Coil Vs Air - Which Is Best? | Blind Trail Testing MTB Suspension

RockShades
98 followers
#sport #travel #running #marathon #cycling #bicycle #training #race #triathlon #swim #bike #run #adventure #inspire
At one point, coil shocks reigned supreme, then air shocks got better and it was, well,
for want of a better term, the era of the air shocks.
More tunable and lighter, they were all the rave, but now we seem to be going back to
coil shocks.
Are they actually an upgrade and well, can they make me any faster?
Let's find out.
Before we crack on, why not like and subscribe to the GMBN channel for all the latest and
greatest in the mountain bike world, but right, let's get cracking.
Coil versus air, there is no right or wrong answer when it comes to choosing a shock.
Both have particular merits, if you like, and both work great in certain situations,
which is what we're going to get into a bit later in the video, but first, we need to
understand how these shocks work.
For that, to the tech set.
Here we are in the set then, which I thought we'd do a little shock explainer before we
actually hit the trails.
We're going to kick things off with an air shock.
Now, an air shock uses pressure in chambers to control its compression.
As the shock compresses, essentially, that feeling of it ramping up or getting firmer
towards the end of the stroke as the air is squished inside that chamber, gives it a kind
of progressive feeling.
Air shocks can be tuned using the rebound and compression dials often found on the unit
itself.
Another bonus to the air shock is it can actually be altered, it's feeling, if you like, by
using volume spacers or bands, if you like, which reduce the air volume or change the
size of the air volume within the shock to give it that different feeling of progressivity
depending upon how many you put inside.
A coil shock, named for obvious reasons, has a much more linear feel to it.
That coil there, when it compresses under load, compresses at the same rate the whole
way through.
The shock will feature a damper inside it to control this rate, and then the rebound
is controlled by the rate of oil flow coming back through it as it returns through its
travel.
What do we really mean when we say progressive or a linear feel?
Essentially, we're talking about just how much force is required to compress that suspension.
Let's dive in a little more.
A progressive suspension system will need exponentially more force to compress the suspension.
Put simply, it gets progressively harder to compress the shock, to compress the unit as
you go through its travel.
In contrast, a linear system will require a linear amount of force to compress the shock.
The force needed to compress your shock will increase at a consistent rate as you go through
the travel.
The suspension design of your bike might be a deciding factor as to which unit you might
be thinking of, coil or air.
If your frame design's got a fairly linear curve to it, then you might be thinking of
an air shock.
That way, you can tune it to ramp up a little more towards the end of the stroke if you
find yourself blowing through the travel, especially.
On the flip side to that, if you think your frame's got a fairly progressive leverage
curve to it, then you might be thinking of something with a more linear feel like the
coil shock to it.
That's exactly what we're going to be looking at today and trying to figure out and compare
the pair of them.
If you are thinking of changing the shock on your frame, be sure to check with the manufacturer
that isn't going to void the warranty if you swap the shock out and that that shock is
actually going to be compatible.
After listening to all that, you might be thinking, well, that's great, but I'm still
not quite sure what the right shock for me is.
Well, I did a little bit of research into who's using what out there and dived in combining
the top 10 men and women from the 2024 World Champs in downhill, enduro, and XC and looked
at what they were using.
Here's some interesting results.
In cross-country, it's 100% air shocks across the board.
This is down to weight saving and the size of the shock.
A coil shock generally just doesn't fit in these types of bike.
In downhill, things swayed heavily in favor of coil shocks.
With 17 of 20 using the coil shock, that's 85% of who I looked at.
Whilst in enduro, it was a more mixed affair with seven of 20 using coil, but it did sway
more in favor of air, 65% of riders opting for the lighter shock.
But why?
Well, for that, let's ask the pros themselves.
Hey, Ray.
How are we doing?
I'm good.
How are you?
I'm good.
It's been a while, isn't it?
It's been a wee bit, yes.
Yes.
Okay.
Coil or air?
Which is it for you?
I've been running air for the last, I think, three or four years.
Okay.
Were you coil before?
I have been coil.
I've switched.
There's a couple of seasons which I'll switch quite often, even per race, I'd switch between
air and coil.
But yes, for the last probably three solid years, it's been, yes, just air all the way.
I'm interested.
Why is that?
Why the more permanent switch?
If you've been going between the two, why the more permanent switch between the two?
I think it probably more came down to the bike's kinematics.
I found that with the live frames, they're progressive, but they're more towards the
linear side of things.
I think that the coil was really good, but you're pinned quite far against one setting.
Whereas with the air shock, I could change the curve within the shock so you could do
different spaces and like positive or negative chambers or even change the air can.
Just sort of the tunability side.
Obviously, like you said, you ran a coil and certainly went between the two for a long
time.
I'm assuming there was moments when you preferred the coil?
Yes, definitely.
The one place that springs to mind was Whistler.
Just when you have, yes, there's so much chunder there and you're having huge runs.
We used to do a race stage from top of the world all the way to the bottom.
