straight here.
He has moved, but not to Wakefield,
but to what's been described as a cushier
prison. It's a Category C, it's HMP Littlehay in Cambridgeshire.
So Russell has asked me to read something to you today.
And what Laura read out from Russell was that he wasn't guilty,
that he'd done nothing wrong.
And that caused absolute fury among his victims.
We have an exclusive story for you today that Russell Brand has now
been banned from communicating with his wife, Laura.
Will that stop his public pronouncements?
Welcome to the News Agents.
The News Agents.
It's John.
It's Maitlis.
And in a moment, we'll bring you the details
of this exclusive from Andy Hughes from the
Crime Agents on what he's learnt
from the prison service in the past few hours.
But to recap, I mean, on yesterday's podcast,
we talked about the fact that Laura Brand
had managed to produce a podcast,
obviously without Russell Brand at her side because
he's in prison, but reading the words.
of Russell Brand and talking about how he wasn't guilty
and how he'd done nothing wrong
and how he had Jesus by his side
and we talked about the appropriateness or otherwise the actual
frankly inappropriateness of it him denying his guilt even
though a court of law had found him
guilty a jury of his peers had found him guilty
and the massive massive offence
That that had caused an upset that had caused to victims
of brands crimes and how this was seen as unacceptable.
Yeah. And Downing Street stepped in pretty early on yesterday
and called it unacceptable.
They said they were launching an investigation.
And the question that sort of kept on hounding us throughout
the day was what part of the law has actually been broken here?
What is the question that we are asking here?
Is it about him profiting?
Or is it about him causing deep distress to victims?
And it is useful, I think,
to go back to the sort of wording that we have on this,
because we know that prisoners are prohibited
from sending correspondence which could be published online.
In other words, you know, if you're writing articles
from prison, you're not allowed to do that.
If you're tweeting, you're not allowed to do that.
If it's in return for payment
or if it's intended to cause distress or anxiety.
To the recipient, who you're sending it to,
or to any other person, i.e. clearly your victims.
Now, I wonder whether Russell Brand would try
and argue within that parameter that it was just a Sunday service.
We were just communing with God.
We were just doing it for listeners.
It's a prayer.
So, of course, it wasn't intended to cause distress or anxiety.
But what if it does? Right? That's the bottom line.
If you're in a place where, you know,
you can't actually just go back to the mens rea and say,
well, we were just doing this because
we like praying together on a Sunday.
They will have known the impact that that statement had.
They will have known by that assertion,
false assertion, that the rapist Russell Brand was
innocent. They will have caused huge distress.
They will have essentially turned.
The law on its head.
Yeah, you raise a really important question.
Was this a prayer or was this a podcast expressing a viewpoint?
Easiest way is for, we played this bit yesterday,
but I think it's worth playing again,
of Laura Brand reading out her husband's words.
Russell has asked me to read something to you today.
Beloved brothers and sisters in Christ,
God bless you for your support.
As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for.
So something strange is happening.
The good news is that Christ is with us when we choose him.
And I do.
So that is Russell Brand in the podcast that aired over the weekend.
And there's been a whole load of other stuff
as well about the kind of kushti lifestyle
that apparently Russell Brand is leading in his new category,
sea prison with kind of
yoga and whatever else and landline telephones.
And I don't know, God knows what else.
I don't think that's the issue.
That's a Category C prison, that's for all prisoners.
It's the issue of this particular message being read out
by his wife saying,
I didn't do it.
With us now is Andy Hughes from the Crime Agents.
And Andy, I gather you've been speaking
to your sources in the prison department?
Prison Service, what are they saying?
So, yeah, I've spoken to a few sources in the Prison Service
and also the Ministry of Justice.
And that was, of course, after that urgent investigation was launched.
I immediately knew, when I saw that on Sunday,
once I got past my disbelief,
I thought, Russell Brand is in trouble here.
And I knew he'd breached the rules.
Because any inmate, they can't just pump out
rhetoric or statements that are going
to get out there you can't put out those statements
if it will potentially cause victims distress.
So I started talking to my sources last night.
And they said to me they were absolutely furious
and that they are going to try and ban Russell Brand from speaking
or communicating to his wife until this MOJ investigation is over.
