This video is in response to a video demonstrating that soft shackles reduced the strength of webbing sewn loops too much to be safe on a highline. We did over 10 break tests to demonstrate that they are super good enough. We even broke a 12mm quicklink with a super old 8mm soft shackle.
Thank you Lorenzo DeMuro and Kyle Lovett for helping make this video.
Stephan Chalkowski from Raed Slacklines is a good slackline company and this is a friendly dispute over two schools of thoughts about a unique tool that we use in highlining to make our rigs lighter and in my opinion (mixed with imperical data)... stronger. I appreciate anyone who makes an effort to move us forward in our slack knowledge. Cheers Stephan!
All donations go straight back into making this channel better. We put donors names in the ending credits and give them exclusive access to the SlackSnap Raw Data spreadsheet + corresponding footage associated with each break. This all couldn't happen without you!
Are soft shackles dangerous on sew-in loops? Find out with these guys on this episode of How Not
to Highline. I am Ryan Jenks, this is Lorenzo DeMuro, and this is K-Love, Kyle Lovett, and we
are here at the Slacks That Machine to find out and to put to rest a dispute against soft shackles
on sew-in loops. The concern is the same concern I had when I first saw sew-in loops on soft
shackles or vice versa, is it squishes it like this, which can be bad for your webbing and
actually reduce the MBS or the braiding strength that you actually get. We don't have sew-in loops
here at our disposal, so what we're doing is sticking it in a weblock and the tail is right
here, so there's actually four layers in here, giving this ultimate strength so it breaks right
here because so oftentimes it breaks at the stitching, and we want it to break right here.
We want to find out how strong it is with different connectors, and that's what we're
going to test today. We're going to test it with quick links, five mil soft shackles,
six mil soft shackles. We're going to turn it around, put it on the fat side. We're going to
test the shit out of this, and now the video that brought this up as a dispute used helium
from Rad's Lack Lines, and we just happen to have some, so we're going to do an apples-for-apples
test here, and then we're going to test it padded, and we're just going to test and test and test
because, as you can see here, we love testing things, as this is sample number 508. Oh my god,
it broke at the loop. Does it smell funny? No, no heat. Hmm, the soft shackle's fine? Weird.
Granted, I've used and abused these. Hmm, hmm, 19.35. That's interesting because
the other test that was done was only 14 kilonewtons, but 19.35 is pretty good before
my soft shackle ruined the webbing, and that is 4,150 pounds, and that, let's take note,
is on the skinny side. Shall we test it on the fat side? So we now have reset this up,
and now this is the fatter side. The diameter, since the tails of the button knot are buried
right here, is actually twice the diameter as this side, and this is properly loaded,
even though all of our brake tests show that no matter how you install this, it doesn't come off.
It's not trying to pull this noose off of the head. It actually is pulling kind of favorably,
but anyways, let's find out what this brake's at.
We need to maybe shorten this up. That's pretty violent. Oh, what did we get? 22.5
and 5,000 pounds of force. Shall we test, um, what should we test next? 5 millimeter or padded?
Okay, 5 mil. So now we have downgraded to 5 millimeter. What I'm holding here in my hand
is 6 millimeter, and you can compare here that we are telling the truth. This is a 5 mil, and we
orientated it poorly on the worst part, scrunching the shit out of it. So look, no micro fractures
when you drop it. Okay, um, I do estimate this will brake lower, but super good enough. Let's
find out. I really need to wear ear protection. Okay, so we're breaking our loops here, right?
We're breaking our loop. Our soft shackle is just fine. It's got a little red mark on it.
16.65. I consider this worst case scenario on a webbing that's not, um, that fantastic. A padded
loop on a 6 mil soft shackle. This is literally what I do on every Highline. Cheese and rice.
Okay, so it fell out of the padding, which is awesome because now we get to use it again.
23.25 kilonewtons or 5,200 pounds, which is actually not that much more. Um, but all loops
are padded. That is a realistic situation for how I've used all my Highlines. So I'm, I'm
pretty happy with that considering it's on this webbing. Let's find out what the RBS, the realistic
braking strength of this is by putting in two web locks to find out what it actually brakes at in
real life. So Helium's NBS, which is minimum braking strength is 24 kilonewtons on the website.
I would like to note that we're using 6 millimeter soft shackles to brake everything and Dyneema on
the slack snap machine. I just think that's fun to point out. Let's find out if we get 24
kilonewtons. How not to protect somebody's dyno. Just don't tell Lorenzo I'm ******* up his dyno.
