Exclusive“Holiday Inn” (1942): Reel Thoughts New Year Special

Reel Thoughts
480 followers
“Reel Thoughts with Tiffany and Rebekah” is a weekly film review show hosted by Tiffany and Rebekah. They dive into traditional and classic films, covering everything from mainstream blockbusters to indie gems. Each episode offers thoughtful analysis, diverse perspectives, and an engaging experience designed to connect with and entertain viewers.
#moviestar #talkshow #classicalmusic #Americantraditions #Hollywood #theatermagic #cinematic #entertainment #celebrity #moviefacts #classicfilms #drama #artshow #performance #movieanalysis
AI Generated·May contain errors
Happy holiday, happy holiday While the merry bells keep ringing
May your every wish come true Happy holiday, happy holiday
May the calendar keep ringing Happy holidays to you
If you're burdened down with trouble If your nerves are wearing thin
Hark your load down the road And come to Holiday Inn
If the traffic noise affects you Like a squeaky violin
Kick your cares down the stairs And come to Holiday Inn
If you can't find somebody Who will set your heart awhirl
Get in your car and motor to The home of Boy Meets Girl
If you're laid up with a breakdown Throw away your vitamin
Don't get worse, grab your nurse And come to Holiday Inn
Happy holiday, happy holiday While the merry bells keep ringing
May your every wish come true Happy holiday, happy holiday
May the calendar keep ringing Happy holidays to you
On the twelfth holiday Classic movies gave to me
Twelve strokes of midnight Eleven Christmas carols
Ten pumpkin pies Nine jack-o'-lanterns
Eight happy workers Seven firecrackers
Six Easter bonnets Five more cherry trees
Three valentines Two stovepipe hats
And an evening at Holiday Inn
I'm Tiffany Brannan. I'm Rebecca Brannan.
This is Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Welcome to our New Year special.
Many movies which feature one holiday.
Some even feature two or three.
But there's only one classic movie musical
which features all the holidays on the calendar.
This movie is Holiday Inn from 1942.
In the early 1940s, there's a trio of performers
who are some of the top performers in New York.
A lady and two men.
One of their most popular skits is that
the two fellas are fighting over the one girl.
Little do they know that the same drama is happening offstage.
Jim, the lovable singer, is planning on marrying his co-star Lila
and retiring from show business to a farm in Connecticut.
Little does he know that Lila has decided
to stay with her dancing career with his co-star Ted
who wants them to keep making people happy with their feet.
Jim decides that he's going to still rejoin the human race
so he goes to the farm in Connecticut
only to find that it's much harder work than being a performer.
So after a year of hard work, he decides that
he's going to find a way to seek that kind of laziness and rest
without rejoining the bustle of show business.
So he decides to turn his farm into an inn.
But what an inn.
It'll be called Holiday Inn
and only be open on the 15 holidays every year
for a show, a home-cooked meal, and a really cozy experience.
At first, his showbiz friends are a little skeptical of the idea
but Jim is determined that it will work.
On Christmas Day, a young hopeful is sent out to the farm
to audition for him.
And this is Linda Mason,
a young lady who's been working in a flower shop
but who has aspirations to become a singer and dancer.
They quickly hit it off, so he puts her in his first show
which opens on New Year's Eve.
However, on that same evening,
Ted arrives at the inn,
drunk and depressed because
Lila has left him for a Texas millionaire.
In his drunken stupor,
he does a fabulous dance routine with Linda
not knowing what he's doing.
When he wakes up with a hangover the next day,
he has no recollection of who the mysterious girl was.
So Jim does his best
to keep her identity secret
so that Ted won't steal yet another girl from him.
This film was made by Paramount Pictures.
It was produced and directed by Mark Sandrich.
It stars Bing Crosby, Fred Astaire,
Marjorie Reynolds, and Virginia Dale.
The opening credits of this film
highlight the fact that the idea was originally suggested
by Irving Berlin,
who also wrote the whole score.
Yes, I think accounts kind of vary
on exactly how he thought of this idea.
A lot of people believe it was inspired
by the song Easter Parade.
There are 12 songs in total in the score,
and 11 of them were written originally for the film.
But that one he wrote back in 1933
for a musical called A Thousand's Cheer.
Yes, and he came up with this idea
of a show originally,
a Broadway show that would feature
all these different musical ideas
depicting the different holidays.
And so then, it became a movie.
And you have to say, it's a pretty unique concept
to have a movie that features
so many different holidays and such great songs.
