Watch Natalie Haynes, Emma Southon and Llewelyn Morgan in this special comedy event that took place live at the British Museum on 2 September 2021, where they discussed all things Nero.
Nero was the last rule of the Julio-Claudian dynasty and is the subject of the Museum's exhibition Nero: the man behind the myth (27 May - 24 Oct 2021). From succeeding to the throne at the age of 16 in AD 54 to his violent death at 30 in AD 68, this conversation covered all the things that have contributed to Nero being considered one of Rome's most infamous rulers, with laughs along the way.
Acclaimed writer, classicist, broadcaster and comedian Natalie Haynes was joined by Dr Emma Southon and Professor Llewelyn Morgan. Southon is author of a biography of Agrippina the Younger and co-hosts a history/comedy podcast called History is Sexy. Morgan, an author, classicist and Fellow of Brasenose College, Oxford, has been a regular guest on Natalie Haynes Stands Up for the Classics on BBC Radio 4.
We’re bringing inspiring stories of humanity’s shared histories and cultural achievements to millions of people online. Your support ensures that we can continue to make the collection and videos like this one available to as many people as possible. If you can, please donate today: https://www.britishmuseum.org/support-us/donate or you can text BMLEARN to 70085. Texts cost £5 plus one standard rate messageCredit: British Museum Events
Oh, we've missed you.
Not going to lie. Look at you all.
Sorry, I'm still overexcited about it.
I've been back on stage since May the 17th
when it was first legally permitted.
And yet still, I'm like this when I go out.
I had that terrible moment where somebody asked me in an interview
what I'd missed most about during lockdowns.
And I accidentally said audiences and not my family.
So thank goodness they didn't notice.
They did, of course.
They were religiously listening to everything I did.
So, hello.
We thought we would talk to you a bit about Nero.
How many of you have already been to the Nero exhibition?
Oh, very good.
We could have an exam.
And how many of you are looking forward to going to the Nero exhibition?
Great. Well, no spoilers, but we'll tell you about some of the bits
that we like the most, I think, as we go along.
So for people who've seen it, we'll try and not bore you.
And people who haven't, we'll try and enthrall you.
Slightly more rhyming than I was aiming for.
So Nero is, was, I can't stand up really without falling off the stage
because it's too small.
So and also, I don't want to cut your sight lines of Emma and Llewellyn.
So I'll stay here, I think.
But it's a bit weird for me to do this sitting down.
So if I suddenly start looking twitchy, you'll know why.
Nero is the last of the Julio-Claudian emperors.
He is emperor from 54 to 68 CE.
He is the adopted son of Claudius.
So we decided we would start by giving you a little bit of backstory.
Claudius, for those of you who are doing your emperors
the Eiklavdiv's way, obviously, Claudius is Derek Jacobi,
to give him his full title.
He is emperor in 41 CE.
He takes over from his nephew, Gaius Caligula,
who famously is assassinated by his bodyguard.
You don't often die of old age if you're a Julio-Claudian.
I think from our perspective, from the from the long lens of history,
Claudius was quite a successful emperor.
Certainly he's successful as far as we're concerned as a country,
because he invaded us with elephants,
which always delights me because I think the Britons here at the time
must have never seen anything so big.
It's like the biggest thing you would ever have seen would be what?
A horse, I suppose.
You're like, what is that horse with a big nose?
And it just makes me feel pleased thinking about it.
But our view of him, of course, is colored by the prejudice
of ancient sources, and Claudius had various physical infirmities,
which by our ancient sources were viewed as signs of mental infirmity.
But in fact, he was extremely clever and wrote, you know, histories,
many volume histories of Rome up to that point.
He also married four times.
And I think there's no better way of saying this than that.
He usually, by the views of our ancient sources, picked a wrong one.
So his third and fourth wives are where we thought we would pick up today's story.
Llewellyn, I wondered if you might talk to us a little bit
about Claudius's third wife, as she is presented by our sources,
Messalina, who is, I mean, is one of the least generous
write ups of anyone in all of Roman history.
And that is setting the bar quite high, because generally
it's a terrible place to be a woman in a Roman historian's account.
Indeed. No, no.
Do we have another microphone?
Does that work?
We did do a soundcheck, I swear, before you.
I know it looks like we were just sitting up there eating crisps.
And I'm not going to lie.
We were sitting up there eating crisps, but we did do a soundcheck, I swear.
And then we ate crisps and now everything's broken.
It's all gone. And I've forgotten the questions.
Oh, Messalina. Oh, yeah. Messalina.
You know, absolutely.
I mean, she gets an absolutely shocking treatment.
So, I mean, it's the worst person of all that you could choose in Rome,
which is saying something too right about you is is juvenile
and juvenile satirist.
And, you know, I love him.
I'm a terrible person.
I know I'm not supposed to.
This is this is satire.
This is what you have to be shocked by and love it.
That's fine. Although it is a personal failure.
He shouldn't be so funny if he didn't want us to like him.
Correct. Exactly. It's his fault.
Yeah. But I mean, there's a there's a really interesting statue
in the exhibition, actually, which which sort of gives you
another aspect of it, which may well be
Messalina, may well be Messalina holding Britannicus, her son by Claudius,
but modelled on a much older statue
of a piece holding wealth, you know.
So Messalina, like all these other
women of the royal family, have a kind of a prominence
in a positive way, in a negative way as well.
They they they're a shocking kind of presence
as far as the authors are concerned.
But actually, to the experience of Romans, they would be semi-divine
figures and figures of great potentially absolute respect and significance.