It's not 24. Whoa. Oh, it's because our radius is too small. Cause in a lab where they come up
with 24 is, um, a giant diverter that we don't use in a Highline situation. Now I'm not upset
by this. I just think the manufacturer's bullshit strength NBS should probably reflect what it is in
a web lock. And maybe in a frost knot, since we use that, and maybe in the so in loop, since they
provide so in loops, it'd be nice to know what those break at too. So we can make accurate
judgments when we go Highlining with this webbing. Now, keep in mind, Helium is not a Highline
webbing. Basically Helium isn't structured to handle, uh, abuse, um, and stay super strong.
So anyways, um, this is pretty damn new webbing. How old do you think this is Kyle?
Um, probably like a year. Oh, it is a year old. Okay. Okay. Fair enough. Fair enough. It's a year
old, uh, 20.5 kilonewtons. Now this is an interesting test because this quick link on
this loop is the alternative to those who don't like soft shackles. This is what people promote
is metal on rope products. And that is actually better. They are less likely to cut through
things as rope on rope moving over each other can cut through things. However, statically pulling,
they don't. Now, something interesting you'll notice on this eight millimeter quick link is
how much it's bending the webbing. It's basically identical to what the soft shackle does now on a
master point, a normal one, you use a bow shackle, which you can either use the pin, which would
keep it ultra flat or the bow part, which is actually also, uh, friendly towards the loop.
However, if you're doing the Eno split and connecting 50 meter pieces in to end on larger
high lines, which is a way I've been promoting in all my videos lately, uh, this is the alternative
method to connecting those high lines is these eight millimeter quick links, but you can notice
that it's still causes this issue, which is the concern. So let's find out, um, how strong this
is. So this is 22.45 kilonewtons, which is identical to the six millimeter soft shackle.
When we put it on the fat side, identical now, Lorenzo, can you, with your two hands,
tell me if that quick link is damaged. Can you unscrew it? When you take quick links to close
to the breaking strength, they basically become useless. They become damaged and no longer safe to
slack line or high line on. Whereas a soft shackle, you can basically take almost all the
way to its, uh, breaking strength and still continue to use it. This thing started to stretch
and bend, uh, which is it's steel. So it doesn't just break like an aluminum object like carabiners,
which is why aluminum is dangerous. This thing is basically warped so badly that it cannot be
unscrewed. And so this is now damaged and I have to basically throw it away. So some fun facts about
quick links versus soft shackles. So now we're going to put to test quick links versus soft
shackles. This right here is a large soft shackle, and this is a six millimeter, uh, just because it
fits in there nicely. And I'm not trying to overstretch this, but what we're testing in this
situation is a five millimeter soft shackle versus a eight millimeter camp stainless steel quick link.
Now this one was the one that was overstretched in sample 513, but we're going to finish busting
it up and then we're going to go to bigger and bigger quick links to find out how strong
our five millimeter is. Now this is on a tripod because I don't want to stand next to this.
All right. 32 kilonewtons. How warm is it? Definitely got some heat to it.
That is pretty cool. How's our soft shackle? What? Something happened.
Uh, no, nope. It's pretty much scrunchied up against this. It was probably, I bet you the
soft, I'm curious to see the slow-mo. Interesting. I didn't slow-mo that one, but uh, huh. I bet the
soft shackle damage might have just come from that sharp hook. It probably could. Um, we're
going to find out how strong, we're going to keep seeing if we can keep breaking quick links.
Now for the grand finale, a five millimeter soft shackle and a 12 millimeter galvanized
quick link. Uh, this is eight mil. This is half inch. That's a big shackle. That's a lot of pulleys.
We'll find out which one's going to win. Oh, so this did not break. Okay. The head, when it's,
uh, not tightened enough, because this is a pretty new soft shackle, even though we did tighten it,
uh, quick link seems to be fine. Our results are 41.45 kilonewtons. So please don't troll me on
that. Um, I don't know. Maybe we should try the hard six mil that we have. Wow. That feel,
feel how warm that is. It's super deformed. Yeah. Yeah. Wow. Okay. Um, okay. So this is our same
12 millimeter quick link that still works. Um, but we're going to use it with a six millimeter
soft shackle. Cause I usually get a mid sixties to 70 kilonewtons out of this. And we're going
find out if we can break this with a smaller soft shackle and don't like to stand next to
these when these break. Okay. 12 mil is still functional at some level and our six mil broke
and all right, go 12 mils. Cause you know, those are practical. Uh, 54. This is a six
Miller millimeter that I have used and abused for 516 samples. It's not been on every single one,
but it has been on a lot of them. And I have reduced the strength significantly because where
it bends around all the stuff and the loops that I've used it on, it broke right there. Um, I
wonder if I did get, uh, I have gotten 70 kilonewtons out of a six mil before. I wonder if
that would break this 12, 12 mil grand finale of 12 millimeter quick link versus not these giant
half inch soft shackles, but my use and abused eight millimeter soft shackle here,
these are just the tails that are buried. And when the tails get buried around the end here,
the stretching and stretching makes them look like this. So ignore that they're perfectly fine.