Yes, I did.
I remember.
That was like a 20-minute stage, wasn't it?
It was massive.
Yes, 20-minute stage.
Absolutely.
The coil did feel amazing there.
I think it got less affected by heat buildup and yes, you can just smash through everything.
I also quite liked the coil because I do think it requires a lot less maintenance and it's
a bit more set and forget.
Easy on that front.
Lastly, have you got any kind of secret tune in on yours or is it a pretty stock shock
what you're running?
It might be a little bit of something in there.
I think nothing major, but maybe a few extra fancy seals and stuff like that.
Nothing crazy, but just make it a bit more buttery slipperiness.
Yes, a little smoother.
Yes, a little bit smoother, yes, but it's still, stock, it's still amazing.
Awesome.
All right, Ray, that's great.
Thank you for the catch-up.
It's been good to have your insights into coil and air.
Yes, honestly, anytime.
Yes.
Yes, wicked.
Well, there we have it.
Straight from the pros' mouths, what they use and why, but for the more average Joes
of us out there, I'm really still not quite any clearer as to whether a coil shock is
actually an upgrade over an air shock.
Now, throughout the video, you might have noticed I've not had a bike, but I'm kitted
up.
Well, there's a reason for that.
The bike has been at the bottom.
Last night, I got my arts and craft skills out with the help of Amy on the sewing machine
and made my super secret shroud.
The bike has been at the bottom with cameraman Louie there, actually, who's been putting
on a mystery shock for me.
Underneath there, I don't know whether there's an air or a coil shock.
We're going to do some blind runs, see if I can actually tell the difference on two
shocks which are pre-set up for me.
We're going to do a flow trail and a much more Tekkers downhill trail, identify which
is which, hopefully, and maybe look at a couple of times along the way.
Let's get cracking with the flow trail.
If there's an air shock in it, it should get a little bit lighter, a little bit more flickable,
but if there's a coil shock, it might trap the ground nicely with that small bump sensitivity.
Oh, that felt nice through there.
It felt like it ramped up, which I would say would be air shock.
It feels nice and floaty through these jumps.
Mystery setup number one, rough downhill track.
Okay, setup one done.
Now, I got a few thoughts and feelings on this on both the flow and the downhill track.
Initial thoughts, it was quite a progressive setup.
I'm hoping that means it was the air shock on there.
I'm not calling it just yet.
I need to give it a bit more thoughts.
It felt nice and smooth.
It felt pretty light, especially on the flow trail jumping around.
The back end felt pretty good.
It felt quite progressive, like I said.
I think now we need to obviously get the stealth setup, whatever's going on in here, down to
our cameraman, Luigi, who's going to do a shock change, and we'll get back out on the trail.
Right, to the van.
Okay, let's swap it over, see if Rich notices, and cue the time-lapse.
Shock switched, flow trail.
How am I going to notice?
Oh, nice jumps.
Mystery setup.
Number two now, back on the downhill track.
Is it going to feel any different?
It starts a little flat on this track, and we get into the steeper rough stuff in a bit.
All right, thoughts.
Shock feels very linear.
Characteristic of a coil shock.
Is that what this one is?
I'm not sure, but big G out there.
Shock felt like it ramped up nicely.
I'd say that was quarter.
Yes, sorry.
I'm getting my words muddled up.
Small bump, and then simply down.
All this chattery stuff is delightful.
Back end feels maybe a little lighter on the jumps there.
Done.
The shroud of secrecy has remained in place.
I really generally cannot see what shock's on what.
I've got a good idea of which setup I think is which, but as the light starts to leave us here in the Forest of Dean,
I think it's time we get back in the set and discuss our findings.
I'll see you back there.
No, this isn't the set.
I'm in Alicante.
It was too gloomy, so I thought I'd wait to summarize on my next shoot.
Look, we need to get down to it.
Setup number one, setup number two, I'm going to call it.
Setup number one was the coil shock, making number two the air shock.
Luigi?
Correct.
Hey, that's what we like to hear.
I was a little bit worried, but I've ridden that bike a lot and on various setups.
Do you know what?
I was really able to drill into exactly how the bike felt.
Ultimately, we're talking about whether a coil shock is actually an upgrade for your bike.
Now, yes, on the whole, I think depending upon the type of riding that you do,
a coil shock is a definitive upgrade.
If you're into free riding, downhill, gnarly trail riding, enduro,
then the advantages that we spoke about from a coil shock do outweigh that of an air shock.
However, coils don't fit on all types of bikes.
We've got to bear that in mind, and you need to bear that in mind
if you are thinking of spec-ing your bike.
There is a weight penalty.
The tunability now of air shocks is incredible,
so you can get them feeling absolutely spot on.
There we go.
I want to know what you think in the comments down below.
Would you consider upgrading to a coil shock?
Or are you fine with your air shock?
Which is it going to be?
Let me know in the comments, people.
It's been an absolute pleasure.
From Alicante, I'll see you next time.
