This Mets Signing Is SNEAKY | New York Mets News

Mets Digest
1 follower
Nov 21, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe New York Mets have signed pitcher Joel Kuhnel to a minor league deal following his strong late-season performance with the Giants. This move comes as a low-risk \"flyer\" after the Mets lost their primary target, Jonathan Loizaiza, to the Yankees. The team faces a significant void in their bullpen and must find reliable late-inning relief to be competitive.
This season, Joel Kuhnel pitched for three different teams,
and two of them designated
him for assignment.
But this week, the New York Mets signed him anyways,
because at his last stop with the
San Francisco Giants, he went 10 games with a 2.79 ERA and two saves,
and his sinker touched
100.5 miles an hour.
But in the same week, a reliever that the Mets had
been targeting went across town.
The Yankees beat the Mets for Jonathan Luizaga
and gave him two years and $18 million.
Luizaga had a 2.42 ERA over 67 innings this year.
The kind of season the Mets bullpen badly needs.
So Kuhnl's finish to 2026 was real and worth a shot.
But it can't be an answer for the Mets bullpen
that is in dire need of some
legitimate credibility at the back end.
And with them losing out on Luizaga,
that hole just got that much bigger.
And to see why the Mets took a chance here on Kuhnl at all,
you have to look to see how he got here in the first place.
The Mets are Joel Kuhnl's 10th organization.
The Reds took him in the 11th round
of the 2016 draft out of UT Arlington,
and his real shot came in 2022
when he pitched in 53 games for Cincinnati.
It didn't go well.
He had a 6.63, I should say 6.36 ERA that year.
After that, it was Houston, Toronto, Milwaukee,
Tampa Bay, Philadelphia, and the Yankees.
And most of those stops were in AAA, not the big leagues.
But every so often, there was a stretch
that made a team take another look.
In 2024, he pitched five games for Tampa Bay with a 1.13 ERA.
Last year in AAA for the Yankees,
he struck out 29 hitters in 31 and a third innings and
picked up five saves.
That got him a minor league deal with the A's last winter,
and on April 7th, they called
him up.
He had four saves and a 4.21 ERA in 25 games there.
And in June, the A's designated him for assignment anyway.
Milwaukee traded him the next.
Day. They traded for him, that is.
And in 10 games as a Brewer, his ERA was 6.52. And
on September 2nd, they cut him loose as well.
Just two days later, the Giants claimed him
off waivers. A guy on his third team
in one season usually gets ignored, and that's exactly
when his year turned around.
Because in San Francisco, he pitched 10 times, and his ERA
was 2.79 against 4.21 with the A's and 6.52 in Milwaukee.
On September 8th, he got his first save as a Giant,
a four-out save, and a 2-1 win over the Cardinals.
He'd been on the team just four days,
and they were already trusting him to close a 2-1 game.
The bigger reason why the Mets are interested in him is his electric.
Fire breathing arm, and that is Kunal's sinker.
We gotta talk about it.
It averaged 95.2 miles an hour this year,
and that's the pitch that touched 100.5.
Across every pitch he threw,
he averaged 92.7 miles an hour in the 89th percentile in baseball.
He threw that sinker on 51.5% of his pitches.
It runs 14.4 inches toward the third base side,
and that kind of run is what gets right-handed
hitters rolling over into ground balls.
What needs fixing is the walks,
he walked 18 of the 202 hitters he faced, 8.9%.
A pitcher with that sinker
and a problem that clear is exactly the kind of guy that a pitching
coach will always think he can fix.
Now the catch, because there is one here,
no doubt about it, and that is that those
10 Giants games add up to only 9 2 3rds innings,
which is a tiny sample size for any pitcher.
Over the whole season, he struck out only 5.6 batters per nine,
which is low for a pitcher
who can throw over 100.
He also gave up seven home runs, and the longest one went 427 feet.
Put all three teams together, and his ERA was 4.4 in 45 innings.
That's why this is a minor league deal,
and no salary has even been reported.
There's a catch for him too, another one I should say,
and that is that he's out of
minor league options, so if he does make the Mets,
they can't send him down without putting
him on waivers.
He has to win a job in spring training,
or he's gone again, and frankly, if you want
every Mets bullpen move this winter covered the day it happens,
hit that subscribe button.
Right now we're at 8,280 subscribers,
and every single one of you helps keep this channel
growing.
The Mets need this bet to hit
because of how empty their bullpen currently looks,
and especially after they got rid of mainstays
in the bullpen after the trade deadline.
Before the August 3rd deadline,
the Mets traded away eight big leaguers.
Four of them were relievers, A.J. Minter,
Brooks Raley, Luke Weaver, and Huascar Brazabon.
Less than a week later, Devin Williams went on the injured list.
Through mid-September, the Mets were ninth in all
of baseball in bullpen ERA for the season.
Pretty good.
But from the deadline on, they were more average, ranking 15th.
By mid-September, the closer was Kodai Senga,
who had actually turned from a starter
to a reliever and did a decent job,
and he racked up seven saves.
But then he blew his first save when Pete Alonzo, of all people,
hit a long home run off of him.
Devin Williams was supposed
to be the answer at the back of this bullpen,
but he didn't prove to be that.
Last December, the Mets gave him three years
and 51 million as the backup plan,
and then Edwin Diaz left for the Dodgers on three years and 69 million.
In his first year in Queens, Williams had a 4.43 ERA.
He also walked 21 of the 184 hitters he faced, which is 11.4% of them.