But, um, we had to put on my 20,000 pound dino, which is for bolt busters coming soon to how not
Oh, bitches. Oh, that's hot. That's, that's pretty warm. You want it? You want to see how
warm it is? What's that? My eight millimeter soft shackle is still mostly functioning.
Let's see here. We'll get to the forces soon, folks. Just what do you think Lorenzo? It's a
little Nard little Nard, but, uh, still, still functioning. What's cool about soft shackles is
they're still pretty usable. Even if you take them, uh, past some serious limits, you can see
here the glazing and the use and abuse that I've done to these over the years, over the year that
I've slack snapped. Yeah, it's pretty bad. Pretty bad. Okay. Really bad. I'm still going to use it
on everything. And that was 68.4 kilonewtons. Fun fact, six millimeter soft shackles. I have gotten
70 kilonewtons before. So technically a six millimeter, if I played with that 12 millimeter
long enough would have broken it. And then over here, we got 15,250 pounds of force.
What do you think Kyle? I like soft shackles. What do you think Lorenzo? What we got here was
the, in the RBS realistic breaking strength of helium was 20.55 kilonewtons and a six millimeter,
um, unfavorably put on the loop was 19.35. So that's basically full strength, maybe one
kilonewton under full strength. But when we put the fat side on the loop, it's actually stronger
than you would even get in a web lock. Keep in mind, uh, web blocks are going to be stronger
than any sewn loop, even though we can get sewn loops pretty strong with seven to 10 bar tacks of
thread number 138. We have a video coming out shortly on that. Um, five millimeter softy on
the skinny side, which is worst case scenario was 16.65, which is actually higher than the
test of the other video showing that soft shackles are dangerous on loops. Six millimeter
softy on a padded loop, a padded loop of course gave us more as well, almost 0.75 more than our
fat six millimeter right here. So then we wanted to show off our soft shackles and we love them so
much. Five millimeter soft shackle, eight millimeter quick link, and they basically
both broke, but that's because the quick link cheated and cut it on the way out.
And we tried breaking this 12 mil with a five mil, six mil, and we finally broke it with just
an eight mil, which is pretty gnarly. At 68.4 kilonewtons, the eight mil softy still works,
sort of, but either way, these forces are ridiculous. We never put more than six
kilonewtons on a highline. So I'm feeling like this is all super good enough. And
uh, I think soft shackles are safe on sewn loops. Now consider that we are super biased towards
soft shackles while testing helium instead of quick links. And you're going to get science
with lots of biases, including those who decide to not like soft shackles. Now, anybody I've met
who doesn't like a soft shackle has never owned a soft shackle and used it in their rig.
Uh, as much as we like to tease, uh, Stefan is, has an awesome company. He has a good point about
soft shackles on sewn loops. If, um, no, he doesn't. The whole time I was like,
I'm all for your ride, but I'm right there. So this is a friendly rebuttal that we like to tease
people who don't own soft shackles, who like to dispute them. Uh, Stefan and Rad company is
somebody I buy gear from. I like him. He's awesome. We're just making a fun rebuttal video
that defends our belief that soft shackles are safe on sewn loops. And, uh, we want to hear more
about the tests he did because I do want to understand how you get 14 kilonewtons when
pulling a sewn loop with a soft shackle, because we don't want to have 14 kilonewtons. However,
high lines are still only six ish kilonewtons ever. So we do want to maintain as much safety
as possible, but we also, especially in Yosemite and big hikes, we have to go light. And this
doesn't work for me. And the Enov split and everything else depends on soft shackles being
used. I actually converted all of my Enov split soft shackles to five millimeters.
And we're going to do a lot of tests on that and a future video coming out soon.
So thank you Stefan for bringing up this topic as we would like to continue to discuss it further
and want to see your independent tests and see how the quick links compare and weblock to weblock
and other soft shackle tests, including, uh, six mils on the fat side, and just get a thorough
testing from your side of the world to make sure that our stuff here is accurate because we want
the information to be awesome. So we like to make sure high lining is super safe. However,
we're standing next to a break test machine. That's not covered why all this shit breaks,
risking our lives for your information. Therefore you shouldn't highline and remember,
keep the balance. It's rad.