That ban may even be in place as we speak right now.
I should say that I've spoken to someone senior within the
The Justice Department,
and the prison service comes under the Justice Department,
a minister there who has said that is certainly the intention.
Yeah, well, that doesn't surprise me.
I mean, these statements clearly cause a massive amount of distress.
And we don't know how long this ban,
if it comes into place, will be for.
It will be initially an interim ban.
But that ban could turn into a punishment
and he could get a significant length of time.
I do know from one case,
when I was back as a newspaper reporter, I'm going back 15 years
here, but I interviewed a prisoner, a convicted murderer.
Now, I did tell him, are you sure you want to do this?
Because you're the one who's going to be in trouble.
And he said, well, I've got nothing to lose.
You put it out there.
We published because we believed it was in the public interest.
I then get a phone call from his wife two days later screaming at me
saying he's just been banned from any calls or visits for 12 months.
I'm not saying that this will happen in this case,
but it shows you how severe these punishments can be.
So here's where it gets really kind
of complicated as we set up the beginning.
If Russell Brand is communing in prayer and that prayer is made public,
I mean, you know, if Russell Brand is pretending to be Jesus
and that prayer is made public, does that cross a line?
Well, it depends. Every case is different.
The reason people in the MOJ in prison service...
are frankly pissed off about this, is the massive coverage it got.
It clearly caused distress to these women
who had just gone probably through
one of the worst periods of their entire lives.
And then for this to be thrown in their faces like this is not on.
He was at Wandsworth.
Then he's been moved to Little Hay.
I mean, he made his jokes about Little Hay and what we heard yesterday.
He clearly thinks that it's kind
of a sunnier place to live out your sentence.
So how does that make sense then with what we know of the anger of the
prison service now or are different parts not speaking to each other?
I mean, it doesn't make sense on so many levels.
I know there's been a lot of head scratching going
on through just prison officers I've been speaking to.
They can't believe that he's already
been downgraded within a week to a Category C prison.
Category C prisons are completely different than Cat B.
They get way more freedom, more visits,
more phone calls, more time out the cell.
Category B is seen as a proper punishment.
And for this, one prison officer said to me,
it is entirely normal for someone
who's been convicted of a sexual offence,
who's got 10 years plus to spend a third
of their sentence in a Category B before being moved to Category C.
So it almost acts like a parole thing, does it?
Yeah, if there's no issues and you behave, then you'll get downgraded.
But the thing, and another factor,
is that Russell Brand will be a target in prison
because he's a sexual offender.
Now, obviously, moving him to a specialist sex offender's wing,
that helps things, but it doesn't rule out.
I mean, sex offenders are still,
there's like a league table within prison.
How bad are you?
You know, does it involve children?
Are you famous?
So he'll still be a target.
So the fact that he's gone to a category C is astonishing.
So the famous bit I'm interested in.
Do you think that the fame potentially makes him more of a target?
And therefore the prison service decides,
you know, him in Wandsworth, that's an accident waiting to happen.
Let's move him quickly now.
I mean, do you think that was part of it?
Well, no, I mean, as I said, it just doesn't make any sense.
You would have thought a high-profile person like this,
moving them into a more secure jail makes sense.
I do know from my sources that there was plans to send him
to a sex offenders jail in the Isle of Wight.
Because that's category B.
For whatever reason, don't know whether it's full,
but that has not been done and he's now in a category C.
It's also not unusual for prisoners to be moved in and out
through different prisons fairly regularly.
I mean, for someone...
Doing a 10-year stretch, you could
find yourself in 10 different prisons.
I mean, yeah, the comedian Jimmy Carr kind
of nailed it in a very dark way, didn't he, last week,
when he said, I think Russell Brand's about
to find out what consent is.
I think Russell Brand's views on sex
and circumstances are going to radically change in the next week.
One of the questions that we're sort of working through then is,
do they think he is still a danger to the public?
I mean, isn't that part of whether you are B
or C, or is that irrelevant?
No, that's irrelevant, really.
It really comes down to your behaviour
and your circumstances in prison.
So, as I said, for someone doing a 10-year stretch for rape,
You would have thought, and it is normal practice for someone
to spend at least two years in a Category B before being downgraded.