And of course, those songs by Irving Berlin,
words and music,
are really the heart of this film.
Absolutely.
All but two of them are centered on holidays.
And those two are I'll Capture Her Heart,
which is the trio, the first number in the film
that Ted, Lila, and Jim perform.
Yes.
And then Lazy, which we hear Bing Crosby singing
over the montage of his first hard year on the farm.
Yes, it's such a great feature
for these four performers.
The two men, of course,
Bing Crosby and Fred Astaire,
fabulous musical performers,
both singing and dancing.
And the two women,
neither of whom that well-known of performers,
but everybody gets featured really well in this film.
And of course, out of the whole great score,
it's interesting to see which holidays were featured.
Absolutely.
The two most notable exceptions, I would say,
are St. Patrick's Day and Halloween.
Yes.
The two really mainstream ones that aren't featured.
But interestingly,
the one holiday that's actually mentioned
that isn't featured is Labor Day.
Yes.
And there was originally, I believe,
a tap dance number written for that
called This is a Great Country.
It ended up getting cut,
but Irving Berlin later reused it
in a musical called Mr. President.
Yeah, it's interesting to see
because he mentions,
oh, there are about 15 holidays.
So people have speculated,
what are all the 15 holidays?
Since only eight are featured in the movie.
Right.
And it begins on, of course, Christmas.
And then there's also a couple of New Year's scenes.
There's Washington's birthday,
Lincoln's birthday,
Valentine's Day,
Easter,
and as you mentioned,
St. Patrick's Day is not featured.
Then 4th of July, Thanksgiving,
and then back to Christmas.
I think the two presidents' birthdays
will be interesting to modern audiences
because Lincoln's birthday
is not really celebrated anymore.
No.
And Washington's birthday
is now called President's Day,
so we can honor all the presidents on that day.
Yes, and it's been absorbed to the Monday
that's closest to his birthday.
But this, back in those pre-President Day days,
has two really great musical numbers
which features the presidents separately
to represent them individually.
The executives expected the Valentine's Day song,
Be Careful, It's My Heart,
to be the big hit of the film.
And I can see why.
It's a really beautiful love ballad.
It wouldn't have to be for Valentine's Day.
It's just a romantic song.
And it's really the only straight love song
in the whole show.
Great solo for Bing Crosby.
And the dance number,
which Fred Astaire and Marjorie Reynolds
do to that,
is one of my favorites in the film.
And honestly,
one of my favorite Fred Astaire numbers.
It's very reminiscent
of some of his Ginger Rogers dances.
Yes, it is.
So I can see why they were expecting
that one to be the hit.
And it was successful at first,
but very soon, as we all know,
it was eclipsed by White Christmas.
Now, we have to talk about
the success of White Christmas itself,
because I think that probably
this movie's greatest claim to fame
is how it catapulted White Christmas
to such notoriety.
And it won the Academy Award
for Best Song that year,
which is interesting
because it wasn't technically debuted
in the film.
He did write it for the movie,
but about halfway through filming,
Bing Crosby debuted it
on the Kraft Music Hall,
which was a radio program
on Christmas Day, 1941.
I have a dream
Of a White Christmas
Just like the ones I used to know
And that highlights the fact
that this is so interesting to me,
that this movie was not released
in the holiday season.
It was released in the summer of 1942.
That's less surprising
than it would be with some other
Yeah, because like we said,
it's a bunch of movies,
a bunch of different holidays.
Yes, it really is a tribute
to all the holidays.
Our family always watches it
around Christmas and New Year's,
but really it is appropriate
to watch any time of year.
I think because Christmas
and New Year's are featured
more, like several times.
Yes, that's true.
Technically it goes through,
it covers three years, right?
Yes, well, two full years.
Because first you see him
on the farm.
Two full years, yeah.
It covers two full years,
so technically there are
three Christmases
and three New Years
in the movie.
White Christmas is of course
an amazing song
any time, any place.
But I think the reason
for its overwhelming success
was the timing.
Like you said, he debuted it
on Christmas Day of 1941.
This was less than a month
after Pearl Harbor.
So we were already
in World War II.
And that is the secret
to the success of this song,
that it was really
a wartime song.
Why are you dreaming
of a white Christmas?
Well, maybe because
you're overseas.
Maybe because you're stationed
far away from your family
in a camp.
That longing for home,
for the homespun days
of your childhood,
that's why this song
became such a huge success.
