These questions sound simple. Answer too soon, and you can give the dealership room to reshape the price, stretch the loan, or fit expensive products into your payment.
Kevin Hunter, The Homework Guy, walks through seven questions dealers love asking—and gives you practical responses to keep control of the conversation.
Learn how to get a complete, itemized written out-the-door quote, compare financing offers, evaluate your trade, question optional products, and confirm exactly what you’re agreeing to before signing.
A $550 payment over 60 months adds up to $33,000. That same payment over 72 months adds up to $39,600. And “just $29 more a month” over 72 payments means another $2,088 in scheduled payments. Watch the whole deal.
Our Hassle-Free Car Buying coaches can help you compare dealer quotes and work through the negotiation. Visit https://thehomeworkguy.com/
WANT KEVIN TO REVIEW YOUR CAR DEAL FOR FREE?
Already bought? Send Kevin a copy of your deal. Include your first quote, your final quote, and what the salesperson said when the numbers changed. Black out your personal information first.
Tell us in the comments which dealer question caught you off guard!
👉 Learn more at thehomeworkguy.com 👉 Homework Guy Car Buying Service available
Do you happen to be on Facebook? If so, would you do us a big favor? Go to our facebook page and click on "Follow." We would greatly appreciate it! https://www.facebook.com/thehomeworkguy/followers
This guide outlines strategic communication tactics to avoid overpaying when buying a car. The primary goal is to shift the focus from monthly payments to a written, itemized \"out-the-door\" (OTD) price, ensuring transparency and preventing dealers from hiding costs through loan extensions or unnecessary add-ons.
Seven questions car dealers love asking,
but you shouldn't immediately answer.
Let's kick things off with this one.
What payment are you trying to be under?
That may be one of the most expensive questions
you'll ever hear at a car dealership.
Give them a number and they can
do loan term magic backwards to get it done.
The car price can stay way too high.
The loan gets longer.
They can even fit a protection package
into the payment you just told them you could afford.
And at the end, somebody hands you a worksheet and says,
we got you right where you want it to be.
Well.
They got the payment where you said you wanted it.
What happened to the rest of the deal? That's
the big question. I'm Kevin Hunter, the Homework Guy.
Today, we've got seven key dealer questions.
What can happen when you answer improperly or too early
and the proper response you can use to get
the conversation back to being focused on the car deal
and the out-the-door price. And if you don't
find the help you're needing for your specific
car situation in this video, visit us at the
homeworkguy.com. And you should know you can use
this advice without making the whole conversation
Most of the time, it takes one calm sentence.
You can be friendly, give the dealer
the information they need to quote the car,
and keep your budget and your walk-away number to yourself.
Let's start with obtaining
the number you can get before you ever set foot inside the dealership.
Question number one, when can you come in?
You reply back with a simple message.
I'm interested in stock number ABJ214.
Please send me a complete itemized out-the-door quote.
A salesman texts you back.
Great news, it's available.
When can you come in?
A lot of buyers answer automatically saying, I can be there at 6 p.m.
Now you've made an appointment
and you still have no idea what the dealer is going to charge.
By the time you've driven all the way across town, waited for the keys,
and taken the test drive, you've invested
a whole day or all of your evening.
That's a hard time to find out.
The advertised price comes with a $1,800 dealer installed option.
Try this.
I could plan a visit after I see acceptable numbers.
Please send me the itemized out-the-door quote for stock number ABJ214,
including the selling price, dealer fees,
add-ons, taxes, and registration.
For registration purposes, my zip code is,
if they need your registration address
or more likely just the county you live in to calculate tax,
give them what they need for the quote.
If the advertised price includes a rebate,
ask them to identify it and explain how you qualify.
Then you can decide whether that card deserves a trip from you or not.
This is one of the first things our hassle-free
car buying coaches work on with buyers.
They do the work for you.
They'll get quotes from dealers for you on comparable vehicles,
and they look at the line items.
Sometimes that listing that got your attention has
the highest total once you see what comes attached to it.
Coaches are great at getting rid of that kind of stuff.
Getting these details in writing saves you from spending all
day Saturday figuring it out while sitting at a sales desk.
That's the wrong place to do it.
Question number two, what monthly payment are you comfortable with?