So, yeah.
There you go. I liked it.
Messalina is. Yeah, yeah.
So the image that we get of Messalina from, I mean, Tacitus, Suetonius
obviously goes to town, is that she is extremely sexually voracious.
Can we go with as a euphemism for Bloomsbury?
And then things get a little tricky.
She marries another man in a sort of mysterious outdoor ceremony.
And it's seen as potentially a coup,
that this is an attempt to overthrow Claudius,
which I suppose implies that Messalina was more both popular and powerful
than our sources would have us believe.
But the result of this is no more Messalina.
And instead, Claudius is set up to marry his fourth wife,
a woman named Agrippina.
Now, it's not often I get to say this, so I'm going to, you know,
take a run up to it and then roll around in it.
Emma, you literally wrote the book on Agrippina.
I did.
I wondered if you might tell us about this particular...
You know, I love her.
She is wonderful.
She is great.
Wonderful and terrifying in equal measure.
That's my favorite kind of lady.
I imagine her, when I think of her,
I imagine her as being basically the White Witch from Narnia,
in that she is immensely
powerful and terrifying and loving when she wants to be
and absolutely monstrous when she doesn't.
And to be fair, nobody's really invented Christmas yet.
Yeah, exactly.
So it's always winter and never Christmas.
All right.
I'll buy it.
But she is actually Claudius's niece.
She is the daughter of his younger brother, Germanicus,
and grew up with him as her uncle.
And she had been exiled by her brother for plotting against him.
And then Claudius brought her back and they cozied up together.
And when she when she saw that her uncle was missing a wife,
she thought there might be nice to fill that spot.
A single man in possession of an imperial throne.
Is even though he already has a son, might need another one.
And she has a son with from her first husband
who is called Domitius Ahenobarbus at the time.
But she has designs that she would like him to be the next emperor
because he is descended from Augustus and Claudius.
And therefore his son are not.
And therefore, in her mind, perhaps they are illegitimate
on the throne, and it would be much better if her son,
the true Julian, were on the throne.
And so she convinces
or her and some freedmen convince Claudius this is a brilliant idea.
They get married.
He I mean, they have to change the law.
They do have to change the law.
And there's a way this is a bit gross.
We've done incest much earlier than I expected to.
I'm not going to lie.
It's not even seven o'clock. I know.
But yes, they have to change the law.
And there's a wonderful scene in Tustis where that happens,
where they get their pet console to go
and propose that this is a brilliant idea and that actually Agrippina
is not just deserving of being his wife, but the only possible brilliant idea
and that she is being given to Claudius as a reward for how great he is as an emperor
and that therefore they should change the law because the Egyptians do it.
So it's fine. And the gods do it.
And he's basically a god.
So and they change the law.
And then Claudius is just kind of hanging around in the forum
outside of like mysteriously for no reason.
Just looking at stalls as they all come out to tell him the great news
that they've decided to change the law so that he can marry this woman
that they're going to give him.
And it's all very kind of staged and wonderful.
But yeah, so she convinced him to marry her.
She convinces him to
unbetroth his daughter
to her husband by having him exiled for incest.
There's so much incest with the Julio Claudians
and then manages to marry her son to Octavia
and also get Claudius to adopt her son
and pop him in the line of accession above his own son,
which is an impressive bit of negotiation.
She is an unbelievable negotiator.
Yeah, I mean, I argued when we did the episode of Stand Up
to Classics on Agrippina, I put forward the argument
that she is the greatest emperor the Romans never had.
She really is.
And I really stand by it.
As a negotiator.
She is incredible.
She's a great diplomat.
The best. She understands money.
She does.
She is manages to resolve all problems with everybody being happy
as a general rule, except the person who's sometimes dead.
Swings and roundabouts.
There's always a small like no full out.
No plan is perfect. Exactly.
If you want to make an omelette.
Yeah, got to break a few emperors.
But the the image that we have of these two women who, you know,
in the latter case, really paves the way for Nero to be emperor.
They are as as they are really interesting examples
of how misogyny works, because Messalina is presented to us
by every possible source as a whole.
She's presented as a woman who is sexually voracious
and morally questionable because she is sexually voracious.
Agrippina, she is.
The words are literally quasi Wirilei.
She is like a man.
Yeah, she's not interested in sex unless she is using it for some.
Yeah. Nefarious gain.
And where Messalina likes pretty gardens and pretty dresses.
She really likes pretty girls. Yeah.
She'll kill for a garden.
Agrippina is only interested in money and things that will get her power
because she is too masculine and she wears sometimes as masculine cloaks
and her lack of feminine charm
is the main thing that is wrong with her.
It's the main thing that's wrong with me.
I'm not going to lie.
It just, you know, once you've got it, it's just a problem.
Yeah. Come on.
Can I add a bit more? Yeah, of course you can.
Does this work? Yes, it does.
A bit more incest.
Yeah, add a bit more incest.
I don't think we've had enough. Everyone join in.
I'm really glad there are people walking past as I say that cheerily.
To be to be strictly fair to Agrippina,
she does, according to the male sources, attempts to seduce Nero himself.
You know, so she can.
I mean, they're very confused about what kind of woman she is.
She's a she's a she's a woman in power.
Therefore, she's terribly frightening.
But that might be because she's a woman acting like a man,
which is kind of completely wrong.
Or it may be because she's acting like a superwoman kind of thing
and sort of deploying her charms, even in the direction of her son.
So, yeah.
But I'm well, I'm going to ask this question later when we come to spoiler.
I mean, you know, she's dead.
It's 2000 years ago.
