Testing the FASTEST Road Bike Money Can Buy

IS THIS THE BEST RIDE
1 follower
May 27, 2024
All right, this is the Scotfoil RC Pro recently independently wind tunnel tested as the fastest
road bike you can buy. And to my left, another aero road bike, the Winspace, was not tested as
the fastest road bike you can buy. In fact, I don't think they tested this bike at all. So today,
here's what we're going to do. We're going to test this claim out in the real world and find
out if it's worth spending $11,000 or if you can spend less than half that on the Winspace. Hang
So how exactly am I going to objectively measure the performance difference between these two
bikes? Well, the secret is in these pedals because these aren't normal pedals. These
are power meter pedals. In other words, they measure the amount of force I am pushing into
the bike at any given moment. And in real time, that information is transmitted right up here to
my cycling computer, which I can monitor. So here's what we're going to do. There's a five
mile loop in this neighborhood. I'm going to put the pedals on the Scott. I'm going to run the loop
and then I'm going to swap pedals, put them on the Winspace, run the same loop with the same
power in the same position. And we're going to find out which bike can do the loop faster. But
here's the thing. Performance isn't just how fast the bike can ride a five mile loop. There's more
to it than that. There's also how heavy is the bike, right? You're probably all wondering what
does an 11,000 pound bike weigh? Well, first, keep in mind, these are aero bikes, so
lightweight isn't their main focus, but it's still pretty impressive. So, um, let's see what the Scott
weighs. And the Winspace. All right. So when it comes to weight, I want to give the wind to the
Scott because it's lighter after all. But here's the thing. The Scott has 50 millimeter wheels.
The Winspace has 67. So kind of a wash when it comes to weight. And actually, one thing I forgot
to mention is we're going to be swapping wheels in between runs too. So not only are we going to
figure out which bike is faster, I also want to answer the question, which wheel set is faster.
Stay tuned for that. Okay. But what else goes into a high performance race bike like this?
And one thing is compliance, stiffness, how the bike feels when you're out actually riding it.
And for this, I have to give the wind to the Scott. And the reason actually might surprise
you a little bit. The Winspace is too stiff. Like it is unforgiving. So, um, we, we especially feel
this back here in the rear triangle. This is something that I noticed right away. And this
is something that will, when we did our review of this bike also picked out. And, um, as a reminder,
guys, I have logged a lot of miles on both these bikes. The difference isn't huge. I'll be perfectly
honest with you, but the rear triangle you will notice is very stiff on the Winspace. I've done
six hour, a hundred mile rides on it. You just have to get the fit just right. But
Scott does something special. I don't know if that's where some of the money goes
into the carbon layup, into the carbon type, something like that. It feels compliant where
you want it. It feels stiff where you want it. Winspace stiff all over. So Scott wins when it
comes to the actual ride, feel, ride quality. All right. And the last thing I want to talk
about is how these brands actually implement their aerodynamic design, because this is actually
really important. For example, the Winspace uses a standard steer, which means I can put on any
bar and stem I want. It is a standard setup. The Scott on the other hand, ouch, one inch
proprietary steer, which means you are stuck in their ecosystem. This is fine. If you know exactly
what your setup is and there's going to be no tweaking of anything. But for example,
if you want to go from like a hundred millimeter stem to 120 millimeter stem, that's going to be
expensive because you're going to have to buy their setup. It's going to be $800. I think on
their website and good luck. It's usually not in stock. This is potentially a big problem. I mean,
you could put a shim in there, but you're shimming a steer on a high-end bike. That's
just like the Achilles heel of the bike. You don't want that to break. You're going to interest
introduce yourself to the pavement real fast. And the other thing that I want to talk about is tire
clearances, right? We did tests on this exact course. A few weeks ago, we learned that spoiler
ahead, wider tires are faster. 34s even we realized are a lot faster than 28s. Well, look
at the Scott. There isn't much clearance for wider tires. These are 28s on here. Now, if we bump this
up to 30, maybe we would start to get rubbed. 32s, 34s, especially out of the question. Wind space,
on the other hand, we got clearance for days. I think I could put, I mean, I know I can put 34s.
We've done that on this bike. We could go even higher. So those are a couple of considerations.
I'm getting rambly here. I think I should just hop on the bike,
do a couple of runs and figure out actually which bike is faster on the course.
All right. Results are in. Let's just dive right into it. Shall we? Okay. First run. Of course,
we did it on the Scott Foil RC. We did it with the Dura-Ace 50 millimeter wheels,
and it took us 14 minutes and 34 seconds to complete this loop, averaging 271 watts.
And then, of course, we came back, we swapped out the wheels. We put on the 67,
slightly deeper wheels, and we did one fewer watt, 270, and actually we saved
five seconds. 14 minutes, 29 seconds. But here's probably the thing that you came here for. How
did the much cheaper Winspace stack up to the Scott Foil? And the first run we did on the
Winspace, of course, it had the 50 millimeter wheels and 14 minutes and 31 seconds at 270 watts.
So essentially the same, a couple of seconds different. And then when we put the 67 stock
wheels back on the Winspace, that was the fastest run, but 14.24 at 271 watts. It's about the same.
So I'll be honest with you guys. I was a little bit disappointed when I saw these results because
it's like, Jeff, you're doing another test video with no big conclusions, but there is a big
conclusion because don't forget this thing costs $11,000 and we are testing it at essentially the
same speed as a bike that costs less than half that. So save your money, right? Yes and no. I
mean, first of all, let's not forget one thing we didn't talk about. This paint job is pretty nice.
So if you want to pay for a paint job, I think this is Scott is the best looking bike you can
buy. I'll say it. It's a personal thing. I think this is a great looking bike, but today we learned
that these modest powers and speeds, you're not going to get a huge performance benefit.
Does that mean the wind tunnel testing is crap? Probably not. Probably this thing starts to shine
at higher speed. That's my suspicion because the wind tunnel testing was independent third-party.
So here's another consideration is Scott has US support. Scott has bike shops. They have
authorized dealers. They have somebody you can speak to in English. They have crash replacement.
Actually, I'm not sure that either of these companies have crash replacement. Drop a comment
down below if you know if Scott or Winspace has crash replacement, but you're going to get much
better English speaking support from a company like Scott. Winspace, not so much. And I realized
these Chinese companies are leading the way in getting better in that regard, but this is
another consideration why you might want to spend more money. But for me, who I like to wrench and
tweak on my own bikes, it's a no brainer. Save your money, get the Winspace, but I'd love to hear
you guys' opinions on this. So please drop a comment down below and let me know what I should
test in the next video. I absolutely love making these. So thanks for hanging in there. I'll catch
you guys in the next one.
