L'intégrale des Questions au Gouvernement | 22/05/2024

it is open as I indicated to you yesterday the Prime Minister is being held to pay tribute to the deceased gendarmes so it is the government which will answer today the questions to the government for the GDR group the floor is given to Mr Steve Chillou thank you Madam President my question is addressed to Mr. also address to Mr. Prime Minister the current situation in Kanaki is more than catastrophic Kanaki is greatly destabilized by your deadly project to unfreeze the restricted electoral body generating a succession of actions thus revealing the deep disagreement of the Canac people with your policy of actions which led to the death of six people I would also like to convey my sincere condolences to all the Canak and non-Canac families having lost a loved one and jeens remind you, Mr. Prime Minister, that your government is entirely responsible for the tragedies currently taking place in this territory. Moreover, I remind you today that the four presidents of the overseas region support the territory of Kanaki and are unanimously in favor of the withdrawal of your text you have to master you have to master the long history of the Oceanic peoples to understand the anger that is great in Kanaki. This is what I tried to explain to you during the crisis meeting in Matigan on Friday May 17 where I I particularly insisted on the fact that the Oceanian people attached great importance to trust and the authenticity of human relations, but the posture adopted by the current government makes any dialogue with the people, to date, we are faced with people who no longer understand each other and who do not understand as a reminder the Canak and Taitian independence movement ends at the same time and shares the same fight that of the independence of our peoples therefore it seemed adequate and appropriate to me to integrate Polynesian independence leaders in your mission in your next dialogue mission as mediator for peace however you have remained evasive on the subject I therefore reiterate my question do you intend to integrate Mr. Mo Bruderson President of French Polynesia into the dialogue mission who will soon visit kanaki thank you thank you very much oup my dear colleague the floor is given to Madame Dominique strong minister in charge of local authorities and rurality thank you Madam President Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament Mr. MP chou so I would obviously like to speak on behalf of the Minister of the Interior on behalf of the entire government tell you to what extent we feel a desire to communicate all these warm thoughts which animate us in the face of the SEP victims including two gendarmes that these riots have given rise to tell you that we also address our support for the 86 police officers who were injured and whose courage we would like to highlight as well as the courage of all their families then tell you Queen reaction to this crisis that the Caledonian territory is undergoing the President of the Republic took the decision last week last to decree a state of emergency you know so that order returns as soon as possible yes you are right the situation is serious the state of emergency has allowed us and still allows us for a few days to send reinforcement and the establishment of exceptional resources, nearly 3,000 law enforcement officers are currently intervening on the territory in addition to the existing internal security forces, hundreds of police officers and gendarmes continue to arrive on the island thanks to by the military means implemented I will come there dear Mr. President already more than 320 arrests have been made since the start of the crisis thanks to the power of house arrest provided for by the state of emergency several dozen violent leaders were brought under control and several administrative searches were carried out. The operation to clear the main road launched this weekend allowed the lifting of 67 roadblocks thanks to the additional police forces who arrived this weekend, including many soldiers from the GGN. and police officers in this context the government welcomes the words of local officials who called for the return of civil peace and in particular that of the president of Polynesia Brerson the institutional debate that you are calling for on the future of the territory will be conducted and will be installed as part of a mission that the President of the Republic that the President of the Republic and the Minister of the Interior are leading thank you Madam Minister the floor is given to Madame Claudia Rouau for the socialist group thank you Madam President Madam Minister of National Education in order to give more to those who have less President François Mitteran launched priority education in 1981 it pursues the objective of correcting the impact of social and economic inequality on success education by strengthening educational action in schools in areas experiencing the greatest difficulties today more than 1.1 million children are educated in more than 6,600 priority education schools more than 40 years later its creation this public policy has proven its worth but the weakness of the allocated resources no longer makes it possible today to achieve the original ambition the release of the PISA 2023 ranking confirms this the results of France are among the lowest ever measured sociology of territories is constantly evolving some of them are marked by increasing poperization there are today schools classified in Rep whose social position index is much lower than schools classified in Rep moreover the