And a lot of kind of
musical historians
consider the release
of this song
sort of a turning point
in Christmas music.
Yeah.
It was, you'll notice,
you don't hear that many
Christmas songs from the 30s.
That's true.
So this was really,
other than of course
the great carols
and the religious...
Yes, sacred music
goes back centuries.
But the more secular
Christmas music I think
really was kind of
turned into a
mainstream industry
by this song.
Particularly the more
sentimental secular, right?
Because you had jingle bells,
you have Here Comes Santa Claus.
Right.
Those were around before that.
But this with the real
deep heartfelt meaning,
but not the religious aspect.
And it makes sense
with Irving Berlin,
the composer, being Jewish.
So the Christian elements
of Christmas wouldn't
mean as much to him.
But it shows how people
of different ethnic
and religious backgrounds,
even Jewish people,
can enjoy the secular
celebration of Christmas.
And that heartwarming feeling.
And that you don't have to
believe in the religious
aspects of Christmas
to enjoy it.
But you also can still enjoy
a heartwarming song like this
even if you do believe
in the religious aspects
of the holiday.
And of course the moment
when Bing Crosby
introduces this song
is so meaningful
as he sings it
to and then with
Marjorie Reynolds,
who's overdubbed of course,
on Christmas,
at the holiday.
And when he says
he hoped to be open
by that time,
but he made a promise
to himself that he would
sing that song
at the end of the evening.
And he's playing the piano,
the fire is burning
in the background,
there's this Christmas tree there
and he takes his pipe
and plays the little bells
on the tree.
And of course,
Bing made so many
recordings of this song.
But it's always so nice
to hear that
original arrangement.
Speaking of World War II,
and its association
with the film,
it doesn't feel like
a wartime film at all
because they started
production before
we joined the war.
Yes.
But the exception to that
is the 4th of July sequence.
Right.
There's a,
almost a newsreel type
video played during
the song.
a movie screen
in this outdoor theater.
And you can see,
if you think about it,
because I didn't think
about this for years
growing up watching this movie
until just recently
knowing more about the history
of saying,
oh that's the beginning
of the war,
that footage you're seeing
of the factory,
the rivets,
and so forth.
And,
I believe that that
was actually added
after the attack
on Pearl Harbor.
And it makes sense.
Fred Astaire's
firecracker tap dance,
I believe,
was already in,
but they added that song.
The song,
Bing Crosby and the Chorus
sing a song of freedom.
And,
if you know a little
about history at this time,
it's very interesting
that the lyrics
to that song
are directly inspired
by President Roosevelt's
annual speech
to Congress,
which he gave
on January 6th of 1941,
which has been dubbed
his Four Freedoms speech.
In it,
he said that the people
of the world
were,
had the right
to four different freedoms.
Freedom of speech,
freedom of religion,
freedom from want,
and freedom from fear.
Those are the lyrics.
Free to speak
and free to hear,
free from want
and free from fear,
free to sell the seven Zs,
free to worship
what is pleased,
all those things
are in the song.
Wow,
he's quoting Roosevelt's speech.
And at the end,
they show a little footage
of Roosevelt
probably making
that very speech,
wouldn't you say?
Yeah,
that's definitely
some newsreel speech
of Roosevelt
from around the time.
So that gives you
a little historical context.
Now,
do you have to know
about that to enjoy this film?
Absolutely not.
Like you're saying,
we didn't really know
about that when we watched it
from our earliest childhood.
It's a great film
without that historical context.
But I think
if you watch it
as you're older
and more aware
of American history,
it gives it
even more meaning
to see how people
felt as they did.
Now,
again,
back to
White Christmas.
That song
and Bing Crosby's
rendition of it
has often been said
to hold the record
even to this day
as the top-selling single
of all time.
Right.
There's actually
kind of a...
There's a little debate
about it.
Yeah,
not a controversy,
but a debate about
whether or not
it was surpassed
by Elton John's
tribute to
Princess Diana
in 1997.
That was,
of course,
Goodbye England's Rose,
an adaptation
of Candle in the Wind,
and was very,
very popular.
But the issue is
when White Christmas
was first
topping the billboard charts
in 1942,
it was 11 weeks straight
on the top
of the billboard charts.
They weren't tracking
as carefully
how many records
were being sold.
The sales were
a little different then.
So,
many people believe
that while
Elton John's record
sold 33 million,
that Bing Crosby
was more like
50 million.