Let's say you have room in your budget for a payment of $600 a month.
You're supposed to know that number.
It's a part of your household budget.
Once you give it to the salesperson as a target,
though, they can change several other numbers
to get you there.
Think about a $550 a month payment.
60 payments of $550 add up to $33,000.
72 payments of $550 add up to $39,600.
It's simple math.
That's $6,600 more in scheduled payments.
To compare the whole deal, you'll also look at anything due up front.
The point is that the same payment can
describe two very different offers.
Here's the line you should use.
I'll handle the monthly budget on my end.
Let's work from the written out-the-door price first.
Then, when it's time to look at the loan,
ask for the APR, the term, the amount financed,
and the total amount of payments.
If you have a pre-approval, ask the dealer to beat the APR
with the same term and the same amount financed.
When someone says, I got the payment down for you,
ask, which number changed?
Make them point it out to you on the paper.
And if your payment really is too high,
even after you've negotiated the car,
Going back to a less expensive vehicle is a decision you get to make.
You can make that call at home with the numbers right in front of you.
Here's another version of this same conversation.
You say $600 and they come back with $589.
Before you start celebrating,
ask what they assumed for the down payment.
Did they put $2,000 down on the worksheet
when you only planned to put down $500?
It's easy to miss that on a sheet with the payment printed in big type
and everything else tucked in the corner.
If it's wrong, ask them to rerun it
with the amount you actually plan to put down.
Then, if you're comparing two dealers,
use that same down payment on both worksheets.
You want to see what each deal costs with your money on the table.
Question number three, are you paying cash or financing?
Got to be careful with this one.
I hear from people who are proud to say,
I'm a cash buyer, before they even ask what the car costs.
I also hear from people who say they're
financing as soon as they're asked
because they think they'll get a better price.
Either way, you've given the dealer a direction to steer the deal
before they put the price in writing.
That's the wrong thing to do.
Here's what I'd say.
I'm open to reviewing the options.
Please send the itemized out-the-door price
and show me any discounts that depend on financing separately.
Or a line that our coach John uses all the time.
He says, I could pay cash, but...
I've heard there's incentives for financing,
and I'm interested in hearing about what those are.
Suppose the dealer offers $1,000 off if you finance.
Ask which lender and what terms apply.
Ask for the written price without the incentive, too.
Then look for changes elsewhere on the worksheet.
If the finance quote adds $3,000 in coverage you didn't ask for,
those two charges alone put your $2,000 behind before you
were even considering interest expense.
If you're considering paying the loan off early, read the actual terms.
And check for any prepayment penalty
and any written conditions attached to that discount.
Always remember, a loan over 61 months can't have a prepayment penalty.
Get those questions answered before signing a verbal.
You can pay it off whenever you want from the finance man.
Leaves you with a lot of homework to do once you're at home.
Question number four, what do you need for your trade?
Here's where people give the wrong number for the right reason.
Let's say you owe $18,000 on the car,
so you say, I need $18,000 for it.
That tells the salesperson what would make you whole.
It leaves the value of your car
and the price of the other car wide open.
Suppose you've got a purchase price at $34,000
with a $16,000 trade allowance from the dealer.
Another dealer comes back at $36,000 with an $18,000 trade allowance.
Before any difference in taxes, fees, or financing,
The second deal gave you $2,000 more on your trade,
but took back $2,000 more for the car.
Add the same payoff to either worksheet,
and that basic math still works the same way.
Remember to say, please quote the vehicle purchase separately,
then give me your written trade offer
and show any payoff on its own line.
You want to look at the numbers separately.
You can give them the VIN, mileage, and condition for the appraisal.
When you're ready to finalize the deal,
they'll need the actual payoff if they're handling it.
Ask them to show you where every dollar goes,
especially if you owe more than the trade offer.
This is another spot where our coaches can
be a second set of professionally trained eyes.
If you get a quote that's one big number after trade,
they can help you see what the dealer is offering for your car
and what you're being charged for the next one.
With that clarity, you get to decide if both sides
of the transaction actually work for you.
Question number five.
If I can get you that number, will you buy today?
To make an offer, the salesperson pushes
the paper back towards you and says,
My manager says, yes, are we doing business right now?
