Einar Askestad välkomnar idén om en svensk kulturkanon men riktar hård kritik mot regeringens lista. Han menar att en kanon alltid finns naturligt genom de verk som överlever tack vare sin kvalitet, men att kommittén bakom förslaget har en ”kulturmarxistisk” syn som betonar sociala och politiska kontexter istället för konstnärliga kvaliteter.
Han framhåller att konst av hög klass står över tidens politiska och sociala villkor och att stor konst berör på djupet. En kanon som väljer verk på andra grunder än kvalitet är enligt honom ingen riktig kanon.
Askestad ifrågasätter också att samhällsfenomen som pappaledighet eller lagtexter inkluderas, vilket han beskriver som ”bisarrt”. Han menar att detta reducerar kanon till ett politiskt projekt, snarare än en samling av de främsta konstnärliga och kulturella mästerverken.
Eino Askestad culture editor at Epoch Times
Today Parisa Lillestrand released the cultural canon
What are your initial reactions
Yes after looking more closely at it I am obviously in favor of a canon for the simple reason tha
A canon exists regardless of whether someone has designated it or not
Canon is just the traded the one that has survived the one that has such quality
So that new generations want to keep it and adopt it and learn from it
The problem with Lars Trädgård's committee and his friends and their approach to the cultural canon questio
It is that they have a we can call it a cultural
Marxist view of they have a contextualization of culture
Therefore the concepts of culture and art that they have are problematic
I would say that it misses what is culture and art
After all what is art or culture is precisely what is most excellent
It's what's best in whatever it is whether it's visual art or literature
But they have actually taken a more contextual societal approach to who they choose
They have fallen out over things so to speak perhaps much has been talked about for example
Oh that's something entirely different how much something has been noticed
It says nothing about the artwork and its qualities
A canon is simply the absolute best that has ever been
produced within a culture that should be highlighted
Oh they have completely missed that dimension through this which is
a more social and societal understanding of what is culture and art
Under a press conference Lars Trädgård said that he quoted a woman who
stated that art can only be seen in a political and historical context
What do you think about it
I think it's completely wrong
So what distinguishes a high-quality artwork is that it stands above
Highlighting the social and political dimension that shifts over time
How could a Greek drama speak to us if it were merely so to speak a reflection of social and political realities
This is problematic because of the idealistic aspect of art
What strives for what is higher more universal and true on a higher level
But then beauty and goodness and other such qualities disappear completely
That's why they can select literary works for example they choose them
It just feels completely arbitrary and some things you don't understand at all
It has to do with other aspects a form what's it called Taiko I think that's her name
I mean it's not because of its literary quality that it's chosen but rather other aspects
A canon that chooses based on anything other than quality is no canon
In this canon one has certainly built in economic and economic historical aspects
Also the legal provisions the freedom of the press act is included the constitution is included the industrial area in Norrköping is included
The point of this seems to be that one wants an inclusive and in some way explanatory image of Swedish culture
What are you missing out on by doing it that way
So I have no problem with that aspect of it but that maybe one shouldn't call it canon
They've basically divided the artwork the art so to speak and that's one aspect of it
But then they have this societal cultural dimension
I don't have much to say about it even though it might also feel a bit pretentious that they've chosen something as typically Swedish
Some pal edicts should be part of some cultural canon
It would almost be bizarre I would say
My main objection which also explains why they have now made this division and generally think along these lines
It's just how one defines and perceives art and culture
Oh but it's a shame that the qualitative and idealistic aspect of what culture and art are is completely overlooked
This striving for something higher is entirely absent
Everything is explained and evaluated based on the position it holds in the social and societal context
That is a misunderstanding of what art and culture are
What would you have liked to see instead
Man is very proud of having arrived at a cultural and art concep
Where one can avoid taking a stance on what constitutes masterpieces in our culture and art
A man's taste is like a measuring stick for what is good and what is beautiful and pleasant
People do not want to take a stance on the very issues that define what is culture and art
Oh that's problematic because we end up with a concept of canon that has nothing to do with culture and art
If one looks at this approach just making art accessible and forming Sweden and Swedish citizens through art
How do you view this approach and how would you prefer to do it instead
Education without an idea of the qualitative and the highest
becomes a quantitative story It becomes like a collection of facts
It's not enough to define what is artistic and cultural
So I believe that someone is completely out of touch when discussing art and culture in that manner
It's nothing strange to do it There is a kind of
leveling there is a relativization about everything
When we take this idealistic moment great art touches deeply
Great art surpasses other art
I think it's fundamentally wrong to believe that one should choose a canon based on other ambitions
o highlight what is most artistically outstanding
New York is a political story
How can we use culture and art to achieve this political goal
This is a problem that other political decisions have led to
Indeed we have actually had a cultural community for a long time in Sweden
Everyone knew Harry Martensson everyone knew Ville Morberg and so on
Now we must somehow use culture and art to achieve a community society
When we have this situation with mass immigration from different cultures and so on
And this is supposed to become some kind of solution
It has actually nothing to do with the artistic and with art
It is not its task to solve political problems
Today culture and art are used to solve political systems
I'm doubtful about that I don't think it's the right path to take
On the other hand not least out of respect for our culture and art and what is most esteemed
One should not misuse these concepts in this way