There's not that much of a spoiler.
If it is, you're at the wrong gig.
I'm not going to lie.
So what happens to Claudius?
He dies in 54, which is when obviously Nero succeeds him.
And he is.
So the rumor goes poisoned by well, Agrippina remotely
because she gets a woman named LaCosta to poison
Claudius using and I still don't eat them now.
Mushrooms, are they poisoned?
Are they poisonous?
It's a valid question.
Agrippina is perhaps murderous, perhaps clever, perhaps lucky.
Llewellyn, I feel like you can tell me more about mushrooms,
something which I won't even look at a picture of because I dislike them so much.
And I'm vegetarian.
So this is a big part of the food people offer me.
And so it means when people go, oh, have you got any dietary requirements?
I have to say I'm vegetarian, but also I fear mushrooms.
And it's slightly awkward at that point.
You think it doesn't really matter what you give me.
You've definitely spat in it.
Sorry, Llewellyn, mushrooms, mushrooms, mushrooms.
Right. What do I say about mushrooms?
Nero has a has a funny thing about mushrooms.
He refers to them as the Kybostiorum, as the as the food of the gods.
You know, he's mistaken.
It was that's how Claudius got to be a god.
But no, there's a there's a really I was going to say a really nice bit in Juvenal.
There are no nice bits in Juvenal.
Of course, there's a funny bit in Juvenal where he's he's trying to convey
how amazing a particular mushroom is,
how this is the best mushroom that could possibly be served to anybody.
And he says it's like the mushroom
that Claudius ate before the mushroom that killed him.
The penultimate mushroom, the penultimate mushroom.
That's the name of your prog rock band, isn't it?
Sorry, I made myself laugh.
Claudius liked his mushrooms, so he sort of walked into that.
That is, I have to say, the absolute limit of my knowledge of mushrooms.
OK. All right.
If that's where it ends, that's where it ends.
So Claudius dies in 54, poisoned, as we've established, with mushrooms.
And Nero, therefore, becomes emperor at the age of 16.
At first, therefore, this is always presented as an absolute given.
Because he's only 16, his mother has a strong influence over him,
say historians who have never had a 16 year old child anywhere near them ever or were one.
But at first, he and Agrippina do have at least, what's the word I want?
A close relationship in terms of their public image and on coins.
And I wondered, Emma, if you would talk to us a little bit about,
there's a glorious set of a couple of coins in there.
Is it three coins maybe that are lurking or four?
Three or four coins.
I wondered if you'd talk us through the fact that Agrippina appears
in slightly different places as their relationship shifts.
She does. It's a really useful way to see who is important,
who the emperor likes in their own family, is who is on a coin.
And Agrippina is numismatically unique in a lot of ways,
which is a great phrase to say.
That's your program.
Yeah.
And there are lots of lovely coins.
If you've not been, then you should go and look just at the coins, if nothing else.
She's the first ever named woman who is alive to appear on a coin,
along with her sisters of Caligula.
And then when she becomes Claudius's wife,
she starts appearing on the obverse of coins, on the back of coins,
which is the first time that a woman is ever put on a coin as a symbol of power
and as a woman who has a role in legitimising the government and as being important.
And then she starts appearing on the face of coins next to Claudius.
And we start to see their faces are overlaid,
so they're pointing in the same direction.
And then Claudius dies.
And then we start to see Nero coins,
where she's not just on the face with him, but she's facing him.
So you can see both of their faces the same amount.
So she's effectively equal to him.
So the Claudius one, she is sort of behind him, as it were.
So he is the foreground and she's in the background.
So you just see the shape of her face.
But then when Nero comes to power, she's like, hi.
She comes out from behind the curtain properly.
And so you get that for about a year.
Big fans of Vitellius, obviously.
And yeah, so she starts to appear next to him as his equal in power.
And then she starts to fade back into the background.
And then she disappears from his coins as they fall out,
because she believes that she's obviously going to have this
equal role that she has because she's put him on the throne and he's a child.
And he obviously cannot be trusted to be making decisions about
who's going to be the governor of Judea, who's going to sort out this problem.
And she thinks she'll do it.
And he does not agree at all.
So he represents her importance and coming in and out with that.
And at the beginning of Nero's reign,
they have a very contradictory relationship with the dead Claudius, let's say,
because firstly, there's this suggestion that he's been poisoned and poisoned deliberately.
And that's how Nero has power.
But it's also the case that he is deified.
He is deified because it looks good for them
to have a deified husband and a deified father.
You can say you're the child of a god.
Yeah. And, you know, I would go around saying that all the time,
certainly if my mum was here.
But I would therefore, Llewellyn, wonder why it was possible in what's essentially a
dictatorship by another more polite name,
why it's possible to publish a poem like Seneca's Apokolokintosis,
which I can say while drunk, you'll be glad to know.
And the Apokolokintosis, one of my very favourite coinages
and one which I always like to hand over to you,
Apotheosis, the act of turning into a god, Apokolokintosis, the act of turning into a pumpkin.
And it's a source of great sorrow to me that as the only nation in the world
which regularly performs pantomimes, and in particular, Cinderella,
we don't routinely use the word Apokolokintosis in the winter months
to convey the moment when something turns into a pumpkin.
I find it genuinely baffling.
And I feel like it's an easy fix.
I'm not going to lie to you.
So if you could casually mention the word Apokolokintosis in a sentence,
I would see that as...
I'm not going to say the least you could.
I am the least you could do.
So, sorry, Llewellyn, I was asking you a question about 40 minutes ago, do you remember?