That might be a reasonable question
if you've already seen the full deal
and you know exactly what you're agreeing to.
I want you to pay attention to the phrase, that number.
Which number are they talking about?
Did you offer 32,000 out the door?
Or is the manager about to approve a $32,000 selling price?
That's very different.
A number before fees and taxes.
Does that include a discount you actually qualify for?
Is it even for the same VIN you were looking at?
You can say, I'm interested at that number,
put the full deal in writing for this VIN
with every condition, and I will review it.
If you're buying used and still want
an independent inspection, say so right there.
If you've agreed to a repair or an extra key,
get the promise in writing.
There's a difference between showing you're serious
and committing before you've reviewed the
terms. Keep this in mind when you hear,
let me see what my manager can do. The person who walks away
from the desk gets time to think.
You get that time to think too. When they come back, take a
Take a breath and read the worksheet.
If a new line appears, ask what it is.
Question number six.
Would you protect your car for just $29 more per month?
Be listening to the words just and a month.
They make it sound like you're picking something small
that doesn't matter. If that change is $29 per month over 72 payments
and the rest of the loan
terms stay the same,
you're looking at $2,088 more in scheduled payments. Maybe you do want
gap insurance. Maybe you're interested in a service contract.
Find out which product they're
They're offering what it costs by itself and what it actually covers.
Ask for the deductible, exclusions, who handles claims,
and how cancellation works if you sell
the car or pay off the loan.
You can compare what the dealer is offering with what your credit union
or insurance company may offer you.
Here's what you say, show me the deal
with the optional products removed,
then give me the standalone price
and the terms for any product I ask about. What if they tell
you they already put the package on the car?
Ask them to identify the dealer installed items on
the quote and tell you which chargers they'll remove,
then compare the complete price with
the next dealer's offer.
You'll know whether this particular car is worth pursuing or not.
When the final contract comes in, check it against the quote.
If you decline something
and the charge still appears,
because that happens sometimes, ask them to correct the
paperwork before you sign anything.
Question number seven, what's the most you'd pay?
We saved this one for last and for the buyer who's done some homework.
You've got a written quote in hand.
You've got a comparable car across town.
The salesperson says, come on, give me your real number.
What's the most you'd pay to take it home today?
The most you'd pay is your walkaway number.
Your offer is the number you're willing to put on the table right now.
If you tell them you're sealing,
expect the conversation to start right there.
Let's say you've got a written offer of $31,900 out
the door quote on a comparable car you'd
actually buy. This dealer is at $32,600.
You can say, I have a written $31,900 out the door quote
on a comparable vehicle.
If you can match it on this VIN, send me the itemized numbers and I'll
review them. Otherwise, I'm prepared to make the trip for the other
car. And then say it like you
mean it. Check that the other car is available
and the quote includes everything you're comparing.
If it's a road trip or a plane ticket,
factor that into your decision before you make the offer.
If they say, could you do $32,300?
You can pause and decide whether this car is worth another $400
for you. There's no requirement to fill the silence.
Just let it be. A simple statement
saying I'm staying at $31,900 is a complete answer and stick with it.
If you remember just one thing from this video
on your next dealership call, remember this line.
Send me the itemized out-the-door quote for that VIN.
In fact, write it down on paper in front of you
so when the dealer says things to get you off track,
you remember it.
Again, send me the itemized out-the-door quote for that VIN.
It gives you something you can read, compare,
and come back to when the conversation starts jumping
from price to payment to trade.
Dealers move things all over the place
just to avoid that question.
Just repeat the line when the conversation gets off track.
And if you've got a deal on your desk
and you'd like help sorting through it,
our hassle-free carbine coaches are ready
to help you compare quotes and work through the
negotiations so even if you started something
with a dealership, it's not too late to get one
of our coaches involved.
You'll find the link in the description box of the video down below.
If you've already bought, send me a copy of your deal.
I'd love to see your first quote,
your final quote, and the line they used when the numbers changed.
Just black out your personal
information first and tell us in the comments
which question caught you off guard. I'll be
happy to give you some free feedback on it.
Your deal might be the very thing another buyer needs
to hear before making a purchase tomorrow.
I'm Kevin Hunter, the Homework Guy. The Amazing
Elizabeth will be back right after the new year.
I'll see you on our next video.