Ranking Member Raskin's Opening Statement: U.S. Census Bureau

Oversight Committee
67 followers
1 Video View·Dec 5, 2024
thank you very much and uh thanks to you
director Santos for joining us here this
morning uh the census is an essential
decennial constitutional function
insisted upon by the founders in
designing a
government of We the People um and the
census was conducted and designed in
2020 under the Trump Administration not
under the Biden Administration and of
course as the chairman says there's
demographic movement in America in a
free Society where people have a
constitutional right to travel across
state lines and to move there's always
demographic movement the chairman
suggests people are fleeing uh taxes in
the blue States I know there are people
fleeing uh the anti-abortion
restrictions in red States because um I
met a lot of them over Thanksgiving
actually young women who don't want to
live in the red States uh under the new
regime of uh State Legislative
Theocratic control over the bodies of
women but in any event that's all part
of the normal course of demographic
movement people Americans can decide to
live where they want to live now the
bureau faced some giant and
unprecedented challenges in conducting
the 2020 census it took place in the
covid-19 global pandemic which
significantly complicated the work of
census staff as huge parts of the public
were worried about Contracting covid-19
it severely affected the world work of
the census many census activities were
suspended or shifted and in many states
and localities lockdowns and travel
restrictions stopped the Census Bureau
from accessing entire communities and
neighborhoods a number of other problems
caused by the pandemic further affected
the count such as double counting people
who had temporarily moved in with their
family or friends to try to survive the
crisis were college students being
counted twice after being sent home from
school mid semester were not being
counted at all if they were missed
overcounts can occur when members of a
family with a second home list their
primary address in different ways or
when a landlord lists a tenant as living
in an apartment even if the tenant lists
another residence as their primary
address if they've gone to try to wait
out the the epidemic in a different
place overcounts and undercounts are not
a new problem uh they are a traditional
problem a long-standing problem is the
goo says but there's always a new
variety of challenges in different
settings and obviously the disastrous
response of the federal government to
covid-19 deeply complicated the work of
the Census Bureau the census also had to
contend with hurricanes and wildfires
affecting a number of different states
and it was conducted following limited
tests because of substantial budget cuts
that had taken place in the years before
the census there's no reason to see
these undercounts and overcounts says
anything more than the normal kinds of
Errors made during exceptionally
difficult circumstances but the usual
profusion of conspiracy theories have
proliferated from people not interested
in making the census work better but
simply in scaring the public and
dividing people along party lines the
post enumeration survey is only intended
to measure accuracy for a subset of the
population for example it doesn't
include people living in college dorms
or people living in military Barracks
moreover it draws its conclusions from a
very small survey of 170,000 housing
units out of 145 million in the country
in other words the post enumeration
survey is a tool to help inform and
guide future census activities it is not
a recount of the census nor can it be or
should it be used to supplant or alter
actual census data for purposes of
apportionment and distribution of
government funds I appreciate the
chairman calling this hearing today
because we should all want a complete
and accurate 2030 census but the
solutions to achieve it are not really a
mystery instead of cutting funding for
the bureau as House Republicans have
tried to do this year and years past we
need to make sure it has the resources
it needs to conduct the planning and
Preparatory work that are essential to a
truly successful count instead of
threatening to add a citizenship
question to the census which experts
have warned will depress participation
we should support the Census Bureau in
fulfilling the clear Mandate of counting
the whole number of persons in each
state set forth in the Constitution the
census must be an independent
non-political exercise conducted by
statisticians and qualified
professionals not an arm of uh the
political office of whichever
Administration happens to be in charge
and we must ensure that the census never
becomes uh an authoritarian tool of fear
and control which is what it is in
authoritarian societies the census must
always remain a tool to nourish and
improve our democracy by empowering
Americans through equal representation
and equal access to resources and
opportunity the census plays a critical
role in our democracy guaranteeing there
will be a fair allocation of House Seats
in the country and house districts of
equal population within each state it
also assures that government resources
and benefits will be distributed fairly
um it's not easy to count