Because you don't know how this person's going to react.
You don't know how the prison population's going to react.
One, you know, potential explanation is the fact
that they think these people in Little Hay are less dangerous
to Russell Brand than people in a Category B prison.
So that might have factored into it.
But from the people I've been speaking
to in the prison service, they're all...
baffled as to why he's already been done.
I mean, you say baffled, angry.
Well, not angry in that sense.
They're angry about the statements
that he made through his wife.
They're just baffled that he's been sent to a Category C.
They're just like, well, why has this happened?
Do you think we'll get more podcasts,
more Sunday services from him?
I mean, well, would they be stupid enough to do that?
Possibly.
I do know that they're going to throw the book at him.
For this alone.
So if he does it again, good luck to him.
And when you say throw the book at him, what does that mean?
Well, that means there may be cut in communication.
As I mentioned that case before.
That inmate was prevented from seeing his family for a year.
Now listen, I'm sure Russell Brand
or his lawyers would have something to say about that.
And they would be going...
I mean, they could stop Laura Brown from going,
but could they stop every visit? Could they stop every phone call?
I mean, all you need is one person who's an acolyte. They could.
Quite often that's the case. And when I put this story to the MOJ,
they said, we don't comment on individual cases.
However, we do have the power.
To stop communications and visits for inmates.
Now, that was sending me a very clear message
that this was definitely on their mind.
This may already be in place.
Who knows?
Andy Hughes, thank you.
Thank you.
So listening to Andy,
the thing that occurs to me immediately is that you just know what
the response is going to be.
Of his supporters, if a punishment is meted out for this podcast,
oh, it's the deep state, it's the establishment,
it's the mainstream media,
it's just because he's become
a right-wing influencer that they're doing it,
he's done nothing wrong,
why are they ganging up on him, etc., etc., etc.
They're censoring free speech.
Yeah.
Right? He's been silenced.
They have silenced him, right?
Look, we don't know where this is going,
But we do know...
From sort of past iterations of Russell Brand,
that there's nothing he enjoys more now than
a conspiracy of the state against him.
I mean, he said as much in the sermon on Sunday.
You know, the people, I think he compared, it was very interesting.
He said that the court reporting was like a football fanzine.
It was like reading a West Ham...
fanzine, mag, where you already knew the side that people were on.
So they were always going
to find him guilty because the establishment had already decided
his guilt. And all you need to do
is implant that idea, I think,
in enough of a vulnerable fan base's mind to see where it's
going, which is our Lord has been silenced.
They cut me down, but I jumped up high.
You know, I am the voice that will never, never die.
I think that is where the brand sort of reach is going now.
The more you try and silence me, the louder I will become,
because obviously he thinks he's Jesus.
I mean, look, he wears victimhood like it's
a couture made to measure suit.
I mean, it's so he's so weaponizes that.
He does it extremely well.
He's got huge numbers of supporters
and probably people listening to this
are already writing in the comments.
He's done nothing wrong.
There's no evidence against him.
This is just the establishment
trying to suppress free speech.
Yeah, I mean, I guess the interesting question is
whether the institutions now will respond to that
or will respond to the letter of the law.
You know, as we've heard, if Andy's...
Spot on with his sources, then they have already severed communication,
for now, between Brand and his wife.
But how long can they maintain
that for without feeling the pressure from outside?
I just hope and I think that they have behaved impeccably
so far that they have followed the law with all due process
and let the rules be what determines what happens to anyone,
whether they are from the left, whether they're from the right,
whether they're libertarian or authoritarian, doesn't matter.
Just follow the rules.
And in a moment, Lewis will be talking with Alan Milburn about
that landmark review into youth unemployment.
Well, a man of the hour, the man of the moment,
almost a man of the year, I think.
Not that we're able to do that on the News Agents award time
of the year, but Alan Milburn
of the eponymous Milburn Review is here.
Alan, how does it feel to be at the centre
of British politics again, even if it's for
a day?
Um.
It's a bit weird. You know, I spoke
to the Parliamentary Labour Party last night. It
was the first time I'd actually been in Committee Room 14 for 21 years.
It feels like it's 2004 or something.