We're not 100% sure,
but honestly,
I'm going with
White Christmas.
I say
White Christmas
is still number one.
And the amount
of adaptations
that have been done
of that is just
mind-blowing.
Everyone sings that
on his or her
Christmas album.
Speaking of other
historical notes,
one of the funnier
sequences,
because there are
these little
animated sequences
throughout.
Every time you
see the calendar,
it's so cute.
It shows you
years and little
animations on
the holiday.
And for,
and I believe
those were done
by Robert Allen,
who's graphic
design credited.
But,
on Thanksgiving,
there's a little
turkey,
a little cartoon turkey,
who keeps running
back and forth
between these
two Thursdays.
And,
you know,
I thought,
because you're never
sure when Thanksgiving
is going to be,
because it's not
a fixed day holiday.
But that's in reference
to sort of a little
controversy about
when Thanksgiving
was in the late
Roosevelt administration,
which was dubbed
by critics
Franksgiving.
Because,
beginning when
Abraham Lincoln
made Thanksgiving
really an official
holiday,
it was always the
last Thursday of
the month.
But in 1939,
there were five
Thursdays in
November,
and this was during
the Great Depression.
And at this time,
because at this time
merchants had
respect for
Thanksgiving,
which now we
don't care anymore.
They're looking
at you.
Yeah,
put up those
decorations as soon
as the 4th of July
is over.
But back then,
it was considered
immoral for stores
to start advertising
Christmas before
Thanksgiving because
it was seen as
putting commercialism
ahead of gratefulness
to God.
So,
merchants were
concerned they
wouldn't be able
to make enough
money because of
how late Thanksgiving
was,
so Roosevelt
decreed that
Thanksgiving would
be on the 4th,
which made it
very early.
The 4th Thursday
of the month.
Yeah,
the 4th Thursday
of the month.
among the
calendar makers,
the football teams,
the school years,
businesses,
oh,
all of a sudden
the holiday is on
a different day
because it was
kind of last minute.
So,
not all the states
observed this.
And it
continued that way
for the next
couple of years
until finally
in 1942,
he officially
made it law
that it would
always be
the second
to last Thursday,
whether it was
4th,
5th,
what have you.
And that
is the issue
that's being
sort of parodied
in that little
cartoon.
The turkey's
confused.
The turkey's
confused because
he's like,
I don't know.
Talking a bit
about the musical
performers,
I would say
the real star
of this film
is Bing Crosby.
Definitely.
He is definitely
the sympathetic
leading man.
This is the
closest,
honestly,
to not a villain
exactly,
but an antagonist
I've seen Fred Astaire
play.
Yeah,
because,
I mean,
you can't help
but love him
since he's
Fred Astaire.
Yeah,
if it were
anyone else,
it's like,
this guy's a jerk.
But because
it's Fred Astaire,
he's still
kind of endearing.
you know,
first,
he steals
his girl
when they're
engaged.
They're about
to get married.
He's bought the farm,
he's bought the ring,
and he convinces her
to stay in show
business with him.
Now,
obviously,
Lila has
kind of a
wandering eye.
She's a very
fickle woman,
and she doesn't
have particularly
deep feelings
for anyone,
but he does
tempt her away
from his friend,
and then,
a year later,
they're still
not married,
which shows
that he wasn't
really that serious.
He just didn't want
to get a new
dance partner
for Pete's sake.
He'll go to any length
to keep a good
dance partner.
I mean,
I'm not saying
I can't relate,
but it's still
not good to steal
your friend's girlfriend.
So then,
when she leaves him,
he goes,
and then he's
trying to steal
his girl again,
the new girl,
because it's more
than just so they're
going to dance together.
He's like,
oh,
I'm in love
with you,
Linda,
and we're going
to dance together,
and he immediately
tries to get her
away from Holiday Inn.
So he's rather unscrupulous,
but through it all,
he's a great dancer
and a good singer,
and we can't help
but enjoy the talent
we see on display.
I think his
shining moment
to this is his
firecracker dance
on the 4th of July.
Yes.
The explosions.
They did 38 takes
of that before
he was satisfied.
He was noted
for being a perfectionist.
Yes.
And kind of a little
behind-the-scenes detail
I love is at the end
of the number,
he hits his end pose
and then he kind of
does this gesture like that,
like he's really excited,
and that was unscripted.
He was just so glad
that he finally got it right.