He's still the closer, and he's signed through 2028.
Minter and Raley are free agents now,
and Reed Garrett is expected back
from Tommy John surgery sometime in 2027,
although it's very much up in the air.
So right now, the back of this bullpen is a closer
who struggled, a pitcher coming off
surgery, and a lot of empty slots,
and I don't think you can include Darwins and Hernandez
in that either.
So, what do the Mets do?
Well, look, the fact is that the Mets were eyeing Jonathan Loizaga.
That was the reliever that the Mets were chasing this month.
But on November 16th, AM New York reported
the Mets were the more serious suitor
while the Yankees looked elsewhere, and then four days later,
the Yankees got him at two years for $18 million,
and a club option for 2029.
MLB trade rumors had projected him for two years and $13 million,
so the Yankees went $5 million past that number to get it done.
John Heyman put it plainly, the Yankees beat out the Mets in the end.
It really does sting because of the Mets' need here
and what Loaizaga did last season,
and that was, in Arizona, he threw 67 innings with a 2.42 ERA.
His whip was 1.03 against 1.49 for Kuhnel.
He walked 5% of the hitters he faced, 13 of 261,
in the 92nd percentile in all baseball,
and 56.4% of the balls hit against him were on the ground.
By pitching war, he was worth 1.7 wins, and Kuhnel was at negative .1.
Kunal is a sinker pitcher who lives on weak contact.
I should say Luizaga is a sinker pitcher who lives on weak contact.
And he doesn't walk many hitters,
which is exactly what the Mets are hoping
that Kunal can become with his sinker.
The difference is that Luizaga did it for a whole season,
and Kunal did it for really just one month.
This is also the second time
that Luizaga has picked the Bronx over Queens.
In December 2024, the Mets reportedly
offered him two years and six million.
And he went back to the Yankees
on a one-year deal with a club option instead.
To be fair, there's a reason the Yankees had to pay for him,
and that's because shoulder and elbow problems
held the wise good of 51 and a third innings
from 2023 to 2025 combined.
This year was his first fully healthy season since 2021.
He's also 32, and an $18 million deal
is a real bet that the arm holds up.
But that's the bet the Mets wanted to make,
and now the team across town has that pitcher instead of them.
Here's the part, though, about...
Joel Kuhnel, that should give Mets fans a little bit of hope here.
A year ago, Lewizica was the minor league flyer.
After the 2025 season, the Yankees turned down
a $5 million club option on him.
Nobody gave him a big league contract, and on January 13th,
he took a minor league deal with Arizona.
He made their opening day roster on March 25th.
Just 10 months after that minor league deal,
the same Yankees, who wouldn't pay him
$5 million, just gave him $18 million.
That's the path Kuhnel needs.
No guarantee in the big leagues.
You're going to have to win the job in March
and you're going to have to make everybody
pay attention by the summer.
The difference here is obviously the track record
because Luizica has already been a
big league reliever and a good one at that before
and before the arm injuries and the
arm broke down.
Kunl's never really been that consistently.
The Mets can hope for a similar path for Kunl as Luizica had,
but they can't plan their
bullpen around it.
So, let's see what's left.
The Mets have made one other bullpen move this month,
and that's what I mentioned earlier.
They agreed to a three-year, $12 million deal
with lefty Derwins and Hernandez, pending a physical.
Hernandez spent 2026 pitching in Japan,
where he had a 1.48 ERA.
One report says he still has one minor league option left,
which Kuhnl doesn't have.
Add Kuhnl, and that's a lefty coming back from Japan
and a minor league flyer.
Neither one is the proven right-hander they just lost to the Yankees,
and this bullpen was 15th in baseball and ERA after the trade deadline.
So, back in August, Sports Illustrated's Mets site listed right-handers
who could fit in free agency.
Pete Fairbanks, Blake Trinan, Andrew Kittredge, and Jason Adam.
Minter and Raley are on the market too,
so a reunion with the two lefties they traded
at the deadline is also on the table.
And money should not be what stops this,
Because for the luxury tax, Spotrak has the Mets...
2027 payroll at $306.8 million,
about $60 million over its projected $247 million line.
Every reliever they add now costs more than their salary
when you consider that threshold,
but Steve Cohen has paid that tax happily before.
The real question is whether Stearns is going
to spend it on the bullpen this time,
because a lefty and a flyer were the easy moves here,
and the hard one is still left, and really the hard two.
Joe Kuno is a smart, free...
option here and the sinker has real bite
to it hitting 100.5 miles an hour. So I don't mind
this signing within itself, but it's a flyer, not a plan.
And he's only coming off of really
nine good innings last year. Loaizaga losing him, that hurts.
That hurts a lot because the
Mets were the serious suitor there
and they lost him to the Yankees for the second time.
So here's what I want.
I want at least one proven right-handed
late-inning reliever before Christmas,
really before December 1st,
because that's when all this is going to break down for the lockout.
I would keep my eye on Pete Fairbanks and Blake Trinan,
but I would also keep an eye on Brooks Raley and A.J. Minter,
who the Mets have been linked
to and that they traded away at this past deadline
to fill that late-inning lefty reliever role
that I'm not confident Darwins and Hernandez can fill.
But who do you guys think the Mets should go after next?
Fairbanks, Tranen, bring back AJ Mentor, someone else?
Comment below, let me know.
And every move this winter will be right here.
And I'll see you guys in the next one.
As always, guys, let's go Mets.