No, yes, actually, it probably was. It was actually 2005
when I was running the election campaign for the Labour Party.
And then this morning, I had the delight of going
to Cabinet for the first time in also 21 years.
So it was a bit sort of, oh, my God, it's still here.
It's exactly the same.
It's still too warm, this room, the Cabinet room, is what I thought.
Tell me about it.
Yeah.
So anyway, so that was interesting.
And no, it was good.
It was very, very good.
And we're making progress.
I mean, you have been described by various scribes in the media
as being more powerful than most Cabinet ministers right now.
How do you feel about that?
Because your report has been so, you know,
prized initially by the Starmer government
and now by the Burnham government.
As a way of trying to address these welfare changes,
at least with regards to NEETs,
people have been talking about you as more powerful than half
the government.
I mean, that's Codswallop, isn't it?
You know it's Codswallop, and I know it's Codswallop.
I don't know.
Well, it's a good, I mean, it's a good yarn,
and it's a good line, but it's not true.
I don't exercise power.
I don't have any power.
Well, I'll tell you one way in which you could exercise power,
which is, of course,
if the government don't do what you suggested
in a six-month time or 12-month time.
You turn around and sound disappointed by X, Y and Z.
I mean, that would be a very big political story.
It would be, but it wouldn't have the same impact as, for example,
a Secretary of State for Defence, let's call him John Healey,
resigning from a government and saying enough is enough.
So I think you've just got to take all that with a pinch of salt.
I mean, I think what has been,
it's been a really interesting process, this,
because it's like...
Obviously it came out, you know what the genesis of all this was,
it came out of the welfare reform debacle in Parliament
a year ago where the government, the then government,
couldn't have got it frankly more wrong than they did,
played it wrongly, it went wrong for the Labour Party,
it went wrong for Keir as Prime Minister, they learned some lessons
and this time round it just felt so different.
When I was talking to the PLP last night it just felt like
a different conversation because you're talking about,
you're not talking about a sort of...
Fiscal imperative. You're talking more about moral imperative.
Did you have all of that in mind
when you were writing it and doing the comms for it,
even before when you had the interim report and so on?
Was that at the forefront of your mind
that you, if we're speaking honestly,
that although, of course, everything in your report is substantial
and you believe in all the policy perspectives,
that you knew that this was a task
of political management for the parliament?
Yeah, but that's not the predominant driver.
You know, you've got to think about...
Look, the easiest thing to do is to write one of these things
and for it to be what I want and what it could be
and it could be a sort of series of...
You know, theoretical changes that would be lovely to have.
But obviously, a lot of my life has been about practicing politics
and has been about doing things, not just writing things.
So, of course, you're thinking about the implementation of it
and what is possible as you're doing it.
But the fundamental driver for me is,
look, I don't need to do this in my life.
You know, it's taken a year out of my life.
And, um...
You know, I believe, I mean, it's an issue, you know,
I've been bothered about this issue of the next generation,
social mobility, a lot of that comes from where I come
from in my own life, and the fact that I've been extremely lucky.
So that was the predominant reason for doing it.
And then you're thinking about, right, okay,
and how do you get this framed in the right way?
But predominantly, it's not really about the framing,
it's about whether the thing is the right thing to do.
Since you mentioned it, in terms of social mobility,
which is something you care about and I care about,
just taking the...
The broad thrust for us, like we are both from working class backgrounds,
you from northeast of England, me from the West Midlands,
we're from different generations, but in a sense we've had quite
a similar kind of trajectory in a sense of, you know,
working class end up sort of political media establishment, all that.
Do you think that a young Alan Milburn will be able to do that today?
No.
Because I think about that myself in terms of, you don't think so?
No, I don't.
That's one of them. I'm eating my biscuits.
That's quite all right. You've earned the right.
It is three o'clock and you've done about 3,000 interviews.
I'm having a coffee and a biscuit.
Why not? We should do this more often.
Definitely, I think we should.
Garibaldi's just on there, Bourbons.
Don't you love a Garibaldi?
I'm more of a pink wafer man.
Are you really?
That's what they say anyway.
That's what the rumours are.
That's unfair.
Yeah, I know.
Yeah, I know, yeah.
Well, I'm eating fruit and art.