implementation of the virtuous inclusive school in many respects also has limits due to the lack of space in the medical-social sector more than 1000 on the island and Villaines the increase in behavioral disorders in certain children and the glaring lack of aesh I would also like to pay tribute to the national education staff who work in difficult conditions the last revision of the priority education map dates from 2015 it is high time to look at it again because the inequalities they do not wait and school must remain a national priority Madam Minister, what timetable do you propose for revising this school map, it being understood that it must respond to real needs which cannot be conceived without new means, thank you I thank you, Madam Deputy, the floor is given to Madame Nicole Boué, Minister of National Education and Youth, Madam President, Ladies and Gentlemen, Madam Deputy, you are right, the objective of national education is to respond to the needs of needs of each of our students by taking into account their specificities and this is why we work to individualize the needs to better provide adequate responses priority education has long been the subject of particular attention with very significant resources deployed in this context, you know very well, we have proceeded to split the classes of these pce1 and now large sections which is a support we have implemented resources in terms of management staff and then in staff medical-social I do not believe that there are any shortages but in any case the objective is very clear the population is evolving the demographics are also evolving and therefore we need to look more precisely at how this has evolved across the entire territory this is the reason why we are committed to resuming the mapping of priority education and as I was able to say I believe in these premises to various various deputies we are going to resume this mapping of priority education in 'adjusting and I have set myself the objective of the 2025 school year. It is therefore for this school year that I will propose changes to better adapt the reality of priority education to demography to the needs of the students. Our objective is really success. students and this is how we act, thank you very much, Madam Minister, the floor is given to Madam Marjoline my milfer for the Renaissance group, thank you Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, ministers, my dear colleagues, my question is for the Minister of Transport and I would like to involve all of my colleagues from the Verneuronalpe region. It is a work in progress and no longer a project. I obviously want to talk about lyonurin, for which the Prime Minister reaffirmed his political and financial support last week, as he did. recalled during his visit Morienne this infrastructure is of national and European strategic interest because it will facilitate the transport of goods and people not only between Lyon and Turin but throughout the entire Mediterranean corridor which connects all of Europe from south from east to west of Lisbon to Kive this project will ultimately allow 1 million trucks to be switched from roads to rail, a breath of fresh air for the Alpine valleys which will be less polluted and concrete proof that economic development and ecological PE must go hand in hand better when this major project meets the project of the president of the Iron Republic of Lyon the interland of the port of Marseille and to develop the Mediterranean river axis ronone up to the kidney the region to the verneuronade will become the first low carbon hub in Southern Europe confirming its strategic position and France with it of European Carrefours the regular confirmation of the Government's commitment to Tururin Lyon is necessary in a file which by nature plays out over the long term after the broad consultations organized with regional elected officials on the phasing of access and recent announcements on the financing of studies this ministerial visit clearly affirms that this file which seemed blocked in casart and is well and truly in progress it is important to all that the Dutil and public declaration which dates from 2013 does not fall it is a strong signal which should allow us to then reflect on the implementation of the major construction site approach for the new accesses which will allow the elected officials concerned to anticipate the work and the base tunnel which we hope the opening in 2030 32 at the latest to realize its full potential to conclude Mr. Minister can you tell us how the government will approach the next steps the State has promised to initiate the financial round table of access to connect this subject to the state region plan contract and with all the transport infrastructures of the auneuronalp region can you give us an overview please thank you thank you mident thank you very much the floor is Patrice Bergrit Minister in charge of transport thank you Madam President Madam Deputy Marjoline Milfire you are right to recall the many virtues of the Lyon Tururin project which has today become a construction site with nearly 40 km of gallery today dug in the perspective of next elections let us also remember that this is a European project which further connects our countries and which allows the development of the different territories, that is why the European Union was mobilized, it finances 40% today today of the project and a request was sent for AUG to increase this participation to 55%. to be complete and as you recall, this project must in the long term provide for access and desaturation of the Lyon railway junction in