It's so real,
and it's such a rare
candid moment you see
from Fred Astaire.
He's very controlled.
Because he's so polished,
so perfect,
so practiced,
but at that moment
he's like,
yes,
I got it!
And it's great to see
that moment of realness
from him.
And there's so much
enthusiasm in that number
that it feels,
you know,
the energy is so high,
you can really feel
his excitement.
I love to see
the back-and-forth
which he and Bing Crosby have.
They were such a great team
as these sparring partners,
and the jokes about,
you know,
that Fred doesn't really sing
and he doesn't really dance,
but they both were great
at both,
as especially evidenced
in the great
I'll Capture Her Heart number,
as they're joking about
one will capture her heart
with singing
and one with dancing,
and then they're trying
to do the other person's talent.
They were so great
at being funny
without being goofy.
There's so much
goofiness today,
so it's very refreshing
to see the clean-scrubbed,
heartwarming humor
of the early 1940s.
Now, as you mentioned,
the two ladies
are not particularly notable
other than that
they were in this film.
That's right.
Marjorie Reynolds
had been...
She's really the leading lady.
She is definitely the leading lady.
She plays Linda,
and she's the one
who really falls for Bing.
Now, she was overdubbed
while Virginia Dale
did her own singing,
but I would say
that she is a better dancer.
Yeah, definitely.
So we'll forgive her
for not doing her own singing.
And she has such a...
The voice,
which is not her voice,
is so beautiful,
especially singing
White Christmas
and some of the other songs.
You can tell, you know.
And her singing
was dubbed by Martha Mears.
It's a very lovely voice.
Yes.
And both of the ladies
were trained dancers.
Virginia Dale
actually trained on point
from age 9 for a few years.
So she was a ballet dancer.
Yes, but she got blood poisoning
in her foot
when she was quite young,
and they had to graft
some lamb skin
on top of her foot,
and it limited
the mobility of her foot
so she couldn't dance
on point anymore,
which was actually good
because she hated it.
But then she and her sister
were actually a dance team,
and they worked in New York
until Darryl F. Zanuck
saw her
and signed her
to 20th Century Fox.
Interesting.
So I guess she must have
been loaned out
for this picture.
Yeah, it's true.
And neither one of them
is a big star.
I feel that there's
a bit of inspiration
from Ginger Rogers
for her character.
Mark Sandwich
originally wanted
Ginger Rogers
and Rita Hayworth
to play the two parts.
Do you know which is which?
I don't.
I've read that too,
and there really isn't
any information on that point.
What would you guess?
I would guess
that Ginger Rogers
would have been
the Linda Mason role,
even though technically
she ends up
with Bing Crosby.
Yeah.
And Lila ends up with...
It would be more fitting
to their character
to be the other way around,
but who knows?
I don't know why,
I just...
Well, I guess
Rita Hayworth was younger,
wasn't she?
Yeah.
I always think
of Rita Hayworth
as older for some reason,
but I think...
She was quite young
at this point.
I'm probably wrong.
She made two
very successful movies
with Fred Astaire
in 1942.
Okay, it probably
would have been
the other way.
Because he has to
end up with Ginger,
it would be wrong
if he didn't.
That's true,
and I think the way
that she sort of
leaves him straying
for greener pastures
is a bit of a light-hearted
commentary on the fact
that a few years earlier
Ginger Rogers had wanted
to stop making movies
with him to pursue
dramatic acting
on her own.
It's interesting
to see Fred Astaire's
different dance styles
with the two women.
As we noted,
Marjorie Reynolds
is definitely
a better dancer.
She's smoother,
she's taller and thinner,
so I think she matches
him a little better.
She's very much
a Ginger Rogers type,
despite what we just said
about Rita Hayworth
and so forth.
I find their big number
together,
the Valentine's Day number,
to be very reminiscent
of his style
when he danced
with Ginger Rogers.
And of course,
they do the really
great and funny
New Year's dance
as he's...
All the people
in the crowd
think he's just
acting drunk,
like he's just pretending.
And even she seems
to think he's joking around.
But he dances a lot
with the other woman, too.
Mm-hmm.
They do the...
Of course,
they dance
in Capture Her Heart.
Probably his biggest
number with her
is You're Easy
to Dance With,
which actually is
a third non-holiday song.
You're right.
I was incorrect.
But they do it
on Christmas Eve.
Yes, they do.
It's a big nightclub number.
And you can tell
from her...
You know,
there are beautiful
Christmas trees around.