So early on in Nero's reign, Seneca produces a satirical pamphlet.
You can tell we're all satire nerds.
He produces a satirical pamphlet called the Apokolokintosis of the Divine Claudius,
which suggests that although Nero is legitimised by having a deified stepfather or adoptive father,
he also is, at least initially, tolerant of mockery of that.
Can you talk to us a bit about it?
Yeah, happily, happily, happily.
And particularly because one of the most amazing things in the exhibition,
at least for satire nerds, is a ninth-century manuscript of the Apokolokintosis.
I can also pronounce this name, though I'm not going to say it as often as Natalie's just said it.
There it is, sitting there, open, with an image of Seneca above it that they've chosen,
because he's looking a little bit awkward.
Did you squeak when you saw it?
I squeaked when I saw it.
Yes, I fainted, actually.
It had to be brought round again.
The Apokolokintosis is a fascinating document, possibly performed at the Saturnalia,
sort of soon after Nero comes to power.
That is Roman Christmas.
That's where anything goes, kind of thing.
And that sort of explains a little bit about its character.
I mean, what essentially it does is take Claudius' deification and reverse it.
It sort of says that Claudius tried to get into heaven, but the gods said, no, don't think so.
And Augustus, in particular, sort of reads the litany of the terrible things that Claudius did
and sends him to the underworld.
Which is rich, coming from Augustus, FYI.
It is, but he's a bit beyond criticism by this point.
But it's actually, I mean, the Apokolokintosis is kind of like a strange and remarkable survival.
I mean, it's a horrible thing.
It's satire, you know.
It's horrible, horrible, horrible, but very clever at the same time.
What, almost the most significant thing about the Apokolokintosis is that it is a satire.
Because satire is, well, satire is the only literary form that Rome ever invented.
It's a very sad thing about the Romans, that they took everything from the Greeks,
apart from this one form of literature that isn't quite sure is literature, you know.
And that is satire.
But satire also became this kind of embodiment of what the Romans thought
was most important about themselves.
And in particular, this word libertas, freedom or freedom of speech, frankness, this kind of thing.
So what's happening in the Apokolokintosis is, at the beginning of Nero's reign,
freedom is being kind of asserted in this form.
In fact, it's modelled on something by a...
I think it wants me to stop speaking.
I think it's you.
I don't know if...
I think it needs to go back to you.
Yeah.
Oh, look at this.
Hello.
No, we want to hear more about the Apokolokintosis.
Well, okay.
Which I can casually say while drunk, as we've established.
Yes, I can say it almost all the time when I'm sober.
It's the one I can do.
And that and Thesmophoriad's suicide, I can do any time you want.
Now he's showing off.
Yeah, I know.
Stop it, stop it.
You're welcome.
Where was I?
Yeah, no.
So there's a character called...
Honestly, you've asked the wrong question here, because I could really...
Ball for Britain on this one.
But there's a character called Lucilius who invents Roman satire, right?
And becomes this sort of icon of Roman-ness himself.
And he has a satire where a character is judged by the gods and then sent to the underworld.
So what we're getting in the Apokolokintosis is actually this very traditional piece of Roman,
we feel good to be Roman, happening.
So you've got to ask who's actually there when it's being performed.
Agrippina probably isn't, because it's not the kind of thing that she would like to hear.
Nero probably is, because there are these little inserts
which say really nice things about Nero, whilst saying nasty things about Claudius.
Amazing text, really.
Okay, so I mean, it's worth pointing out, though, that Seneca also doesn't die of old age.
That although he's able to write and publish the Apokolokintosis,
and presumably to perform it or to have somebody perform it,
he is then forced to kill himself at a later point.
Yes, yes, indeed he was.
But not directly as a consequence of the Apokolokintosis.
And to be fair, we're not 100% certain that Seneca wrote it either, 99%.
But yeah, I mean, it's a tough gig being a friend of Nero, really.
Yeah, being close to power is always dangerous at home, isn't it?
It is, yes.
There's no time when it's...
Absolutely.
None of them dies, really, at old age, or happily.
One of the most excellent facts about Seneca, though, is the suggestion that actually what
provokes the rebellion of Bodicea, Boudicca, is Seneca drawing in the loans.
He's given these loans to the British at sort of massive rates of interest,
and suddenly wants it back again, and the British kind of revolt.
So, you know, there are other respects in which Seneca isn't the perfect philosopher.
There we go.
There's a wonderful bit of Dio, which goes off for absolutely no reason,
about how Seneca owns too many tables to be a proper Stoic, which is my favourite thing about
Seneca.
It comes out of nowhere, and just says he owns too many tables, and they're too nice.
I mean, that is always a measure of a person, in my view, said the woman with a single table.
So Nero becomes emperor in 54.
It takes till 59, which is not bad going, really.
So he gets through all the hormonal years before he kills his mother,
or rather before he has her killed.
And this is genuinely one of my favourite stories in all of Roman history, even though
women die in it, because Nero commissions a Nicetas, who is the commander of his fleet,
to kill his mother, which isn't the obvious person to ask, I would think.
I mean, I do see that killing your mother isn't something that most of us have to consider,
but getting the head of the navy to do it still seems weird to me.
And a Nicetas gives the famous reply when asked if he could help out with the killing of Agrippina.
Nihiltam capax fortuitorum quam mare.
Nothing is so prone to accidents as the sea.
And so they put Agrippina and her freed woman, a woman named Acaronia, on a collapsible boat,
which sounds like I'm making it up.
But not only am I not making it up, I think this was my GCSE set text.