Anyway, so there we are.
Moving on.
So...
Yeah, I think it's quite hard to imagine there's
a kid growing up on a council estate in the
North East today who's going to end up in the Cabinet.
And that really disturbs me. And I think
that's for a whole variety of reasons,
some changes in the labour market, what's happened
to society. And in some senses,
the inequalities have sort of got worse and the distance, I think,
between this world that you and I are in today
and the world that we came from.
These are such different worlds
and I find that really disturbing and I don't think it's right
and I don't think it has to be like that.
I don't think so a lot of you know if you look at this
neat issue it's almost like sometimes people think
it's just inevitable. It's just a fact of life
isn't it? There's going to be a bunch of kids that fail
and we know where they come from but I think
what's really interesting about this is this used
to be an issue for other people's children.
And now, one in seven of these young people have got a degree.
Well, that's precisely what I was going to ask you.
So it's interesting, isn't it? It's changed.
It's really interesting and also, again, maybe slightly disturbing
in the sense that I think you're totally right,
that this has always been assumed that there's just always
a certain number of kids that are going to be like this
and they're basically going to have unfulfilling lives and that's it.
But do you think the reason that this has started
to actually rocket up the agenda is because suddenly, you know,
The front page of the Times is talking about this,
and the Telegraph, because it's become a middle-class issue.
Yeah, I think so.
And it's interesting, if I do something like a radio phone-in,
most of the callers, honestly, are not ringing about the NEET cohort.
They're ringing about their graduate son and daughter,
who hasn't been able to get a graduate entry-level job
and is working as a barista somewhere.
So I think the terms of trade have changed,
and I think that this is now, you know, I keep using the word visceral.
I think it is a visceral issue.
For families, people are worried about this.
I mean, I do think, I think it's, you know,
your generation's different from mine, as you say,
but I think we probably both grew up with a sense that
if you put in effort, you get a reward.
Each generation was going to do better than the last generation.
There was progress almost inevitable in society,
and each generation would be a beneficiary of that.
And I think what's happened is that people don't feel that anymore.
And that's a huge, it's more than a public concern,
I think it's a fear, to be honest, and I think what the reason
this thing has taken off is that it's sort of, it's touched that nerve.
So what do you think has changed? Because I think you're totally right,
actually, I mean, funnily enough, I was growing up under you,
in a sense, or under the New Labour government,
which actually, I think, you know, for all of its faults.
I mean, I remember as a kid basically thinking,
and maybe this is how New Labour very much approached it,
which was kind of like, you know, social mobility was a big, big thing.
And there was a sort of sense of the almost,
I mean, I felt as a teenager, which is very naive in retrospect,
but I almost felt like sort of class had been sort of abolished.
You could just sort of, as you say, if you worked hard enough
and there was a lot of money sloshing around,
there was a lot of money as well for slightly brighter kids
in working class areas and all that.
But what's changed, because that...
To me now feels like it's disappeared.
What do you think has changed?
Because you were growing up under the kind
of post-war kind of sense of a similar sort of thing.
So what's changed?
So I was born in 1958, which by coincidence,
the academics there was the sort of peak year of social mobility.
And for a reason, which is the economy was changing effectively
from being a blue-collar economy to a white-collar economy.
So that provided more opportunities, more room at the top.
You know, people described it.
And, of course, women's role in society was profoundly about to change
in the sexual revolution, the pill, and more women going out to work
and all of that sort of stuff.
So we were beneficiaries of a particular wave.
And I think when you look and take a big step back...
There's obviously not a single reason why all of this has gone wrong
and why young people, a million young people,
are trapped in this sort of neat trap.
But it's predominantly about, I think, two things.
One, the labour market has fundamentally changed.
There are fewer entry-level jobs, 1.6 million fewer
than there were 25 years ago.
So the ability to get into the labour market is just harder,
and that's what graduates and non-graduates are finding.
And then I think the second thing that has changed, in a sense,
or rather hasn't is that.
The system, from education through to welfare,
is trying to solve yesterday's problem, and not today's,
and yesterday's problem was all about cyclical youth unemployment.