January the government reached an agreement concerning the financing of studies with the region and the local authorities concerned I welcome this mobilization which also made it possible to send to the European Commission a request for financing up to 50% of eligible expenses and the State, putting the remaining 2 thirds in parallel, the State and the region also agreed on a plan contract particularly ambitious regional state for mobility for the region since we have 1.4 billion euros which will be invested for the territories, therefore 430 million for rail and 322 million for express services in metropolitan regions, here are two new very concrete proofs of the Government action for the decarbonization of mobility, thank you, thank you, Mr. Minister, my word is to Mr. Florian Chuche for the France Insoumise group, thank you, Madam President, Mr. Prime Minister, last Thursday 4,000 firefighters came from all over France set foot on the Parisian pavement in an unprecedented historic demonstration, even since all the staff representative organizations came together as an inter-union union. Their demands are clear. The first of their demands is first and foremost not to die from their work. can no longer see their colleagues contract cancer or fall ill a few months after retiring you have launched an observatory of the health of firefighters but the time is no longer for observation it is for action that It has been 2 years since the International Agency for Research on Cancer classified the activity of firefighters as carcinogenic. Immediate measures must be taken for our volunteer firefighters as professionals. Establish a single medical file and an end-of-career medical examination. Ensure the traceability of the operational activities of each firefighter and post-pressure monitoring ask the Minister of Health to modify the table of occupational diseases second demand the Olympic and Paralympic Games SNCF agents RATP drivers hospital caregivers of Paris the garbage collectors of the city of Paris all police officers and gendarmes will benefit from bonuses but nothing for the firefighters why this unequal treatment and this lack of consideration for our firefighters very demanding we need more professional firefighters between 2002 and 2022 the number of firefighters only increased by 3.5% while the number of interventions carried out increased by 37.5%. we need an overhaul of the funding model of the 10 and a massive recruitment plan for professional firefighters the unions were received by the general directorate of civil security but they received no concrete response I ask you so Mr Prime Minister will you listen to our firefighters will you exceed their demands the discomfort of the profession is deep a few weeks before the Jos and the fire season do not play with fire thank you sir MP the floor is for Dominique Fort Minister in charge of local authorities and rurality thank you Madam President Ladies and Gentlemen MP Choche you are addressing three subjects three subjects the first which concerns health the second which concerns the Olympic Games and Paralympics and the third which is the financing model of the 10 very difficult in 2 minutes to answer these three points you know to what extent I am attached to our civil security fire forces alongside Gérald Haranin also I was particularly attentive to their demands during the demonstration that you cite on May 16 the first subject on health you say it is the time for action you are completely right after the observation after the operational doctrine guide which is entitled prevention of risks linked to the toxicity of smoke this subject is at the heart of our concerns and yes we are in action with the Ministry of Health on the second subject you mention the Olympic and Paralympic Games we are currently working with both the President Sauvadé and the 10 and both with the firefighters union to try to converge at the dawn of these Olympic and Paralympic Games and thirdly on the financing of the 10 and for these three subjects I want to say we have just launched last April 26 with Gérald harmanin a beautiful calf of civil security we are so aware that we have a lot of issues working with the unions and with the departments of France I thank you I thank you Madam Minister you have 5 seconds left go ahead you have 30 seconds left and no concrete response has been provided so what concrete response for our firefighters please Madam Minister I thank you Mr Deputy the floor is now given to Madam for the group ecologist thank you Madam President my question is addressed to the Minister of Economy and Finance Mr Minister ellisa and William lost their mother in storm Alex in 2020 an extratopical storm attributed to climate change her body was only found 13 days later climate change is broken lives, others lost but climate change is not inevitable it is companies shareholders who have consequences on human lives make the cycal choice to increase production of oil and gas total energy AINS devotes more than 70% of its investments to oil and gas projects and has developed 30 new projects since 2011 2021 sorry this is why Elisa and William continue today with its other victims total energy and its shareholders for involuntary manslaughter endangering others and abstaining from fighting a total disaster and liability but we are also responsible if we do not let them do it we can among other things reduce the profitability of these oil investments by taxing the profits even if only to finance the protection of the French against climate change, Italy and Spain did so. This contribution brought in 