So I know more about collapsible boats than you would think, likely,
of a woman who grew up in Birmingham quite a long way from the sea.
And they get out onto a lake, and I think it is anyway, and the ceiling collapses.
But Agrippina and Acaronia are on a couch which has really high sides.
So because of the high and sturdy sides of this couch,
they are protected when the roof falls in and they don't get crushed.
But the boat comes very close to capsizing and they are thrown overboard.
And it is one of the great moments, I think, in this.
It is such a great bit of story that Acaronia and Agrippina are therefore both in the water.
And Acaronia, who just isn't as clever as Agrippina, sees a bunch of men
rowing towards them who can presumably rescue her.
And she shouts, help me, help me.
I'm the emperor's mother.
Whereupon they club her to death with their oars.
Agrippina, much smarter, stays quiet and swims to shore.
Which, by the way, is surprising because, you know,
we have no real evidence for the number of people,
and especially the number of women, who could swim.
But obviously she could.
So she swims to shore and survives the entire collapsing boat episode.
But it's not enough, of course, because when the emperor's decided you're going to die,
you're going to die.
And so he sends soldiers to kill her,
the sailors having shown themselves to be, you know, not up to the task.
And the story that we are told, of which more in a moment,
is that when a soldier approaches her with his sword drawn,
she bears her womb at him and says,
strike here, because this is where she gave birth to Nero.
And so this is the organ that she wants to die through.
Now, this is obviously an excellent and highly melodramatic story.
Emma, is it a little bit too theatrical?
What's going on here?
The exhibition has a fantastic suggestion that is not news to you, I know.
But there might be something genuinely theatrical going on.
There's something very theatrical going on.
Certainly with the last words, strike here,
here is where, you know, this is where you're going to be really killing me,
is taken straight from plays.
And it's incredibly, this comes from Tacitus,
and then is repeated from a Seneca, again, play called The Octavia,
about how much he likes Nero's wife.
And it is very much coming from Tocasta and these ideas of...
And Clytemnestra.
Yeah, and, you know, you are...
The good curses and da-da-da-da-da.
That's sometimes then expanded out to be the whole thing is maybe theatrical,
because the play has the collapsing boat.
In the play, it's not a collapsing boat,
it's an old boat that another boat drives into on purpose,
because no one really seems to understand how the boat worked.
And no one can put it together in their head,
but they know, they're pretty sure that it happened.
And it appears everywhere, so I'm pretty sure that it occurred.
And it was a way for Nero to kill his mother
and still benefit from her popularity,
because the reason that he got the navy to do it
is when he asked Burrus, who's the head of the army, to do it.
He said, no one is going to kill Germanicus's daughter.
There is not a chance that a soldier will...
Like, they'll just turn on you, basically,
which is his greatest fear.
So instead, he gets the navy to do it,
because they don't like her as much.
But everything I think about Nero
and the fact that he was a rubbish son,
apart from the murder,
is the fact that he attempted to kill her
and put a huge amount of effort into getting this boat
and inviting her to dinner and putting on this whole display
so that he could get her on the damn boat
that will collapse and throw her into the water
and didn't know she could swim.
Yes.
It's her own mother, didn't know.
I mean, there is that slight thing, isn't there,
with teenagers, I say with love in my heart for you all,
that you don't always think of your parents as people.
Yeah, she just doesn't think.
Yeah.
And so I think it's completely reasonable that you wouldn't...
I really believe it.
But there's a fantastic bit after the collapsing roof has happened,
where some of the sailors,
realising that the plan hasn't gone as well as they were hoping,
start trying to all be on one side
in order to try and make it tip up.
So perhaps they could all swim.
Maybe, yeah.
But he obviously thought it was going to go better than it did
and that he would be able to be the mourning son of the mother
and possibly deify her
and he would be able to get all of her popularity
and he'd be very sad about the fact that she was dead.
And instead he had to stab her
and everybody said he was a bad man who murdered his mother instead,
which was the exact opposite of what he needed.
Luella, what do you reckon?
I'd like to bring in another birth thing right here.
We've done incest, haven't we?
Because one of the weirdest things about Agrippina,
from a Roman point of view,
and possibly from our point of view actually,
sort of thinking about Roman women,
is that she writes a kind of autobiography.
She writes these commentarii,
which are what sort of established male sort of politicians
write when they've retired.
And we've got a couple of fragments
and one that we're not certain about.
But one that we're not certain about,
but probably comes from this,
is Agrippina describing Nero's birth
and how Nero was a breech birth,
came out feet first.
And because it's in Pliny,
he says that's completely wrong
because he meant to come into the world headfirst
and leave it feet first.
But...
You can always rely on Pliny, can't you?
Pliny, just to bring it all down.
But I mean, she's probably...
I mean, it's a weird thing we might think
to put into an autobiography
because that's meant to be a bad omen.
Yes.
But it also connects him to Agrippa,
who also was meant to be born that way.
So perhaps it's kind of linking him to his past.
But I mean, it's kind of fascinating what is happening,
that she's writing commentaries.
She's writing an account of her life.
A woman is writing an account of her life
in Rome.
But it'll never catch on.
But what is she writing about at the same time?
She's writing about the birth of her son.
That would be a text that would be nice to find somewhere.
But we won't, I don't think.
This is the bit where we have to feel woeful
about the quantity of lost Latin and Greek literature.
So yes, we are where we are.
So Nero's reign is presented to us
and it follows the same narrative arc
as that of earlier emperors,
which is that he starts well,
but everything, the wheels come off
and the quality of his ruling power degrades over time.