So when I was growing up in politics in the North East,
in the trade union movement as it happened in the,
I guess, the sort of late 80s,
You know, this was a time of the People's March for Jobs,
three million people being unemployed,
but the truth was it was a cyclical thing
and then the economy recovered and then people went
back into work. This is not cyclical.
Six out of ten of these young people have never had a job,
so this is detachment, it's not unemployment,
but we're still trying to fix the unemployment
problem. As if it was cyclical.
As if it was cyclical and it's not structural.
So I think that's what's gone on.
And then you're throwing in AI as well.
And the mental health epidemic on top of it.
So you've almost got a perfect storm of these things coalescing.
And that's why, actually, the only way of solving it,
people go on about welfare reform, and of course it's important,
but that's only part and parcel of the action.
But is there another sort of structural thing?
I don't know if you've thought about this, but...
We live in a society, right, which is just older, right?
And it's just a demographic structural thing.
It's like the rest of the West.
There are just fewer young people.
I mean, young people's political power.
It's just so much lesser if we're thinking about it generationally.
And there are fewer people with children
and all of those sorts of things.
So, you know, you talk about the 1980s.
There were just way more.
I mean, it sounds almost redundant.
It's sort of reductive.
But there were just way more young people.
It feels to me that in terms of how the media
and politics sort of talks about this.
Look, we've got a great society.
Yes.
Great issues are more important.
That's not to say
that older people don't care about what happens to kids.
They really, really do.
They do, yeah.
But it does seem to me
that there's something demographically there as well,
Well, which is that actually sometimes.
These kids, or young people, they've had
a very different experience almost from any other generation.
But they've got sort of less political power
to sort of tell that story.
It's interesting that I hadn't really thought of that in that way.
But there's a really interesting article with Gordon.
Brown wrote it, I think, in The Guardian,
I don't know if you saw it a few weeks ago,
but this sort of youthquake idea, you know,
which was basically saying, look,
there's something happening across,
it's not a peculiar UK phenomenon. I mean, it happens to be
worse here for a variety, I think, of structural reasons,
the way our labour market is formed and
so on and so forth.
But this is not an unusual phenomenon.
The gulf between older generations and younger generations
is widening in terms of income and wealth, just is.
The opportunities are diminishing, just are.
And therefore, that has an impact.
Now, of course, then that leads to the sort of political question,
which is where do the politicians gravitate?
And we've seen where they gravitate. So we've done some analysis
for this report that we just published, which
It looks at per spend, spend per pensioner compared to per child, okay?
And it's effectively doubled the gap over
the course of the last 20 years.
So we can keep doing that,
but let's not pretend it doesn't have a consequence.
The consequence is a million young people.
And in terms of, I mean, you know,
you mentioned some of the structural factors.
I mean, is it just simply the case?
And they may have done it for perfectly good reasons.
Some of it connected with sort of just the way
the Labour Party views the world in terms
of workers' rights.
And of course, young people need workers' rights as well.
There's no question about that.
And also, Rachel Reeves, the
then-chancellor, did have a fiscal problem.
It was not clear where that, or easy to see where that would be solved.
But she obviously made the choices
that she did on employers' national insurance.
The truth is that the Labour Party, perhaps for good reason,
has made this problem worse over the last two years rather than better
because of the choices they've made.
So I think it's undoubtedly some of those choices have had impact
on the youth labour market. I think that's true.
I think we've just got to be really careful about
this because I get asked about this a lot for obvious reasons.
It's not as if the net rate has been below 10% in 25 years. It has.
So this is a long running problem and successive governments,
I think, when we come to this
issue of regulation, legislation,
impact on the youth labour market, it's had a corrosive
effect over very, very many years.
And so one of the things I suggested.
This review is, I think we've got to have a structural response to that
because governments, whether they're right or left,
they just keep legislating and they keep regulating
and it's almost a sort of inevitable fact of life.
It's a way of exercising political power.
And so one of the things we say is,
look, there should be a statutory test,
we call it the Youth Opportunity Test,
by which you judge whether a fiscal measure, a regulatory measure,
a legislative measure is going to have a harmful or a helpful impact
on the youth labour market.
Do you have more confidence?
That the Burnham government will be able to pull this off then,
if Starmer's still in power and you're doing it for him.
Yes, I've got literally no doubt about that.