It's a very festive routine,
even though it's not
actually a Christmas song.
And in that dance,
I think it's one
of the greatest examples
of Fred Astaire's
leading abilities.
If you really watch,
I mean, she's doing it,
but he's really
making her do it.
I mean, he's leading her
all over the place.
She's also shorter
than a lot of
leading ladies he had.
So that's an interesting
bit of a dichotomy.
Mm-hmm.
Now, speaking of holidays,
since this is
our New Year's special,
we have to talk about
the New Year's Eve sequences.
Right.
So although we go
through New Year's
three times...
Yeah, the first New Year's Eve,
we just see Bing Crosby
beginning to work on the farm.
Yes, he's carrying firewood,
I believe,
and falls down the stairs.
So that's not really
an important event.
But the...
But the first one
that's really important,
which is the second year,
is the opening
of Holiday Inn
on New Year's Eve.
They sing the song
Happy Holiday,
which is now
a very well-regarded
Christmas song, actually.
Yeah, one of the old ones.
Andy Williams
sings the New Year's song
as One Minute to Midnight,
which he sings in the kitchen
while they're serving up food,
and she's got a little
checkered apron
on over her fancy dress.
It kind of is a medley
into We'll Start
the New Year Right.
Yes, you're right.
Almost two separate songs.
And it's sort of
a tender moment between them
as, you know,
they've only known
each other a week,
but you see
the beginning of,
they're beginning
to really feel strongly
about each other,
both as they're
growing together
as musical partners
and maybe in real life too.
And then, of course,
Ted shows up
and does his first number
with Linda.
Yes.
Which, supposedly,
Fred Astaire,
in order to get
into the proper mood
for the scene,
took a couple
of drinks of bourbon
beforehand,
and then he took
an extra drink
before each take,
and they did seven takes.
And the seventh take
is the one they use,
so I think he's actually
rather tipsy.
He was a method actor.
But it's funny
to watch that number
as a dancer
because there are
several kind of
partnering fails in it,
and if you dance,
you feel like,
yep, that happens very easily.
It's like they
miss each other's hands
or you can't find her.
Especially when
your partner's drunk.
And the music,
that's not a sung routine,
but the music is,
you're easy to dance with.
Right.
It's sort of a
comical arrangement,
almost like it
plays on it.
So a reprise of that,
and then it ends
on New Year's Eve.
Yes, it does,
with sort of a
reopening of the end
on its first anniversary.
And it starts out
with a reprise
of I'll Capture Her Heart
with some new lyrics,
and then goes into
We'll Start the New Year
Right Again.
Yes.
It finishes with
their singing,
and Ted and Lila
are dancing.
Beautiful exterior shot
of the snow.
Very festive.
My outfit is inspired
by the gown
which Linda wears
at the opening
of Holiday Inn
on the first
New Year's Eve.
It is a long,
rather form-fitting gown
like this
with a lot of sparkles.
My dress is inspired
by the gown
which Lila wears
on the reopening
of Holiday Inn
at the closing scene,
which is the third
New Year's sequence.
It's a long gown
which is white on the top,
black on the bottom,
with sort of a
form-fitting silhouette.
She wears long black gloves
and some sparkly jewelry,
and she often wears
many sparkly headpieces.
Now, of course,
I would recommend
this movie
to anyone
during the holiday season,
and I think you can also
watch it on
either the President's
birthdays,
Valentine's Day,
Easter,
Fourth of July,
or Thanksgiving.
It's sort of our tradition
to watch it on Thanksgiving,
and then we often watch it
again later,
either on Christmas
or New Year's,
or sometime in there.
Now, in recent years,
some television networks
have stopped
wanting to play this film
because there's a
blackface sequence in it.
That's right,
on Abraham Lincoln's birthday
because he freed the slaves.
So the whole number
is the song Abraham,
and it's talking about
what a great man he was,
and everybody is in blackface,
all the instrumentalists,
even the waitresses.
The girls,
in kind of standard
Hollywood form at this time,
are wearing more
of a brown face,
like a light,
it's like a really
dark tanned makeup.
Except for Linda,
who's in full blackface,
because it's actually,
what they play it as,
he wasn't going to do
the number in blackface
originally,
and he decided to do so
to disguise her from Ted
because he's looking for her.
Now, it's understandable
why blackface is now
considered problematic.
Right.
Even by the time
that White Christmas was made,
1954,
the Mandy number
was not done in blackface
because by that time
it was considered
controversial and offensive.