So it's usually presented to us
in the case of Caligula, for example,
he starts well, but then gets some kind of brain fever
and then is mad.
And the entire horse's console pinnacle is reached.
With Nero, we're presented with him
when he arrives as emperor.
He's just a child,
but he has these older influential figures
who are, you know, good or bad,
Seneca, Boris, Agrippina,
they nonetheless have a sort of restraining influence on him
as our sources present it.
And then gradually they are shaken off
or murdered or both.
And he becomes a much less good emperor
Llewellyn, I wondered if you would talk to us
about this sort of way that this narrative is built
of good man gone bad.
Is the idea that the office of emperor corrupts inevitably?
Is that what we're aiming for?
Our sources are usually not in favor
of an imperial system, right?
No, exactly.
And I think that's probably the point
where you need to start
is that the sources that we have come
from a fundamentally kind of conservative position
to start with.
I mean, Taustus in particular
is sort of constantly yearning for something
that he'd never experienced,
but something in the past,
which was a Republican government.
And I suppose what is happening with somebody like Nero,
one of the things that's happening with Nero,
I mean, I suggested this a bit before
with the Apokolokentosis is that he's fine
so long as, you know, on a dark night,
you could mistake Nero's principle
for something like the old res publica.
You know, there's something like that going on.
That's becoming less and less something
that you can maintain
as you move through the Julio-Claudians.
But, you know, that seems to be what they're approving of
if he's, you know, allowing the elite
to spread their wings a little bit
and not sort of imposing his power
upon people too badly.
The truth is that the imperial system,
though, is not that.
The imperial system is a strong man
who has control of the armies,
more control than anybody else does.
And it seems to me what happens repeatedly
in this dynasty is the truth
inevitably emerging over time.
And it's when the truth emerges yet again
that Nero gets a bad press.
One exception to this a bit later is Domitian.
On my reading, who's the grandson of Vespasian,
who eventually takes over
after the year of the four emperors,
after Nero's death.
And Domitian, the way I read him at any rate,
is that he just can't be bothered
to pretend how the system works.
And he just says, I'm in charge
because I have big armies and you don't.
And he, again, I mean,
he is just a baddie from the start, really,
as far as anybody is concerned.
But all he's doing is making it clear
what the new system is.
Wake up.
We've been doing this for 100 years.
You know, you haven't noticed
that I'm in charge and you're just pretending.
That's my theory.
I like it.
I like it a lot.
Because, Emma, we were talking upstairs
a bit about this and how what we have
is this formerly ruling class,
the senatorial class,
who basically spend the whole of Nero's reign going,
could I, if I lay on the ground,
could you walk on me?
Yeah.
They are so subservient.
It's actually kind of creepy.
And Tacitus likes to record every single time
that they are subservient.
So he's read all of the senatorial,
like their archiving is quite good.
The Romans, they then lost it all.
But at the time, it was very good.
So he's reading all of the senatorial debates
and things, and they're all saying,
like, hi, Nero.
Hi, hi, hi.
We were thinking maybe we'd change
the month of December to call it Nero
instead of December.
And he says, no.
Because what happens if you have 13 seasons?
What are you going to do then?
And they go, oh, OK.
Can we build you a temple?
Can we?
And he says, no.
And they just keep offering him things,
like, desperately.
Like, please, do you want my daughter?
Do you want me?
Is there anything I can do for you?
Will it get me something?
And eventually, my general theory
is that no matter how high-minded they start out,
so many of them just end up being like,
all right, fine.
God, make me a god.
OK, fine.
Just stop asking.
Then that's certainly how it's going to work for me.
Just FYI.
Just keep asking.
Eventually, I'll say yes.
Yes to deification.
Nero's later years do coincide
with some terrible events.
And you can't always blame an emperor for these.
I would obviously cite poor Titus,
who in power for about 20 minutes,
nonetheless manages to lose both Pompeii and Herculaneum,
which is careless at best.
But Nero is in a position of power in 64,
which is when the great fire of Rome happens.
And I think this is one of the more interesting ways
in which his story is framed.
Because people still now talk about him fiddling
while Rome burns.
And yet, in our sources,
what you get is a really interesting response
to what is genuinely good fire safety measures.
He insists on buildings being further apart,
on them having essentially stone cladding
so that fire can't jump from one wooden building to another.
Flatter roofs, no cooking indoors on an open fire, etc.
And this is all good stuff.
And Tacitus tells us it,
and then basically moves straight to one side to say,
but he built a really big new palace for himself.
He also says like people,
so he says, oh, he made the streets wider
and he made the houses further apart
and he made it look nicer
and everyone hated it because it made the face too hot.
All right.
But I mean, this has to be,
Tacitus says, you know, he's framing the Christians.
Tacitus is not a supporter of Christianity, I might add.
But even Tacitus, oh, everyone thought he was,
it's astonishing, isn't it?
How once you've been decreed a monster,
no matter what good things you do,
it really makes no difference.
Llewellyn, do you feel the same way?
I totally feel the same way.
And in particular, you know,
what he does with Rome after the fire,
which is what, you know, any sensible emperor would do
is, you know, build and in particular,
build a great palace for himself,
which becomes a focus of these authors,
you know, their proof, if proof be needed,
that this guy is just a tyrant,
just out for his own satisfaction,
you know, as tyrants all are.
But it, you know, it makes perfect sense.
Or you could certainly see it as making perfect sense
of Nero's view of his own relationship to Rome
that he places a palace at the heart of Rome.