And why is that?
Because I think, one,
I think it's more seared in Andy's soul, to be honest.
All the conversations I've had with him, I was in Cabinet today,
you know, sort of reporting to Cabinet about it.
You just feel it. I feel it very much.
You didn't feel that from Keir Starmer?
No.
Not to the same extent, no.
So very much I feel like Andy, this is a big thing for him.
And why do you think that was with Keir Starmer?
I honestly don't know the answer to that question.
I think it was, I think in some ways,
you know, Keir was an unusual politician
in that he wasn't particularly one.
He was sort of, you know,
he's more a lawyer by way of thinking, more technocratic.
Andy is very political.
He thinks in political terms.
He thinks in strategic terms.
And I think it's really interesting
when I compare the Andy that I knew, you know, when
I was in government alongside him and the Andy I see now,
he's been through a transformation
as a consequence of actually doing politics in Manchester.
And I think he's learned about how you actually make change happen.
And so, for him, I think this is a really big,
he sees it as a big thing as a sort of moment for the country.
I think he sees it as a big thing as part of his long-term project.
Perfect.
Um,
And I'm pretty convinced he wants to do it.
And you think he will?
Yeah, I do.
And has he given you that assurance that he wants to,
he's going to carry it out?
Yeah, yeah, no, so far, so good.
I mean, look, you know, it's a big report.
It's 250-odd pages.
And there's some big fiscal implications over the long term.
You want to spend a lot more.
A lot of money to save money.
There's a lot of implications for it.
There's a lot of policy implications, there's a lot of change.
There's a lot of change in how we're going to do government.
There's a lot of change in where power lies in the state.
So we suggest, for example, consistent with his devolution agenda,
that a lot of this, the delivery engine for it,
has got to be more local than national.
That's a challenge to Whitehall.
And that isn't going to be,
none of this is going to be straightforward.
And obviously your report, Alan, was mainly,
what was about young people, doesn't extend to?
To older people, but a lot of the issues are the same.
I mean, one thing that really struck me that you say, though,
is the number of young people claiming disability benefits
is expected to quadruple from 2012 to 2037.
That's crazy.
Yes.
And as you say yourself, that simply cannot be right.
No, it isn't right.
Well, because that's not what's happening in society.
Exactly. So how can that be?
Because surely young people can't be four times
as disabled as they were back in 2012.
No, they're not.
And this is where, look,
this is really difficult and you've got to be really careful.
You've got to get this absolutely right.
So I was really struck.
Did you read Peter Fonagy's review?
It's worth reading.
So Peter did this really important report on mental health prevalence.
Mental ill health, I suppose, prevalence.
And his conclusions, I thought, were really interesting.
One, he says, distress amongst the young is rising.
It's a real thing, anxiety, depression.
Two, these neurodevelopmental conditions, ADHD and autism,
there has been a rise, but it's been much more modest
and is sort of broadly flat.
But diagnosis is rising very rapidly, much faster than prevalence.
And he says that we are at the tipping point where...
The diagnosis is rising so much faster than the prevalence
that cannot be right and so I think what we've done culturally
is we've made the seeking of a diagnosis the answer to a problem
and the answer to the problem if you are have got ADHD
or autism is much more to be found not in health treatment.
But in getting you to participate in normal society.
And do you think that something has changed
with the Labour Party in terms of how they see this?
In the sense that, you know, you go back to say the 40s or 50s,
it's very clear the way the Labour Party
talks about what we would now call welfare.
They wouldn't have called it that then.
But it's very clear that the Labour Party obviously believed
in the welfare state
and believed in benefits for those who fell on hard times
or who couldn't work and so on.
But there was a sort of harder edge to that.
Even if you go back to the 90s and the governments you were involved in
talking about, you know, welfare to work and all those sorts of things.
Has something changed with this parliamentary Labour Party in the sense
that it almost feels as if, I mean, OK, you're totally right.
Rachel Reeves completely botched it when they did it before.
But it almost got to the point, I mean, I've heard Labour MPs basically
say that they could never vote for anything which would take,
in any circumstances, anyone's benefits away.