2 billion in Spain and 2.8 billion in Italy, so Mr. Minister, can you tell the national representation how much has been reported the temporary solidarity contribution that you put in place for the 2022 results of oil and gas companies and why you refused to extend this temporary solidarity contribution in 2023, I thank you, the floor is given to Mr. Tonas Casaznav, Minister in charge of the budget, thank you Madam the President Ladies and Gentlemen the MPs Madam the MP Evva SAS first of all you mention a legal proceeding in progress before the courts it is not up to me it is not up to the government to comment on the legal proceedings but that makes me still allows us to recall a fundamental evolution in our law and France was a pioneer in the matter it is the law on the duty of vigilance of large companies of 2017 which imposes because it is a question, Madam Deputy, of the requirement of vigilance of companies with regard to their social impact and their environmental impact and this law allows it, under the control of the judge, to verify that companies are meeting the responsibilities that are theirs and elsewhere and I I hope that you will support and support this approach. We have defended the extension of this framework to the community level with a draft duty of vigilance directive which will also go well beyond the national framework and I believe that in this matter there are additional protections for those who suffer the effects of global warming but also the effects of human rights violations in other countries, particularly by subcontractors and that is 2 years of negotiation when it comes to taxation, I say it again here, it is better to fight as we did on legal and regulatory obligations than to think that for every problem there would be a tax solution the taxation that you mention will not take away anything from the pain of those you cited in the introduction to your question and I believe that this is what we need to succeed together and there is no taboo on the part of the government as we have said we work with the general rapporteur on energy taxation for example but we look at subject after subject but forgive me Madam Deputy for each problem there cannot systematically be a solution tax I thank you Madam Deputy Mr Kn you did not answer my question at all and I will give you the figure Mr CASNAV the tax on fossil energy companies brought in 61 million euros in 2023 it is in the law settlement 61 million you admit that it is not much and I remind you that the AGET of shareholders of Total Energy takes place in a few days and that they have already announced 19.9 billion in net profit in 2023 you say that you cannot do but you do not want to do Spain and Italy have done it they do not have fossil energy production on their soil so when will you finally put in place a tax on energy companies at the height of the challenges I thank you the floor is Mr. Emu Mandon for the democratic group thank you Madam President my question is addressed to Mr. Minister Delegate in charge of public accounts and concerns fraud and its consequences on our economy the credibility of the call for rigor which underpins the government's economic policy and the government's general policy, in the national interest, will be all the more understood as the public authorities will be intractable against all forms of fraud, whether fiscal or social the anti-fraud plan put in place a little over a year ago has already produced significant results, reflected in particular by the increase in recoveries after tax audits, but the inventiveness of fraudsters from criminal networks and individuals alike is recognized without limit it constantly poses new challenges to the effectiveness of anti-fraud systems in the face of the development of encryption technology, particularly such as the famous cryptoassets, but we also see that public aid such as the Renov bonus and maprive Renov can be targeted. and this is how we see that teleconsultations are particularly exposed to fraudulent practices. Mr. Minister, faced with this alarming observation, can you give us an initial assessment of the 2023 anti-fraud plan, can you tell us the measures you intend to take to amplify and strengthen the fight against fraud, thank you, thank you, the floor is given to Mr. Thomas, Minister in charge of public accounts, thank you Madam President, Ladies and Gentlemen, Deputy Mandon, you are right in the fight against fraud we have taken stock the balance sheet is the increase in recoveries in the fight against tax fraud in particular 15 billion 15 billion euros in constant increase since 2021 in terms of work hidden by the URSAF 1.2 billion euros in recovery it's a record amount and it's good results it's the result in particular of the assessment and the plan which was carried out by my predecessor Gabriel Atal in terms of the fight against all frauds and I think I think we can welcome it and moreover around twenty legislative provisions included in the finance law and the social security financing law however we must continue the offensive you are right sir the deputy there is a subject in particular to which I draw your attention and I know that a certain number of you have made proposals to me to move forward on the subject it is public aid fraud we pay 100 billion in public aid that this concerns learning aid my bonus returns the CPF and I am regularly informed by the Bercy services of suspicions of fraud and abuse in matters of public FDI and I believe that we must strengthen our arsenal in this area to be able to example immediately suspend the payment of aid in