I mean, what the emperors, amongst other things,
are sort of often trying to do
is kind of square the circle between being all powerful
and being the servant of the people.
And their kind of physical presence in the city
is a token of that.
So it...
Because it's not a guarantee, right?
Tiberius spends years and years not at home,
just refusing to go there.
Exactly, exactly.
So building it, I mean, as far as the text goes,
he built a palace in Rome.
He turned the whole center of Rome into his own playground.
You know, he didn't...
He located himself as emperor in a space
which was available to meetings of the Senate
and presumably sort of people in general
kind of using parts of it as well.
It was about really sort of embodying,
sort of making his presence intrinsic to the city.
And all the emperors had done that to somebody.
Augustus had done this kind of thing as well.
So you're absolutely right.
It's a decision is made.
The narrative becomes Nero is a baddie
and everything is kind of...
is brought to bear to support that.
I think the problem with the big house
is that other people's houses,
they were there previously
and they were like, well, hang on.
I mean, again, so Augustus kind of plays around a bit with this
sort of knocks down Fedius Pollio's house
who used to sort of feed his slaves to lampreys
and sort of, yeah,
as if there's anything particularly wrong with that.
I mean, so yes, it's...
But it depends how we understand that.
So I can't remember what building Augustus puts up
on Fedius Pollio's house,
but it's something good and public.
It's a basilica or some description
or something like that.
If Nero's house is just a palace,
bingo.
OK, that's tyranny.
If Nero's palace is a place
where we can all be with our emperor,
then it's a question,
is it a private residence?
Is it a public residence?
And he could have understood that as a public...
We could understand that as a public residence.
Yeah, I do think it's a matter of
what interpretation you choose to apply.
I mean, we have one indisputable
and enormous piece of evidence
that Nero must have been relatively popular
even after his death
because the Colosseum has...
It takes its name from a colossus
and that was a giant statue of Nero.
So presumably people would have just vandalised it,
wouldn't they?
Or torn it down.
We have fantastic examples of statues of Sejanus
being torn down.
So we have to assume, don't we, a bit,
that he was popular enough after his death.
Well, there were kind of false Neros as well,
afterwards as well.
People who saw it in their interest to say,
I'm Nero, you know, in a way
that it wasn't anybody's interest to say,
I'm Agrippina, as we've heard.
Yeah, but also the Flavians put up
a great big amphitheatre
and we're sort of comfortable with the idea
that that's a people's palace.
You know, the fact that it's a major engine
for directing the people's kind of love
in the direction of the emperor
because he's put on a rhinoceros, you know.
That's fun to watch though.
Watching somebody do a big building project over there,
that's not very fun to watch.
Someone killing a rhinoceros,
that sounds quite...
That's a day out.
Some people are vegetarian.
Put the Romans away.
They're horrible.
Do we accept this?
I like a good building project, you know.
Maybe that's our difference.
You like a good civil engineering project
and I like more blood.
You like rhino death.
God, WWE are going to come for me.
So things kind of go from bad to worse
as far as Nero's reign is concerned
insofar as the chaos which spreads through Rome
as a fire in 64 spreads as revolt.
Across the empire.
And that of course includes us.
Famously, we revolt under Boudicca in 68, 7.
I'm not very good at modern history.
We're revolting anyway.
We are revolting.
We're perpetually revolting.
And so this is my feeling.
This is where Agrippina gets the wrong kind of press
because one of the reasons that these revolts take off
is because the army feels underpaid
and I don't think she would have allowed that to happen.
Partly because she was an army brat
and her dad was in the army.
She was born in an army camp.
Her brother took his nickname Caligula,
meaning little boots from army uniform.
And so she would never have allowed this to happen.
That was my exact question.
What would have happened do you think?
Well, I mean, it all happens as Llewellyn said
in large part because Seneca decides to call in
these massive loans that he's loaned out
to all of the British tribes that they're trying to get on side.
So we're revolting and skinned.
Yeah.
Okay.
Some things don't change, eh?
Because they now have to build loads of Roman stuff
and now somebody needs to pay for it.
And so Seneca calls in all this.
One, she wouldn't have let him do that
because she brings him back from exile
after he is exiled by Claudius for sleeping with her sister.
So she brings him back from exile and he basically owes her.
So she would never have let him do that.
And if I think that she would not have messed about with the army
and also, I feel like if there was a diplomatic solution,
she would have come up with it.
She is extremely good at coming up with a solution
that keeps everybody happy.
And if she could have dealt with that, then she would have.
But at the same time, she was also a Roman.
She probably thought the British all sucked
and were disgusting barbarians in trousers.
Main problem with the British, as all the ancient authors point out,
is that they have this weird tolerance of leaders who are women.
I mean, and that's the main problem.
People like Boudicca and the best of all, Cartamandua.
I love, love Cartamandua.
Outstanding Cartamandua.
But which makes Boudicca and Cartamandua and Agrippina,
all of them kind of victims of this kind of perception
of who can be who can be leaders and who can't be.
It's interesting, though, isn't it, that the literature of the time,
we sort of celebrate poor, tragic Octavia,
who basically just limply turns up and doesn't have a single line.
And yet there are all these incredible women
who would absolutely be in place in Greek tragedy.
And we don't get any sense of them becoming
the sort of literary inspiration that we might have hoped.
Well, no, I mean, to be an appropriate woman,
you're effectively invisible, you know.
And that's Agrippina's great, well, mistake, as it turns out to be.
Yeah, is that she's both seen and heard.
Yeah, and then, you know, she has to be
because this is where the empire is coming from.
She is the connection to the sources of power in the empire.