Yeah, but 10 years earlier,
it's a minstrel number.
It absolutely would have
been done in blackface.
Yeah.
So the question remains,
was this done as a parody
or to make fun of someone,
or can we find
something positive about it?
Well, I think the character
of Mamie,
who is his maid at the inn,
played by wonderful
black actress Louise Beavers,
I think she's a really
great character in the film.
She gives him some good
romantic advice later.
She's sort of like
a mother figure.
Yeah, both him and Linda.
And during this number,
they cut to her in the kitchen
with her two children,
and she sings one verse of it
about how he freed the slaves,
and I think it's quite
a beautiful tribute.
Yeah, that's a nice moment
that they do feature her
showing that she gets to sing.
She gets to have a feature moment
as do her children.
And yeah,
if you want to be
really sensitive, sure,
you can be offended,
or you can understand
that this was still considered
okay at the time,
and that Bing Crosby
was really good friends
with a lot of black musicians.
Louis Armstrong,
he learned from their
style of music
and actually brought that
into his own style.
This film actually was,
or not this film, sorry,
White Christmas,
coming from this film,
was the first
of Bing Crosby's records
to be in the Harlem
top charts.
Oh, interesting.
So it was his first record
that was ranked by
sort of the black audience.
Interesting.
So yeah, he was very close
with the community.
Like, in his early days,
he worked with
the Mills Brothers,
and you hear that kind of
scat singing,
that laid-back style he had,
which was different
than a lot of other
white recording artists
at the time.
And that's one reason
why he was so popular.
So I think if you want
to be offended by everything,
you can be offended,
but if you can,
just like we talked
about Thanksgiving
and the beginning
of World War II,
if you can open
your mind a little
and try to look at it
from that point of view,
and it's the product
of its era,
and consider maybe
they didn't mean this
as something offensive,
but as appreciation.
Maybe we can consider it
racial appreciation
instead of
racial appropriation.
That's beautiful.
Maybe it's no worse
than having
a Chinese dance
in the Nutcracker,
which I know some people
are starting to
consider offensive,
but maybe we just
could consider it
a loving tribute
to another race
and not consider it
something offensive
and try to look at it
with a bit of
a more open mind.
What was surprising to me,
actually pleasantly surprising,
is in spite of that,
one thing that might
be controversial
about Thanksgiving
is that when you go
film, it has a 100%
approval rating
on Rotten Tomatoes
based off of I believe
27 critic reviews,
and that's a lot.
That just goes to show
that deep down
when you watch
an old movie,
it's because you want
to be transported
to a different time,
and you have to do it
by understanding that.
It's like when you go
to a foreign country,
you need to understand
the customs of that country.
When you go to
an old movie,
you need to understand
the customs of that time.
When in Rome.
Yes.
So when you're
in classic Hollywood,
try to put yourself
there like you're
a guest at Holiday Inn.
How would you react
to these things,
and are you just going
to have a knee jerk reaction,
or are you going to actually
listen to the lyrics
of the song
and take it in
and see this isn't
actually offensive.
It's actually paying tribute
to that it was good
that the slaves were freed.
It wasn't saying
it was good
that there were slaves.
It's good that they
stopped being slaves.
So I think that,
you know,
we can't pretend
it doesn't exist,
and I don't think
we need to.
I think we need to
understand
these interesting issues
of the past,
and at the same time
appreciate how
unlike the modern
Christmas classics
that are full of violence
and inappropriate content
and bathroom humor,
this movie is a beautiful,
clean, inspiring,
and morally uplifting film
that people of all ages
and backgrounds can enjoy.
And that's the beauty
of this era of Hollywood.
This movie,
because it's very popular,
is available to watch
both on DVD
or Blu-ray
from Amazon,
Walmart,
eBay,
Barnes & Noble,
or for streaming.
You can rent
or purchase it,
often at a reduced rate
during the holidays,
on YouTube,
Amazon Prime Video,
Google Play,
and many other
streaming platforms.
But I must caution,
in recent years,
there is a colorized version
that has often
been perpetuated.
It's okay,
but I urge you
to stick with the original
black and white.
It's the classic
and how it was made.
If you enjoyed
our New Year's special,
we hope you'll watch
our other episodes.
We have a weekly release
where we talk about
a different classic film
every week
from all different genres
to help you start
your classic film journey.
Thank you for watching!
Happy New Year!