the event of suspicion today it is not possible to allow administrations to share with each other useful information to tighten the meshes of the net today it is not possible strengthens it is the powers of investigation and control of the administrations which pay aid I am thinking for example of the ANA in particular for aid for energy renovation so on this subject I am ready to undertake work and I have already done so some of you to go further and complete our arsenal in the fight against all fraud, thank you, Mr. Minister, the floor is given to Mr. Jean-Louis Bricou for the lot group, thank you Madam President, my question is addressed to the members of the government most sensitive to solidarity whether it is social territorial budgetary my question concerns the worrying budgetary situation of certain departments like Arege for example but like the INE in particular my department is missing 23 million euros to complete the budget of the INE department to ensure at least its skills in terms of social and territorial cohesion to continue to support families, communities, associations to continue to invest in these colleges or roads for example, so how can we be arrived there as you know about fifteen years ago the State transferred the human solidarity allowances the disability not the RSA to the department without compensating the evolution of these benefits result in 2022 it is 92 million euros not compensated by the State to the INE department on the revenue side the inequalities are also glaring you also know when a property is sold the department collects a revenue which we call the transfer rights for valuable consideration the DMTO they are of the order of €150 per inhabitant in the groin when the average in France is 250 because obviously the real estate dynamic is much less in the INE than in the high stages or in Haute Savoie this situation Madam Minister is completely unacceptable, Madam Minister, it seems to me that the time has come for solidarity and equalization, a government which respects itself and which respects us must be guarantor of fairness between men and territories, so Madam Minister, what are the your intentions what provision will you take in the next financial year to give all departments the means to exercise their skills what guarantee can you give to the INE and its inhabitants I thank you I thank you Mr. Deputy The floor is given to Madame Dominique, Minister in charge of communities and rurality, thank you Madam President, Ladies and Gentlemen, Deputy Bricou, you are right, the departments are the subject of an extremely brutal scissors effect with the drop in DMTO that you know well and the increase in charges that the departments are faced with we talk about it at the discretion of our QAG very regularly and I work personally with all the departments in the department of the INE in the department of Riège so faced with this situation degraded the time is for research yes yes the time is for research and it is my daily life with the department of France to find collective solutions but I cannot tell you then that yes the time has come for solidarity you to hear that we are not doing anything we are doing a lot even if the diagnosis must mean that we must work for 2025 even so finance law 2024 an exceptional contribution of 150 million euros to help the departments in the financing of laoc a ation personalized autonomy plan with the objective of a rate of coverage by the state of all autonomy expenses of the departments of at least 40% 2,106 million euros for the safeguard fund distributed between the departments whose financial situation is the most difficult then a substantial increase from 68 million euros to 100 million euros but as you know, Mr. Deputy, the sums allocated by the State to support the care of unaccompanied minors so yes, several works have been launched now and already to simplify the lives of local activity groups and also allow them to make savings then exceptional financial assistance that I mentioned safeguard fund equalization fund zoning of the 14 departments in FRR the most fragile departmental pact yes sir the deputy of this government Christophe Béchu and I are at work to prepare the 2025 finance law on with the departments I thank you Madam Minister Mr. Briou thank you for your response Madam Minister but I believe that today is the right time simply listening to the social and economic singularities of our departments the time has come for solidarity and it is high time I believe to activate the equalization mechanisms I thank you again thank you very much my dear colleague the floor is now to Madame Émilie Bonivard for the group the Republicans thank you Madam President my question is addressed to the guards of the jump Mr. Minister today seenstage nation in honor of Fabrice Moello and Arnaud Garcia the two prison officers cowardly murdered by a command on May 14 I would like to reiterate the tribute of the entire national representation to these two men and our sincere thoughts of their families it is VO of the penitentiary men and women in the field that I want to bring today we could not more madam the deputy tell them up there that it's going to end badly this is one of the messages that the prison guards of the graves convey to me today absence of firmness of the cannabis cell phones of the ceramic knives which are introduced into prison during the visiting rooms or by drones of trafficking which undermines the effectiveness of the prison response and endangers the staff Marc we ask them not to do their job too well to buy social peace in the prison madam we are