And it just leaves me thinking, I mean,
there's nothing particularly left wing, at least to me.
independence on the state when you don't need it,
in the ending or stopping of individuals flourishing, you know,
having a flourishing life just because they're on benefits.
Has something shifted in terms of the psychology of the Labour Party
or do you think it's always been that way?
No, I don't think so.
I think Labour is what it says on the tin.
It's a part of your work.
It's part of your Labour.
It's called Labour for a reason.
I think what it's interesting when you talk to constituency MPs,
they know fine well.
That the life chances of young people
are being ruined by being stuck on benefit, you know.
If you're on benefit, you're never going
to be anything other than poor.
You're always going to be in poverty.
You've got no prospect of prosperity.
It is a trap, and that's the problem.
But we know that today, if you're a young person getting a health
and disability benefit for the
first time, you stand a 50% chance
of still being on that benefit in 15 years time.
And we also know...
But there's a bunch of young people,
say, with moderate ADHD or anxiety,
but they would be far better off being in work.
And we've got to stop asking this question,
which is, what can't you do?
We've got to start asking a different
question, which is, what could you do?
And what support and what opportunity do you need to do it?
And that's the job of the state.
The welfare system always, from the get-go,
has had two functions, hasn't it?
Function one, support you when you fall on hard times, of course,
people with disability and so on.
Unemployment, but secondly, it's also been.
A springboard into work.
And one function has risen and the other function has fallen.
That's what we've got to change.
And, you know, going back to where we started, Alan,
you've been dominating the airwaves today,
the newspapers, Westminster politics.
Has it whetted your appetite for a potential return?
If the Prime Minister were to ring you up and say,
Alan, I want you to personally come and oversee this,
this huge transformation to government departments,
because you're basically talking about a whole new type
of youth service,
so many different...
Government departments working together,
big long-term fiscal implications.
Lord Milburn, why not?
Well, let me say two things.
One, I'm never returning to frontline politics, thank you very much.
I've done that. That's great.
It was wonderful. It was very nice to be a visitor in the Cabinet Room.
I don't want to be a permanent member, thank you very much.
You know, I've turned down the House...
You sure?
Yes, I've turned... 100% sure.
And I've turned down the House of Lords at least once.
So, you know, that is not...
So no arise, Lord Melbourne.
That's not going to be my bag.
Look, do I care about this issue?
Of course I do.
You know, I wouldn't have spent a year doing this.
And so, look, it's not straightforward, any of it.
And it's very challenging.
And you're always in difficult arguments and conversations with people.
You know, would I like to stay involved in some way, shape or form?
Yeah, because I want to see this thing through.
I want to help with it.
I want to make sure that this stuff is delivered.
I don't just want to write a nice report that people can admire
and for it to lie on a shelf.
My politics has always been about how
do you translate ideas into actually getting things
done.
That's what I'm interested in.
Alan Milburn, thanks so much for coming in.
Appreciate it.
So yesterday we got the big announcement.
It's one that we've all been waiting for and a nation,
frankly, the world has been holding
its breath on.
And the really disappointing news was.
It wasn't me.
I think an opportunity was missed by the makers of James Bond.
I could not agree more.
I can say shaken, not stirred.
Yeah, I could do all of that very, very easily.
I could look moody with a gun.
Instead...
Robert Pattinson got it.
This is how it was greeted on GB News.
We've got some breaking news to bring you now, and it's this.
The new James Bond has just been announced.
It's Robert Pattinson announced as the new James Bond.
Yes, the fellow from the Vampire movies.
He's not even British, surely.
Bond should be a Brit.
What do I know?
Robert Pattinson there has been announced as the new James Bond.
He's American, right, Chris?
No, he's British.
Is he?
I'll take that back.
I think the key phrase in that is, what do I know?
So, yeah, Robert Pattinson, not even British, not even white.
Oh, yeah.
He is white.
He is.
Oh, he seems whitish.
Yeah, he is.
Yeah.
So, another bloke's day completely ruined on GB News.
I know.
What was that?
I needed to feel rage about something.
I had it and it's been taken away from me.
How cruel is that?
Life is cruel.
We'll see you tomorrow.
Bye-bye.
Bye for now.
The News Agents podcast is brought to you by HSBC UK,
opening up a world of opportunity.
This has been a Global Production.