So it's not just her that's causing this.
Nero's final moments are, again, one of the great deaths,
I would suggest, in ancient literature.
Once he realizes that the whole empire is disintegrating
and collapsing into civil war,
it will result in the year of four emperors
where one after another man tries to take control.
Nonetheless, there is a fantastic sequence,
which we get in great detail,
where he realizes he's going to have to die or be killed,
which will be worse,
and runs around trying to find somebody who'll assassinate him.
At one point, he tries to bribe an ex-gladiator, I think,
and the guy does a runner rather than,
yeah, yeah, give it here, I'll do it, disappears.
And so Nero is reduced to having to stab himself in the neck
while assisted by his secretary, a man named Epaphroditus,
which always seems to me the absolute worst way to die,
that even in your final moment,
you'd still sort of be thinking about Admin.
And his famous last words are, of course,
Qualis Artifex Pereo,
what an artist, but still I die,
which is entirely what I intend to say,
just so you know.
I might put it on record now,
so that if I accidentally say something else
after I've said it and then die, it's there.
I thought we might wrap up,
because I don't want to keep you here getting cold,
but we started a little bit late,
so I don't want to shortchange you either.
I thought we might wrap up by my asking you,
since this is the end of one dynasty,
since this is where the Julio-Claudians stop
and then chaos ensues,
there has actually been quite a successful,
easy route to who inherits the throne up to now.
There haven't been civil wars
and the end of Nero creates chaos,
but it's relatively quickly brought under wraps by Vespasian.
We were talking upstairs
about the intrinsically experimental nature of empire,
which is, at the time of Nero's reign,
still only a few decades old,
and I wondered, Llewellyn,
if you might talk us through that a little bit,
if I throw to Emma for the last word.
Sure, yes.
I was thinking about this in relation to Agrippina,
actually Agrippina the Younger,
who we've referred to a few times,
who, you know, you look at the accounts of what she does
and you think,
this person seriously believes that she can share power,
she seriously believes that her ancestry is such
and her gender is not so much of an issue
that she can have some power,
and to us, knowing the Romans,
we think, never, it's never going to happen,
that's crazy,
but it seems to me that the empire is, as you say,
such an extended exercise in experimentation.
Nobody at any particular point,
I'm exaggerating here,
but nobody at any particular point
in the Julio-Claudian dynasty
really knows what they're doing,
they don't know what the plan is
to sort out this fundamental problem,
which is that an individual is going to be in power,
but somehow we're going to maintain Roman tradition
at the same time.
So in that context,
why might it not be the case
that the true significance of women in this family
would be reflected in the power
they actually exerted in Rome?
It isn't so outlandish under those circumstances, I think.
And just as Nero thinking,
why shouldn't I put a dirty great big palace
in the middle of a city?
Because everybody is discovering,
attempting to discover what the answer is,
and getting more and more difficult to know, I guess.
And there's this essential contradiction, isn't there,
between somebody having ultimate power
and everyone pretending sort of that they don't,
but everyone's just consented to it.
And in a way, once you have that,
you must think, well, if not me, then who?
So in Nero's case,
there's so much disparaging commentary
on the fact that he sees himself as a singer and an actor,
because these are professions
that a slave or a freedman would have.
So he is too, this is a status issue,
but also there's a sort of vanity issue.
There's a fantastic sequence in Suetonius,
and I think also in Tacitus,
where women are giving birth
because his performances are so long.
Men are pretending to be dead
so they can get carried out of the theatre
without it being an insult, et cetera.
But you think, well, if you had ultimate power,
you would probably be thinking, why not me?
If I want to take part in a singing competition,
why wouldn't I?
And also, just because some stuffy senators don't like it,
doesn't mean nobody likes this.
It doesn't mean that, you know,
he isn't performing to a satisfied audience.
I'm not the ones who are pretending to be dead,
probably, no, but.
Amber, what do you think?
I think the contradiction at the centre
of the Roman principa
is that it's a principa, not an emperor.
If they all just admitted that they had a king,
then they'd all be a lot happier.
But they keep calling it principa and princeps
and the first citizen.
It just so happens that the best person amongst us
to make all the decisions is the son of the previous guy.
And it is everybody just pretending that they agree,
actually, that this is a democracy
and that Augustus gave back the republic and restored it.
And they'd all be just a lot happier and easier
if none of them believed that they could one day be emperor,
which is what they really want.
Like when Tacitus is writing about how bad emperors is,
what he means is, I want the ability to compete
so that I could be the top man one day,
or my son could be the top man,
and we could all have something,
we could all have power like that.
And if they had all been able to find a way to just go,
you know what, guys, give it up,
then far fewer people would have been murdered
and probably emperors wouldn't have gone so bad
because there would have been a way through being a king
that made sense.
But it doesn't make any sense the way that they do it
and the way that they insist for hundreds and hundreds of years
that they do not have a king
and that he is ruling with the consent of all of the Senate
and the people of Rome do things, not him,
and is a ludicrous way to send every single person involved
completely insane, which is what it does.
Ladies and gentlemen, the Romans,
we hope very much that you'll be able to go
to the Nero exhibition before it ends,
which is in October, I'm going to say.
And I'm going to say it with so much confidence,
it's going to sound like it's true.
It's in October.
We have loved being back here with you tonight.
I hope you're happy to be back in the perimeter, I guess,
the confines of the museum,
even though we're not yet indoors.
But thank you very much to my guests for joining me,
to Emma and Llewellyn.
I've been Natalie Haynes
and we hope we'll see you back here soon.