now in the hotel business our profession no longer has any meaning, they are the ones we must listen to, yes we must make a 180° turn in terms of penal and penitentiary firmness, there is an urgent need for the explosion of violence outside as inside we can no longer respond with xism and angelism ba firmness must once again become the rule let 's not let the sacrifice of these two men for France go unpunished and let's change things let's massively reduce extractions best way to reduce the risks 130000 judicial extractions in the year 130,000 in matters of judicial hearing the rule must become visionreference extraction the exception and if our must does not allow it and well let's modify it we are here for that let's put back in place the systematic searches at parlor how Mohamed Amra's phone was entered through which he organized his escape and the death of these two people the protection of the lives of the agents requires that we put back in place controls and do not oppose us the law international law our fellow citizens no longer support these responses which justify our helplessness in the face of the unspeakable, I thank you my dear colleague, the floor is given to Madame Saintra ouch Minister in charge of children, youth and families, thank you very much, thank you very much, Madam President, ladies and gentlemen. Members of Parliament, Madam Deputy Bonivard, I ask you first of all to excuse the guard of the saau because he is currently there for the national tribute to prison officers and with the Prime Minister, but Madam Deputy our support for the prison administration it is total it is old and I also want on behalf of the prison administration to thank you for your support and the work that you do for the penitentiary the saau guard is totally committed to their side first of all with measures which were also voted by you Madam Deputy and this majority more than 6000 job creations since 2017 transition from category B of supervisors to January 2024 transition to category A of officers massive investment to secure our prisons but we must go further Madam Deputy we must go further and we will pursue actions without respite the arm of justice will not tremble and we will go as far as necessary the guard of the saau brought together the inter-union a few hours later they demonstrated a great and an enormous responsibility Madam Deputy the extensive exchanges allowed an agreement signed yesterday with very concrete measures for example allocations of machine guns because yes it is necessary developments in terms of equipment to reinforce the vehicles in term of security but also the development and use of videoconferencing because yes we are counting on the national representation to help us implement these measures Madam Deputy there is also the overhaul of the escort levels and the composition of the teams or even the expertise to have the possibility of expanding the post-parlor searches which today we know is a flaw a large part of these measures will be immediately applicable and beyond that particularly for the security equipment give clear instructions to the director of the prison administration we will stop at nothing to better protect the prison officers thank you thank you Madam Minister the floor is given to Madam Anne Leenanf for the Horizon group thank you Madam President my question s addressed to the Minister responsible for local authorities and rural areas 21,000 is the number of apprentices that communities wish to recruit this year, a record which we are very pleased with and which is the result of the government's ambitious policy in recent years years to amplify the dynamics of the recruitment of apprentices throughout the civil service, however on April 26 we learned that the National Center of the Civil Service could only finance 9,000 contracts and only in professions in shortage in fact it It is the CNFPT which now finances 100% of the training costs of apprentices, the State and France Compéten gradually but significantly reducing their financial assistance in this context more restrictive selection criteria for applications had to be introduced in the communities leading to frustrations of the disappointments on the community side as well as on the student side, such orientations call into question the agreement on the reform of the financing of apprenticeship in the territorial public service that the government and territorial employers had negotiated in 2021, it is therefore urgent to put in place a new long-term funding mechanism that encourages the recruitment of apprentices and is financially sustainable for the CNFPT and local employers whose allocations are too often revised downwards, Madam Minister, at a time when our communities too often find themselves caught between the application of public policies and the means at their disposal what actions do you envisage so that communities can recruit more apprentices, thank you, thank you, Madam Deputy, the floor is given to Madame Dominique, strong minister in charge of communities territorial and rurality thank you Madam President Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament Madam Deputy Leinanf then we are all convinced here in this assembly we also in the government of the absolute necessity of this apprenticeship in the world of local authorities allowing our young people to access the territorial civil service but everyone must do their part to make this formidable system come to life and public employers are also fully committed since in 2023 we will have more than 30,000 apprentices in the civil service so two points on the first c is that the State invests in local authorities for apprenticeships in the local civil service and last year we concluded with the CNFPT, as you said, a three-year agreement to train 9,000 apprentices by 2025 but we participates financially, it is my colleague Stanislas Guerini who has committed to a contribution from his ministry of 15 million euros per year over the period 2023-2025 as in 2022 and who thereby participates in the financing of the training of its apprentices we have said it to local employers and I will say it again before you we will keep this commitment then second point we are also committed to ensuring that apprentices can integrate the public service more easily at the end of their apprenticeship here again we TI will keep our commitment my colleague Stanislas Guerini has also expressed his wish that a path of access to the public service dedicated to apprentices be created. This fully echoes a recommendation from territorial employers who provide apprenticeships. a real pre-recruitment route this year they have issued nearly 23,000 applications for recruitment of apprentices so you see it, Madam Deputy, this government is taking concrete action with territorial employers with the CNFPT and I want to welcome the election to the presidency of the CNFPT Johann nedélec whom I am meeting within 15 days and I will address this subject I am committed to it I thank you thank you very much Madam Minister the floor is Mr. Emerck Salmon for the national gathering Madam President my dear colleagues my question s 'addressed to Mr. Minister of Industry, Mr. Minister, unfortunately absent, you proclaim loudly and clearly your project for the reindustrialization of France, I therefore invite you to demonstrate it to us today to convince us that the Choose France summit does not is not just another blow of like but a sincere desire to strengthen our industrial tools I would like to draw your attention to a major concern for our companies concerning the ban on packaging made of non-recyclable tyrenic polymers provided for by the climate and resilience law which is due to come into force on January 1, 2025, this measure goes well beyond the requirements of the European directive on single-use plastics, we therefore see once again that France is overtransposing EU regulations by restricting the French business leaders the future European regulation on packaging which should come into force in November 2024 prohibits Member States from preventing the placing on the market of packaging that complies with the requirements of this regulation the conformity of stylish packaging to the obligation of recyclability will be evaluated in 2030 by making the French ban incompatible with this European framework moreover from an ecological point of view such a ban makes no sense because alternative materials are generally heavier and more difficult to recycle and have therefore a larger carbon footprint the ban on this packaging will lead to the closure and relocation of dozens of industrial sites and the elimination of thousands of jobs for example the company knau has closed several factories in the region and we could close others if this question is not resolved quickly my question is therefore the following can you confirm to us that the European regulation will make the ban on this packaging provided for by law inoperative and are you able to reassure the industrialists on this issue of concern for them I thank you the floor is Madam to Sir excuse me Thomas kenav minister in charge of public accounting thank you Madam President Ladies and Gentlemen the the the the deputies sir the gentleman the deputy in the back you ask the next question is there an incompatibility between the ecological transition and and the reindustrialization of our country and I believe that the figures which are ours our results for years prove the opposite you started your question if it 'is the meaning of the question' tells me I doubt the results of CHUS France how can you doubt the results of CHUS France which revealed more than 18 managers gathered in Versaill around fifty projects which concern our entire territory 10,000 jobs 10,000 employment at stake and Mr. Deputy among all these projects among all these projects many projects are in the field of energy transition and climate transition because we must not oppose the ambition of reindustrialization and the fact that we be very attached to environmental requirements to protect the health of French and European consumers and if you were right from the start we would not have reindustrialized the country this year it's 600 additional industrial companies it's more than 2 million jobs that we have created it is 7.5% of unemployment it is proof that we can be very demanding on the environmental level and this is our case at the European level it is our case at the national level while succeeding while succeeding and I understand and I understand that you don't like it ultimately you regret form of success of the country this industrial reconquest which is found in all the figures which is found in all our figures and which clearly proves that we cannot can't, as you try to do, oppose ecological transition and industrial success, thank you very much, Mr. Minister, the question session with the Government is over, excuse me, go ahead, Mr. Minister, you have not responded to a concrete case today there are companies present and who will leave there before starting to reinstate let's start saving our industries thank you I thank you the session of questions to the Government is over the session is suspended